Can some people never fit in a sz 2?

malibukaty11 · February 2012

I think most average framed people can fit into a modern day size US size 2 (which really isn't that small). I can't imagine that the majority of the population is large framed. I have a huge butt and I fit into a 2/4 at my current weight. I used to be a 14 before all the weight loss. Below a 2 or 4 for a tall person might be harder I'm guessing but its not that unattainable.

I don't get why everyone thinks they would look "sickly" at a healthy weight still.

I am 5'6, and my goal weight is about 135-140 depending on how muscular I am, and size 6. I went through a really awful breakup and got down about 130 for awhile and probably could have worn a size 4 but my hair was falling out lol. My goal pic is me at a 6 and about as skinny as I want to get. If I get much further below 6 it doesn't look good on me so I have no desire to attain a 2. I would consider myself "average" framed.

Goal_Seeker_1988 · February 2012

I'd never want to be a size 2. I like my curves! My goal is a size 6... Currently size 8. I'd never aim for a size 2 HELL to the NO!

LuckyLeprechaun · February 2012

5'9", 155, I wear a size 8.
I'm hoping when I reach my GW of 145 that I'll be wearing a 6.
Size 2 would be too small for me.

njmp · February 2012

I was a a size 3...back around the time I was 18, weighing a ridiculous 115 being 5'8". I was, probably goes without saying I was ridiculously skinny. BUT, I do have hips. I weigh a bit under 150 now and usually wear a size 7 or 9. Hoping to eventually get back in to 5s!!!

kaybelmore · February 2012

I'm 5'8" with a BMI around 18.5 (I know, I know its a little low) and I cannot fit into a size 2. Any less weight i would be pretty darn unhealthy and i still prolly wouldn't fit into a smaller size :P

spectralmoon · February 2012

I've been a size 4 before, but I don't think I was ever a 2. Hips and all, even at my skinniest (112 lbs).

hazelnut861 · February 2012

Sure you can! But if you're anything like me the other thigh and butt check isn't going to fit. I have a medium frame and baby making hips lol. They just won't go over the hips no matter how much I lost. I wouldn't look good st a size 2 anyways.

shamr0ck · February 2012

Smallest i've ever been as an adult was a size 5. I don't think i could get into a 2. Nor would i want to. Now my daughter, on the other hand, when she was 16 and weighed the same as i did at the same age, could wear a 0 or a 2.

victoria4321 · February 2012

Because at 125 (and I'm 5'1") I was a size 8/10.... I have incredibly thick muscles in my thighs (I used to climb... a lot).... I would literally have to lose muscle mass for me to be thin enough to wear a 2.... I have friends that wear a 0/2... there is no way I could ever be as thin as they are.... again, not without starving myself.... and that's not to even mention my DD boobs.

I didn't factor in the big breasts part, lol I'm definitely flat chested. Wouldn't you be be smaller with more muscle though? I'm only smaller now at a higher weight because I've been lifting heavier weights and have more muscle. I'm 5'3ish so we're kinda close in height. 125 is my goal weight.

CoryIda · February 2012

Sure you can! But if you're anything like me the other thigh and butt check isn't going to fit. I have a medium frame and baby making hips lol. They just won't go over the hips no matter how much I lost. I wouldn't look good st a size 2 anyways.

Best. Answer. Ever.

blv0267 · February 2012

I can be a size 2 between 100-105 lbs and the brand of clothing, but it is questionable as to whether I look good or not. And I'm thinking "not" is what I look like there.

summonfire · February 2012

I think so, pretty much only petite framed women probably could be that size surely? (which I think is a 6 here in the UK). and I've seen size 6 on a hanger, its tiny.

I am 5ft 10 and now 132 (after 23lbs lost, woohoo), I now fit a size 10 (uk) in jeans. If I were to lose any more weight then I would be classed as 'underweight'. So reckon I will never be lower than a 10 (usa 8?) because of my health, but also my hips!! Clothes sizes over here in the UK vary widely depending on where you shop, so I could be a size 8(uk) in some shops.

My story if any of you want to see: http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/436225-21lbs-lost-with-photos

Clothes that fit and look good is more important than the label, and more importantly be a healthy size! (for your frame)

_Kitten_Kate · February 2012

You would have to have a petite frame to be a size two not matter how tall you are. I have a friend who is 5'9 125. She is a small frame... she wears a 2 or 4. She has hips and a butt for that size. But every where else she is SKINNY. And honestly TOO skinny. She would look much better with a lil weight and muscle on her. But thats all personal preference I suppose.
I am 5'10 and large build. The smallest I ever was ... was a juniors 8/10. A nd I was SKINNY then. Skin and bones.
Thats why BMIs are so off to me.... never true and accurate. Becouse there are so many different frames that that wieght can sit on.

springermad · February 2012

I am an American size 2 which is a UK size 4 x

mznisaelaine · February 2012

The smallest I can get to is a size 9 (been there before when I was 135 pounds) and currently I am your height, I currently weigh the same as you and my goal is to get to 140-150. The smallest I have ever been was a size 9....So I am satisfied with getting back down to that

christine24t · February 2012

I've lost 50 pounds which is a pretty substantial amount. I can even tell I've lost that much weight. But I've only gone down from a 16 to a 12.

Ocarina · February 2012

I think size 2 would be awesome and all except for the annoying fact that there is not a consistency in our sizing in America. A size 2 can mean a size 00 or a 4-5 in totally different stores.

With that being said, I'm 5'9'' and I will be absolutely happy to be a size 5. I'm already ecstatic to be under the double digits. I really think you have NOTHING to fret about once you are size 12 or under. At that size you can basically shop anywhere. There will obviously be things you shouldn't wear but we all are female with curves and can pull off plenty of outfits. We just have to know what looks good and find it. Also if you aren't happy with what you have you can always weight lift or do other things to form your body into what you want.

But I really think it should NOT be about size but about how you LOOK and FEEL in the outfit.

craziedazie · February 2012

I think most average framed people can fit into a modern day size US size 2 (which really isn't that small). I can't imagine that the majority of the population is large framed. I have a huge butt and I fit into a 2/4 at my current weight. I used to be a 14 before all the weight loss. Below a 2 or 4 for a tall person might be harder I'm guessing but its not that unattainable.

I don't get why everyone thinks they would look "sickly" at a healthy weight still.

how tall are you if you don't mind me asking? nevermind i see you are 5'3 - that explains the whole post. lol.
when you get into the 5'9 + range it is physically impossible for some of us to get a size 2 around our hip bones no matter what we weigh.

warmachinejt · February 2012

i don't know about sizes but i just wanna say that people keep saying this frame stuff are wrong. If i eat like a pig for 2 years I will be huge. My "frame" will be bigger. There is no such thing as frame, only, underweight - healthy - overweight - obese - past obese

craziedazie · February 2012

i don't know about sizes but i just wanna say that people keep saying this frame stuff are wrong. If i eat like a pig for 2 years I will be huge. My "frame" will be bigger. There is no such thing as frame, only, underweight - healthy - overweight - obese - past obese

Right, but the size of your bones will not change. I am sure you can agree that all people of the same height do not have the same exact bone structure/size. That is what people mean by "frame."

victoria4321 · February 2012

how tall are you if you don't mind me asking? nevermind i see you are 5'3 - that explains the whole post. lol.
when you get into the 5'9 + range it is physically impossible for some of us to get a size 2 around our hip bones no matter what we weigh.

I wasn't too sure about taller people really. I just keep seeing a lot of people who are short also all saying they have large frames and could never be that size or would look sick. I've never seen a person my height look sick at a size 2 personally.

I'll also admit that I do take a little offense to all the "that size looks sick etc etc" comments so that probably influences my comments lol.

helloiloveukitty · February 2012

I think most average framed people can fit into a modern day size US size 2 (which really isn't that small). I can't imagine that the majority of the population is large framed. I have a huge butt and I fit into a 2/4 at my current weight. I used to be a 14 before all the weight loss. Below a 2 or 4 for a tall person might be harder I'm guessing but its not that unattainable.

I don't get why everyone thinks they would look "sickly" at a healthy weight still.

this. but hey, if someone want's to be a size 10 or 12 and thinks they would look unhealthy lower whatev....their body. Personally I don't generally think double digit sizes are healthy or "normal" for any woman who is under 6' but I'm not the queen of the world and someone should look how they want first and foremost.

But a size 2 is not universal and not that small. I'm almost 5'8" and 150, I'm a size 6 in most things, wear extra small and small tops, yoga pants, sweats, ect even though I'm really busty and have curves and seriously...they aren't that tiny...clothing sizes are getting bigger. I always assumed I was large boned because I was fat and it was a nice excuse.

craziedazie · February 2012

how tall are you if you don't mind me asking? nevermind i see you are 5'3 - that explains the whole post. lol.
when you get into the 5'9 + range it is physically impossible for some of us to get a size 2 around our hip bones no matter what we weigh.

I wasn't too sure about taller people really. I just keep seeing a lot of people who are short also all saying they have large frames and could never be that size or would look sick. I've never seen a person my height look sick at a size 2 personally.

I'll also admit that I do take a little offense to all the "that size looks sick etc etc" comments so that probably influences my comments lol.

I agree about the comments, I think that it is stupid to say a size 2 looks sick - it totally depends on the person. There are a lot of tall people in my family and we just happened to have large hip bones. As a skinny, and I mean ribs sticking out skinny, teenager a 6/7 was the smallest size I wore.

hbrittingham · February 2012

Lots of people wear a size 2 and look great in it!

I have never worn smaller than a size 10. I am 5'5" and my lowest weight was 118 (too thin for me) and I wore a size 10. So those who assume that people who are not smaller than a "double digit" are fat just don't have the same bone structure as those of us who have wider hips and shoulders. Just like there are apple shaped, pear shaped and hourglass shaped people, everyone has a different structure.

I know I will look good in a 10/12, I already look good in a nice fitting 14. I only have 20 lbs to go to hit my goal and I will be a 10/12 at that time. I will look and feel good and that's what matters. And I won't judge those who have different frames from me by insinuating they are fat because they wear a size larger or insinuating that they are anorexic because they wear a size 2.

craziedazie · February 2012

Lots of people wear a size 2 and look great in it!

I have never worn smaller than a size 10. I am 5'5" and my lowest weight was 118 (too thin for me) and I wore a size 10. So those who assume that people who are not smaller than a "double digit" are fat just don't have the same bone structure as those of us who have wider hips and shoulders. Just like there are apple shaped, pear shaped and hourglass shaped people, everyone has a different structure.

I know I will look good in a 10/12, I already look good in a nice fitting 14. I only have 20 lbs to go to hit my goal and I will be a 10/12 at that time. I will look and feel good and that's what matters. And I won't judge those who have different frames from me by insinuating they are fat because they wear a size larger or insinuating that they are anorexic because they wear a size 2.

Can some people never fit in a sz 2?

Replies

Categories