Tracking in grams
jenwil1999
Posts: 38 Member
I know the importance of weighing food to be most accurate, but logging that can be so difficult when all the entries don't use weight. For example, I had oatmeal and my box tells me that one serving is 1/2 c or 45 grams. So I measure 45 grams. But when I go to log it, most options for oatmeal use cups or milliliter or ounces.... it's so frustrating that most foods don't seems to have grams as one of their options. So whatever, I pick the half cup. After all, I need to keep this quick and easy to be consistent with tracking.
But then, I'll get something like the teaspoon of brown sugar that I added to it. I don't have the box, so I'm not sure how many grams are in a teaspoon. When I check on here, none of the brown sugar entries that seem reliable have grams! So I measure by teaspoon, weigh it to get an idea (it was about 5 g), and then enter 1 teaspoon. But I have no idea if 5 g is 1 teaspoon. I googled it, answers seem to range from 4.3 to 17 g.... but honestly if I can't find the answer in a few minutes, I just take my best guess and move on with my life.
So how do you do it? Weighing everything is not the problem, it's figuring out how many grams are in a serving and using that on MFP.
But then, I'll get something like the teaspoon of brown sugar that I added to it. I don't have the box, so I'm not sure how many grams are in a teaspoon. When I check on here, none of the brown sugar entries that seem reliable have grams! So I measure by teaspoon, weigh it to get an idea (it was about 5 g), and then enter 1 teaspoon. But I have no idea if 5 g is 1 teaspoon. I googled it, answers seem to range from 4.3 to 17 g.... but honestly if I can't find the answer in a few minutes, I just take my best guess and move on with my life.
So how do you do it? Weighing everything is not the problem, it's figuring out how many grams are in a serving and using that on MFP.
0
Replies
-
I enter the items that I use in My Foods and don't share them with the database. It takes time to set up (but not really much more time than searching for a usable entry) and is so much easier after that. I use grams as the serving unit for solids and any semi-solids or liquids that have grams listed in the nutritional info and milliliters for liquids that list milliliters in the nutrition info.
Entering items myself also lets me customize the names.3 -
jenwil1999 wrote: »I know the importance of weighing food to be most accurate, but logging that can be so difficult when all the entries don't use weight. For example, I had oatmeal and my box tells me that one serving is 1/2 c or 45 grams. So I measure 45 grams. But when I go to log it, most options for oatmeal use cups or milliliter or ounces.... it's so frustrating that most foods don't seems to have grams as one of their options. So whatever, I pick the half cup. After all, I need to keep this quick and easy to be consistent with tracking.
But then, I'll get something like the teaspoon of brown sugar that I added to it. I don't have the box, so I'm not sure how many grams are in a teaspoon. When I check on here, none of the brown sugar entries that seem reliable have grams! So I measure by teaspoon, weigh it to get an idea (it was about 5 g), and then enter 1 teaspoon. But I have no idea if 5 g is 1 teaspoon. I googled it, answers seem to range from 4.3 to 17 g.... but honestly if I can't find the answer in a few minutes, I just take my best guess and move on with my life.
So how do you do it? Weighing everything is not the problem, it's figuring out how many grams are in a serving and using that on MFP.
A lot of the entries have a pull down menu so you can choose grams, ounces, etc. If they don't, and it's a food that you use often, create the entry yourself and just use that one in future.
It's a bit labour-intensive at first, but once you get all your 'normal' foods input, it gets much easier. I've been here two years, and only occasionally do I have to add a new entry when I eat something I haven't logged before.
5 -
@seska422 That does sounds very time intensive but customized. I can definitely see the value and accuracy in that.
@snickerscharlie I am aware of those options, but they usually don't include grams. In fact, I find it annoying when an item has 10 options, three of them are for cups (1/4 c, 1/2 c, 1 c - all of which could be calculated easily by adjusting the servings) and none are for grams.
Both of you mentioned time-intensive, and I get that, but for me it's not just "at first". I did all that back when I first tracked in 2008 (databases were HORRIBLE then and no smartphone) and after a few months, I realized how rarely I repeat foods. I was still constantly entering the info. Then I moved to a new country, where it was completely impossible (I had no idea what the ingredients were most of the time). Then I moved to a third country.... I just move every 1-2 years and find that I don't keep the same diet / routines. It makes all routines hard to keep for more than a few months (sleep, exercise, food) and it's exhausting constantly trying to establish new routines. I'll be moving again in 5 months after 2 years here. Anyway, the point was that I really like to be able to use the database - the vast improvements in the databases over the past couple years is the exact thing that's brought me back to tracking on an app.
Anyway, I guess I just wish there was some way I could edit other people's items on the database to include grams. Many of them have great detailed info, I just want one more key piece. Then again, half the time I don't know what the grams are either!0 -
jenwil1999 wrote: »@seska422 That does sounds very time intensive but customized. I can definitely see the value and accuracy in that.
@snickerscharlie I am aware of those options, but they usually don't include grams. In fact, I find it annoying when an item has 10 options, three of them are for cups (1/4 c, 1/2 c, 1 c - all of which could be calculated easily by adjusting the servings) and none are for grams.
Both of you mentioned time-intensive, and I get that, but for me it's not just "at first". I did all that back when I first tracked in 2008 (databases were HORRIBLE then and no smartphone) and after a few months, I realized how rarely I repeat foods. I was still constantly entering the info. Then I moved to a new country, where it was completely impossible (I had no idea what the ingredients were most of the time). Then I moved to a third country.... I just move every 1-2 years and find that I don't keep the same diet / routines. It makes all routines hard to keep for more than a few months (sleep, exercise, food) and it's exhausting constantly trying to establish new routines. I'll be moving again in 5 months after 2 years here. Anyway, the point was that I really like to be able to use the database - the vast improvements in the databases over the past couple years is the exact thing that's brought me back to tracking on an app.
Anyway, I guess I just wish there was some way I could edit other people's items on the database to include grams. Many of them have great detailed info, I just want one more key piece. Then again, half the time I don't know what the grams are either!
You *can* easily edit an existing entry to include grams.
Click on the green box underneath the entry in the database that says "Nutrition Information." That will then bring up a mini screen asking, "Is this data accurate?" If you click on "No," you can then change the entry to whatever suits you. I have often converted good entries that were measured in cups or servings, for example, to the gram equivalent and then saved it for my future use. 4 -
jenwil1999 wrote: »I know the importance of weighing food to be most accurate, but logging that can be so difficult when all the entries don't use weight. For example, I had oatmeal and my box tells me that one serving is 1/2 c or 45 grams. So I measure 45 grams. But when I go to log it, most options for oatmeal use cups or milliliter or ounces.... it's so frustrating that most foods don't seems to have grams as one of their options. So whatever, I pick the half cup. After all, I need to keep this quick and easy to be consistent with tracking.
But then, I'll get something like the teaspoon of brown sugar that I added to it. I don't have the box, so I'm not sure how many grams are in a teaspoon. When I check on here, none of the brown sugar entries that seem reliable have grams! So I measure by teaspoon, weigh it to get an idea (it was about 5 g), and then enter 1 teaspoon. But I have no idea if 5 g is 1 teaspoon. I googled it, answers seem to range from 4.3 to 17 g.... but honestly if I can't find the answer in a few minutes, I just take my best guess and move on with my life.
So how do you do it? Weighing everything is not the problem, it's figuring out how many grams are in a serving and using that on MFP.
If it's something I know the calories are right (or close enough) on, then I just say, "Hey, I know what I ate, this log is accurate." It doesn't matter that the entry says cups, just that I know that I ate one serving of so many calories.
If it's something I don't know the calories for, I search the USDA Nutritional Database. Once I know the calories I'm looking for -- say, that I know 3oz of X is Y calories -- I can use a database entry that reflect those numbers.
This may be tedious, if you eat a wide variety of foods. I tend to stick in the wheelhouse of the same things in different combinations.
Edited to add: sometimes you can use the USDA number and name to find an entry that reflects the USDA values, e.g. if you wanted to find an entry that reflected this value for apples, you could search "apple usda 09003". I've done it with chicken breast and had luck, but I imagine it varies.1 -
If you measured 45 grams, and 45 grams equals a half-cup on the packaging, then by entering a half-cup on your diary you entered the correct amount.1
-
quiksylver296 wrote: »If you measured 45 grams, and 45 grams equals a half-cup on the packaging, then by entering a half-cup on your diary you entered the correct amount.
No, because 1/2 cup is volume and grams is weight. 1/2 cup of my oatmeal (dry) always weighs more than 45 grams, as much as 60g. That's why weighing is important, rather than cups.
OP, does your scales toggle between ounces and grams? Mine does. If you are having trouble finding grams, you can press the units button on the scale to get the readout in ounces. I understand that your diet might change every few years, but does it change so radically from day to day that you rarely use the same entry? Sugar? Oatmeal? That's amazing!2 -
I've found that most things can be found with weight as an option...are you looking up your particular brand of oatmeal...if it's listed in grams on the packaging, there should be such an entry in MFP.0
-
quiksylver296 wrote: »If you measured 45 grams, and 45 grams equals a half-cup on the packaging, then by entering a half-cup on your diary you entered the correct amount.
No, because 1/2 cup is volume and grams is weight. 1/2 cup of my oatmeal (dry) always weighs more than 45 grams, as much as 60g. That's why weighing is important, rather than cups.
OP, does your scales toggle between ounces and grams? Mine does. If you are having trouble finding grams, you can press the units button on the scale to get the readout in ounces. I understand that your diet might change every few years, but does it change so radically from day to day that you rarely use the same entry? Sugar? Oatmeal? That's amazing!
Some labels state that a cup/spoon size equals a certain weight.
All the entries I use are for grams (unless liquid)... I haven't had any issues finding entries, and I just make my own entries for the few obscure things I've eaten0 -
quiksylver296 wrote: »If you measured 45 grams, and 45 grams equals a half-cup on the packaging, then by entering a half-cup on your diary you entered the correct amount.
No, because 1/2 cup is volume and grams is weight. 1/2 cup of my oatmeal (dry) always weighs more than 45 grams, as much as 60g. That's why weighing is important, rather than cups.
If the packaging on the oatmeal states .5 cups (45 g) is 100 calories, and OP weighs out 45 grams, but enters it on MFP as .5 cups, she'll get 100 calories. It'll work.
However, if she uses a measuring cup to measure .5 cups, there is definitely room for error.4 -
I just looked up Oatmeal, dry. It has the option of 1g. So you can weigh the oatmeal dry.
Look up Brown sugar, grams. I also has the 1g option.0 -
Wow, thanks everyone! This is awesome!
@snickerscharlie So glad to know how to edit an entry! I looked for the options, but thought only the original contributor could do it. That will definitely make my life easier.
@gramarye The USDA numbers are great advice - it never occurred to me to search with the USDA numbers.
Everyone's right, my log is technically correct if I put 1/2 c for 45 grams. It just gets annoying to constantly convert. Also, I tend to buy things that aren't in standard packaging - my peanut butter was fresh ground at a farmer's market. So often the best I can do is take a good estimate. I know that an average serving is 2 tbl with 180 calories.... but I'm adding 30 g to my smoothie. If just feels like a lot of estimating and room for error. And I have to repeat it every time I use that peanut butter.0 -
OP, does your scales toggle between ounces and grams? Mine does. If you are having trouble finding grams, you can press the units button on the scale to get the readout in ounces.
Yes, my scale has both measurements. I'm honestly worried about using ounces because I'm often not sure if the entry on the database means weight or fluid ounces. For example with the peanut butter - it could be either, depending on the person who made the entry.I understand that your diet might change every few years, but does it change so radically from day to day that you rarely use the same entry? Sugar? Oatmeal? That's amazing!
I know this sounds crazy, but it seems like it. Your question has made me think carefully about my breakfasts. I know for a fact that the last time I bought oatmeal was 3 years ago in Thailand. I had it every day for a couple weeks. Since then, I've lived in 3 countries and many things were purchased once, fully consumed for a week or two, then never purchased again. Or I made a recipe that I never repeated or changed significantly. I'd say probably only 30% of my food is commonly repeated, with maybe another 10-20% repeated within a year.
0 -
Lovee_Dove7 wrote: »I just looked up Oatmeal, dry. It has the option of 1g. So you can weigh the oatmeal dry.
Look up Brown sugar, grams. I also has the 1g option.
You're absolutely right about adding grams to the search!0 -
I really appreciate everyone's responses! I've definitely got some great ideas here.
One final question if people don't mind. I rarely make a recipe exactly the same - I tend to cook to taste and substitute. For some of the things I cook more often, I'd like to create a recipe with portions... but the ingredients can change radically from time to time. Any suggestions on that? Should I just log the ingredients separately each day?0 -
jenwil1999 wrote: »I really appreciate everyone's responses! I've definitely got some great ideas here.
One final question if people don't mind. I rarely make a recipe exactly the same - I tend to cook to taste and substitute. For some of the things I cook more often, I'd like to create a recipe with portions... but the ingredients can change radically from time to time. Any suggestions on that? Should I just log the ingredients separately each day?
I would log the ingredients for one portion separately - you can copy the meal in to other days to make it easier after that.0 -
livingleanlivingclean wrote: »jenwil1999 wrote: »I really appreciate everyone's responses! I've definitely got some great ideas here.
One final question if people don't mind. I rarely make a recipe exactly the same - I tend to cook to taste and substitute. For some of the things I cook more often, I'd like to create a recipe with portions... but the ingredients can change radically from time to time. Any suggestions on that? Should I just log the ingredients separately each day?
I would log the ingredients for one portion separately - you can copy the meal in to other days to make it easier after that.
This is what I do. Like, if I cooked chicken with butter and sauces and whatnot, I'll logged each thing separately (7g of butter, 160g of chicken breast, 1 tbsp lime juice, etc).
I also leave standard recipes in the recipe builder -- like, I have a potato soup entry, because we make it frequently but it's not exactly the same each time. When I'm cooking I write down what I'm using on a dry erase board in the kitchen, and then update my recipe in MFP before dinner.0 -
livingleanlivingclean wrote: »jenwil1999 wrote: »I really appreciate everyone's responses! I've definitely got some great ideas here.
One final question if people don't mind. I rarely make a recipe exactly the same - I tend to cook to taste and substitute. For some of the things I cook more often, I'd like to create a recipe with portions... but the ingredients can change radically from time to time. Any suggestions on that? Should I just log the ingredients separately each day?
I would log the ingredients for one portion separately - you can copy the meal in to other days to make it easier after that.
This is what I do. Like, if I cooked chicken with butter and sauces and whatnot, I'll logged each thing separately (7g of butter, 160g of chicken breast, 1 tbsp lime juice, etc).
I also leave standard recipes in the recipe builder -- like, I have a potato soup entry, because we make it frequently but it's not exactly the same each time. When I'm cooking I write down what I'm using on a dry erase board in the kitchen, and then update my recipe in MFP before dinner.
I do the same thing with my recipes. I adjust the ingredients I used that time and put the new weight for servings in every time i make it.
1 -
jenwil1999 wrote: »Wow, thanks everyone! This is awesome!
@snickerscharlie So glad to know how to edit an entry! I looked for the options, but thought only the original contributor could do it. That will definitely make my life easier.
When I edit or correct an existing entry, I also add my initials to the title line in brackets. That way, if I'm ever searching the database again for that particular item, the one that's mine is easy to find. 1 -
I have been logging it all separately, but one thing I don't like is how it make the log look. I know that sounds minor, but when I flip through a few days before and see "chicken, yogurt, avacado...." I have to try and guess which recipe it was. Plus it makes the log pretty long. It's so much easier to see "Chicken Salad, bread..." and know I had a chicken salad sandwich. However, I know it's accurate, and that's most important.I also leave standard recipes in the recipe builder -- like, I have a potato soup entry, because we make it frequently but it's not exactly the same each time. When I'm cooking I write down what I'm using on a dry erase board in the kitchen, and then update my recipe in MFP before dinner.
I love this idea! Especially the white board - I keep scribbling it on my grocery lists. One question, does updating the recipe change past entries? I'm guessing not if you're using it, but maybe you haven't checked.
I'm also thinking I might just make a "base recipe" for common things and leave off the ingredients that often change, then just add those to the log. One problem is remembering which parts of recipe are not in log. Looks like I just need to experiment more.snickerscharlie wrote: »When I edit or correct an existing entry, I also add my initials to the title line in brackets. That way, if I'm ever searching the database again for that particular item, the one that's mine is easy to find.
Also a great idea! So much easier to start with good procedures / practices from the beginning.
0 -
The other one is, if you use the app - use the barcode scanner - that way you are taken to the entry that usually matches the label. And if the label is in grams, so will that entry usually be0
-
dutchandkiwi wrote: »The other one is, if you use the app - use the barcode scanner - that way you are taken to the entry that usually matches the label. And if the label is in grams, so will that entry usually be
I find the barcode scanner to be completely inaccurate..... I rarely have food with labels to scan, but the few I have tried to scan were wrong and I had to change them anyway!1 -
livingleanlivingclean wrote: »dutchandkiwi wrote: »The other one is, if you use the app - use the barcode scanner - that way you are taken to the entry that usually matches the label. And if the label is in grams, so will that entry usually be
I find the barcode scanner to be completely inaccurate..... I rarely have food with labels to scan, but the few I have tried to scan were wrong and I had to change them anyway!
The barcode scanner still looks items up in the same mostly user-entered database that's accessed when you use the search function. As you discovered, database items need to be double-checked for accuracy no matter which lookup method is used.0 -
jenwil1999 wrote: »I have been logging it all separately, but one thing I don't like is how it make the log look. I know that sounds minor, but when I flip through a few days before and see "chicken, yogurt, avacado...." I have to try and guess which recipe it was. Plus it makes the log pretty long. It's so much easier to see "Chicken Salad, bread..." and know I had a chicken salad sandwich. However, I know it's accurate, and that's most important.I also leave standard recipes in the recipe builder -- like, I have a potato soup entry, because we make it frequently but it's not exactly the same each time. When I'm cooking I write down what I'm using on a dry erase board in the kitchen, and then update my recipe in MFP before dinner.
I love this idea! Especially the white board - I keep scribbling it on my grocery lists. One question, does updating the recipe change past entries? I'm guessing not if you're using it, but maybe you haven't checked.
It doesn't -- I wondered the same thing the first time I did it. Deleting recipes also doesn't remove them from your log. (I delete stuff out of my personalized recipes all the time to keep it tidy.)
That said, I haven't checked that in a couple of years. It's possible that they've changed that function, but I can't imagine why they would.0 -
It doesn't -- I wondered the same thing the first time I did it. Deleting recipes also doesn't remove them from your log. (I delete stuff out of my personalized recipes all the time to keep it tidy.)
That said, I haven't checked that in a couple of years. It's possible that they've changed that function, but I can't imagine why they would.
Cool, I'll check it out and experiment. Thanks for the tips!
0 -
jenwil1999 wrote: »I know the importance of weighing food to be most accurate, but logging that can be so difficult when all the entries don't use weight. // Weighing everything is not the problem, it's figuring out how many grams are in a serving and using that on MFP.
@jenwil1999 I recommend some good reads for you and Yes I have "Spammed - Copied and Pasted" this same post to others. I suggest some links to good posts that have been a great help to many.
Picking an item from the Food Database can be a challenge due to the huge number of Multiple Entries with similar names and bad data. As stated by others above it gets easier once the 4 pages of your Food Item's gets populated.
I also look for items that have a Grams Reference and USDA in the name - especially if followed by the reference number as this indicates someone took the time to look in the USDA web site for that item and used it as their reference. I will compare the MFP Nutrition Data to the USDA Data.
An example would be Usda 08130 Instant Oatmeal - Maple & Brown Sugar.
I recommend the link below to Logging Accurately as it has been one I constantly refer back to.
logging-accurately-step-by-step-guide
At the Top of most Forums you will see a Discussion with the Words Announcement underneath them. As an example go into the General Diet and Weight Loss Forum.
general-diet-and-weight-loss-help
You will see Announcement Posts ( Closed ) and a list of additional posts by members. If you open the Announcement Post you will see a list of Links to posts that are a great source of information.
most-helpful-posts-general-diet-and-weight-loss-help-must-reads
Of all the "Stickied" Posts these are some of the ones that I keep referring back to all the time.
important-posts-to-read
youre-probably-eating-more-than-you-think
A-guide-to-get-you-started-on-your-path-to-sexypants
how-and-why-to-use-a-digital-food-scale
A 4 part Blog about the power of habits.
The-power-of-habit-part-1-why-habits-matter-688130
These are just a few of the many other great posts that have been so helpful.
http://blog.myfitnesspal.com/1-hour-to-food-prep-your-fast-easy-plan-for-success/
http://blog.myfitnesspal.com/meal-planning-for-beginners/
http://fit101.org/the-step-by-step-guide-to-losing-weight-with-myfitnesspal/
https://blog.myfitnesspal.com/the-beginners-guide-to-myfitnesspal/
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1296011/calorie-counting-1010 -
@juliet3455 thanks for all the helpful links! I'll definitely check them out!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions