Potatoes

2»

Replies

  • janejellyroll
    janejellyroll Posts: 25,763 Member
    snowflake954 wrote: »
    janejellyroll wrote: »
    B_Plus_Effort wrote: »
    if you want to loose weight and just get it over with, then no potatoes just eat a meat ie protein and a green vegetable, so chicken and broccoli NO rice, salmon and green beans NO quinoa, steak and asparagus NO potatoes, eggs and spinach NO bread, something and something NO tortilla

    protein + green veggie

    you can thank me after 6 weeks! ha ha

    How is eating 400 calories of salmon and potato going to result in me losing weight faster than me eating 400 calories of salmon and broccoli?

    Jane--you've got it turned around. He thinks that if you eat salmon and broccoli you'll lose more and faster than salmon and potato, but then again, he's keto and that's pretty much a religion. I suppose because it's hard to stick to if you don't convince yourself that it's marvelous. My apologies to those ketoer's who like it and don't try to convince everyone to to it.

    Oops, I knew that -- I just switched it around in the writing! Thanks.
  • snowflake954
    snowflake954 Posts: 8,399 Member
    janejellyroll wrote: »
    snowflake954 wrote: »
    janejellyroll wrote: »
    B_Plus_Effort wrote: »
    if you want to loose weight and just get it over with, then no potatoes just eat a meat ie protein and a green vegetable, so chicken and broccoli NO rice, salmon and green beans NO quinoa, steak and asparagus NO potatoes, eggs and spinach NO bread, something and something NO tortilla

    protein + green veggie

    you can thank me after 6 weeks! ha ha

    How is eating 400 calories of salmon and potato going to result in me losing weight faster than me eating 400 calories of salmon and broccoli?

    Jane--you've got it turned around. He thinks that if you eat salmon and broccoli you'll lose more and faster than salmon and potato, but then again, he's keto and that's pretty much a religion. I suppose because it's hard to stick to if you don't convince yourself that it's marvelous. My apologies to those ketoer's who like it and don't try to convince everyone to to it.

    Oops, I knew that -- I just switched it around in the writing! Thanks.

    Sorry--I immortalized it in my quote. Want me to wipe it all out?
  • ccrdragon
    ccrdragon Posts: 3,374 Member
    B_Plus_Effort wrote: »
    if you want to loose weight and just get it over with, then no potatoes just eat a meat ie protein and a green vegetable, so chicken and broccoli NO rice, salmon and green beans NO quinoa, steak and asparagus NO potatoes, eggs and spinach NO bread, something and something NO tortilla

    protein + green veggie

    you can thank me after 6 weeks! ha ha

    You should do a Google search on the Penn Jillette potato diet... might dispel some of your nonsense about potatoes.
  • janejellyroll
    janejellyroll Posts: 25,763 Member
    snowflake954 wrote: »
    janejellyroll wrote: »
    snowflake954 wrote: »
    janejellyroll wrote: »
    B_Plus_Effort wrote: »
    if you want to loose weight and just get it over with, then no potatoes just eat a meat ie protein and a green vegetable, so chicken and broccoli NO rice, salmon and green beans NO quinoa, steak and asparagus NO potatoes, eggs and spinach NO bread, something and something NO tortilla

    protein + green veggie

    you can thank me after 6 weeks! ha ha

    How is eating 400 calories of salmon and potato going to result in me losing weight faster than me eating 400 calories of salmon and broccoli?

    Jane--you've got it turned around. He thinks that if you eat salmon and broccoli you'll lose more and faster than salmon and potato, but then again, he's keto and that's pretty much a religion. I suppose because it's hard to stick to if you don't convince yourself that it's marvelous. My apologies to those ketoer's who like it and don't try to convince everyone to to it.

    Oops, I knew that -- I just switched it around in the writing! Thanks.

    Sorry--I immortalized it in my quote. Want me to wipe it all out?

    No, it's a useful reminder of my fallibility! ;)
  • psychod787
    psychod787 Posts: 4,099 Member
    janejellyroll wrote: »
    B_Plus_Effort wrote: »
    if you want to loose weight and just get it over with, then no potatoes just eat a meat ie protein and a green vegetable, so chicken and broccoli NO rice, salmon and green beans NO quinoa, steak and asparagus NO potatoes, eggs and spinach NO bread, something and something NO tortilla

    protein + green veggie

    you can thank me after 6 weeks! ha ha

    How is eating 400 calories of salmon and potato going to result in me losing weight slower than me eating 400 calories of salmon and broccoli?

    Well... are we talking listed calories or useable calories??? ;)
  • Snugbug6
    Snugbug6 Posts: 30 Member
    Unless you're talking crisps, fast food fries, or some prepacked frozen creation, it's just a vegetable! Lots of fibre and nutrients, and a healthier carb than bread.
  • yirara
    yirara Posts: 9,906 Member
    Snugbug6 wrote: »
    yirara wrote: »
    Snugbug6 wrote: »
    Unless you're talking crisps, fast food fries, or some prepacked frozen creation, it's just a vegetable! Lots of fibre and nutrients, and a healthier carb than bread.

    Nothing wrong with crisps, fries or other stuff. Yeah, the nutritional value is probably not great, but it's food. I always make sure to add comfort food to my meals every now and then. Chunky chips with peanut sauce is fantastic! And if I really feel like eating a big bag of crisps then it's the bag of crisps instead of dinner, and still go over my calories. And enjoy the water weight gain the next day. :D

    I'm not saying there's anything wrong with fries. I'm a big fan of fish and chips! But they're not in the "just a vegetable" pile at that point. There's a line where I stop to consider salt and saturated fat intake, and whether it's the occasional treat or a bad habit that could impact future health.

    Agreed!

    Note to self: Don't read MFP while working :s
  • springlering62
    springlering62 Posts: 8,352 Member
    Snugbug6 wrote: »
    B_Plus_Effort wrote: »
    if you want to loose weight and just get it over with, then no potatoes just eat a meat ie protein and a green vegetable, so chicken and broccoli NO rice, salmon and green beans NO quinoa, steak and asparagus NO potatoes, eggs and spinach NO bread, something and something NO tortilla

    protein + green veggie

    you can thank me after 6 weeks! ha ha

    You mean anyone who wants to crash diet. And it's called crash for a reason.

    Call me crazy, but I thought mfp was a place for people who wanted to build lifelong healthy habits, not yo-yo diet.

    Love this!!!!!!!

  • kristingjertsen
    kristingjertsen Posts: 239 Member
    I love potatoes, sweet, yukon gold, mini potatoes, russet, you name it. Key is how you dress them up--high fat toppings means a caloric potato. Instead, I top sweet potatoes with a half tbsp. of maple syrup (25 calories), toss mini potatoes with carrots, onions, garlic, and olive oil and season with salt and spices. For mashed potatoes, I add some soy or almond milk, goya adobo seasoning, and a half tablespoon of plant based butter. Vegan mushroom gravy with peas, cut carrots, and onions is another delicious option. Or use them to top a shepherd's pie (mine is with lentils) after whipping with some plant milk (or real milk--I have a dairy allergy so I have to substitute) with a little paprika and cheese on top. As long as you watch portion sizes, you will be fine. My favorite weight loss tool is my food scale and measuring cups and spoons.
  • goal06082021
    goal06082021 Posts: 2,130 Member
    Potatoes are food. Log them accurately, and as long as they fit into your calorie budget, go nuts. The statement "you could eat nothing but potatoes all day, every day, and still lose weight" is factually true, as long as you're eating fewer calories than your body consumes in the course of keeping you alive each day. It's factually true of any other food, too. It probably wouldn't be pleasant to be on the All Potatoes, All the Time diet - they'd be processed relatively quickly in your body so you'd be hungry all the time, and also you'd eventually develop vitamin deficiencies - but like, if your only metric of success is "weigh less," it would work.
  • janejellyroll
    janejellyroll Posts: 25,763 Member
    edited December 2020
    goal06082021 wrote: »
    Potatoes are food. Log them accurately, and as long as they fit into your calorie budget, go nuts. The statement "you could eat nothing but potatoes all day, every day, and still lose weight" is factually true, as long as you're eating fewer calories than your body consumes in the course of keeping you alive each day. It's factually true of any other food, too. It probably wouldn't be pleasant to be on the All Potatoes, All the Time diet - they'd be processed relatively quickly in your body so you'd be hungry all the time, and also you'd eventually develop vitamin deficiencies - but like, if your only metric of success is "weigh less," it would work.

    There's at least one study showing that potatoes rank pretty high on the satiety scale for many people. I'm not saying it would be a particularly FUN diet for a lot of us, but eating just potatoes probably wouldn't be that bad for many in terms of actual physical hunger. I'd be at a deficit at 1,500 calories and eating 500 calories of potatoes three times a day . . . is a lot of potatoes.

Categories