Cutting off communication with a family member
Elizabeth_C34
Posts: 6,376 Member
Have you ever completely cut off all communication from a family member?
If so, do you regret your decision?
EDIT:
I am asking because I am thinking of completely cutting my dad out of my life. He's become a very toxic person for me. He's a liar, has tried to mooch money off me and his elderly father, takes advantage of me and my grandfather, and only calls when he wants money or on the holidays when his ex wife forces him to. It's difficult for me because we were really close when I was young. I was the first person to finish high school in my family, and after I graduated college, I think he and my aunt got very nasty towards me. Hubby seems to think it's jealousy, but I am not sure. I've tried to talk to him and given him multiple chances to get back in my life, and he's never once apologized.
I was just curious to see who else had to do this.
If so, do you regret your decision?
EDIT:
I am asking because I am thinking of completely cutting my dad out of my life. He's become a very toxic person for me. He's a liar, has tried to mooch money off me and his elderly father, takes advantage of me and my grandfather, and only calls when he wants money or on the holidays when his ex wife forces him to. It's difficult for me because we were really close when I was young. I was the first person to finish high school in my family, and after I graduated college, I think he and my aunt got very nasty towards me. Hubby seems to think it's jealousy, but I am not sure. I've tried to talk to him and given him multiple chances to get back in my life, and he's never once apologized.
I was just curious to see who else had to do this.
0
Replies
-
yes.
and,
not at all.0 -
1. Yes...
2. No.
If she decides not to be a slanderous thundering sow, I'll reconsider speaking to her again.0 -
Yes and not even slightly. Some people are just not worth it.0
-
yes I have and it was because our relationship was toxic! I have no regrets I made the choice to live healthy physically and mentally0
-
Yes. No.0
-
I no longer speak to my oldest brother. He became a holy roller and constantly denigrated everyone around him. I don't regret not speaking to him as it always turned into a religious argument.0
-
1. Yes, but I it might have been easier because I was away at college at the time so it was easier to remove myself from her life. This is an immediate family member.
2. Yes. Because while I didn't agree with her decisions, that is when she needed me (and the rest of us) the most.
SIde Note: all is a thousand percent fine now. She is my best friend now.
So every situation is different. Best of luck... {hugs}0 -
Yes.
Absolutely not.0 -
Yes and it took me 10 years to decide that forgiveness is the way to go......Life is too short to be nagry and unhappy, that was my experience.0
-
Yes - a brother and a sister
No - but my other sister (who also cut off communication with the same people) died unexpectedly and made for a VERY uncomfortable family gathering...0 -
Yes I have. Personally, I don't regret it, but I do miss the way our relationship used to be and how much fun we had together. Sometimes, though, you can't control how people change, even a family member. I'm sure it will be hard, but if the circumstances are there, and you think you will lead a healthier life (physically, mentally and emotionally) then you need to do what's best for you!0
-
1. Yes, but I it might have been easier because I was away at college at the time so it was easier to remove myself from her life. This is an immediate family member.
2. Yes. Because while I didn't agree with her decisions, that is when she needed me (and the rest of us) the most.
SIde Note: all is a thousand percent fine now. She is my best friend now.
So every situation is different. Best of luck... {hugs}
Thanks. The person in question for me is actually my dad. He's a very toxic person in my life. Hubby says I should cut him off and never look back. I'm starting to think he's right.0 -
Yep, it wasn't easy but life has improved. Cut off anybody who doesn't listen to you, acknowledge you, or support you. Get your head right by thinking about how to take care of YOU.
I don't regret it but sometimes I wonder if person X has started getting their own sh** together or if they're still in denial.0 -
have i cut off communication - YES!
do i regret it - very VERY seldom!
some people, they just make life harder. and bring you down. at a MK retreat i was at 2 weekends ago, one of the guest speakers said this:
"You have to break up with the people who bring you down. If someone is always like 'oh i'm having a bad day', you have to be like 'sorry to hear that, I am having a GREAT day!' and eventually your positive attitude will bug them so much because you aren't feeding into their wanting you to be down with them, that they will 'break up' with you!"
what i took from that is if someone can't be happy for you, or keeps bringing you down, "BREAK-UP" with them!
and it has come to a point in my life, that if they aren't going to support me and my family, i'm BREAKING UP WITH THEM! and it will be THEIR loss. not mine!0 -
Yes I have and I do not regret it one bit. I made the decision a year ago and should have done it a lot sooner.0
-
Yes, some people...especially family can be way to hurtful and negative to be around!
No regrets, it is way better than dealing with the drama every single time we were all in the same room! Mexico for Christmas is awesome...highly recommend it!0 -
My sister and I didn't speak for 8 years. Why? I still don't know to this day. At first, I was angry and couldn't care less if we ever spoke again. I carried that anger around for years. When I finally realized that I was only hurting myself, by staying angry, I let go of it. It isn't healthy to carry around that kind of anger. Not only was it a strain between her and I, but with the rest of the family as well. Last December, she let go of it as well and contacted me. We've been working on things ever since. It isn't like it used to be and I don't think it will ever be, but I have my sister back to some degree. I did miss her and regret the years lost!0
-
Yup. I haven't spoken to my father since I was 20. And that was only because he approached me at my brother's HS graduation. Not including that brief exchange, he's been out of my life for a total of 8 or 9 years. I don't regret it.0
-
Yes I have. Personally, I don't regret it, but I do miss the way our relationship used to be and how much fun we had together. Sometimes, though, you can't control how people change, even a family member. I'm sure it will be hard, but if the circumstances are there, and you think you will lead a healthier life (physically, mentally and emotionally) then you need to do what's best for you!
I think I'm still stuck thinking he'll come around to being my dad again instead of this really nasty person in my life.0 -
Yep, it wasn't easy but life has improved. Cut off anybody who doesn't listen to you, acknowledge you, or support you. Get your head right by thinking about how to take care of YOU.
I don't regret it but sometimes I wonder if person X has started getting their own sh** together or if they're still in denial.
This is exactly my husband's attitude about it. I'm starting to think he's right.0 -
Could not imagine it. Even if the person would be not so nice, I would have diplomatic peace rather then having war or neglect. I would not feel comfy with that. But I did broke relation with coulpe of my so call friends...And still miss one of them sometimes. Family is diffent for me...0
-
I wouldn't cut him off altogether, but I would definitely limit my contact to miniscule amounts and him exactly why. . . then from there I would pray for them. .0
-
Could not imagine it. Even if the person would be not so nice, I would have diplomatic peace rather then having war or neglect. I would not feel comfy with that. But I did broke relation with coulpe of my so call friends...And still miss one of them sometimes. Family is diffent for me...
This is my hangup. I'm fiercely loyal to my family for the most part. I feel like a diplomatic peace is only possible if he's willing to stop his behavior.0 -
Absolutely I have, and no, I do not regret my decision. Just because they are family, doesn't mean they get to treat you like crap.0
-
Yes, I quit talking to my mom's brother & dont regret it one bit.0
-
no.
but i really should.0 -
Yes. and Yes.
When I was 18 I cut off all communication with my mother because she was also a very toxic person. For the first year I tried repeatedly to allow her back in my life but finally gave up. I saw her 2 times in the next 17 years and didnt really feel like she was a very different person.
About 5 years ago every once in a while I would do a google search on her name and see if I could find out her address. Every time I did that there would be 5 of them and I wouldnt know really which one was hers and I never got up the courage to call.
Two years ago I did that google search and a link came up for a company that my mother worked at when I was a young child and I thought that was strange so I clicked the link. Sure enough it was a company profile and had my mothers picture on it. For the next 2 hours I sat at my chair with that page up and every few minutes I would go back and look at the page. It took me 2 hours to gain the courage to call that number and ask for my mother. When the receptionist answered the phone and I asked for my mother by name the girl on the phone paused for a good 20 or 30 seconds and then she said my first and middle name. I was a little shocked and I said yes and she said "hold on". About a minute later she came back and said "Sweety where are you" and I replied I was at home. She said "your mother passed away yesterday evening" and I said "thank you" and hung up the phone.
Those last years my mother had changed drastically and had told many stories about me to her co-workers that I found out after her funeral during discussions with them. My mother had even told them she had been a bad parent and that she regretted what all she had done to myself and my brother through out the years. She wouldnt even join people for holidays she sat at home waiting to see if we might show up.
After I found out all of this I felt horrible. Why had I waited so long, why had I not tried earlier to contact her. My mother had a rough time of it the last year as she had been battling cancer pretty much alone. I'm not really sure I will ever really forgive myself or her for putting us both in that position to not be able to enjoy each other at the end.
My mother was a very toxic person, but she was still my mother and I still loved her. Try having less contact with your dad and see if that helps.0 -
My...
mother
father
sister
step-brother
two uncles
one aunt
a mess load of cousins....
mother-in-law
sister-in-law
Do I regret this? NOT ONE BIT.... Too many problems arise from them, too much drama and Im just not in the mood to be treated like s*** and walked all over.
The top of the list is my mother. She is a very toxic, ragingly mad woman with a serious alcohol problem who will cut you down and treat you like garbage just to make herself feel better about her self.... the numerous nights of her calling my house drunk as a skunk and getting downright nasty was stopped immediately. Even had to call the police because it got THAT bad!
Just because you are related doesnt mean they can walk all over you and still come over for dinner. While Im definitely not a person to hold anger continuously, I am someone who will definitely make it known that their garbage will NEVER be tolerated and if I have to draw a line that severs any sort of communication, its because they have left me no choice.0 -
this sounds like my life.... my dad and i were pretty close when i was a kid. but he changed or i opened my eyes not sure which. he is a manipulative liar who uses anyone and everyone he can. about 5 years ago he tried to force me to go to court for him during his 3rd divorce and lie about his wife so he would get the kids (i have a brother n sister who r much much younger than i am), simply because he did not want to pay child support. i refused to do it, i am not a liar and certainly would never tell lies that could cause a mother to lose her children. when i refused he disowned me and also turned the rest of my family from his side against me, i have not talked to any of them in 5 yrs. i tried to talk to him about 2 yrs ago i called at christmas time and he asked who i was, i said brandy, he said brandy who.... and then hung up. i have also tried to contact my grandma: his mom, she won't talk to me at all either. so i just let it go. i am really ok with it, he was not a good person. every now and then the thought of him dying and me not evening knowing or being contacted upsets me but i have accepted that too. i moved from cincinnati to la county about 6 months ago and know that there is a very good chance i will never see him or any of my paternal family again.
it is a sorry situation, but u have the think of ur own happiness for once. sorry u r going through this, i hope u make the right choice for u.0 -
Thank you all so much for opening up on here. As horrible as it sounds, it's nice to not feel so alone in this. My husband loves me and backs me 100% but he doesn't really understand it. His family is really wonderful.
I've got a lot to chew on in the coming days.
Thank you again for the support and for sharing.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions