Intermittent Fasting 16/8
stephyjones2018
Posts: 6 Member
5 days in and feeling great. Anyone else on the intermittent fasting train?
8
Replies
-
Yup 16:8 for about 13 years..welcome to the the club! There's quite a few IF'ers here. The fellow below is right. It won't really do much for weight loss over time but what it did for me was help me stop my mindless eating at all hours. It can give you a real feeling of accomplishment and control. Combine IF with your MFP calorie deficit and you've got a great system. Good luck..I'll be following your progress.
5 -
Depends if I want bigger meals or not. Considering it’s just an eating schedule and no direct benefit itself in terms of body composition, it takes out of social events too much for me. So considering at the end of the day whether I eat 3000 calories in one meal or over 24 hours, It’ll still be.....3000 calories4
-
Been doing it since end of March...i do a 18:6 but am thinking about switching to a 16:8 ...i have lost about 25 lbs and now have 10 lbs to goal.2
-
Are you strict with daily calorie intake?2
-
Yes always on target. I actually have been missing my calorie target lately because of very long work hours but it's important to eat enough to maintain muscle mass and good nutrition. You're very pretty you don't look like you need to lose weight. Can I ask why you're changing your eating habits? If you prefer not to go into it I understand.
3 -
stephyjones2018 wrote: »Are you strict with daily calorie intake?
you have to be in a calorie deficit. you dont have to be strict though. just a deficit will do. I have done 16:8(sometimes 18:6) most of my life before I even knew what I was doing and at one point I became overweight because I ate more than my body burned. Im currently maintaining my weight fasting. its still all about the calories4 -
Yup 16:8 for about 13 years..welcome to the the club! There's quite a few IF'ers here. The fellow below is right. It won't really do much for weight loss over time but what it did for me was help me stop my mindless eating at all hours. It can give you a real feeling of accomplishment and control. Combine IF with your MFP calorie deficit and you've got a great system. Good luck..I'll be following your progress.
Been doing 16:8 since June. Using it to maintain (maintaining since Aug 2016) and like that it freed up a bunch of calories which was mindless - for example late night snacking which I never really enjoyed. Also I found breakfast to be chore. Not super strict about the 16:8 - I have a small low kcal coffee in the morning for the kickstart. But pretty much no eating away from the 8 hour slot. I also like snacking - and snack away during the 8 hours.
All of this strictly within/ and mostly at my required maintenance kcal.1 -
I do 16/8 every day and then on days when I know I have a social event I’ll do 18/6 to limit my eating window.
I fast because the smaller my eating window is the less likely it is that I will binge and pick all day.
I’ve never been a breakfast person even when I was younger in school so I found i was fasting in the morning without even realising. Now I’m more conscious to stop eating earlier instead of snacking all the way until bedtime.2 -
I've been doing 14/10, so I don't know if that is really intermittent fasting. But, it's the best I can do. I stick to 1600 calories and I have lose 23 lbs in the past two months.2
-
I just started reading about IF and think I might give it a try. Could I do a 15/9 and still be in the zone?2
-
TeresaW1020 wrote: »I just started reading about IF and think I might give it a try. Could I do a 15/9 and still be in the zone?3
-
TeresaW1020 wrote: »I just started reading about IF and think I might give it a try. Could I do a 15/9 and still be in the zone?
Absolutely if you are maintaining a calorie deficit. 14:10, 13:11, 12:12, etc. are all fine too if you are in a deficit.6 -
stephyjones2018 wrote: »Are you strict with daily calorie intake?
Looking at both of your posts, I fear you have a misunderstanding of what IF is. This is very common.
In terms of weight loss, the only thing that matters is eating in a caloric deficit. To the extent that IF helps you do that, it can help you. It has zero direct bearing on weight loss all by itself.
I use IF most of the time. But I use it for one purpose: to control the amount I eat. I like to eat more at one sitting.
There are some claims that timing and insulin response and all that make a difference. This is unproven (and some of it complete rubbish), and even if it was true the magnitude of the effect of IF (in and of itself) is not significant compared with the effect of a caloric deficit.
Based on your second post, your caloric control is what matters. IF doesn't give you leeway to be any less strict than you would normally be. There's no magic there.
If I've misrepresented how you think about IF, forgive me. But there are many posters who believe all they have to do is eat in a certain window and magic will happen. Not so.10 -
I like 8:12 so I can always be snacking.5
-
I wake up hungry everyday!!! Hunger comes and goes but it’s hard to wait until 12 to eat 🙄😀0
-
stephyjones2018 wrote: »I wake up hungry everyday!!! Hunger comes and goes but it’s hard to wait until 12 to eat 🙄😀13
-
I've done it in the past, and it lines up well with how I normally eat so I'll probably do it again. But for the time being... no, I'm not. It can, at times, exacerbate my binging tendencies, and that's what I'm focused on right now.1
-
I do and many others do. If it aligns with your preferences, it can be a good way to control calorie intake. If not, not. A quick search will reveal 10s if not 100s of threads on this topic.4
-
stephyjones2018 wrote: »I wake up hungry everyday!!! Hunger comes and goes but it’s hard to wait until 12 to eat 🙄😀
If you do decide to do it, here are a couple of things that helped me:
1. Black coffee mid morning - helps suppress appetite.
2. Do IF for at least 3 days. After that it gets easier once your body adapts and you are used to the initial hunger pangs. They go away.3 -
kommodevaran wrote: »stephyjones2018 wrote: »I wake up hungry everyday!!! Hunger comes and goes but it’s hard to wait until 12 to eat 🙄😀kommodevaran wrote: »stephyjones2018 wrote: »I wake up hungry everyday!!! Hunger comes and goes but it’s hard to wait until 12 to eat 🙄😀kommodevaran wrote: »stephyjones2018 wrote: »I wake up hungry everyday!!! Hunger comes and goes but it’s hard to wait until 12 to eat 🙄😀kommodevaran wrote: »stephyjones2018 wrote: »I wake up hungry everyday!!! Hunger comes and goes but it’s hard to wait until 12 to eat 🙄😀
2 -
I’ve researched the benefits of fasting and wanted to test my body’s reaction to it. Trying 16/8 for a few months at least... jury’s still out 😝9
-
Just FYI - most stated benefits are, at best, overstated. If it's not something that feels pretty natural, I wouldn't force it.
It's kinda like running shoes - if they don't feel good out of the box, breaking them in isn't going change things all that dramatically.11 -
I've done the 16/8 and felt amazing. I mainly did it for work focus since I work 11-12 hours per day, study after work, then hit the gym. I don't have a ton of time to meal prep. Fasting makes my eating style more nutrition focused, cheaper, and easily manageable. I bumped it up to 18 hours of fasting after the first month. I then switched to keto and no fasting, loved that as well, and currently I'm back to regular meal prep and fasting with the 16/8
1 -
Silentpadna wrote: »stephyjones2018 wrote: »I wake up hungry everyday!!! Hunger comes and goes but it’s hard to wait until 12 to eat 🙄😀
If you do decide to do it, here are a couple of things that helped me:
1. Black coffee mid morning - helps suppress appetite.
2. Do IF for at least 3 days. After that it gets easier once your body adapts and you are used to the initial hunger pangs. They go away.
Agreed. Again, I'd say look at some of the other threads. A couple have studied and meta analysis regarding benefits, proven or not.
Bottom line is; the primary proven benefit is calorie control. End of story so far.7 -
I do IF on and off, sometimes I'd go for months on a 16/8, other times I go for months with 3 meals a day, sometimes I go for 5 (rarely actually).
It's all about the amount of food you end up with at a single sitting. That's it. The amount of calories is the same, it just depends on how you distribute them over the day and how you feel most comfortable.
End of story.
But just the other day I had a long, and I mean LONG discussion with a friend, who was claiming that the idea of IF is to skip the food you'd normally eat. As in if you do a single meal in a 20/4 style, then you'd have to eat only the calories in that single meal (so for example a normal lunch ~ 800ish calories and end of story). Aaand yeah... it would work as you'd suddenly be anywhere from 400 to 1800 calories deficit (depending on your TDEE)... but... that's not IF. It can, of course, help you limit the number of calories, but the idea is how to distribute them so that you're most satisfied/comfortable, not how to eliminate calories that you should actually be taking in...3 -
Nothing anabolic either about not eating....2
-
pinggolfer96 wrote: »Nothing anabolic either about not eating....
Did someone suggest there was?5 -
stephyjones2018 wrote: »I’ve researched the benefits of fasting and wanted to test my body’s reaction to it. Trying 16/8 for a few months at least... jury’s still out 😝
I have skipped breakfast for 20+ years and eaten most of my food in a 6 to 8 hour window because it is my natural eating pattern. How much longer do I need to wait to see an additional health benefit or some kind of bodily reaction?
15 -
I was under the (possible) misconception that IF 16/8 would kick your metab. butt into gear and help with loss. NO?? All thoughts welcome. I'm in a stall and trying the easiest way possible to shake it3
-
I was under the (possible) misconception that IF 16/8 would kick your metab. butt into gear and help with loss. NO?? All thoughts welcome. I'm in a stall and trying the easiest way possible to shake it
Nope. It just an eating schedule that helps with calorie control. It doesn't do anything to your metabolism. That is all marketing hype.7
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions