One Meal A Day aka OMAD
Isabelisik
Posts: 12 Member
Hello!
Anyone tried to do OMAD or doing right now? Any ideas or suggestions?
Thank you, Isabel!
Anyone tried to do OMAD or doing right now? Any ideas or suggestions?
Thank you, Isabel!
1
Replies
-
There is a special OMAD Group - lots of info, not much activity. Here's the link:
https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/group/20634-omad-revolution
Have you already started it? Why did you choose this? How do you get 1500 calories in one meal while still getting sufficient nutrients?
When I was losing weight I stuck to two big meals and then a couple small snacks.6 -
I have been doing it for more than 2 years. In my opinion, omad goes best with keto. I couldn't bear doing one meal a day with high carbs because I would be in and out of ketosis and that would give me mood swings. On the now defunct /r/omad subreddit, most users were on a high carb diet, but that never worked for me.0
-
cmriverside wrote: »How do you get 1500 calories in one meal while still getting sufficient nutrients?
You basically add all the food you would/should eat in one day and you eat it in a window of 1 hour or so. The added bonus is that it gives you the motivation and the discipline to avoid snacks that you would forget to count.1 -
mariomicro wrote: »cmriverside wrote: »How do you get 1500 calories in one meal while still getting sufficient nutrients?
You basically add all the food you would/should eat in one day and you eat it in a window of 1 hour or so. The added bonus is that it gives you the motivation and the discipline to avoid snacks that you would forget to count.
Well of course I understand the logistics.
I just don't know that I could get enough fruits and vegetables without being overly stuffed. I guess if you do KETO it would work, but I actually like fiber and nutrition.
10 -
cmriverside wrote: »There is a special OMAD Group - lots of info, not much activity. Here's the link:
https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/group/20634-omad-revolution
Have you already started it? Why did you choose this? How do you get 1500 calories in one meal while still getting sufficient nutrients?
This has always been my question. I'm currently doing just two big meals plus occasional dessert (often something like cheese), and it's hard enough to get all my cals when I also meet my protein and nutrient goals (I like 2 meals for a deficit at the moment, since it fits my schedule and workout preferences, but will probably add another meal or snack for maintenance or if I change up my workout timing -- I lost 90 lbs back in the day doing 3 meals, no snacks).
There have been people here off and on who do it. I recall one guy who was really into it (he was pretty high carb), but he's not here anymore.2 -
You can get fibre on keto from avocados, chia seeds, nuts, spinach, broccoli, linseeds, pumpkin seeds, sunflower seeds (in moderation). Meat has more nutrients, especially vitamins, than fruit and veggies.cmriverside wrote: »mariomicro wrote: »cmriverside wrote: »How do you get 1500 calories in one meal while still getting sufficient nutrients?
You basically add all the food you would/should eat in one day and you eat it in a window of 1 hour or so. The added bonus is that it gives you the motivation and the discipline to avoid snacks that you would forget to count.
Well of course I understand the logistics.
I just don't know that I could get enough fruits and vegetables without being overly stuffed. I guess if you do KETO it would work, but I actually like fiber and nutrition.
0 -
mariomicro wrote: »
You can get fibre on keto from avocados, chia seeds, nuts, spinach, broccoli, linseeds, pumpkin seeds, sunflower seeds (in moderation). Meat has more nutrients, especially vitamins, than fruit and veggies.cmriverside wrote: »mariomicro wrote: »cmriverside wrote: »How do you get 1500 calories in one meal while still getting sufficient nutrients?
You basically add all the food you would/should eat in one day and you eat it in a window of 1 hour or so. The added bonus is that it gives you the motivation and the discipline to avoid snacks that you would forget to count.
Well of course I understand the logistics.
I just don't know that I could get enough fruits and vegetables without being overly stuffed. I guess if you do KETO it would work, but I actually like fiber and nutrition.
There are certain nutrients that are higher in meats but you can't make that blanket statement as it would be wrong.
Btw OP, what is your goal? The issue with OMAD is the ability to get adequate protein. And you will end up limiting muscle protein synthesis which may affect your ability to sustain muscle.9 -
One meal a day? I would be so sad. I am a perpetual grazer. I'd lose my mind if I could only eat once a day.4
-
One the two statements below is right and one is wrong:mariomicro wrote: »
You can get fibre on keto from avocados, chia seeds, nuts, spinach, broccoli, linseeds, pumpkin seeds, sunflower seeds (in moderation). Meat has more nutrients, especially vitamins, than fruit and veggies.cmriverside wrote: »mariomicro wrote: »cmriverside wrote: »How do you get 1500 calories in one meal while still getting sufficient nutrients?
You basically add all the food you would/should eat in one day and you eat it in a window of 1 hour or so. The added bonus is that it gives you the motivation and the discipline to avoid snacks that you would forget to count.
Well of course I understand the logistics.
I just don't know that I could get enough fruits and vegetables without being overly stuffed. I guess if you do KETO it would work, but I actually like fiber and nutrition.
There are certain nutrients that are higher in meats but you can't make that blanket statement as it would be wrong.
1) Meat has more nutrients than vegetables.
2) Vegetable have more nutrients than meat.
It is not about a blanket statement. A poster doubted that one could get enough fiber and nutrition on keto and I replied that this is not true. If anybody has evidence against my statement, please can they post it.
0 -
I wouldn't do it0
-
"A poster doubted that one could get enough fiber and nutrition on keto"
No, "a poster" (cmriverside) did not say that. The person who brought up keto was you. cmriverside asked OP: "[h]ow do you get 1500 calories in one meal while still getting sufficient nutrients?" I think many of us would have similar issues. I dislike feeling super stuffed, and even apart from that would have trouble getting sufficient protein, fiber, or veg in a single meal, although from your posts I suspect my idea about what sufficient veg is (based on my own goals) or sufficient fiber is quite different from yours (and was when I was doing keto too).
OP may or may not have such issues, but it's a fair question and something worth thinking about.7 -
KickassAmazon76 wrote: »One meal a day? I would be so sad. I am a perpetual grazer. I'd lose my mind if I could only eat once a day.
Haha someone can disagree all they want. I know myself and my relationship with food. I WOULD be miserable. 😂6 -
mariomicro wrote: »
One the two statements below is right and one is wrong:mariomicro wrote: »
You can get fibre on keto from avocados, chia seeds, nuts, spinach, broccoli, linseeds, pumpkin seeds, sunflower seeds (in moderation). Meat has more nutrients, especially vitamins, than fruit and veggies.cmriverside wrote: »mariomicro wrote: »cmriverside wrote: »How do you get 1500 calories in one meal while still getting sufficient nutrients?
You basically add all the food you would/should eat in one day and you eat it in a window of 1 hour or so. The added bonus is that it gives you the motivation and the discipline to avoid snacks that you would forget to count.
Well of course I understand the logistics.
I just don't know that I could get enough fruits and vegetables without being overly stuffed. I guess if you do KETO it would work, but I actually like fiber and nutrition.
There are certain nutrients that are higher in meats but you can't make that blanket statement as it would be wrong.
1) Meat has more nutrients than vegetables.
2) Vegetable have more nutrients than meat.
It is not about a blanket statement. A poster doubted that one could get enough fiber and nutrition on keto and I replied that this is not true. If anybody has evidence against my statement, please can they post it.
I attempted to find research (from a reputable source) backing your opinion that meat has more nutrients than vegetables and instead kept coming up with websites and research that proposed eating more veg.
I personally eat almost no veggies (simply don’t like them), so I was all for getting everything I need from meat (and my lovely starchy carbs), but it would appear that your blanket statement is inaccurate. So, unless you wish to present your evidence (real evidence not some paleo blog or other ridiculous info) I shall have to go with your statement appears to be inaccurate.
@mariomicro typically the individual making the claim would present evidence to back it not claim that other posters need to find evidence to debunk their claim. 🤷🏻♀️6 -
KickassAmazon76 wrote: »KickassAmazon76 wrote: »One meal a day? I would be so sad. I am a perpetual grazer. I'd lose my mind if I could only eat once a day.
Haha someone can disagree all they want. I know myself and my relationship with food. I WOULD be miserable. 😂
Not sure why it warranted a disagree. There are endless diet choices because we are all individuals. I would also fail miserably on OMAD, so I’m curious as to why OP would choose this. Maybe they feel they would enjoy it..... or maybe it’s just the fad of the week wherever they are in the world 😜2 -
Dogmom1978 wrote: »KickassAmazon76 wrote: »KickassAmazon76 wrote: »One meal a day? I would be so sad. I am a perpetual grazer. I'd lose my mind if I could only eat once a day.
Haha someone can disagree all they want. I know myself and my relationship with food. I WOULD be miserable. 😂
Not sure why it warranted a disagree. There are endless diet choices because we are all individuals. I would also fail miserably on OMAD, so I’m curious as to why OP would choose this. Maybe they feel they would enjoy it..... or maybe it’s just the fad of the week wherever they are in the world 😜
I mean... It would help with my hatred of needing to decide WHAT to eat all the time... But I think all I would do is think about the food I couldn't eat! Haha2 -
mariomicro wrote: »
One the two statements below is right and one is wrong:mariomicro wrote: »
You can get fibre on keto from avocados, chia seeds, nuts, spinach, broccoli, linseeds, pumpkin seeds, sunflower seeds (in moderation). Meat has more nutrients, especially vitamins, than fruit and veggies.cmriverside wrote: »mariomicro wrote: »cmriverside wrote: »How do you get 1500 calories in one meal while still getting sufficient nutrients?
You basically add all the food you would/should eat in one day and you eat it in a window of 1 hour or so. The added bonus is that it gives you the motivation and the discipline to avoid snacks that you would forget to count.
Well of course I understand the logistics.
I just don't know that I could get enough fruits and vegetables without being overly stuffed. I guess if you do KETO it would work, but I actually like fiber and nutrition.
There are certain nutrients that are higher in meats but you can't make that blanket statement as it would be wrong.
1) Meat has more nutrients than vegetables.
2) Vegetable have more nutrients than meat.
It is not about a blanket statement. A poster doubted that one could get enough fiber and nutrition on keto and I replied that this is not true. If anybody has evidence against my statement, please can they post it.
No, your statement was"Meat has more nutrients, especially vitamins, than fruit and veggies". This is a false blanket statement. Meat has higher levels of iron, B vitamins and cobalamin. Most fruits and veggies have more potassium, magnesium, vitamin c, vitamin A, etc...Both are very valuable. I can tell you, even when I focus on fiber, I often come short of the recommended amounts. For males, the recommended about is about 38g. That is more than most people following keto eat.
So even if we ignore the keto vs non for having one meal a day. The OP would need to aim for about 25g of fiber and 90-120g of protein (typical needs for a women). How likely do you think those targets would be hit?
OP, if you could expand on what your goals are, that would be awesome. At that point, we could provide a better recommendation.
7 -
mariomicro wrote: »
One the two statements below is right and one is wrong:mariomicro wrote: »
You can get fibre on keto from avocados, chia seeds, nuts, spinach, broccoli, linseeds, pumpkin seeds, sunflower seeds (in moderation). Meat has more nutrients, especially vitamins, than fruit and veggies.cmriverside wrote: »mariomicro wrote: »cmriverside wrote: »How do you get 1500 calories in one meal while still getting sufficient nutrients?
You basically add all the food you would/should eat in one day and you eat it in a window of 1 hour or so. The added bonus is that it gives you the motivation and the discipline to avoid snacks that you would forget to count.
Well of course I understand the logistics.
I just don't know that I could get enough fruits and vegetables without being overly stuffed. I guess if you do KETO it would work, but I actually like fiber and nutrition.
There are certain nutrients that are higher in meats but you can't make that blanket statement as it would be wrong.
1) Meat has more nutrients than vegetables.
2) Vegetable have more nutrients than meat.
It is not about a blanket statement. A poster doubted that one could get enough fiber and nutrition on keto and I replied that this is not true. If anybody has evidence against my statement, please can they post it.
Worst game of telephone ever.
Here's what I actually said:cmriverside wrote: »mariomicro wrote: »cmriverside wrote: »How do you get 1500 calories in one meal while still getting sufficient nutrients?
You basically add all the food you would/should eat in one day and you eat it in a window of 1 hour or so. The added bonus is that it gives you the motivation and the discipline to avoid snacks that you would forget to count.
Well of course I understand the logistics.
I just don't know that I could get enough fruits and vegetables without being overly stuffed. I guess if you do KETO it would work, but I actually like fiber and nutrition.
For crying out loud.
Pay attention if you're going to get all up in my grill.
My point was one meal a day would make it tough to get enough fruits, vegetables, fiber. Period. I acknowledged that KETO would work. This entire highjacking of the thread was unnecessary.
6 -
I do OMD. It works with my lifestyle and enjoy it. Of course it’s not for everyone. Try out a few types of eating patterns to see what works best with you.3
-
KickassAmazon76 wrote: »One meal a day? I would be so sad. I am a perpetual grazer. I'd lose my mind if I could only eat once a day.KickassAmazon76 wrote: »Haha someone can disagree all they want. I know myself and my relationship with food. I WOULD be miserable. 😂
Yes, it's really lame for people to disagree with YOUR personal preferences.5 -
I have been doing some form of IF (16/8-20/4 depending on whatever life has going on) for 7 mths. Life-changing for me! Not only have I lost weight and inches, but I feel amazing. My inflammation is gone. I have more energy than I can remember. I just feel young and vibrant, a feeling I haven't had in 13 yrs! I do OMAD 3-4 days a week. I don't do Keto. I just eat real, whole foods about 80% of the time and reserve the right to eat crap 20% of the time, when the urge arises. I LOVE food and do not feel deprived at all. It may not be for everyone, but it is my lifestyle. Please don't feel the need for any negative feedback, I am an RN with a secondary degree in fitness and nutrition. I have done the scientific research before I ever started this journey. Again, just sharing my experience. Not for everyone, but it is for me. Have a Merry Christmas y'all!
5 -
I am on a keto diet, started with intermittent fasting but as the months go along I'm just not hungry in the day so I end up having dinner as my main meal, and maybe some snacks for a few hours after that. I can plan out everything and it just makes life simpler. I feel great (not tired!) and am close to reaching my goal weight. It took a lot of eduction on what and when to eat to let this happen. I did keto before in a not-healthy way and had bad cravings. Not this time!2
-
Very good on you!silverpl2525 wrote: »I am on a keto diet, started with intermittent fasting but as the months go along I'm just not hungry in the day so I end up having dinner as my main meal, and maybe some snacks for a few hours after that. I can plan out everything and it just makes life simpler. I feel great (not tired!) and am close to reaching my goal weight. It took a lot of eduction on what and when to eat to let this happen.silverpl2525 wrote: »I did keto before in a not-healthy way and had bad cravings. Not this time!
What do you mean by that? What was unhealthy in your keto regime? I'm genuinely interested.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions