I went from morbidly obese to 6 pack abs! Ask me Anything
Replies
-
See my above post. As for weight gain, that depends on a lot of factors. Was the weight gain rapid (1-2 weeks) or over the long term (1-2 months)? If you gained it rapidly it is likely to be neither fat nor muscle but water. If you are new to weights the likelihood that it is water weight increases. Long term weight gain has far less to do with your exercise program and is very much related to your calorie intake.babybeast1 wrote: »Congrats! You look pretty amazing.
Question: My trainer has me doing more weights than cardio. I gained a bit... like 5 lbs, I'm trying to lose weight and it kinda freaked me out. I know people have said they should have started weight training sooner but I wanna trim. Not sure what s the best approachpiddings1951 wrote: »Did you ever experience fatigue when you lising weight?
Absolutely. It's part of the process. Something that helps with this is a diet break. Every 8-12 weeks of dieting I usually recommend doing a 2 week "diet break". That doesn't mean go HAM and eat everything in sight, it simply means increase calories to maintenance but still be diligent with your tracking. After 2 weeks resume your calorie deficit. This helps with both physical and mental fatigue associated with dieting.brenn24179 wrote: »My 58 year old husband is slim every where except his stomach. How does he get rid of that stomach?
You just have to keep losing fat. You cannot spot reduce fat and different people lose fat from different parts of their body first. If he is "too skinny" everywhere else but his stomach a focus on resistance training (weights) can help.2 -
Answers in boldHow long was your journey?
It's never ending...
How long before abs appeared?
2 years until they were really noticeable
How do you know when to rest?
I rest when I'm tired...not sure I totally understand what you're asking
How much protein are you eating?
depends on if I am gaining or losing weight. When gaining usually 1 gram per lb I weigh, when dieting a little more than that.
Are you eating carbs?
absolutely. I do very poorly on low carb
Do you bulk?
Yup! Only way that I can reliably gain muscle and strength at this point12Sarah2015 wrote: »I've got six pounds to go. How did you lose the last little bit?
That last few lbs can be troublesome. You just have to keep consistent and maintain reasonable expectations. 1-2 lbs a week of weight loss is reasonable when you have a lot to lose. When you are already lean trying to get very lean it can be 0.5 lbs per week or sometimes even less.marcuswilkens wrote: »Thats awesome! and good work!
My question is how to get enough protein while still in deficit, using the formula in the video you've linked put me in a protein goal of 560 calories, thats 32% of my total daily calorie allotment, did you aim for your protein goal when you started lifting and do you have to chug proteindrinks? I find it hard to meet my protein goals every day.
I don't drink many protein shakes. Whole foods rich in protein are all that's usually needed. 12 ounces of chicken breast get you about 75 grams. Greek yogurt or cottage cheese are easy ways to get a bunch of protein in as well. Lean meats, dairy, eggs/egg whites, and occasionally protein supplements if necessary to hit your goal.6 -
You rocked it out!1
-
Many thanks Vismal!! I'm feeling a little stumped. I'm carefully counting calories and exercise regularly, but my weight loss has stalled. It was moving along fine for the first 20lbs, then I started feeling terrible and had less and less energy (started feeling very tired and cold all the time too). So I increased my calories by 250/day and immediately started feeling better, but now my weight loss stalled and I just fluctuate up and down 1lb (for 5 weeks now)! Any ideas? TIA1
-
Do you find that certain muscle groups, groups that would have gotten a lot of work when you were heavier, had meteoric rise in functional strength, and some take a lot of time? I started at 265 at my heaviest, 255 in December. I'm at 205 now. I started lifting in February and I can lift an extraordinary amount with my legs, and can really do a lot of weighted work on core, more than expected. My back is surprisingly strong as well, but my chest and arms have been a much slower, methodical progression.1
-
Also... Moobs. At what point close to goal weight did they go away?0
-
So no surgeries?2
-
Very inspirational sir, your dedication is really motivating!0
-
I'm basically 100% over body fat percentage at this point. To me it's essentially a worseless number. There is no really reliable way to track it for most people and even if you had access to one of the more accurate measurements (dexascan) I still don't know that it's terribly useful. If you are losing weight over the long term, you are almost certainly losing fat. If while you are losing fat you are maintaining your strength you can safely assume that you are not losing significant muscle mass. At the end of the day, look in the mirror. Are you as lean as you'd like to be? If not then continue to lose body fat. I think too often people chase a number and when they finally hit that number they may not be as happy with how they look as they thought they would be. For instance, somehow between magazines, bro science, and internet groupthink the idea that men achieve visible abs at 10% bodyfat and women at 15% became "common knowledge". Problem is, it's very hard to know with any accuracy what your body fat % is, and even if you do, if your goal is abs then lose weight until you have abs. You don't need to know your body fat % to do that. As far as using body fat as another data point to track alongside weight, measurements, and the mirror that's fine. Just don't get too caught up with that number because it's likely to be one of the least accurate numbers you have to track.sdancer2017 wrote: »Hi! I was happy to see you were still answering our many questions in your thread. Thank you for your video you posted in June. Very honest & in terms I can understand.
When you think about what is realistic/long term (mainly related to measurements). Are there any ways you feel are reliable for measuring body fat? Between my home scale, the hand held one at my former gym & a hand held attached to the scale at my current gym I'm getting a little anxious about that number. I'd love to have accurate measurements, but I'm just not sure how.
Morbidly obese, non-trained individuals, and teenagers are all capable of building muscle while losing fat much more efficiently than people who do not fall into those categories. The advice to "lose weight first than do weights" is stupid for 1000 reasons. First off, even if you don't gain a terribly significant amount of muscle mass you will maintain muscle mass you already have. You will also build strength. Finally, lifting weights does NOT inhibit weight loss. That's something people say all the time and it's complete nonsense. So in short, anyone who says lose weight first then lift weights is just wrong.You keep mentioning about lifting early. So is it bs that you can't build muscle and lose weight at the same time? Besides noob gains at the beginning.
From someone who is morbidly obese all I hear is lose weight first then work on muscles. It's kinda disheartening
To the bolded, A-freaking-MEN!2 -
How much muscle would I be able to gain in a deficit? I’m 130lbs, 5’1” and have a BF% of about 30. I’m also breastfeeding (which I know can mess with hormone levels). My goal is to lose between .5-1lb/week right now (eating ~1650 calories per day right now, with 1 day per week of maintenance). I haven’t exercised in 5+ years, and lost a significant amount of muscle since being pregnant.0
-
brittneyalley wrote: »How much muscle would I be able to gain in a deficit? I’m 130lbs, 5’1” and have a BF% of about 30. I’m also breastfeeding (which I know can mess with hormone levels). My goal is to lose between .5-1lb/week right now (eating ~1650 calories per day right now, with 1 day per week of maintenance). I haven’t exercised in 5+ years, and lost a significant amount of muscle since being pregnant.
Since you are breastfeeding, you should be eating more. The lower calories that you are aiming for can compromise your milk supply. I have heard that breastfeeding will burn an additional 500 calories per day, so you should be able to eat at least 2000 and still lose some weight without risking milk supply.
I realize this isn't what you asked about, but it is what jumped out at me.3 -
nutmegoreo wrote: »brittneyalley wrote: »How much muscle would I be able to gain in a deficit? I’m 130lbs, 5’1” and have a BF% of about 30. I’m also breastfeeding (which I know can mess with hormone levels). My goal is to lose between .5-1lb/week right now (eating ~1650 calories per day right now, with 1 day per week of maintenance). I haven’t exercised in 5+ years, and lost a significant amount of muscle since being pregnant.
Since you are breastfeeding, you should be eating more. The lower calories that you are aiming for can compromise your milk supply. I have heard that breastfeeding will burn an additional 500 calories per day, so you should be able to eat at least 2000 and still lose some weight without risking milk supply.
I realize this isn't what you asked about, but it is what jumped out at me.
If I eat 2000, I pretty much maintain my weight. I’ve been eating 1650-1750 since February and haven’t had supply issues. I just started going to the gym last week and eat back my cardio calories (10 minutes on elliptical). Other than that, I’ve been very sedentary 2-3k steps per day, so I maintain at a lower range than most.1 -
What is your height and weight? As you get leaner you can start to feel crummy. It starts earlier with some people then others. What I usually do is take a diet break and eat at maintenance for 2 weeks then go back to the deficit.tthickens637 wrote: »Many thanks Vismal!! I'm feeling a little stumped. I'm carefully counting calories and exercise regularly, but my weight loss has stalled. It was moving along fine for the first 20lbs, then I started feeling terrible and had less and less energy (started feeling very tired and cold all the time too). So I increased my calories by 250/day and immediately started feeling better, but now my weight loss stalled and I just fluctuate up and down 1lb (for 5 weeks now)! Any ideas? TIA
This is mostly variable from person to person but from my own observations (non-scientific) calves. Be it males or females, if they've lost tons of weight the usually have pretty impressive calves. My calves are bigger/stronger than most people I encounter and I rarely train them directly.Spadesheart wrote: »Do you find that certain muscle groups, groups that would have gotten a lot of work when you were heavier, had meteoric rise in functional strength, and some take a lot of time? I started at 265 at my heaviest, 255 in December. I'm at 205 now. I started lifting in February and I can lift an extraordinary amount with my legs, and can really do a lot of weighted work on core, more than expected. My back is surprisingly strong as well, but my chest and arms have been a much slower, methodical progression.
Just depends on the person. Also depends if you simply have chest fat or actual gynecomastia. Chest fat will go away at about the same rate as all other body fat. Gynecomastia won't ever fully go away short of surgery, although gaining muscle/reducing fat helps quite a bit.Spadesheart wrote: »Also... Moobs. At what point close to goal weight did they go away?
4 -
No bariatric or cosmetic surgery of any kind.So no surgeries?
I wouldn't make muscle gain my concern if I was you. You don't gain much muscle in a deficit regardless of circumstances though some circumstances are more favorable than others. Breastfeeding is certainly working against gaining muscle. You should probably be looking at eating maintenance calories to begin with if you plan on breastfeeding. Breastfeeding itself requires quite a few calories. So basically, losing fat and gaining muscle are competing goals, through in breastfeeding and you have 3 competing goals. If I were you I would eat a maintenance. I would focus on training and gaining strength. Rebuild good habits with both diet and exercise. Once you are finished breastfeeding you will be in an excellent spot to start a fat loss phase. Once you achieve the amount of fat loss you want you can really focus in on gaining muscle.brittneyalley wrote: »How much muscle would I be able to gain in a deficit? I’m 130lbs, 5’1” and have a BF% of about 30. I’m also breastfeeding (which I know can mess with hormone levels). My goal is to lose between .5-1lb/week right now (eating ~1650 calories per day right now, with 1 day per week of maintenance). I haven’t exercised in 5+ years, and lost a significant amount of muscle since being pregnant.
2 -
What is your height and weight? As you get leaner you can start to feel crummy. It starts earlier with some people then others. What I usually do is take a diet break and eat at maintenance for 2 weeks then go back to the deficit.tthickens637 wrote: »Many thanks Vismal!! I'm feeling a little stumped. I'm carefully counting calories and exercise regularly, but my weight loss has stalled. It was moving along fine for the first 20lbs, then I started feeling terrible and had less and less energy (started feeling very tired and cold all the time too). So I increased my calories by 250/day and immediately started feeling better, but now my weight loss stalled and I just fluctuate up and down 1lb (for 5 weeks now)! Any ideas? TIA
This is mostly variable from person to person but from my own observations (non-scientific) calves. Be it males or females, if they've lost tons of weight the usually have pretty impressive calves. My calves are bigger/stronger than most people I encounter and I rarely train them directly.Spadesheart wrote: »Do you find that certain muscle groups, groups that would have gotten a lot of work when you were heavier, had meteoric rise in functional strength, and some take a lot of time? I started at 265 at my heaviest, 255 in December. I'm at 205 now. I started lifting in February and I can lift an extraordinary amount with my legs, and can really do a lot of weighted work on core, more than expected. My back is surprisingly strong as well, but my chest and arms have been a much slower, methodical progression.
Just depends on the person. Also depends if you simply have chest fat or actual gynecomastia. Chest fat will go away at about the same rate as all other body fat. Gynecomastia won't ever fully go away short of surgery, although gaining muscle/reducing fat helps quite a bit.Spadesheart wrote: »Also... Moobs. At what point close to goal weight did they go away?
Thanks for the response... I'm 5'8" and weigh 155 now. Since writing my question on April 14th, I've lost another 10 lbs for total of 30. My goal is 135-140 (BMI ~20%), so I'm getting close. I fine-tuned my food tracking and started body-weight training and that seemed to get things moving again. I'm at another stall point now (5 weeks same weight), but I've slacked on my diet (macros and CICO) - so time to up my game again! Once I get to my goal weight, I'm planning on building some muscle. At 60 y/o I need all the strength and balance I can get! I've been working on my fitness goal for 9 months now - which seems like a long time to only be down 30lbs. What was your rate of loss when you got close to your goal weight?1 -
@vismal One of the finest success stories I've read here. Thanks a million.1
-
What is your height and weight? As you get leaner you can start to feel crummy. It starts earlier with some people then others. What I usually do is take a diet break and eat at maintenance for 2 weeks then go back to the deficit.tthickens637 wrote: »Many thanks Vismal!! I'm feeling a little stumped. I'm carefully counting calories and exercise regularly, but my weight loss has stalled. It was moving along fine for the first 20lbs, then I started feeling terrible and had less and less energy (started feeling very tired and cold all the time too). So I increased my calories by 250/day and immediately started feeling better, but now my weight loss stalled and I just fluctuate up and down 1lb (for 5 weeks now)! Any ideas? TIA
This is mostly variable from person to person but from my own observations (non-scientific) calves. Be it males or females, if they've lost tons of weight the usually have pretty impressive calves. My calves are bigger/stronger than most people I encounter and I rarely train them directly.Spadesheart wrote: »Do you find that certain muscle groups, groups that would have gotten a lot of work when you were heavier, had meteoric rise in functional strength, and some take a lot of time? I started at 265 at my heaviest, 255 in December. I'm at 205 now. I started lifting in February and I can lift an extraordinary amount with my legs, and can really do a lot of weighted work on core, more than expected. My back is surprisingly strong as well, but my chest and arms have been a much slower, methodical progression.
Just depends on the person. Also depends if you simply have chest fat or actual gynecomastia. Chest fat will go away at about the same rate as all other body fat. Gynecomastia won't ever fully go away short of surgery, although gaining muscle/reducing fat helps quite a bit.Spadesheart wrote: »Also... Moobs. At what point close to goal weight did they go away?
Unfortunately I have confirmation from a doctor that it is indeed gynocomastia. Which is a bummer as it was like the #3 reason for me to lose weight. Sigh.
I've just gotten down to 195 now. Unfortunately my body composition doesn't quite look like yours, which makes sense. You started at a much higher weight so your body likely had a good deal more lean mass to begin with. I still have a bit of a belly and moobs, but the latter isn't quite going away without surgical intervention. I do have a good deal of muscle, but the navy method puts me at about a 20% body fat. Everywhere else is pretty lean.
I'm just reverse dieting into a goal of 190, and hitting the gym even harder moving forward. Here's hoping the extra calories make the recovery quicker.
1 -
Ab question: pregnancy provided loose skin of course, but i really didn't have much trouble with my stomach until after I had an umbilical hernia. Now I have an odd shape around my bellybutton area. Any suggestions on exercises to kind of target/tone this area more? I do cardio and weights 5-6 days a week0
-
You look incredible! 👏🏼
I lost 100lbs and am recently dealing with 8lbs of regain. This motivates me to get focused and stop making excuses. 😁0 -
amazing tranformation. Good Job!0
-
Your transformation is amazing! And thanks for the offer of your knowledge and insight.
Of which I'm going to use right now....
My only exercise ATM is brisk walking 2+ miles a day. (I'm a lazy one
) I'm a 66 yo female, retired, not really any health issues, been overweight all my life but am now about 5 lbs. above my goal weight(due to holidays) of 135. Oh yeh, I'm 5'9".
I'm looking for some other exercise to support my walking and have given lifting weights(or even using resistance bands) some thought. I've got lots of firming up to achieve, phobia of gyms, so with all that information, do you have any suggestions?
Thanks so much and congratulations!!2 -
Did you exercise daily? How could you run at 315? How many calories were you usually under daily? I’m in a huge rut.I've always wanted to do an AMA so I thought I'd set one up here. The basics about my story are that I went from 315lbs to 195 and have been making small gains in muscles/losses to fat ever since. Ask me anything, anything at all!
Add me as a friend on here too!I've always wanted to do an AMA so I thought I'd set one up here. The basics about my story are that I went from 315lbs to 195 and have been making small gains in muscles/losses to fat ever since. Ask me anything, anything at all!
Add me as a friend on here too!
0 -
Wow - that is awesome. Congratulations on your transformation! Keep up the great work and dedication!1
-
quiksylver296 wrote: »
I'm basically 100% over body fat percentage at this point. To me it's essentially a worseless number. There is no really reliable way to track it for most people and even if you had access to one of the more accurate measurements (dexascan) I still don't know that it's terribly useful. If you are losing weight over the long term, you are almost certainly losing fat. If while you are losing fat you are maintaining your strength you can safely assume that you are not losing significant muscle mass. At the end of the day, look in the mirror. Are you as lean as you'd like to be? If not then continue to lose body fat. I think too often people chase a number and when they finally hit that number they may not be as happy with how they look as they thought they would be. For instance, somehow between magazines, bro science, and internet groupthink the idea that men achieve visible abs at 10% bodyfat and women at 15% became "common knowledge". Problem is, it's very hard to know with any accuracy what your body fat % is, and even if you do, if your goal is abs then lose weight until you have abs. You don't need to know your body fat % to do that. As far as using body fat as another data point to track alongside weight, measurements, and the mirror that's fine. Just don't get too caught up with that number because it's likely to be one of the least accurate numbers you have to track.sdancer2017 wrote: »Hi! I was happy to see you were still answering our many questions in your thread. Thank you for your video you posted in June. Very honest & in terms I can understand.
When you think about what is realistic/long term (mainly related to measurements). Are there any ways you feel are reliable for measuring body fat? Between my home scale, the hand held one at my former gym & a hand held attached to the scale at my current gym I'm getting a little anxious about that number. I'd love to have accurate measurements, but I'm just not sure how.
Morbidly obese, non-trained individuals, and teenagers are all capable of building muscle while losing fat much more efficiently than people who do not fall into those categories. The advice to "lose weight first than do weights" is stupid for 1000 reasons. First off, even if you don't gain a terribly significant amount of muscle mass you will maintain muscle mass you already have. You will also build strength. Finally, lifting weights does NOT inhibit weight loss. That's something people say all the time and it's complete nonsense. So in short, anyone who says lose weight first then lift weights is just wrong.You keep mentioning about lifting early. So is it bs that you can't build muscle and lose weight at the same time? Besides noob gains at the beginning.
From someone who is morbidly obese all I hear is lose weight first then work on muscles. It's kinda disheartening
To the bolded, A-freaking-MEN!
Seconded.... I just wanna be strong like my favorite power lifting heroine!!!!
1 -
Judging from your responses to others, I gather you aren't a proponent of the recomp approach when one nears the end of their initial fat loss process. If my assumption is correct, why don't you believe in it?0
-
Right on man!!.. you look amazing! Very inspiring for sure!0
-
Thank you for being so clear, kind, and motivating. I’m excited to check out your YouTube channel.
0 -
msalicia07 wrote: »Thank you for being so clear, kind, and motivating. I’m excited to check out your YouTube channel.
Nvm I guess you’re not making them anymore. Your explanation makes sense.1 -
Well done dude😊
So I guess I want to know...
Did you ever *kitten* up and binge? And if you did, what drove you to keep going and not give up?0 -
I haven't read through all the posts (obviously, there are so many pages), but I am wondering if you lost any friends? I am not very far along in my own journey, but I notice two of my friends are acting differently around me. One seems to be WAY overcomplimenting me, almost like she's uncomfortable with me taking charge of my life, but she doesn't want to admit it. She's trying to be supportive, but it's almost weird. And the other friend seems to be responding to my texts less and less. (We didn't have a fight or anything).
Thanks for all the advice! Especially about lifting and loose skin. I hope one day to be able to post a similar AMA.3
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions
Do you Love MyFitnessPal? Have you crushed a goal or improved your life through better nutrition using MyFitnessPal?
Share your success and inspire others. Leave us a review on Apple Or Google Play stores!
Share your success and inspire others. Leave us a review on Apple Or Google Play stores!