Are bananas that bad?
Replies
-
Dead_Darling wrote: »
My other half and his friends have said that it's bad for me, because it has a lot of sugar. I keep stressing that they are naturally occurring sugars and I have it for recovery and energy.
That's just bananas.
Eat bananas if they fit into your goals for the day. They're not evil. Sugar is not evil.
Next time they say those things to you, take a huge bite of banana and ask them, "So what's your point?" It would help if you spew a banana giblet or two onto their face when you ask them that.
I guarantee they will leave you alone after that.
4 -
Do they say that as they drink a nice can of diet soda? Seriously.... I eat Bananas every single day. They are so healthy for you and the pottassium is awesome. Eat away...2
-
I eat a banana almost every day, it's my favorite fruit. I don't see the problem with them, I've managed to drop 80 lbs while still eating them.
2 -
I freeze bananas all the time but in love with the parchment paper idea. The riper the banana the more nutrients and more sugars. Also, focusing on hitting your macros based on your goals, there is nothing wrong. You decide as to how much sugar and what type of sugar, either from whole foods or added sugars. I choose whole foods from fruits and vegetables. I eat green smoothies all the time and I am amazed by all the nutrients I get as oppose to just eating a salad. If it fits your macros, then go for the bananas...0
-
Always remember to eat LESS than 400 at once though, guys:
http://metro.co.uk/2015/09/12/how-many-bananas-would-you-have-to-eat-to-kill-you-5388867/
That catches a lot of people out.9 -
Don't listen to your hubby and their friends...UNLESS they are all nutritionists. I just got pulled from 'nanas and tomatoes, and avocados, and a whole lot more... because, my potassium was dangerously (like LETHALLY) high. I'm diabetic, and this is all related to that. I do so miss these foods, but first, I have to make sure my heart is out of danger. So if you are in generally good health, PLEASE, have a 'nana for me ;-)1
-
Always remember to eat LESS than 400 at once though, guys:
http://metro.co.uk/2015/09/12/how-many-bananas-would-you-have-to-eat-to-kill-you-5388867/
That catches a lot of people out.
*whew*
I was on 399. Was about to eat number 400 - thank goodness you posted this!
I owe you my life, sir. 9 -
Alyssa_Is_LosingIt wrote: »Always remember to eat LESS than 400 at once though, guys:
http://metro.co.uk/2015/09/12/how-many-bananas-would-you-have-to-eat-to-kill-you-5388867/
That catches a lot of people out.
*whew*
I was on 399. Was about to eat number 400 - thank goodness you posted this!
I owe you my life, sir.
Here to help, ma'am.4 -
Once they start getting mushy, I peel and freeze. Awesome straight up or mixed into a shake.1
-
bananas give me awful heartburn...absolutely get rid of the evil things. lol.1
-
Whether they are good or bad is relative to your diet as a whole...they are one of the most sugar rich and hi GI fruits out there....but you have to look at that in the context of your diet as a whole...are you grossly over consuming sugar in general? Do you have blood sugar issues or insulin resistance that would warrant approaching your choices of fruit more carefully?1
-
I eat a banana almost every morning after I run. I find them very filling and love the things.1
-
This content has been removed.
-
The only stage of banana I actually like is when it's still a little green and hard. Any riper and the smell/taste nearly makes me sick.3 -
The only stage of banana I actually like is when it's still a little green and hard. Any riper and the smell/taste nearly makes me sick.
To me, the banana has absolutely no flavor at that point.0 -
cwolfman13 wrote: »Whether they are good or bad is relative to your diet as a whole...they are one of the most sugar rich and hi GI fruits out there....but you have to look at that in the context of your diet as a whole...are you grossly over consuming sugar in general? Do you have blood sugar issues or insulin resistance that would warrant approaching your choices of fruit more carefully?
I usually have low blood sugar levels, but I do try to keep it as low as I can. If I want to consume something sweet, I would go for a piece of fruit, rather than a chocolate bar - and that is not easy for me lol0 -
Frozen bananas in a high speed blender are the best thing ever. I like it BETTER THAN ICE CREAM.1
-
I like unripe bananas .1
-
The only stage of banana I actually like is when it's still a little green and hard. Any riper and the smell/taste nearly makes me sick.
Right there with you. Still a touch of green, still firm, but no longer starchy. That, to my taste buds, is the sweetest stage.2 -
Bananas are amazing. Eat them. Count the calories.
Edit: But throw them away once they get spots on them because then they're gross and evil.
Oh come on people!! This is why I go through huffs of not buying bananas (I work in a kitchen ). They come half way across the world, wrapped in bubble wrap, taken so much time and effort to grow and harvest for people to turn their nose up and bin a banana with a tiny brown patch. That's the sweet bit.
Anyway I watched a programme the other day that apparently bananas have anti viral properties. So, not off my list even though when I was pregnant got told to stay away from fruit's because of the high sugar. I thought they can't be that bad in moderation and they keep me full.2 -
AmberSpamber wrote: »Do they say that as they drink a nice can of diet soda? Seriously.... I eat Bananas every single day. They are so healthy for you and the pottassium is awesome. Eat away...
There's nothing wrong with diet soda, either.....4 -
Chef_Barbell wrote: »
The only stage of banana I actually like is when it's still a little green and hard. Any riper and the smell/taste nearly makes me sick.
To me, the banana has absolutely no flavor at that point.
Under-ripe bananas always leave a weird coating in my mouth. No idea what that is, but it doesn't happen when they're left to ripen properly.0 -
For me, the perfect banana is yellow with a slight tinge of green, no brown spots. However, i store mine in my veggie crisper now and the skin goes a yucky brown colour, but the inside stays the same as when i bought them. I usually eat them within 4-5 days, obviously they wont stay fresh inside if they're left too long.1
-
-
Only if you had a medical issue. Bananas aren't bad. And they are carbs and fiber that feed good bacteria in your gut as well. I just found that out because I am in a study about the gut microbiome. I was low in a specific bacteria that reduces inflammation (I do have an inflammatory disorder). One of the things they suggested I try eating is bananas because it has the carbs that feed that bacteria. Also fried bananas with cinnamon is a yummy dessert (easy to make too).0
-
You can make great, super-healthy "ice cream" by pureeing a sliced, frozen banana with some (unsweetened) cocoa powder, maybe some cinnamon, and just enough plant milk (I use Silk unsweetened vanilla cashew milk). You can even throw in a little frozen mango, too. It comes out like soft serve ice cream, and it's loaded with potassium and all kinds of good things. Banana is great for you, and so is the unsweetened cocoa powder.2
-
You can make great, super-healthy "ice cream" by pureeing a sliced, frozen banana with some (unsweetened) cocoa powder, maybe some cinnamon, and just enough plant milk (I use Silk unsweetened vanilla cashew milk). You can even throw in a little frozen mango, too. It comes out like soft serve ice cream, and it's loaded with potassium and all kinds of good things. Banana is great for you, and so is the unsweetened cocoa powder.
I had been wanting to try this for ages, so i finally did it and my ninja blew up half way through mixing :sad: But yes, it was delicious!!0 -
0
-
Christine_72 wrote: »YES
NO
Definitely NO
Heh, and as usual I am the odd one out, as I would switch the 'no' and the 'yes' here.
Still agree with the 'definitely no', though. Those are for banana pancakes.1 -
Carbs = sugar
I don't know why but I hear that bananas are bad a lot too. Usually from people that don't drink water (soda only) and eat takeout 4-5 times a week. I eat 2 per day usually. Eat up man, bananas in smoothies are the bomb.1
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions