binge eating

Kylandme
Kylandme Posts: 42 Member
edited November 22 in Health and Weight Loss
I have very strict diets in my past.... now I cant stop binge eating... any tips pls as this is happening alot
«1

Replies

  • janejellyroll
    janejellyroll Posts: 25,763 Member
    I have no idea what is leading to your binges, but strict diets are often associated with binges. What is your calorie goal per day?

    I struggled with binges in the past when I tried to go too low calorie or when I restricted too many foods or restricted macro nutrients like fat or carbohydrates. Do you think this could be contributing to your issues?
  • madhatter2013
    madhatter2013 Posts: 1,547 Member
    How many threads will you start with this?
  • Kylandme
    Kylandme Posts: 42 Member
    im surely not eating enough protein
  • WBB55
    WBB55 Posts: 4,131 Member
    Kylandme wrote: »
    im surely not eating enough protein

    Why not try a sensible deficit then, with plenty of protein, and take control. You don't have to starve yourself (and then binge as a result) to lose weight. If you'd like help determining a sensible deficit, let us know.

  • janejellyroll
    janejellyroll Posts: 25,763 Member
    Kylandme wrote: »
    im surely not eating enough protein

    Is there a reason why you can't add more protein to your daily plan?
  • Kylandme
    Kylandme Posts: 42 Member
    I only like fish.... how can I add more protein? im sorry I really don't know where to start from
  • WBB55
    WBB55 Posts: 4,131 Member
    Kylandme wrote: »
    I only like fish.... how can I add more protein? im sorry I really don't know where to start from
    Here's a list I made of foods that enjoy with more than their fair share of protein. But if you want to lose weight, all you need to do is eat at a sensible deficit.

    Greek yogurt
    Cottage cheese
    Swiss cheese
    Eggs
    Milk
    Steak
    Chicken breast
    Tuna
    Salmon
    Tilapia
    Anchovies
    Tuna
    Sardines
    Navy beans
    Lentils
    Jerkey
    Peanut butter
    Mixed nuts
    Edamame
    Green peas
    Wheat germ
    Soba noodles
    Quinoa
  • TavistockToad
    TavistockToad Posts: 35,719 Member
    Kylandme wrote: »
    I have very strict diets in my past.... now I cant stop binge eating... any tips pls as this is happening alot

    Stop the strict diets then.
  • TavistockToad
    TavistockToad Posts: 35,719 Member
    Kylandme wrote: »
    I only like fish.... how can I add more protein? im sorry I really don't know where to start from

    More dairy, beans, lentils, eggs, seafood
  • janejellyroll
    janejellyroll Posts: 25,763 Member
    Kylandme wrote: »
    I only like fish.... how can I add more protein? im sorry I really don't know where to start from
    Kylandme wrote: »
    I only like fish.... how can I add more protein? im sorry I really don't know where to start from

    Do you mean that fish is the only animal product that you like?

    You can still get protein from beans, grains, tofu, seitan, lentils, peas, and protein powders. Do you know how many grams of protein you're averaging per day now?
  • Kylandme
    Kylandme Posts: 42 Member
    I don't count calories but I guess like 50 g per day because I focus on carbs... and binge alot
  • WBB55
    WBB55 Posts: 4,131 Member
    Kylandme wrote: »
    I don't count calories but I guess like 50 g per day because I focus on carbs... and binge alot
    Define "binge" and "a lot"
    3000 calories in one sitting daily? 600 calories of peanut butter once a week?

  • Kylandme
    Kylandme Posts: 42 Member
    its daily in 1 sitting... I feel guilty of eating something and I blow out like a lot in 1 sitting... its daily or every 2 days
  • TavistockToad
    TavistockToad Posts: 35,719 Member
    Kylandme wrote: »
    its daily in 1 sitting... I feel guilty of eating something and I blow out like a lot in 1 sitting... its daily or every 2 days

    Eating what?
  • happysquidmuffin
    happysquidmuffin Posts: 651 Member
    So start counting calories then! I have had short spouts of binge eating in my past, up to a month at a time where I would binge terribly at least once a day. I found it was more a habit than anything. So once you break the habit - don't go back! If I have one bad day, yes it's tempting to give up the next day too but that turns it into a habitual cycle all over again. So if you are concerned about eating too many carbs, use MFP to log your food for a while, then make adjustments based off of what you see you are truly eating. The food diary is a great tool, so since you're here already, you might as well give it a try. I find that pre-planning and logging at least one or two meals for the next day helps me stay on track. I've successfully broken my last overeating phase and have been mostly on track for about 2 weeks now. It feels great. But if I didn't log my food, I wouldn't be able to keep myself accountable.
  • Kylandme
    Kylandme Posts: 42 Member
    Kylandme wrote: »
    its daily in 1 sitting... I feel guilty of eating something and I blow out like a lot in 1 sitting... its daily or every 2 days

    Eating what?

    binges mainly are on 3 things: cookies, cereal and crisps
  • WBB55
    WBB55 Posts: 4,131 Member
    Kylandme wrote: »
    binges mainly are on 3 things: cookies, cereal and crisps

    (1) you could not buy them or keep them in the house.
    (2) have you calculated how many calories it is? Maybe it's not as much of a "binge" as you think.
    [(3) Someone using cookies and crisps in one sentence? What country are you from? *WBB's brain explodes*]


  • Kylandme
    Kylandme Posts: 42 Member
    im from malta Europe...I guess im abnormal
  • WBB55
    WBB55 Posts: 4,131 Member
    Kylandme wrote: »
    im from malta Europe...I guess im abnormal
    Stop it. Just STOP feeling sorry for yourself. I know it's hard to hear, but ain't no one here to put you down.
  • Kylandme
    Kylandme Posts: 42 Member
    I know the more I feel pity the more im in this cycle... I guess I have to put up my sleeves and change my diet and count everything... im trying to eat at maintainance for few weeks
  • WBB55
    WBB55 Posts: 4,131 Member
    Kylandme wrote: »
    I know the more I feel pity the more im in this cycle... I guess I have to put up my sleeves and change my diet and count everything... im trying to eat at maintainance for few weeks

    You can eat cookies and crisps in maintenance or a deficit. I really recommend logging everything you eat. You might find it's not as many calories as you think when you look at your week as a whole.
  • Kylandme
    Kylandme Posts: 42 Member
    I will try seriously not just for a few days and back to square one! yeah most probably I can eat more variety now that I see it infront of my eyes
  • ewoksrule3
    ewoksrule3 Posts: 230 Member
    I struggle a lot with binge eating too, and I have found that the two things that help me the most are tracking calories, and exercise. If I exercise, I am less likely to want to eat junk food overall. So if you can get on a regular schedule, you'll hopefully have less cravings...and log everything you eat, no matter how painful. It will help motivate you to not want to do it again tomorrow. I also limit myself to one "bad" item per grocery trip, and intentionally measure one or maybe two portions of that food to eat at a time, and let myself enjoy eating it, savor it -- but in a healthy portion size. If I have a bunch of junk that I love in the house, I get tempted to jump from craving to craving and stuff myself, but if I keep it to just one, and make sure I measure it out, I still get to enjoy the things I love, but not in such an unhealthy and out of control way. I used to stuff myself until I felt like throwing up almost every day...and I still struggle with it, but now it's down to once or month or so that I really go over my calorie limit. I'm hoping to get it down to even less often. It's incredibly hard, but you can do it!
  • Kylandme
    Kylandme Posts: 42 Member
    ewoksrule3 wrote: »
    I struggle a lot with binge eating too, and I have found that the two things that help me the most are tracking calories, and exercise. If I exercise, I am less likely to want to eat junk food overall. So if you can get on a regular schedule, you'll hopefully have less cravings...and log everything you eat, no matter how painful. It will help motivate you to not want to do it again tomorrow. I also limit myself to one "bad" item per grocery trip, and intentionally measure one or maybe two portions of that food to eat at a time, and let myself enjoy eating it, savor it -- but in a healthy portion size. If I have a bunch of junk that I love in the house, I get tempted to jump from craving to craving and stuff myself, but if I keep it to just one, and make sure I measure it out, I still get to enjoy the things I love, but not in such an unhealthy and out of control way. I used to stuff myself until I felt like throwing up almost every day...and I still struggle with it, but now it's down to once or month or so that I really go over my calorie limit. I'm hoping to get it down to even less often. It's incredibly hard, but you can do it!


    very good tips ! thankyou
  • mbrough58
    mbrough58 Posts: 27 Member
    Some people have cravings for carbohydrates because they are not getting enough sleep. Perhaps you need more sleep.
  • Kylandme
    Kylandme Posts: 42 Member
    mbrough58 wrote: »
    Some people have cravings for carbohydrates because they are not getting enough sleep. Perhaps you need more sleep.

    that's true also... I tend to sleep very late
  • Biggirllittledreams
    Biggirllittledreams Posts: 306 Member
    edited July 2015
    1. We tend to reach for sugar-dense foods when we deprive ourselves/don't eat enough, since sugar is a quick-fix for energy, but not a healthy one, nor does it help energy wise as it's not sustainable (like with healthy fats, or protein since it's a spike and crash). So your being deficient in protein could be why you reach for such sugary foods.
    2. Over-eating due to deprivation is not the same as binge eating. You may have secondary reactions to over-eating, but it's important to realize first and foremost where the problems with your eating comes from. I've come a lot of people who equate over-eating in large amounts with binge eating, which surely isn't the case. There are a lot of people who aren't in tune with their hunger cues, but binge-eating is a very specific experience in which you eat for emotional, and specifically emotional reasons. It may be exasperated by hunger and whatnot, but when it comes down to it, the triggers for eating such massive amounts are always emotional. From what you've said thus far, the emotions you mention have been secondary (in reaction to the situation, not precipitating it) and surrounding how you see yourself after you eat. I'm not saying you can't have a problem with binge eating because i don't know you and the situation personally, and i'm only going by what you've mentioned. Also, depriving yourself/restricting yourself in the end usually leads to over-eating.
    3. I agree with what was mentioned about. Regardless of what's causing this problem, lose the self-pitying attitude. It'll get you nowhere. It really sucks that you have to deal with this, but there are sucky things we all have to deal with, and what defines you as a person is how you choose to deal with, and hopefully overcome your problems. The things in life worth having tend to take hard work, and your health is definitely something worth having.
    4. If you do have a problem with binge-eating, counting every calorie obsessively is not what you do, and if anything quite the opposite. You should learn to eat with moderation and to eat mindfully, see a therapist for Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, or Dialectal Therapy (or psychotherapy, but the first two are the most statistically supported), and once you're recovered, think about going back to using something like a MFP app. If you were obsessively counting calories, it could easily trigger binges, since black and white thinking is at the base of Binge Eating Disorder, Bulimia, Anorexia B/p type, etc. Like i mentioned above, binges are emotionally based - so if you find it has an emotional basis, you can't only focus on the food and tangible aspects. You need to also focus on the emotions driving your food choices, find support groups, and focus on self-care.

    Best of luck!
  • TavistockToad
    TavistockToad Posts: 35,719 Member
    Kylandme wrote: »
    I know the more I feel pity the more im in this cycle... I guess I have to put up my sleeves and change my diet and count everything... im trying to eat at maintainance for few weeks

    I was just going to say, eat at maintenance for a while to stop the binges, and then add in a small deficit.
  • Kylandme
    Kylandme Posts: 42 Member
    yes that's my idea
  • flamingblades
    flamingblades Posts: 311 Member
    How many threads will you start with this?

    When she gets a sensible answer to her question.
This discussion has been closed.