Help! Optavia - concerned for my health.

Hi all! Haven’t really ever been active on here but I lack a community or knowledgeable person to ask.

I started Optavia 5 days ago. I’m down 7 lbs.
I LOVE how fast I’m losing weight. But what I’m really struggling with is how sustainable this is. For those of you that don’t know. It’s basically eating 6 small meals a day (5 of those are 100 calories each) for a total of 800-1100 calories a day.

I started at 230lbs, I’m down to 223 on day 5.

But I HATE the food. And my cravings are INSANE. Plus, I can’t really workout since my deficit is so high.

Wondering everyone’s thoughts and if there are any trainers/dietitians on here I can talk with.
«1

Replies

  • katrinabrown123
    katrinabrown123 Posts: 1 Member
    Intent app is also a very affordable coaching service done through app
  • Steelkid
    Steelkid Posts: 74 Member
    brettakuss wrote: »
    Hi all! Haven’t really ever been active on here but I lack a community or knowledgeable person to ask.

    I started Optavia 5 days ago. I’m down 7 lbs.
    I LOVE how fast I’m losing weight. But what I’m really struggling with is how sustainable this is. For those of you that don’t know. It’s basically eating 6 small meals a day (5 of those are 100 calories each) for a total of 800-1100 calories a day.

    I started at 230lbs, I’m down to 223 on day 5.

    But I HATE the food. And my cravings are INSANE. Plus, I can’t really workout since my deficit is so high.

    Wondering everyone’s thoughts and if there are any trainers/dietitians on here I can talk with.

    It's Medifast with a new name. I did it from March 2010 to December 2010 and lost 150 lbs but couldn't keep it up. It does work but it's goal is to teach you how to eat better, it's not made for the long term, thats what I didn't keep in mind. It has helped me keep off 70 of the 120 consistent pounds I've lost since 2009. What it basically does is put your body in light ketosis. There are better ways to lose the same amount of weight without the high costs.
  • monicarn64
    monicarn64 Posts: 1 Member
    So glad you guys are talking about Optavia. What an absolute ripoff. Do you lose weight? Sure. The coaches are SO pushy. I am an RN, and don’t need to be told what to eat. I just have to do it!
  • LynnJ9
    LynnJ9 Posts: 414 Member
    I eat the Optiviia bars. I like the macros of them and that they are only 110 calories. I don't follow their plan of 5 a day, but I use them in my calorie count. I also like the mashed potatoes which are great to add to a meal when I have some extra calories.
    I also think their 300 calorie meals aren't bad when you are in a pinch and need to bring something premade but you don't have a way to keep it frozen until you heat and eat it.
    I treat them like any other food, I count the calories and fit them in.
    Some of their stuff though, chili, sloppy Joe's, are awful!
  • CharlieBeansmomTracey
    CharlieBeansmomTracey Posts: 7,682 Member
    Venencia wrote: »
    I joined Optavia Nov 4, 2018 and have lost 33 lbs and my cholesterol is down too which is a big deal to me. I’m halfway to goal. The first order comes with Dr Anderson’s Habits of Health book. He advises Medifast aka Optavia in it because it’s balanced and easy. The book also lays out his approach on eating for health among other things. I’m great full for the plan in giving me direction! I’ve justified the costs too by saying it’s a trade off for groceries and eating out. However...

    Myself and a friend of mine switched over to the plan in Dr A’s book, which uses real foods, and we canceled our Optavia orders. It’s only day 2 but I think we will continue our weight loss without the packaged fuelings. I’m Loving my fitness pal for tracking and planning!
    I too think Optavia is a MLM program.

    losing weight for some in itself can cause cholesterol to go down
  • amy19355
    amy19355 Posts: 805 Member
    brettakuss wrote: »
    Hi all! Haven’t really ever been active on here but I lack a community or knowledgeable person to ask.

    I started Optavia 5 days ago. I’m down 7 lbs.
    I LOVE how fast I’m losing weight. But what I’m really struggling with is how sustainable this is. For those of you that don’t know. It’s basically eating 6 small meals a day (5 of those are 100 calories each) for a total of 800-1100 calories a day.

    I started at 230lbs, I’m down to 223 on day 5.

    But I HATE the food. And my cravings are INSANE. Plus, I can’t really workout since my deficit is so high.

    Wondering everyone’s thoughts and if there are any trainers/dietitians on here I can talk with.

    I think you answered your own question. Sustainability with things you hate does not seem like a realistic proposition.

    eat what you like, just don't eat more than you need - calorie wise.
  • WilmaValley
    WilmaValley Posts: 1,092 Member
    No way to live
  • zeejane03
    zeejane03 Posts: 993 Member
    I am a health professional (not nutrition-based) who speaks about obesity 20-30 times/year at conferences. I think my wife and I have tried every major diet and lifestyle plan we've discovered. It's a journey!

    I've come to believe that few diet plans are purely evil or purely good. Optavia is no exception. As you already know, it is a very low carbohydrate way of eating that emphasizes purchasing "fuelings" for each of 5 meal times a day. The 6th meal time is a lean-and-green with a substantial amount of protein and veggies. The goal is to maintain a consistent blood sugar level. Once you hit a healthy weight, you transition to more calories and a wider variety of food.

    This concept of small meals with one bigger, healthy meal is a positive aspect, one we've tried to adopt as a long-term life strategy.


    1. Your health coach is motivated by money made by purchases you make. It is not altruistic by any means, though the language of the program suggests it is. Higher sales result in special "levels," including trips, etc. My health coach has been quite disconnected, not a great match for my wife or I, but there is NO recourse in Optavia for getting a new one (it's not about matching, it's about their level above you in making money).

    2. Eating the same few pre-packaged options is convenient but also gets tiring. Oh, and expensive. We found the average cost is about $400/mos/person. As a coach you are trained to emphasize that this is probably similar to how much you spend at the supermarket and eating out most months. That being said, we still use the fuelings sometimes ... they're well-balanced and great if you're on the go.
    Here's the math:
    $20 for 7 fuelings (+ shipping, but also some discounts if you get regular deliveries)
    5 fuelings/day x 30 days = 150 fuelings/mos
    = 21 boxes/person/mos, or around $400/mos

    3. Is it sustainable? There's a passionate group that sustains the lifestyle, and the thought is once you buy into being a health coach (literally buy in, a couple hundred dollars if I recall) you'll be motivated to stay healthy as your success is your billboard for promoting sales. For most people, I would say it is not sustainable, but I know some great people that have adapted to it long-term.

    4. De-emphasis on physical activity. You are discouraged from exercising (you're consuming too few calories), although you are encouraged to be active (find activities other than eating that you find value in).

    5. Finally, the thing that bothered me most about the program is that it is heavily focused on secrecy. You post your own weight loss photos on social media, but you never, ever, ever publicly disclose how you are getting healthy. You message people and tell them you'd like to personally video chat and tell them how you've gotten healthy. It is heavily scripted with an emphasis on caring about your health, and you are closely monitored by your own health coach until you have the company script down. I hate, hate, hate secrecy. If it's that good, let's talk about it, be open, honest, educate on the weaknesses of Optavia, etc.

    Holy Dang, my family of five's grocery budget for the month is $400 and that covers pretty much all our breakfasts, 4 of our lunches and then all our suppers (plus we host several times a month).

    I can't even wrap my mind around having $400 a month, per person...can I come live with you? :D