No Carb Diet
AndrelleJohnson
Posts: 47 Member
I would like to know how to a no carb diet works? Can someone please explain how this works and what I can not eat if I do decide to do it? Will it really me help lose these last 20 -30 pounds?
0
Replies
-
A calorie deficit will help you lose the last 20-30 pounds, and it will be a hellof a lot easier if you eat carbs. Don't buy into the no carb hype, it's nothing special.0
-
A calorie deficit will help you lose weight, however you choose to create it.0
-
Everything has carbs including fruits, vegetables a meat. I don't even know how this is possible. I can see no grain/rice/potatoes type thing. Though no thank you for me. Carbs are not bad though complex are better for you.0
-
No carb or low carb because no carb would be close to impossible.
But as above, there's nothing magical about cutting out carbs.0 -
Your brain uses glucose. Glucose is produced by consuming carbohydrates. If you want to eliminate anything, eliminate simple sugars.
Meats do not have carbs, by the way.0 -
Your brain uses glucose. Glucose is produced by consuming carbohydrates. If you want to eliminate anything, eliminate simple sugars.
Meats do not have carbs, by the way.
Not much, but they do have carbs
From the USDA nutrient database, http://ndb.nal.usda.gov/ndb/foods/show/7184?manu=&fgcd=
Basic Report: 23093, Beef, chuck for stew, separable lean and fat, all grades, raw
Value per 100 g 3.0 oz
Water g 72.51 61.63
Energy kcal 128 109
Protein g 21.75 18.49
Total lipid (fat) g 4.48 3.81
Carbohydrate, by difference g 0.16 0.14
Fiber, total dietary g 0.0 0.0
Sugars, total g 0.00 0.000 -
Everything has carbs including fruits, vegetables a meat. I don't even know how this is possible. I can see no grain/rice/potatoes type thing. Though no thank you for me. Carbs are not bad though complex are better for you.
Sooo, will it be better if just cut out the rice, grains, potatoes, breads out my diet? Cause I basically just eat what I want I just try to eat less, healthier.0 -
You'd have to be eating literally nothing but meat, which sounds utterly miserable. Even eggs have one gram of carbs. Just eat at a calorie deficit and you'll lose the weight.0
-
My mom has been low carb for over 10 years. Her diet is meat, dairy and some vegetables. When she first did it in 2005 she lost 30 pounds and has been able to keep it off following low carb.0
-
AndrelleJohnson wrote: »Everything has carbs including fruits, vegetables a meat. I don't even know how this is possible. I can see no grain/rice/potatoes type thing. Though no thank you for me. Carbs are not bad though complex are better for you.
Sooo, will it be better if just cut out the rice, grains, potatoes, breads out my diet? Cause I basically just eat what I want I just try to eat less, healthier.
If you want to lose the last 20-30 lbs, your best bet is to track your calories. You can overeat anything including fruits and vegetables and cutting out food groups won't help if you don't know how much you're taking in.0 -
Unless you have some medical reason to prefer a low-carb diet, it isn't really worth it. I've got PCOS and personally, I've lot weight just counting calories, but because I'm trying to get pregnant, I'm attempting to eat low carb to try to get my body to ovulate. If I didn't care about getting pregnant, I'd just eat at a typical balanced diet at a deficit.0
-
You are not better off cutting anything food group for your diet, no food is inherently bad unless you truly have an allergy or sensitivity to it. The key is moderation, portion control and throw in some activity. Cutting out food groups is typically unsustainable.0
-
Say no to the No Carb diet.0
-
As a nurse, I'm going to tell you, Low Carb Diets can and do work very well. But as it has already been commented above almost everything has carbs. But the thing is finding out which is good carbs and which are bad carbs. And the amount your allowing your body to take in each day. Following a low-carb diet can help you lose weight, keep blood sugar balanced and lower the amount of triglycerides in the bloodstream. The tricky part is deciding how many carbs you’ll consume and being careful not to go too low unless you’re under the supervision of a registered dietitian or your physician. While some carb-containing foods are on the “do not eat” list, you can still include a variety of healthy carbs on a low-carb diet, as long as you limit portions. As a general guideline, following a low-carb diet means consuming fewer than 130 grams of total carbs daily. Getting fewer than 30 grams of carbs is a very low-carbohydrate ketogenic diet, reported Nutrition and Metabolism in 2008. To protect your health, don’t begin a low-carb diet until you consult a healthcare professional. Once you know your daily carb goals, you can begin to choose the carbs to include on your “do not eat” list. Sweets and baked goods are at the top of the “do not eat” list for several reasons. For starters, they have more carbs than other foods, and they also contain added sugar, which contributes carbs and calories without nutrients, and often have unhealthy saturated or trans fats. Many baked goods provide 30 to 80 grams of carbs per serving, depending on the type of food and serving size. Read all your food labels and look everything up and remember to log it, that way your keeping a good track of what and how much your body is taking in. And remember to drink lots of water. Water is Key in any diet, and it helps flush everything out and helps with keeping you full. I hope this is helpful. And no matter what you choose, I wish you the best of luck, cause let's face it . . . We are all on here for getting fit and staying fit!0
-
I just lost 30 lbs from cutting sugar,potato's,rice,pasta,bread and such I also don't eat corn but I eat tons of veggies and a little meat with every meal and I feel great . I was told to watch my starch and sugar due to diabetes running in the family and the doc says what you do is look how many carbs something has and how much fiber subract the fiber number from the carb number and that is what's called a net carb the net carbs are what you need to watch. Veggies have fiber and so those are complex carbs just Google the difference between net carb, complex carbs and simple carb . knowlage is power God bless and good luck
0 -
Take a look at your logging first
How are you measuring your foods? Are you weighing your solids?
How are you estimating how much you should be eating? Are you eating back exercise calories?
For some people, low carb is an easy way to induce a calorie deficit. I don't know the names, but there are a few low carb groups around here. You don't have to do it unless there's a medical reason to do so.
0 -
Kay2016Sexy wrote: »As a nurse, I'm going to tell you, Low Carb Diets can and do work very well. But as it has already been commented above almost everything has carbs. But the thing is finding out which is good carbs and which are bad carbs. And the amount your allowing your body to take in each day. Following a low-carb diet can help you lose weight, keep blood sugar balanced and lower the amount of triglycerides in the bloodstream. The tricky part is deciding how many carbs you’ll consume and being careful not to go too low unless you’re under the supervision of a registered dietitian or your physician. While some carb-containing foods are on the “do not eat” list, you can still include a variety of healthy carbs on a low-carb diet, as long as you limit portions. As a general guideline, following a low-carb diet means consuming fewer than 130 grams of total carbs daily. Getting fewer than 30 grams of carbs is a very low-carbohydrate ketogenic diet, reported Nutrition and Metabolism in 2008. To protect your health, don’t begin a low-carb diet until you consult a healthcare professional. Once you know your daily carb goals, you can begin to choose the carbs to include on your “do not eat” list. Sweets and baked goods are at the top of the “do not eat” list for several reasons. For starters, they have more carbs than other foods, and they also contain added sugar, which contributes carbs and calories without nutrients, and often have unhealthy saturated or trans fats. Many baked goods provide 30 to 80 grams of carbs per serving, depending on the type of food and serving size. Read all your food labels and look everything up and remember to log it, that way your keeping a good track of what and how much your body is taking in. And remember to drink lots of water. Water is Key in any diet, and it helps flush everything out and helps with keeping you full. I hope this is helpful. And no matter what you choose, I wish you the best of luck, cause let's face it . . . We are all on here for getting fit and staying fit!
Because you are a nurse, you are an authority. Lots of nope in your post.0 -
AndrelleJohnson wrote: »Everything has carbs including fruits, vegetables a meat. I don't even know how this is possible. I can see no grain/rice/potatoes type thing. Though no thank you for me. Carbs are not bad though complex are better for you.
Sooo, will it be better if just cut out the rice, grains, potatoes, breads out my diet? Cause I basically just eat what I want I just try to eat less, healthier.
Why would you want to do that?! What a miserable existence!
You can lose weight with ALL of those things included!0 -
Funny!!!, Cause there are Lot's of Yeses in my comments. And that's the truth sister, sorry if you don't like it but??? You know I can't please everyone, Not everyone likes the truth. But then again everyone will always have something to say. It should be up to them to decide, My comment was for her and if she want's to she can very freely ask her very own Doctor about my comment and I'm positive that he or she will agree with all that my comment states. And FYI, we are all supposed to be on here as friends to be supportive and offer helpful information. I'm not sure how anyone else feels, but honestly, . . . How does your comment on my Post help this person an anyway at all other then you just being a jerk, thinking that (Oh because she's a Nurse she thinks she know's everything)??? It doesn't I'm sure. Cause I'd much rather take advice from someone in the medical field then from someone who's just being rude commenting post's on what someone with medical field experience says. Let work together for the better of all of us on MFP. And Take away all of this negativity. Helping people and giving the best advice I can is not just in my job description. It's who I am, It's what I live for. Sorry that you don't like that.0
-
Unfortunately, being a nurse does not make you an expert in dietetics anymore than it makes anyone else in the medical field an expert that is not a registered dietician. With that said, you were countered because science contradicts your post. Low carb diets work IF they are creating a caloric deficit. The same caloric deficit with lots of carbs would show the same results.
While it's nice to be civil, I'm definitely not friends with everyone on here and I don't support posts that aren't true because a lot of people read these threads without commenting and need good information.0 -
Kay2016Sexy wrote: »Funny!!!, Cause there are Lot's of Yeses in my comments. And that's the truth sister, sorry if you don't like it but??? You know I can't please everyone, Not everyone likes the truth. But then again everyone will always have something to say. It should be up to them to decide, My comment was for her and if she want's to she can very freely ask her very own Doctor about my comment and I'm positive that he or she will agree with all that my comment states. And FYI, we are all supposed to be on here as friends to be supportive and offer helpful information. I'm not sure how anyone else feels, but honestly, . . . How does your comment on my Post help this person an anyway at all other then you just being a jerk, thinking that (Oh because she's a Nurse she thinks she know's everything)??? It doesn't I'm sure. Cause I'd much rather take advice from someone in the medical field then from someone who's just being rude commenting post's on what someone with medical field experience says. Let work together for the better of all of us on MFP. And Take away all of this negativity. Helping people and giving the best advice I can is not just in my job description. It's who I am, It's what I live for. Sorry that you don't like that.
It helps because it debunks bad information. Which most of that post was... Like you said, not everyone likes the truth.0 -
Kay2016Sexy wrote: »As a nurse, I'm going to tell you, Low Carb Diets can and do work very well. But as it has already been commented above almost everything has carbs. But the thing is finding out which is good carbs and which are bad carbs. And the amount your allowing your body to take in each day. Following a low-carb diet can help you lose weight, keep blood sugar balanced and lower the amount of triglycerides in the bloodstream. The tricky part is deciding how many carbs you’ll consume and being careful not to go too low unless you’re under the supervision of a registered dietitian or your physician. While some carb-containing foods are on the “do not eat” list, you can still include a variety of healthy carbs on a low-carb diet, as long as you limit portions. As a general guideline, following a low-carb diet means consuming fewer than 130 grams of total carbs daily. Getting fewer than 30 grams of carbs is a very low-carbohydrate ketogenic diet, reported Nutrition and Metabolism in 2008. To protect your health, don’t begin a low-carb diet until you consult a healthcare professional. Once you know your daily carb goals, you can begin to choose the carbs to include on your “do not eat” list. Sweets and baked goods are at the top of the “do not eat” list for several reasons. For starters, they have more carbs than other foods, and they also contain added sugar, which contributes carbs and calories without nutrients, and often have unhealthy saturated or trans fats. Many baked goods provide 30 to 80 grams of carbs per serving, depending on the type of food and serving size. Read all your food labels and look everything up and remember to log it, that way your keeping a good track of what and how much your body is taking in. And remember to drink lots of water. Water is Key in any diet, and it helps flush everything out and helps with keeping you full. I hope this is helpful. And no matter what you choose, I wish you the best of luck, cause let's face it . . . We are all on here for getting fit and staying fit!
Advice to drink water to "flush everything out" is not helpful.
0 -
Kay2016Sexy wrote: »Funny!!!, Cause there are Lot's of Yeses in my comments. And that's the truth sister, sorry if you don't like it but??? You know I can't please everyone, Not everyone likes the truth. But then again everyone will always have something to say. It should be up to them to decide, My comment was for her and if she want's to she can very freely ask her very own Doctor about my comment and I'm positive that he or she will agree with all that my comment states. And FYI, we are all supposed to be on here as friends to be supportive and offer helpful information. I'm not sure how anyone else feels, but honestly, . . . How does your comment on my Post help this person an anyway at all other then you just being a jerk, thinking that (Oh because she's a Nurse she thinks she know's everything)??? It doesn't I'm sure. Cause I'd much rather take advice from someone in the medical field then from someone who's just being rude commenting post's on what someone with medical field experience says. Let work together for the better of all of us on MFP. And Take away all of this negativity. Helping people and giving the best advice I can is not just in my job description. It's who I am, It's what I live for. Sorry that you don't like that.
Firstly. What are good carbs and bad carbs? What does that mean?
Secondly. If you meet your macros for the day and have leftover calories, what would be wrong with some ice cream.
Third. Drinking lots of water is good but it doesn't help you lose anymore weight than drinking tea or coffee.0 -
Being a nurse makes me more accountable for my post, If it wasn't true I would not have said it. That's all. And NO It wouldn't. If you eat more higher carbs, it's not going to be the same as eating low carbs. It doesn't take a genius to know that. High carb food are bad, sorry but they are? If they wasn't then everyone could eat whatever they wanted to. Especially Diabetes patients.0
-
Kay2016Sexy wrote: »Being a nurse makes me more accountable for my post, If it wasn't true I would not have said it. That's all. And NO It wouldn't. If you eat more higher carbs, it's not going to be the same as eating low carbs. It doesn't take a genius to know that. High carb food are bad, sorry but they are? If they wasn't then everyone could eat whatever they wanted to. Especially Diabetes patients.
Where do you work as a nurse? I just wanna know so I never go there for treatment.0 -
Kay2016Sexy wrote: »Being a nurse makes me more accountable for my post, If it wasn't true I would not have said it. That's all. And NO It wouldn't. If you eat more higher carbs, it's not going to be the same as eating low carbs. It doesn't take a genius to know that. High carb food are bad, sorry but they are? If they wasn't then everyone could eat whatever they wanted to. Especially Diabetes patients.
But the OP has said nothing about having diabetes.0 -
i eat high carbs ( around 300 gram a day and sometimes over) and lost weight just fine by eating a balanced diet, counting and weighing my food and creating a deficit. And in 400 days...but i worked hard for it.
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
You should check this website out. Gives you lists of low card fruits veggies, and foods in general. Also give you a list of low carb options for pretty much all fast food restaurants:
http://lowcarbediem.com/
I started low carb diet (<50g carbs/day) Start out at 260 Got down to about 205-210.
Macros were 45% protein/40% fats/15% carbs
I am currently and have been on a diet with 35% calories deficiency which is a bit much but I want to lose fat/weight fast.
2200ish normal cal intake with light activity
1500ish with 35% deficiency.
To help calculate your cal intake and what deficiency you want to be at check out this website below. its simple and great to help calculate your macros and what % deficiency you want to set your diet at
keto-calculator.ankerl.com
If you want to know why the keto diet and why it works, just private message me and I can try to do my best to explain.
Hope this helps0 -
I've lost 95 pounds in 11 months following a low carb high fat diet. I find it a heck of a lot easier to follow this plan then following a low calorie diet. I usually consume 20-30g of carbs per day. The low carbs comes in the form of meet, diary and lots of veggies. I also include berries of many kinds. Following a low carb high fat diet helps fight cravings, keeps blood sugars consistent and I don't restrict anything other then high carb fruits, grains, processed foods and starches. I still have tons of options and tons of energy. Also following this way of eating and the consistent blood sugar levels (aka less cravings), keeps me from getting hungry. I eat one to two meals a day and maybe a snack, which naturally means less calories consumed as well. I eat when I'm hungry and that's it. If you have insulin resistance I highly recommend a low carb diet but be aware that if you do decide to try it you can't eat cake, candy, ice cream even if you are under your macos for carbs for the day. That will defeat the purpose of keeping you insulin levels low and keeping your body in a fat burning mode. Many people think a low carb diet is negative but do some research on your own body. Cutting calories never worked for me because I have insulin issues (not diabetic but just resistance) and as soon as I would eat fruit, processed grains or starchy foods my body would grab onto these foods and instantly turn it to sugar and then fat. I did the low calories, day after day at the gym thing, it just didn't work. My doctor advised me to check this low carb/high fat diet out and my body took to it instantly. Check out Butter Bob on Youtube, he has a lot of great information in video form.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions