oohhh new study!! too much water is bad for u

sesefeeney
sesefeeney Posts: 71 Member
edited September 29 in Health and Weight Loss
new study says too much water can actually damage ur kidney and dehydration is a myth!!!
http://style.uk.msn.com/health/could-drinking-too-much-water-be-bad-for-you
sorry but they do state how much is too much - Dr. Margaret McCartney, a general practitioner who works in Glasgow, says telling people to drink two and a half pints, of water every day "not only nonsense, but thoroughly debunked nonsense."
would love to hear peoples views on this!
my opinion- water is a bit overated. 2 pints a day has always been fine for me but most articles say 2and a half or more depending on body mass
«134

Replies

  • RagtimeLady
    RagtimeLady Posts: 172 Member
    I trust mother nature! When I'm thirsty, I drink. Wow. What a concept! I've never had a problem dehydrating.
  • Rage_Phish
    Rage_Phish Posts: 1,507 Member
    Too much water is bad for you and can be lethal
  • brendalyne
    brendalyne Posts: 497
    If you read carefully, it says: 'The current evidence is that there really is no evidence' to support the idea that water helps people to lose weight by suppressing their appetite. MY COMMENT - I DONT EXPECT IT TO "SUPPRESS" MY APPETITE!

    We've also been told that drinking water is good for flushing out bacteria from our kidneys but a study has found that it could actually cause kidney damage, instead of preventing it. It has also been found that drinking excessive amounts of water can also lead to disrupted sleep as people have to get up in the night to go to the toilet. MY COMMENT - WHAT'S THE DEFINITION OF "EXCESSIVE AMOUNTS" OF WATER? AND YEAH - IF YOU DRINK LOTS OF WATER BEFORE YOU GO TO BED, YOU'RE GONNA WAKE UP TO USE THE RESTROOM. SO MAYBE STOP A FEW HOURS BEFORE BED - BUT FRANKLY, I'M AT THAT AGE WHERE I'M GONNA GET UP AND USE THE RESTROOM DURING THE NIGHT ANYWAY.

    So, I suppose if you're looking for an excuse to drink less water, here it is. Me? I'll just keep drinking my 10-12 cups a day. I believe in the benefits of drinking water.
  • suprfast
    suprfast Posts: 49
    too much of anything is bad. I would guess most people consume too little water so the story would apply to the one in ten million.

    I consume upwards around one gallon of water per day. There are days where I feel its too little, others that I must force myself to choke down. Just drink it.
  • brianpride
    brianpride Posts: 27 Member
    Too much of ANYTHING can be bad for you. Everything in moderation is my motto. (Someday I might even live up to it.)
  • greeneyed84
    greeneyed84 Posts: 427 Member
    Obviously too much of anything isn't good. Duh. But dehydration a myth? That's just stupid
  • mialsya
    mialsya Posts: 188 Member
    If you read carefully, it says: 'The current evidence is that there really is no evidence' to support the idea that water helps people to lose weight by suppressing their appetite. MY COMMENT - I DONT EXPECT IT TO "SUPPRESS" MY APPETITE!

    We've also been told that drinking water is good for flushing out bacteria from our kidneys but a study has found that it could actually cause kidney damage, instead of preventing it. It has also been found that drinking excessive amounts of water can also lead to disrupted sleep as people have to get up in the night to go to the toilet. MY COMMENT - WHAT'S THE DEFINITION OF "EXCESSIVE AMOUNTS" OF WATER? AND YEAH - IF YOU DRINK LOTS OF WATER BEFORE YOU GO TO BED, YOU'RE GONNA WAKE UP TO USE THE RESTROOM. SO MAYBE STOP A FEW HOURS BEFORE BED - BUT FRANKLY, I'M AT THAT AGE WHERE I'M GONNA GET UP AND USE THE RESTROOM DURING THE NIGHT ANYWAY.

    So, I suppose if you're looking for an excuse to drink less water, here it is. Me? I'll just keep drinking my 10-12 cups a day. I believe in the benefits of drinking water.

    Well said!
  • MissTomGettingThin
    MissTomGettingThin Posts: 776 Member
    Obviously too much of anything isn't good. Duh. But dehydration a myth? That's just stupid

    I agree.
    If you're thirsty you're already in need of a drink by then.
    Drink a bit throughout the day and more if actually thirsty. Should be good :O)

    I think that makes sense anyway,
  • PeachyKeene
    PeachyKeene Posts: 1,645 Member
    http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/292099-great-article-to-read-about-drinking-water-and-hydration



    Interesting in deed! I posted this topic this morning.^^^
  • DonM46
    DonM46 Posts: 772 Member
    I was hospitalized for dehydration a few years ago. There for 3 days. You don't want to go there.
    Better to overhydrate than UNDER.
  • Amo_Angelus
    Amo_Angelus Posts: 604 Member
    pft, everyone knows too much water is bad for your kidneys, but too much water is almost impossible to do without trying.
    And dehydration a myth? That's just ridiculous.
  • waterjogger
    waterjogger Posts: 114
    My kidney dr is always telling me to drink more water to prevent dehydration! I'm going to do what he tells me to do!
  • kappy_hollowell
    kappy_hollowell Posts: 399
    This study seems very vague. It just says "evidence" and "studies," but gives no real hard facts about them.

    When I get thirsty, I'm going to drink water. Regardless of how much I've already had.

    IMO, water just takes up room in the stomach making you feel fuller; it does for me anyway.

    In the end, something is going to end up hurting us or killng us, I'd rather it be too much water than to be thirsty all the time. :wink:
  • fbmandy55
    fbmandy55 Posts: 5,263 Member
    This is my opinion on studies. For every one study, therer are 20 more that prove it wrong. Studies are usually funded by special interests that are looking for a specific result anyway.

    I think it's safe to drink a moderate amount daily. You should have at least a little bit but you don't need 20 gallons a day.
  • kappy_hollowell
    kappy_hollowell Posts: 399
    Too much water is bad for you and can be lethal

    and do you have proof? Just sayin
  • FairyMiss
    FairyMiss Posts: 1,812 Member
    i would not hold much to that article , it has random quotes and the word study thrown in a few times, but no indication of what studies and done where. Infact no real facts to back up anything it says
  • kerriknox
    kerriknox Posts: 276 Member
    Sounds like a non-news article to me. They quote one general practitioner, and claim to have new studies but do not reference them or give any links.

    Yes - excessive water can be damaging but not the amounts currently recommended to us.

    Looks like they just needed a filler article.
  • brendalyne
    brendalyne Posts: 497
    I read an artical that said - A lethal amount of water in a full grown human is about 100 oz at once, give or take. The "AT ONCE" is an important statement. Spread your water intake out over the day, and it would never be lethal. I personally am not going to take the risk of getting dehydrated! I do not believe that "dehydration is a mthy! Beside - I LIKE water! - :drinker:
  • Mad_Dog_Muscle
    Mad_Dog_Muscle Posts: 1,251 Member
    I call BS on this one! Its just like the egg debate, one year too many eggs are bad for you, the next year you can eat 12 in one sitting and its good for you!
    Besides, I am sure I dont drink too much water! I drink a lot, anywhere from 3-6 litres in a day!
    always a good discussion through! thanks for the post!
  • webdiva1
    webdiva1 Posts: 326 Member
    I drink a lot of water, so I checked it out.

    I see no scientific data at all. The two experts quoted include a general practitioner (really? a GP?) and Dr. Stanley Goldfarb from the University of Pennsylvania. He, at least, has some cred. His one and only quote: "'The current evidence is that there really is no evidence' to support the idea that water helps people to lose weight by suppressing their appetite". OK. That's plausible, I guess. Makes me feel more full, so that's all the proof I need. :)

    But then the article really lost me, starting with this ridiculous quote: "We've also been told that drinking water is good for flushing out bacteria from our kidneys but a study has found that it could actually cause kidney damage, instead of preventing it." WHO said that -- and who did they tell? Who did the study? When was it? If it was an honest-to-goodness scientific study, the author should have named names and provided publication details.

    At this point, the article had zero credibility, far as I was concerned, But there was one final straw -- and it made me laugh out loud: "It has also been found that drinking excessive amounts of water can also lead to disrupted sleep as people have to get up in the night to go to the toilet."

    Wow. I'm shocked.

    The article is dribble, far as I'm concerned. Just my opinion.
  • Rage_Phish
    Rage_Phish Posts: 1,507 Member
    Too much water is bad for you and can be lethal

    and do you have proof? Just sayin

    the kid who died my freshman year of college from being forced to consume huge amounts o water during a frat hazing.

    http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5012154

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_intoxication
  • ktblum
    ktblum Posts: 15 Member
    Well, here's my opinion. The clincher for me is that this a "new study". In my mind, one new study does not negate years of study showing the benefits of drinking water. Water is one of the only natural liquids that doesn't have a bunch of junk added to it. Our bodies are mostly made up of water. We need it. And I find that as I drink water, I want more water.

    I suppose if you are a person who sits all day and drinks copious amounts of water just for the sake of drinking water, you will probably have some unpleasant sife affects.

    If they did a study on North America, they'd probably find that the majority of people are dehydrated.
  • chevy88grl
    chevy88grl Posts: 3,937 Member
    Everything is bad for you if you consume it in LARGE quantities.

    I'll continue to drink my 80-100oz of water a day - I feel better, my skin looks better, I have energy AND I sleep better (course, I don't drink a HUGE glass of water RIGHT before bed... which would make me need to use the bathroom). The positive side effects *I* personally witness hold far more weight with me than an article.
  • Meyra77
    Meyra77 Posts: 5
    Dehydration happens and it doesn't feel good at all. It is true, that too much water is not good for you, but a "normal" person can not drink the amount of water that is needed to damage your kidneys or any body functions. So do not worry! If you are looking for an excuse to stick to your sodas go ahead, but before you do that, you should read up on the ingredients and what they "can" cause. You should keep everything in moderation and that it is just fine. 8 cups of water are recommended, 12 will not hurt you one or two less will not hurt you either, just like a soda once in a while won't hurt you.
  • bcattoes
    bcattoes Posts: 17,299 Member
    new study says too much water can actually damage ur kidney and dehydration is a myth!!!
    http://style.uk.msn.com/health/could-drinking-too-much-water-be-bad-for-you
    would love to hear peoples views on this!

    I didn't see anything in there about a NEW study. It seemed they were just repeating what previous studies have shown. The real problem is not that 8 glasses (eight 8 oz glasses) of water a day is bad for you, it's that people think that guideline is based on scientific fact, which if they took even a little time to research it they would see has never been true. It's just a simple way of telling the public how much the fluid "average adult" (whatever that is!) needs daily. It doesn't have to be in the form of plain water, nor does it need to be in liquid form. Water can be obtained from any beverage and from many foods. But I think the experts who first started touting the 8 glasses a day failed to realize just how lazy the average adult is. Many just read the headline "drink 8 glasses of water a day" and extrapolate from there they need 8 glasses of plain water in addition to anything else they consumre, and that if 8 is good, surely more must be better. And that, simply is not true. It's also not new information. Many reputable medical sources have been saying the same thing for years.
  • greeneyed84
    greeneyed84 Posts: 427 Member
    Too much water is bad for you and can be lethal

    and do you have proof? Just sayin
    [/quote



    There was actually a woman who died hours after having a water drinking contest. I don't remember hoe much she had but it was a lot more than anyone drinks on here day to day
  • jpeper1966
    jpeper1966 Posts: 79
    If yu have to force yourself to drink, then you are drinking too much. Your body knows what it needs and will let you know when you need it. Drink when you are thirsty, it is as simple as that.

    People swarm on these "studies" much like fishermen swarm a spot on a lake where someone catches a trophy fish. It's the curse of the "information age". We get way too much information. It makes people paranoid and obsessive
  • ktblum
    ktblum Posts: 15 Member
    Too much water is bad for you and can be lethal

    and do you have proof? Just sayin

    the kid who died my freshman year of college from being forced to consume huge amounts o water during a frat hazing.

    http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5012154

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_intoxication




    Well yeah, too much of ANYTHING can be lethal. That is really sad that happened to him. But you can't blame water. Water isn't the problem. Stupidity of people abusing a good thing, is.
  • risefromruin
    risefromruin Posts: 483 Member
    Too much of anything is bad for you. I actually have some kidney disease issues and I have problems with drinking too much water. My urologist told me a few months ago I was basically drowning myself in water (I was complaining of peeing literally all the time) and told me to scale back my water intake. He said the best way to tell if you need to drink water is to look at your urine, duh! I don't even log my water on this site because I'm sure everyone would get after me for what they think I need to be drinking. It's different for everyone.
  • millermichellelea
    millermichellelea Posts: 226
    I think that if you drink too much water to close together it is lethal - water poisioning I believe it is called. While at basic training a person died to from too much water all at once.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories