CrossFit
Replies
-
I have been somewhat sore from running and other workouts, but not sore to the point where I'm barely able to walk, which is what I've seen happen to many people that do Crossfit.
Here is an example from a blog post of the extreme, cult like mentality of Crossfit. No normal person with a healthy attitude towards fitness would want to continue with a program that made them feel this terrible.
"CrossFit: Open Source Fitness
Posted on November 21, 2011
My hands started to tingle. I pushed with my hamstrings and *kitten* to finish another air squat. Thirteen. I bent over and placed my hands on my knees. I could barely breathe. I was getting light-headed. What was going on? I stood up and did another squat. Fourteen. One more. Fifteen. I dropped to my hands and knees. No more.
A couple of minutes passed. I stood up and attempted to stretch. I felt dizzy and had to sit on the ground for a few minutes. I stood up and walked to the open door for some fresh air. It didn’t help. I sat on the plyo boxes for a minute but quickly moved to laying on the ground. This trainer is either worried about me or holding back a laugh. I’m glad no one else is here, because this is embarrassing.
It was October 31st and I had just completed my first CrossFit mini-session with Matt at Survival Fitness. I think it was about a half hour before I was able to leave the gym. When I got home I spent about an hour laying on the couch. My body was exhausted and I felt terrible. But the only thing I could think about was going back on Wednesday for another workout. It couldn’t come soon enough. I was hooked."
then i know what kind of "athlete" you are...only been mildly sore? not working hard enough!0 -
Discontinue feeding the troll. :indifferent:0
-
My best friend and her dad do crossfit and live by it!! They have both gotten in great shape and love the sense of community at their gym. That being said...injuries can happen doing ANY workout, so just make sure you are using proper form and being safe. My friend has not had any injuries because she pushes her body but knows when to take rest days and uses the proper form at all times. I really wanted to try crossfit but unfortunately tore my rotater cuff doing the 30 day shred (like I said...injuries can happen at in ANY workout) when it heals I may give it a try, but as of right now I can't lift weights at all so crossfit isn't right for my body at the moment. But if you can stick with it, you really can get excellent results.
Oh and one more thing! Crossfit isn't the final answer, you still have to eat well, as they say "You can't outwork a bad diet".0 -
LOVE this...I have a thing for Captain Picard :blushing:0 -
http://michaelashcroft.net/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/2-week-beginner-cf-program.pdf
I'm going to give this a go after reading all the great experiences I have read about on this thread. Bob Harper raves about cross fit and if its good enough for him.....swoon!
I guess I don't have anything to lose and not one box jump in sight, even sno-blower can't find fault in this I think. If anyone else fancies complementing their workout by giving this a trail I'd love to hear how you get on with this at home version.0 -
Crossfit was intentionally designed to get people addicted to coming back to the "box" and spending more money.
But it's no better than any other fitness system, and worse than most because of it's extreme workouts.0 -
This example of crossfit workout is free. You can get any of them on youtube and for a lot of the workouts you don't need equipment. Nearly all of the exercises are similar to any bootcamp, biggest loser or circuit training workouts but set up in a fun way so you don't get bored.
Many of the people who are doing the workouts at the gym use the classes to complement their other workouts and I don't see that they are at more risk of injury than they are at risk of death by doing nothing.
I'd rather spend 6 weeks strapped up because of a crossfit, horseriding, skiing, cycling, running injury than explain to my kids that I am dying of heart disease, diabeties, obesity because someone put me off trying something new by posting negativity about it on a forum full of strangers. That I listened to their opinion made up from zero personal experience instead of getting out there and giving it a go and making an opinion and a change for myself.
Also, which exercise programme was not designed to appeal to the masses? To try to get people addicted?
I also think that sometimes we need a bit of extreme. It was our search for all things comfortable that got most of us unfit and unhealthy in the first place wasn't it?0 -
It is a unhealthy addiction when you work out so hard that you can barely move and will be sore for days, then can't wait to do it again.
Crossfit is worse than a lot of other fitness programs because the workouts are so extreme and include so many different elements that most people probably don't have the correct form to do -- all those olympic lifts, etc.
Some variety in an exercise program is fine, but you don't need to have exercise moves that hardly anyone outside of Crossfit has ever heard of.0 -
You get the last word, RachelSNO job. We know you don't like Cross Fit, cults, military style extremism, elitist, "Pukey," Cross Fit Kool-Aid because it is addictive, blistered or bloody hands, people who engage in Cross Fit that don't have adequate health insurance, people who spend their money on Cross Fit when they should be exercising for free at the YMCA, other members who call you an idiot because it is against MFP rules, Paleo, people who make the decision to have gastric bypass surgery instead of joining the YMCA, people who follow the HGC diet instead of joining the YMCA, and on and on. Did I miss anything?
I hear the telephone ringing. It is the YMCA on line 2. They are ready for your dance class, you elite athlete!
End of play time. I don't spar with opponents that are lesser equipped than I am.
Hugs~
P.S. I may be 61, but you have CONVINCED me I have to join a Cross Fit class!0 -
I will happily trade it for any of my previous unhealthy addictions to be honest. These include junk food, diet sodas, smoking, drinking, high sugar intake and feeding the trolls.
Must be bedtime then.
I have such a lovely crossfit at home workout planned for tomorrow I will be nodding off to sleep thinking about it. Easy for me though I guess since my husbands father is an orthapedic surgeon so he should be able to fix most things if on the off chance you opinion is more than just what the odor suggests. Bonne nuit.0 -
If you end up in the emergency room from doing some of those crazy Crossfit stunts, you won't think your comments are nearly as funny as you do now.
And yes, you did miss some things.0 -
OMG give it up!0
-
Greg Glassman is the main reason I refuse to have anything to do with Crossfit.
He admits that his workouts can kill people, and apparently, sees nothing wrong with that.
Please read this eye opening article from the NY Times before you continue to promote Crossfit as if it was something positive.
Getting Fit, Even If It Kills You
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/22/fashion/thursdaystyles/22Fitness.html?pagewanted=all0 -
:sick: :sick: :sick: :sick: :sick: :sick: :sick: :sick: :sick: :sick: :sick: :sick: :sick: :sick: :sick: :yawn:0
-
Greg Glassman is the main reason I refuse to have anything to do with Crossfit.
He admits that his workouts can kill people, and apparently, sees nothing wrong with that.
Please read this eye opening article from the NY Times before you continue to promote Crossfit as if it was something positive.
Getting Fit, Even If It Kills You
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/22/fashion/thursdaystyles/22Fitness.html?pagewanted=all
Are you his ex wife?:bigsmile:0 -
i don't understand how any one work out can be more addicting then others? i know plenty of people that are addicted to running. their are people out there (yours truely included) that feel better after a work out. this is no different then when Joseph Pilates came up with a new form of exercise (i'll give you three guesses to what he invented).
any person that is passing out in the middle of a work out is probably going way outside of their comfort zone. it is no different then a runner adding more miles on to their run before they are ready, and putting themselves out of commision for a week, or meeting pukey.0 -
Greg Glassman is the main reason I refuse to have anything to do with Crossfit.
He admits that his workouts can kill people, and apparently, sees nothing wrong with that.
Please read this eye opening article from the NY Times before you continue to promote Crossfit as if it was something positive.
Getting Fit, Even If It Kills You
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/22/fashion/thursdaystyles/22Fitness.html?pagewanted=all
Are you his ex wife?:bigsmile:
you know... it kind of makes sense now...0 -
No, I never met the Glassman guy, but any fitness instructor that says their workouts can kill people, but expect people to do them anyway, must have a few screws loose .
Crossfit creates addiction in many ways. Here are a few to start with
1.Convincing people that a Crossfit workout is better than anything else, when there is absolutely no evidence of that being the case. Making participants believe that if they leave Crossfit, they will never become as fit as they could be. Making people believe that Crossfit will do for them what no other exercise program could possibly do.
2. Making it about Crossfit community. While admittedly, a lot of fitness franchises could do a better job of creating community within their exercise classes, community would not give me reason to join or stay in an exercise program I found too extreme or didn't like. But it would some people -- especially those who do not feel they have community. That is how cults often recruit members -- by promising people who have no real feeling of community in life that their organization will give them what they always wanted.
3. Making participants feel they have failed their Crossfit community if they do not show up for the WOD, and being encouraged to feel that way about others in the "box" -- which keeps everyone in the box feeling obligated to come to workouts.0 -
ya ya ya a simple NO would suffice!
Girlfriend-find something better to do with your time- anything other than Crossfit of coarse!0 -
Defamation—also called calumny, vilification, traducement, slander (for transitory statements), and libel (for written, broadcast, or otherwise published words)—is the communication of a statement that makes a claim, expressly stated or implied to be factual, that may give an individual, business, product, group, government, or nation a negative image. This can be also any disparaging statement made by one person about another, which is communicated or published. It is usually a requirement that this claim be false and that the publication is communicated to someone other than the person defamed (the claimant).
I'm sure Glassman would appreciate it if you keep the name calling to a minimum, due to your lack of experience/education.
Why is exercise addicting? It's called endorphins - it doesn't matter what it is ... some people get that release from boxing, running, rowing, crossfitting, what have you ... THAT'S WHY THEY KEEP GOING BACK FOR MORE! Those little chemicals are released in your brain and make you a happy person.
I'm pretty sure her next platform is going to bash MMA/Boxing athletes. Talk about insurance co-pays.
Pukie ... have yet to meet pukie officially in a WOD, but let me tell you - highschool basketball ... met pukie a few times running suicides over and over again. Want to bash highschool/college sports too? How about the countless PT sessions the men and women of our military have been through that have caused them to puke, DI yells at them to get moving, calls them a worthless POS ...0 -
LOL! Thanks guys!!! I needed that...and NO, I'm NOT talking to you... :laugh:0
-
I've been really interested in getting into CF. I'll be honest, I'm fat. But, CF is a goal of mine. I did Krav Maga for awhile and loved the less traditional type work out and have come to love the exertion from Krav. I love doing things that aren't typical girl things; I'd rather be working out with the guys. When I hit the gym, I love pushing myself at weight lifting - I've never really been a cardio freak. I do love biking, but I don't think I'd ever be a runner. Anyway, I think that's part of the allure to CF: pushing myself in a way that helps me maneuver my body in ways that you can't quite do in a typical work out.
With that said, and yes I know I'm feeding the troll....
I go to the Y. It's not free. It's more expensive than the gym I had been going to and a half hour trainer session is more at the Y. Anyway, yes, I have a trainer at the YMCA...and...*drum roll* HE'S A CROSSFITTER! :noway:
He's given me some awesome moves that come from CrossFit and I love it. Granted they've been simple things, like kettle bell swings, sumo lifts...tire flipping. I have absolutely loved his workouts. Before I do anything he always checks form. I've been sore, but it's a good sore. So, I can't wait until I'm in better shape and I can check out a box.
On one more note, I definitely agree with the statement that diet is the biggest component. You can bust your *kitten* trying to run marathons, swim, hoola hoop...whatever, but if you aren't fueling your body properly, no workout regimen is going to fix you.
0 -
I do Crossfit and I have never even heard of this Glassman guy that a certain poster can't get enough of bashing! And guess what, I don't really care what he has said about it! Every single concept that has ever been invented has evolved from the inventor to present day! Just because he was involved in the early stages doesn't mean that he still controls how the workouts are today. I have gone to many different workouts over the years, including the YMCA and I have never had a better workout than a Crossfit workout! The instructors are awesome, they keep the classes small, no more than 5 people in a class so they can properly supervise and make sure everyone is doing everything safely! I personally have never tried a box jump...but have you ever watched the Biggest Loser? Bob Harper has 300lb contestants on that show doing it!
I totally agree with one of the previous posters comments on runners dropping dead at marathons! I don't know anyone who has dropped dead while exercising in a gym, but a lady near where I live was hit by a car and died while out for a run! The fact of life is that every single sport has risks and benefits and each person has to weigh and decide what their limits are. And like another previous poster said, I would rather be hurt trying something new while I am improving my life, than be out of shape and at risk of dying with obesity related illnesses!
If you don't have the courage to at least try it for yourself, then do us all the courtesy of not bashing it and keep your negativity to yourself.0 -
this thread has amused me greatly. Especially the zombie part! totally awesome there!
I want to try crossfit even more so now...just because somebody out there is filled with such hatred...I want to know why!
I feel the need to say I dont CF right now but after some of my workouts at the gym I am so sore I can barely sit down to use the toilet without yelping... days when I have a body pump and bootcamp in the same day...OUCH...but LOVE!!!0 -
No, I never met the Glassman guy, but any fitness instructor that says their workouts can kill people, but expect people to do them anyway, must have a few screws loose .
Crossfit creates addiction in many ways. Here are a few to start with
1.Convincing people that a Crossfit workout is better than anything else, when there is absolutely no evidence of that being the case. Making participants believe that if they leave Crossfit, they will never become as fit as they could be. Making people believe that Crossfit will do for them what no other exercise program could possibly do.
2. Making it about Crossfit community. While admittedly, a lot of fitness franchises could do a better job of creating community within their exercise classes, community would not give me reason to join or stay in an exercise program I found too extreme or didn't like. But it would some people -- especially those who do not feel they have community. That is how cults often recruit members -- by promising people who have no real feeling of community in life that their organization will give them what they always wanted.
3. Making participants feel they have failed their Crossfit community if they do not show up for the WOD, and being encouraged to feel that way about others in the "box" -- which keeps everyone in the box feeling obligated to come to workouts.
Don't you know that running can kill you too or don't you have traffic in sno-ville? Nothing more dangerous than some dumbass jogger with their ipod on full jogging down country lanes oblivious to their need to get out of the freaking way!0 -
I have a trainer at the YMCA...and...*drum roll* HE'S A CROSSFITTER! :noway:
He's given me some awesome moves that come from CrossFit and I love it. Granted they've been simple things, like kettle bell swings, sumo lifts...tire flipping. I have absolutely loved his workouts. Before I do anything he always checks form. I've been sore, but it's a good sore. So, I can't wait until I'm in better shape and I can check out a box.
"Crossfit moves" did not originate from Crossfit.
The Glassman guy that started Crossfit took them from pre-existing workout routines, made the workout so tough that most people can't do it, and sold it with a stick-and-a-carrot approach that if you pay money to his organization and do his Workouts of the Day, you might eventually become one of those ripped elite Crossfitters, which very few people will actually be able to do, because they don't have the right gene pool to develop that kind of a muscle structure.0 -
I've been really interested in getting into CF. I'll be honest, I'm fat. But, CF is a goal of mine. I did Krav Maga for awhile and loved the less traditional type work out and have come to love the exertion from Krav. I love doing things that aren't typical girl things; I'd rather be working out with the guys. When I hit the gym, I love pushing myself at weight lifting - I've never really been a cardio freak. I do love biking, but I don't think I'd ever be a runner. Anyway, I think that's part of the allure to CF: pushing myself in a way that helps me maneuver my body in ways that you can't quite do in a typical work out.
With that said, and yes I know I'm feeding the troll....
I go to the Y. It's not free. It's more expensive than the gym I had been going to and a half hour trainer session is more at the Y. Anyway, yes, I have a trainer at the YMCA...and...*drum roll* HE'S A CROSSFITTER! :noway:
He's given me some awesome moves that come from CrossFit and I love it. Granted they've been simple things, like kettle bell swings, sumo lifts...tire flipping. I have absolutely loved his workouts. Before I do anything he always checks form. I've been sore, but it's a good sore. So, I can't wait until I'm in better shape and I can check out a box.
On one more note, I definitely agree with the statement that diet is the biggest component. You can bust your *kitten* trying to run marathons, swim, hoola hoop...whatever, but if you aren't fueling your body properly, no workout regimen is going to fix you.
I dont know if you can see my profile photo... but I did all that WITH Crossfit. It doesnt matter your size. Everything is scale-able. Definitely try it if you want to. Even fit people who come in start somewhere.0 -
I am about 6 months in on my Crossfit membership and as with any fitness program you have to scale to your comfort level and ability. This is definitely a love / hate situation but you shouldn't knock it before you try it. Our local Crossfit affiliate focuses on safety and form and will yank you out of the workout to correct you, pull weights off your bar or whatever needs to happen to be sure you are safe and avoid injury. Yes the workouts are hard but nobody will make you feel bad for not coming or living your life like a normal person. We have 70 year old men, obese middle age women, beginners and yes a few that are in amazing shape from years of Crossfitting but to anyone who is interested in trying it.... I highly recommend it.
For those Crossfitters that puke and pass out, they are doing that to themselves... and choose to. It is definitely not recommended at our Crossfit.0 -
No thanks, I don't want to spend my money with organizations whose founder makes statements like"
Mr. Glassman, CrossFit's founder, does not discount his regimen's risks, even to those who are in shape and take the time to warm up their bodies before a session.
"It can kill you," he said. "I've always been completely honest about that."0 -
Changed my mind. It is not worth my time.) 0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions