Peanut butter problems
beehappee09
Posts: 19 Member
I eat sooooo much peanut butter. It adds an extra 500 calories a day. I'm going to try to avoid it for a week and see what happens (by weaning off of course cause I'm addicted:)
0
Replies
-
I love peanut butter as well! It's not bad for you as long as you don't eat to much
I am eating natural peanut butter since a couple of months and that works out great for me.
I can eat a little bit more, but it contains less calories and stuff! Maybe you can look for an healthier version?
0 -
Peanut butter is delicious, I find that I snack in chunky way more so I don't keep it in the house. Just like any other food that you have to learn to manage.0
-
If you can't moderate your intake of it, I agree that the best solution for the time being is to cut it out completely.0
-
You aren't addicted. You just like it, because it's nice.
Eat it within the confines of your calorie and macronutritional goals. By doing that you are a) Going to be successful in weight loss and b) Doing so by eating things you like.
There's no need for over the top phrases such as 'addicted'. Stop making a big deal out of it and fit it in to your calorie and macronutritional goals.
Problem solved.0 -
It is possible that you will do better with the kind that does not have added forms of sugar or honey.
Look at the peanut butter's jar for ingredients to see what you have.0 -
i put powdered peanut butter (just great stuff) in my greek yogurt (4 tbs = 100 calories, add 100 calories of greek yogurt and you're eating pb flavor foreeever with only 200 cals, and its a meal with protein) OR, I add 1 tbs or 2 of real peanut butter into yogurt or oatmeal and put it on the side of my bowl and get a tiny little taste with each bite so that it all lasts longer....0
-
Could you substitute regular peanut butter for PB2 (powdered peanut butter) or a mix of both? I like adding peanut butter to my Greek yogurt, though I currently do a mix of 16g real peanut butter and 6g PB2 (about 2Tbsp equivalents of peanut butter in total). I still get the taste of "real" peanut butter, but I save about 70-75 Calories than if I did all peanut butter (enough for me to add a piece of fruit to my meal or sprinkle 8g of nuts/seeds onto my yogurt). If I substituted all the peanut butter for PB2, that would be about a 140-150 Calorie savings.0
-
I too love peanut butter and I buy the most natural I can find. Always with no sugar and preferably no salt, and organic. I put it in the same cupboard as my husbands cakes and biscuits with an egg spoon attached. If "I find myself opening the cupboard" (!!) I dig out an egg spoonful and shut the cupboard and lick it off the spoon slowly -yes I am the sort of person that would make a custard cream last three courses- and I am satisfied.0
-
I love peanut butter too but I make myself stop at a tablespoon! where theres a will....0
-
I heartily second those suggesting PB2; I like it because it's very versatile - you can mix it in its powdered form into shakes, etc., or put a little water in it and make peanut butter to your preferred consistency. I like to make it creamy and spread it onto apple slices for a snack.0
-
Whoa that is a lot of peanut butter. If I knew that something I ate was 500 (unneeded) calories per day, I think I would find it extremely easy to just stop eating it most days. Maybe I'd keep it in one day per week. That's a pound's worth of calories if you cut it out every day or .85 pounds over six days.0
-
beehappee09 wrote: »I eat sooooo much peanut butter. It adds an extra 500 calories a day. I'm going to try to avoid it for a week and see what happens (by weaning off of course cause I'm addicted:)
It is a trigger food for me. I keep my jar in a storage bin in my underground parking space so I have to walk down 2 flights of stairs to get it. If I want some or need some for a recipe, I bring the jar up, then return it to its spot. Sometimes avoidance is the best strategy.0 -
You aren't addicted. You just like it, because it's nice.
Eat it within the confines of your calorie and macronutritional goals. By doing that you are a) Going to be successful in weight loss and b) Doing so by eating things you like.
There's no need for over the top phrases such as 'addicted'. Stop making a big deal out of it and fit it in to your calorie and macronutritional goals.
Problem solved.
I like that. Will Try.0 -
You aren't addicted. You just like it, because it's nice.
Eat it within the confines of your calorie and macronutritional goals. By doing that you are a) Going to be successful in weight loss and b) Doing so by eating things you like.
There's no need for over the top phrases such as 'addicted'. Stop making a big deal out of it and fit it in to your calorie and macronutritional goals.
Problem solved.
Agreed. And if it's a trigger food, try a week without it and see how you do. No need to ween yourself off. I promise, not eating peanut butter does not actually cause delerium tremens.0 -
I eat it to round up my calories to 1200. It's my treat right off the spoon. If I have already had 1200 cals, no pb for me.0
-
Can I just say that I love the title of this thread?
0 -
Peanut butter would be a trigger food for me, too. I switched to almond butter about two years ago and am less inclined to eat it by the spoonful!0
-
I love peanut butter. Every day in the summer I add 32 grams to my breakfast smoothie for my fat macro and its yumminess. I make it fit into my calorie budget. It's something I can easily over eat if I don't use portion control, but it's not a trigger food for me, so I keep it in the house.
If it were a trigger food, I'd try one of the other strategies mentioned on this thread.0 -
I love peanut butter! My solution has been to have it once a day (so that way I know I'll always have more tomorrow). My favorite (don't diss it until you try it) is to put it on a baked yam. The peanut butter overpowers the yam's flavor, making it into a warm, gooey, peanut butter treat that makes it feel like I'm eating forkfuls of peanut butter!
I've also tried pb2 and I'm a fan. It's great for recipes like homemade peanut sauce, but it doesn't really do the melty gooey thing since it doesn't have oil.0 -
I LOVE THE MIXING OF PB2 and peanut butter, that idea is genius and simple!!! I will do this! And it's a trigger food for me. Haha I know I'm not addicted, and I could live without I just want to be comfortable enough to eat it in healthy portions. I'm also upping my fat and protein intake and the cravings may lessen. And yes I know! It's crazy weight gain and not helping me at all. I'll try these wonderful ideas and keep you updated on my peanut butter problems.0
-
That is a good plan. Enjoy feeling good about your decisions.beehappee09 wrote: »I LOVE THE MIXING OF PB2 and peanut butter, that idea is genius and simple!!! I will do this! And it's a trigger food for me. Haha I know I'm not addicted, and I could live without I just want to be comfortable enough to eat it in healthy portions. I'm also upping my fat and protein intake and the cravings may lessen. And yes I know! It's crazy weight gain and not helping me at all. I'll try these wonderful ideas and keep you updated on my peanut butter problems.
0 -
beehappee09 wrote: »I eat sooooo much peanut butter. It adds an extra 500 calories a day. I'm going to try to avoid it for a week and see what happens (by weaning off of course cause I'm addicted:)
I have a better suggestion if you want to try it. Why not portion the peanut butter, weight it, log it, and put the jar away, and then eat peanut butter? Unless you have an allergy or intolerance to peanuts, in which case abstinence is the best idea, cutting back might work better than just cutting it out. Also, if it's a trigger food for you, you might put it in a different part of the house so it's not staring you in the face every time you open the cabinet.
Also, you may feel addicted because it tastes so darn good, but it sounds more like compulsion eating of peanut butter. Food in and of itself is not bad, but it's important to look at the behaviors around food.0 -
Rachel0778 wrote: »I love peanut butter! My solution has been to have it once a day (so that way I know I'll always have more tomorrow). My favorite (don't diss it until you try it) is to put it on a baked yam. The peanut butter overpowers the yam's flavor, making it into a warm, gooey, peanut butter treat that makes it feel like I'm eating forkfuls of peanut butter!
Oooooo!
/runs off to inventory yams/0 -
i put powdered peanut butter (just great stuff) in my greek yogurt (4 tbs = 100 calories, add 100 calories of greek yogurt and you're eating pb flavor foreeever with only 200 cals, and its a meal with protein) OR, I add 1 tbs or 2 of real peanut butter into yogurt or oatmeal and put it on the side of my bowl and get a tiny little taste with each bite so that it all lasts longer....
I like p2p too. It tastes so good. Just good stuff!0 -
I lived on peanut butter growing up. If our school would have had a no peanut butter sandwich rule due to allergies I would have been even thinner than I was already growing up because I ate a peanut butter and butter sandwich every single day until sixth grade. That being said, I am not addicted so much to it anymore because my tastes have expanded (I was quite the finicky child). Now I can't keep Nutella in the house- love that stuff. I could eat it straight out of the jar!0
-
I quit peanut butter cold turkey about 20 years ago when I discovered that it was one of the causes of some pretty serious and very painful digestive problems I was having.0
-
If it makes you feel better, I was convinced my child would have been born a peanut butter baby. But hey, she came out 100% human, so yeah haha! I have a problem with peanut butter, so I stop it with 1 PB & J a day0
-
I add it to my "nICE cream," too0
-
I've had to move on to powdered peanut butter. I have tried peanut butter in moderation challenges, and even now that I'm BULKING-literally, I'm trying to gain weight, I still can't have it around because it temps me beyond a reasonable surplus.0
-
Thank you all for your thoughts... I didn't realize peanut butter could negatively affect my digestive system I'll have to look into it! I also researched a bit and peanut butter contains components that help to moderate your cortisol levels... No wonder I eat it when I'm stressed! Also update... Switched to almond butter (much easier to say no to but still DELICOUS) put every last jar in the basement, and had one tablespoon with breakfast and going strong!!!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions