300 kettlebell swings a day?
annalisbeth74
Posts: 328 Member
Has anyone ever done this challenge?
I recently started doing kettlebells regularly, and came across this challenge when browsing workouts. Any thoughts?
I recently started doing kettlebells regularly, and came across this challenge when browsing workouts. Any thoughts?
0
Replies
-
I've done the 10,000 Swing challenge 4 times over the past year and a 1/2. This challenge is completed by doing 500 Swings per day/workout.
It's tough but doable... Each time I've done it, I have lost weight, inches and fat. Yet gained strength at the same time.
Go for it!0 -
Those are the results I am hoping for!
I was actually debating doing 300/ day versus the 10,000, figuring that with the latter I might take a rest day here and there, but I decided to start out with the smaller number to begin with. I can always do more the second time around, right?0 -
I'm personally not a fan of any of these "challenges" (squats, swings, etc) because they focus way too much on one particular movement, and you're not getting a great overall workout. And kettlebell swings are something that I've noticed MOST people do incorrectly, so to do 300 a day seems like it would be setting people up for possible injuries with questionable benefit. JMO.0
-
Why? What do you want to achieve? You can do a lot more with kettlebells than just swings, so rather look at a good program - Sarah Lurie has great dvd's - and those are a lot better than mindlessly swinging a kettlebell for hours.....0
-
I wholeheartedly disagree with all of this.
First of all, kettlebell swings are a total body workout. And I do appreciate that most people do them incorrectly, but I know what to do and what not to do.
And second of all, 300 reps a day doesn't take hours and hours, and it's certainly not mindless. I can knock out 100 reps in less than 5 minutes, with plenty of rest between sets of 25. Then a few hours later I do my next set of 100.
I appreciate you playing devil's advocate, but I was hoping to hear from those that have actually done this, not those who haven't and want to talk me out of it.0 -
annalisbeth74 wrote: »I wholeheartedly disagree with all of this.
First of all, kettlebell swings are a total body workout. And I do appreciate that most people do them incorrectly, but I know what to do and what not to do.
And second of all, 300 reps a day doesn't take hours and hours, and it's certainly not mindless. I can knock out 100 reps in less than 5 minutes, with plenty of rest between sets of 25. Then a few hours later I do my next set of 100.
I appreciate you playing devil's advocate, but I was hoping to hear from those that have actually done this, not those who haven't and want to talk me out of it.
That's not what you asked for. You asked for thoughts. This person gave an honest perspective. They said they're "not a fan" and gave specific and helpful reasons why. It doesn't mean they're judging you, or picking on you, or even yucking your yum.
If you want people to just agree with you and tell you what you've already decided to do is a great idea, probably a better idea to say so up front.0 -
I like the single-arm kettlebell swings better. I think they are worth adding for better core stability. My kettlebell is only 15lbs so single-arm has been my way of achieving more resistance too. I'm thinking of double-arm swinging 25lbs next and then progressing to single arm for that weight.0
-
annalisbeth74 wrote: »I wholeheartedly disagree with all of this.
First of all, kettlebell swings are a total body workout. And I do appreciate that most people do them incorrectly, but I know what to do and what not to do.
And second of all, 300 reps a day doesn't take hours and hours, and it's certainly not mindless. I can knock out 100 reps in less than 5 minutes, with plenty of rest between sets of 25. Then a few hours later I do my next set of 100.
I appreciate you playing devil's advocate, but I was hoping to hear from those that have actually done this, not those who haven't and want to talk me out of it.
Sorry, I misunderstood. I thought you wanted people's "thoughts", but looks like you've made up your mind. Good luck with your challenge!0 -
I've done this before. 300/day for 30 days. Personally, I am a powerlifter and it made my glutes more sore than I'd like them to be before squatting and deadlifting and I definitely saw no carryover for strength. But it made my butt perkier. I still will occasionally throw in 300 hundred swings with a 35# Bell just for the calorie burn. I do sets of 30-50 single arm, alternating arms each set and it literally takes me 30 minutes max.0
-
My max is 1200/ day. I usually use the 70 lb KB but if you have different weights, you can mix them up. I did like 20000 swings in 4 weeks. One thing I didn't expect after was to break my Dead lift plateau. My Squats and BP remained same though. The swings loosened up my hips too. Go for it but do with a good form.0
-
deluxmary2000 wrote: »I'm personally not a fan of any of these "challenges" (squats, swings, etc) because they focus way too much on one particular movement, and you're not getting a great overall workout. And kettlebell swings are something that I've noticed MOST people do incorrectly, so to do 300 a day seems like it would be setting people up for possible injuries with questionable benefit. JMO.
KB swings is total body work out. Its a compound movement, you don't need 100 different exercises if you use a challenging weight. Same with Back Squats and Dead lift they use multiple muscles. If I have 20-30 min a day, I will go for KB swings, Squats, some kind of press or deadlifts.0 -
@smaclean8 and @leonidas_and_spartacus --You guys are killing me with that weight! How did you transition to heavier Kettlebells? I was going to go up by 10 lbs at a time after one arm swings. Does that sound like a good transition?0
-
deluxmary2000 wrote: »I'm personally not a fan of any of these "challenges" (squats, swings, etc) because they focus way too much on one particular movement, and you're not getting a great overall workout. And kettlebell swings are something that I've noticed MOST people do incorrectly, so to do 300 a day seems like it would be setting people up for possible injuries with questionable benefit. JMO.
This article by Dan John one of the most respected strength and conditioning guys in the world, explains why the swing is a full body workout.
https://www.t-nation.com/workouts/10000-swing-kettlebell-workout0 -
I like the single-arm kettlebell swings better. I think they are worth adding for better core stability. My kettlebell is only 15lbs so single-arm has been my way of achieving more resistance too. I'm thinking of double-arm swinging 25lbs next and then progressing to single arm for that weight.
I find myself drawn to the single-arm swings the more I do these. I could probably go up to a heavier KB for the double-arm swings, but while funds are tight and I can't afford it I'm having more fun with the singles. And I can definitely feel it in the core!
0 -
I've done this before. 300/day for 30 days. Personally, I am a powerlifter and it made my glutes more sore than I'd like them to be before squatting and deadlifting and I definitely saw no carryover for strength. But it made my butt perkier. I still will occasionally throw in 300 hundred swings with a 35# Bell just for the calorie burn. I do sets of 30-50 single arm, alternating arms each set and it literally takes me 30 minutes max.
I could definitely use a little more perk back there! The flat glutes run in my family. Hoping for a nice kettlebooty one of these days!
0 -
leonidas_and_spartacus wrote: »My max is 1200/ day. I usually use the 70 lb KB but if you have different weights, you can mix them up. I did like 20000 swings in 4 weeks. One thing I didn't expect after was to break my Dead lift plateau. My Squats and BP remained same though. The swings loosened up my hips too. Go for it but do with a good form.
Um... All I got to say is Holy Cow! That's a lot. But good to know I could possibly do more than the 300/day at some point in the future and still see results. I did notice my form slipping a bit yesterday, so I'll keep an eye out for that. Maybe drop down in weight for a few days.
Thank you!
0 -
Packerjohn wrote: »deluxmary2000 wrote: »I'm personally not a fan of any of these "challenges" (squats, swings, etc) because they focus way too much on one particular movement, and you're not getting a great overall workout. And kettlebell swings are something that I've noticed MOST people do incorrectly, so to do 300 a day seems like it would be setting people up for possible injuries with questionable benefit. JMO.
This article by Dan John one of the most respected strength and conditioning guys in the world, explains why the swing is a full body workout.
https://www.t-nation.com/workouts/10000-swing-kettlebell-workout
I love this. And my butt (and hams) is sore.0 -
annalisbeth74 wrote: »I like the single-arm kettlebell swings better. I think they are worth adding for better core stability. My kettlebell is only 15lbs so single-arm has been my way of achieving more resistance too. I'm thinking of double-arm swinging 25lbs next and then progressing to single arm for that weight.
I find myself drawn to the single-arm swings the more I do these. I could probably go up to a heavier KB for the double-arm swings, but while funds are tight and I can't afford it I'm having more fun with the singles. And I can definitely feel it in the core!
Will you go up by 10lbs?0 -
@smaclean8 and @leonidas_and_spartacus --You guys are killing me with that weight! How did you transition to heavier Kettlebells? I was going to go up by 10 lbs at a time after one arm swings. Does that sound like a good transition?
I follow the Russian KB hard style swinging. They recommend normal Men starting start with a 16 Kg KB (35 lb) and Women start with a 12kg or 26lb (KB). Usually the increments are in 4kg (~10lbs). Start with two armed swing and as it gets lighter, do one arm or mix it up with heavier KB two arms and lighter one with one arm. Make sure you are following the right breathing flow.0 -
annalisbeth74 wrote: »leonidas_and_spartacus wrote: »My max is 1200/ day. I usually use the 70 lb KB but if you have different weights, you can mix them up. I did like 20000 swings in 4 weeks. One thing I didn't expect after was to break my Dead lift plateau. My Squats and BP remained same though. The swings loosened up my hips too. Go for it but do with a good form.
Um... All I got to say is Holy Cow! That's a lot. But good to know I could possibly do more than the 300/day at some point in the future and still see results. I did notice my form slipping a bit yesterday, so I'll keep an eye out for that. Maybe drop down in weight for a few days.
Thank you!
Form is most important, comes above anything else. I stop when my form suffers, there were days I could barely do 150 with proper form. Cheat reps don't count may be except when you get hurt with a lousy form.0 -
Will you go up by 10lbs?
I have an 8 kg and a 12 kg. I use the 8 more for the single-arm swings and the 12 for the 2-arm. I can do the 12 for 1-arm, but for 300/day I thought I'd take it on the easier side until I get used to the increase in reps. I guess I'll just see how I feel from day to day. I've never done kb more than sporadically, so I'm assuming too much too fast is a bad thing?0 -
Packerjohn wrote: »
This article by Dan John one of the most respected strength and conditioning guys in the world, explains why the swing is a full body workout.
https://www.t-nation.com/workouts/10000-swing-kettlebell-workout
Damn, that workout is no joke. Something to aspire to, definitely.
0 -
annalisbeth74 wrote: »Has anyone ever done this challenge?
I recently started doing kettlebells regularly, and came across this challenge when browsing workouts. Any thoughts?
This is a must do. Thank you for the inspiration!0 -
I'm going to give this a go but start it on Monday as going away for the weekend0
-
I love the idea of this challenge. However, I JUST started using my kettlebells regularly. Currently, I am up to 3 sets of 25 swings with a 10 lb kettlebell. I am getting ready to move up to 15 lbs. (I am starting low and slow to get my form correct and work up.) I am striving to be in a place where I could do a challenge like this, I am just not there yet.
If you feel up to the challenge, I say go for it!
0 -
I am so new to all this....I just started strong lifts 5×5. Are kettle bell swings more cardio or more weight lifting? Do you need rest days like in weight lifting?
Should I do the kettle bells on the same day as strong lifts or on rest days?I love the idea of this challenge. However, I JUST started using my kettlebells regularly. Currently, I am up to 3 sets of 25 swings with a 10 lb kettlebell. I am getting ready to move up to 15 lbs. (I am starting low and slow to get my form correct and work up.) I am striving to be in a place where I could do a challenge like this, I am just not there yet.
If you feel up to the challenge, I say go for it!
0 -
Began Day 1 yesterday. I'm on my way!0
-
I am so new to all this....I just started strong lifts 5×5. Are kettle bell swings more cardio or more weight lifting? Do you need rest days like in weight lifting?
Should I do the kettle bells on the same day as strong lifts or on rest days?I love the idea of this challenge. However, I JUST started using my kettlebells regularly. Currently, I am up to 3 sets of 25 swings with a 10 lb kettlebell. I am getting ready to move up to 15 lbs. (I am starting low and slow to get my form correct and work up.) I am striving to be in a place where I could do a challenge like this, I am just not there yet.
If you feel up to the challenge, I say go for it!
I add swings to help the hams and glutes that can help with the SL 1x5 deadlift. I swing a 15lb KB on the DL days or between workouts. I ordered a 25lb and 35lb from Amazon. With the heavier weight I am going to do them only on lifting days.
I also use one for Turkish Get-ups on off days.0 -
annalisbeth74 wrote: »I wholeheartedly disagree with all of this.
First of all, kettlebell swings are a total body workout. And I do appreciate that most people do them incorrectly, but I know what to do and what not to do.
And second of all, 300 reps a day doesn't take hours and hours, and it's certainly not mindless. I can knock out 100 reps in less than 5 minutes, with plenty of rest between sets of 25. Then a few hours later I do my next set of 100.
I appreciate you playing devil's advocate, but I was hoping to hear from those that have actually done this, not those who haven't and want to talk me out of it.
Might I ask where the challenge in all of this is then if you're able to complete it in 15 minutes?(not including 2-5 minute rest times). Personally I'm not a fan of a movement that relies heavily on momentum. Work outs just feel more pleasing if you're able to fatigue every muscle with controlled movements. Not bashing the swings at all, everyone's got their own personal preferences.
0 -
If you are doing them right you are overcoming inertia, rather than relying on momentum. I know this is about swings, but I'd like to mention the Turkish get-up as another worthwhile thing to do with a kettlebell. I do 10 after my swings.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions