Should I eat back my exercise calories?
Options
jmath0303
Posts: 71 Member
Ghjj
0
Replies
-
Try eating about 75% of your earned exercise calories for a couple weeks and see how you do.0
-
Yes, eat most of them back. Try 50% for starters and if you are losing too much then you can safely eat more1
-
No17
-
No...17
-
I set my diet at maintenance calories, with high protein, mid range fat and then enough carbs for daily workout energy. I consume 90% of my carbs before daily workout my calories in addition to fat and protein and then eat the rest of my daily calories after I work out and before I log my work out at the end of the day. I do not back eat but use these as my loss for the day. Using this method I am cutting just under 1% body fat per week but not losing massive pounds or muscle mass. Over last 5 weeks down 4.5% body fat but only three total pounds body weight.1
-
Yes, at least a portion until you know they're accurate.
If my normal maintenance calories for my activity level at 2000 and I do 200 calorie workout I will absolutely eat those calories back. That's how MFP is set to work.0 -
-
Stockholm_Andy wrote: »Nojanicelo1971 wrote: »No...
This is the answer if you're following a TDEE calculation that includes exercise. If you're going by MFP's goals, then you should be eating at least a portion of them.12 -
Yes - at least some of them. The MFP goal is calculated before any exercise, and you want to fuel your activity. However, be mindful of whether the numbers are likely to be accurate. Things like step trackers with HR monitors have a tendency to ridiculously over-estimate calories, including resting time or over-estimating exertion level when logging an activity, stuff like aerobics is a complete wildcard, etc.. which is why many people suggest only eating back a fraction. Logging walking/running based on mileage (or distance & average speed) will usually be pretty spot-on though.1
-
I always do. I need to fuel my workouts and I earned those calories. Starving myself would not be sustainable in the long term. I've been eating back most of my exercise calories for over 7 years now with success in both losing and maintaining.4
-
If you want to maintain weight then you must eat back all your exercise calories burned.
(But your actual burn and your estimated burn may not be the same.)3 -
I'm eating 1200 calories a day...I'm 12 stone and 5'7 .I started running today so I'm earning quite a lot..I don't want to hinder my weight loss2
-
I'd do it at maintenance ..why wouldn't you? In reduction, yes if you're hungry or want to eat more. But so near goal...i'm not eating them back...i want to lose faster.1
-
Usually when this question is asked, the answer is a disappointing no. Calories burned are never accurate, so if say your fitbit and MFP integration said you burned 560 cals, chances are you didn't actually burn this much. The way I look at it is if I'm absolutely STARVING then I'll have something extra in say the 100-200 cal range max when I have that exercise "deficit but not really a deficit". Also exercising so you can eat more is an unhealthy mindset to get into, it can actually turn into a disorder called exercise bulimia.12
-
I am trying to maintain and lost more so I plan on eating some this week.1
-
catsareevil wrote: »Usually when this question is asked, the answer is a disappointing no. Calories burned are never accurate, so if say your fitbit and MFP integration said you burned 560 cals, chances are you didn't actually burn this much. The way I look at it is if I'm absolutely STARVING then I'll have something extra in say the 100-200 cal range max when I have that exercise "deficit but not really a deficit". Also exercising so you can eat more is an unhealthy mindset to get into, it can actually turn into a disorder called exercise bulimia.
The site is designed for you to eat your exercise calories and it works. Not as a reward, but as a way to fuel your body. Yes, calculators are estimates but it doesn't take much effort to determine what your calorie burns are. Start conservatively and adapted based on real results. Not eating exercise calories greatly affects my workouts. And MFP was actually pretty darn close for me in both cardio and lifting so it's not correct to say they're never close.
Worth linking again: https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10300319/most-helpful-posts-general-health-fitness-and-diet-must-reads#latest
6 -
I am trying to maintain and lost more so I plan on eating some this week.
But you need to eat ALL of your actual exercise burns or you will continue losing.
If you are having trouble getting reasonable estimates then maybe use the common net calorie formula for walking as that looks to be your predominate exercise....
Bodyweight in lbs x distance in miles x 0.302 -
That is terrifying going to have to experiment a bit at a time1
-
catsareevil wrote: »Usually when this question is asked, the answer is a disappointing no. Calories burned are never accurate, so if say your fitbit and MFP integration said you burned 560 cals, chances are you didn't actually burn this much. The way I look at it is if I'm absolutely STARVING then I'll have something extra in say the 100-200 cal range max when I have that exercise "deficit but not really a deficit". Also exercising so you can eat more is an unhealthy mindset to get into, it can actually turn into a disorder called exercise bulimia.
My FitBit underestimates my calories by about 200 per day. If I were using MFP numbers, it would be appropriate to eat ALL of the adjustment calories.
Hopefully, OP has it figured out by now as to what works for him.2 -
Stockholm_Andy wrote: »Nojanicelo1971 wrote: »No...
This is the answer if you're following a TDEE calculation that includes exercise. If you're going by MFP's goals, then you should be eating at least a portion of them.
It's not even the right answer if you are doing the TDEE method - TDEE takes exercise into account when the goal is calculated. They are eating exercise calories, they just aren't separating them out like MFP does. They are actually making an even less accurate estimate. That the method still works when the actual duration of exercise isn't known should reassure people exercise calories aren't to be feared.
When you see people get to maintenance and then sat they are "terrified" to eat back their exercise burns then it should be obvious that it's a skill best to learn while losing weight.9
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.5K Getting Started
- 259.7K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 390 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.2K MyFitnessPal Information
- 22 News and Announcements
- 922 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions