Low Carb Lifestyle?? Yay? Or Nay?? Did you have success?

I've done the Atkins type of diets over and over. You discover new and unique ways to satisfy that sweet-tooth - and still drop pounds. My favorote was Half and Half, and use a handmixter to mix in Sugar-Free Chocolate Fudge pudding. It whips up to a frosting type of consistency - then chill and you have low-carb Chocolate Mousse. Freeze for chocolate ice cream.

So, yes it works. Get those Keto-strips and monitor your ketosis. You can over-do it.

But, I don't support them. Why? Did I lose weight? Yes, I lost 20-50 lbs each and every time I tried it; this is a TEMPORARY lifestyle change. Sooner or later, you are going to have some spaghetti, bread, real ice cream, pancakes - those carbs are going to come back; and you'll resume your old eating habits - and before you know it; you are smack back where you started, plus usually another 10 lbs for good measure.

To get the weight off, and KEEP IT OFF - requires a diet that you can eat, literally anywhere - and some exercise. I'm using MFP to learn to budget my calories. So, light breakfast; and I get Chinese buffet (anything I want) for lunch, and a light supper before bed (probably lightly buttered microwave popcorn and Crystal Light) - and I'll be below my calorie intake for the day - and will STILL manage to lose weight. It's about learning portion control, caloric intake, and budgeting. These are key concepts that the low carb diet does NOT take into acccount.

That weight is only going to come back if you go back to the real ice cream, pancakes, bread, etc. I have a sensitivity to carbs. I eat processed sugary carbs and my blood sugar spikes, I crave more and it is a never ending circle. I dtiched, donuts, pancakes, white bread, spaghetti and tons of other carbs mainly to them being to high in calories and then once I read The Carbohydrate Addicts Diet I kept them gone. It is healthier for me and the only way I can maintain my weight loss. I have tested it time and again. If I add those foods back, I gain and have a terrible time controlling my food intake.

For me it has to be a lifestyle and it has been. I don't miss any of those things that much and I certainly don't miss how they made me feel.

Lindsey thats just awesome with the success you have had over the years. Congrats!

I am doing low carb but not to low... I try to keep it around 100 a day give or take. I do much better without breads, rice, pasta.

The best thing and the most intelligent thing a person can do before starting or making a decision to try a diet is ask YOUR DOCTOR!!!!!! I wish people would stop giving out advice as to whether or not a diet is good or not based upon your own personal experience.

My Endo. Dr. set my Carbs, cals, and fat. As a Diabetic my carbs are set at 130 per day, 5 meals per day, 30 carbs per meal and NOT one over. I guess if a low carb diet was bad for you there would be a lot of dead Diabetics out there.

For those of you that like or on a low carb diet and want to eat pasta, try "Dreamfields". This pasta is really good and was made specifically for Diabetics and low carb dieters. I know a heck of a lot of Diabetics that eat this pasta including me. You only consume like 5 grams of carbs per serving. My Dr. this the one that told me about this pasta.

I eat 1400-1500 calories a day and exercise without thinking about carbohydrates and I am absolutely not hungry. And I still lose weight. I am just doing what MFP has set up here at this website and it has worked for me. My profile pic tells the story.

If you had rather not eat carbohydrates, then that is great! Whatever makes you happy.

And that is great FOR YOU. Certain carbs mess up my leptin levels in my blood and make me gain. So I have to each my carbs. Everyone is different. Gotta do what works for you.

As a student majoring in nutrition, I say nay. Low carb diets are very unhealthy for the body. Diets such as the Atkins diet are so low in carbohydrates that your body will go into a state of ketosis.

You can read more detail about it here: http://women.webmd.com/guide/high-protein-low-carbohydrate-diets

Although low carb diets are tempting due to the quick results, they are not healthy in the long run. If your looking to be fit and health, feed your body with the nutrients it needs and consume a balanced diet. The key to loosing weight is simple, expend more calories than you consume. You will have success and feel great

Hope this helps!



PS- Carbohydrate restricted diets are beneficial for people suffering from insulin resistance issues such as diabetes and polycystic ovarian syndrome.

As a student majoring in nutrition, you should know that Atkins is high fat, not high protein.

Still ends with the same result. It stops your body functioning as it should and forces it to protect its major organs by putting you in ketosis.

And as a student majoring in nutrition, you should know that ketosis is not a dangerous state...it's the body burning stored fat for energy, instead of burning carbs for energy.

Just a question.... If one is following a low carb diet, then how is MFP helpful to you? I wouldn't think you'd need MFP at all if you are doing low carb. ???

I'm following Atkins. I like MFP because they seem to have the widest range of food/nutrition info, they have an app for my smart phone, and i can (and do) set my diary to show carbs, fiber, sugar and calories (because it seems to be defaulted to track calories, I can't seem to remove it). These are the only things I care about tracking. And, of course, these lovely forums...

I don't fear carbs. I fear foods that can make you sick or ill or make you die. Ground beef (e coli); fish (mercury); dairy (just not into cholesterol).

I would like to eat foods that fill me up but not in calories. As I read, some here don't do well with carbs, some do.

For me, eating a low fat diet works, and I am trying to make it a lifestyle.

I do find that products low in fat by weight usually has high sodium (as well as other things).

I would say to go and find comparable products (bring a calculator) and compare calories from a "regular" product and a "low carb" product.

http://www.livestrong.com/thedailyplate/nutrition-calories/food/ezekial-4.9/bread/

http://www.livestrong.com/thedailyplate/nutrition-calories/food/food-for-life/low-carbohydrate-savory-herb-bread/

What the label doesn't tell you in the "low carb" version of the bread is the weight in grams, only 1 slice. So next time you are at the market, compare the two and see if the serving size is the same as well.

Food for thought.

Are there somethings I use to eat that I miss? Sure, but I enjoy being almost 100lbs lighter more.

There are few topics that start more debate than low-carb lifestyle questions! Just reading to learn more, but that quote has to be the best so far!

I followed the Atkins diet for 2.5 years and I was able to maintain my goal wieght. It took a lot of getting used to but once I did I was fine. I felt great. The only reason I stopped was that my appendix burst. While I was in the hospital all the Dr.s and nurses told me to stop following the Atkins diet. I did ....and I have gained 40 lbs. I tried WW several times and I even went back on Atkins but it didn't work the way it did the first time. I have no idea why. As I've tried to drop the lbs. I've tried every diet you can imagine and what I have found is I just can't follow them for long. WW is the best I think because you can eat all the food groups with an emphasis on fruit and vegtables. So the answer to your question is....it worked but not for long and it's difficult to maintain over the long haul. The medical community doesn't like it and you'll catch a lot of grief with them. I'm just trying to follow the nutrient guidelines onmyfitnesspal. I don't seem to ever get it right but I'm still trying. Sugar is a problem for me...that I know so I'm trying to stay away from it as much as I can. Fat I've managed...sugar ....not so much.

I started a Dr recommended low carb diet. It was monitored monthly, but after 3 months was advised to go off. Yes, I lost weight and yes, I lost it fast. But its extremely hard on your body. You will spend many hours in the bathroom and could possibly have trouble with losing your hair. This is probably not typical for everyone but is what happened in my case. Good luck making your decision You have to find what is best for you (and healthy)

Carb Cycling and Keto diets are VERY effective.

Carb Cycling is more with weight training, but it's basically dependant on your training days and what you do. On heavy training days I eat high carbs (2 days a week), Lower intensity days I eat medium carbs (2 days a week), and then I eat very low carbs the other 3 days.

Keto dieters normally eat under 20g-30g of carbs 6 days out of the week, enter ketostis and then they have a refeed day on the 7th day in which they eat high carbs. Then they go back to eating very low again the next day. It's proven to work VERY well depending on your goals. There are some people who can't do it for health reasons or they get sick. Some can though and swear by it.

I hate the 'everything in moderation' approach. If you know something is crap for your body, why eat it? And what is moderation? Once a day, once a week, once a month?

But complex carbs aren't crap for your body. They are fuel. Simple carbs maybe but then they still CAN form part of a healthy diet.

And Ketosis can be dangerous, there is no point just going "it's just making the body burn fat rather than carbs" it's HOW it does that. It's all well and good doing it, having great results, well done. Don't kid yourself that it's without risk. Ketosis is considered an "unhealthy metabolic state" which is why in large the medical profession don't think it's a great idea. And just because your doctor thinks it's ok doesn't mean that all of them do. Effectively you are messing with the normal function of your liver and kidneys so there will be some risk.

It can cause kidney failure, osteoporosis, high calesterol. studies have shown there is an increased risk of cancer, gout, kidney stones, nausea, bad breath, and it messes with monthly cycles in women often making them heavier. Ketoacidosis can cause death as well.

I did it years ago, it worked, then I gained it back despite eating sensibly. Then I got disheartened and didn't eat sensibly and ended up where I am now. For me restrictive diets don't work, lifestyle where nothing is out of bounds as long as the portion is right does. Whatever works for you long term is important.


Some interesting reading...which gives a balanced (ish) view.

http://women.webmd.com/guide/high-protein-low-carbohydrate-diets

For the love of god, will you PLEASE stop spreading misinformation and outright bs? Read a book for goodness sakes. If you don't even know the difference between ketosis and ketoacidiosis you should NOT be posting on this topic at all. Honestly, I read this crap and for the most part can let it slide as just ignorance but when the same person persists in posting the same idiocy over and over I'm going to reply and I don't care whose feathers get ruffled.

And Ketosis can be dangerous, there is no point just going "it's just making the body burn fat rather than carbs" it's HOW it does that. It's all well and good doing it, having great results, well done. Don't kid yourself that it's without risk. Ketosis is considered an "unhealthy metabolic state" which is why in large the medical profession don't think it's a great idea. And just because your doctor thinks it's ok doesn't mean that all of them do. Effectively you are messing with the normal function of your liver and kidneys so there will be some risk.

It can cause kidney failure, osteoporosis, high calesterol. studies have shown there is an increased risk of cancer, gout, kidney stones, nausea, bad breath, and it messes with monthly cycles in women often making them heavier. Ketoacidosis can cause death as well.

I did it years ago, it worked, then I gained it back despite eating sensibly. Then I got disheartened and didn't eat sensibly and ended up where I am now. For me restrictive diets don't work, lifestyle where nothing is out of bounds as long as the portion is right does. Whatever works for you long term is important.


Some interesting reading...which gives a balanced (ish) view.

http://women.webmd.com/guide/high-protein-low-carbohydrate-diets

For the love of god, will you PLEASE stop spreading misinformation and outright bs? Read a book for goodness sakes. If you don't even know the difference between ketosis and ketoacidiosis you should NOT be posting on this topic at all. Honestly, I read this crap and for the most part can let it slide as just ignorance but when the same person persists in posting the same idiocy over and over I'm going to reply and I don't care whose feathers get ruffled.

Don't worry, I'd have to give a *kitten* about your opinion to ruffle my feathers. I've read plenty of books, including Atkins, but funnily enough people trying to sell you things don't give a balanced view. Ketosis can cause problems, I have first hand experience of the problems it causes plus I see a lot of people go through clinic and see it too.

Information such as that presented in this article where it says:

There are several disadvantages and dangers of ketogenic diets. The most significant danger is the risk associated with ketosis itself. Pregnant women, alcoholics, or persons suffering from kidney or liver disease should never undertake a ketogenic diet.

Says nothing about ketoacidosis. I did mention there is a difference in my first post, one injures your body and the other kills you.

There is plenty out there too support how I feel about the "diets" which use Ketosis, including the American Heart Association. It IS a risk, that's proven fact, I didn't say anywhere that it would happen to you, all I said is there are risk factors.

I'm not sure what about my posts has shot your panties so far up your *kitten* other than you seem to be very defensive. Ketosis itself does carry risks, that's why pregnant women, those with kidney or liver function problems and diabetics are told NEVER do do diets which encourage Ketosis. Ketoacidosis is much more serious and not recognised as a good diet for anyone (although I'm told you lose 7lbs when you die, which is a pretty good loss instantly).

ATEOTD I said there are risks. Forcing your body to work in a way it's not designed too, like being a big fat *kitten* does, will always carry risks. You'd have to be a total dumb *kitten* not to realise it. I did have a great book which clearly explained what happened to the body when it went in to ketosis but it's packed up as I'm moving in two weeks.

But seriously. Calm down dear. It's only a diet. With risks. Like any diet.