Skip to content
  • Register
    • We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

    Anyone doing No Carbs diet?

    24

    Replies

    • Posts: 138 Member
      I try to stick to around 60 ish carbs but generally below 100. And I try to aim for around 100g protein.

      But my question is, do you all take off the fibre or just count the carbs? I'm a bit confused by this. And if you do take off the fibre, is there a tool to do this or do you just do it mentally? Thanks
    • Posts: 588 Member
      I try to stick to around 60 ish carbs but generally below 100. And I try to aim for around 100g protein.

      But my question is, do you all take off the fibre or just count the carbs? I'm a bit confused by this. And if you do take off the fibre, is there a tool to do this or do you just do it mentally? Thanks

      Problem with low carb diets and people in general is that they end up doing everything wrong to begin with. They feel crappy and moody all the time, and refuse to take 1-2 days a week to carb load. Some people abolish every carbohydrate possible in their diet, ignore fiber as an important element in their diet, and end up quitting their diet altogether. In addition to doing all that they end up doing massive amounts of cardio and by the time they are done cutting they loss a lot of muscle.
    • Posts: 12,142 Member
      show previous quotes

      Minimum protein requirements is 150g regardless of weight. Reason is studies have concluded that for some reason eating under 150g of protein leads to nitrogen loss regardless of weight.

      Lol
    • Posts: 300 Member
      show previous quotes

      Problem with low carb diets and people in general is that they end up doing everything wrong to begin with. They feel crappy and moody all the time, and refuse to take 1-2 days a week to carb load. Some people abolish every carbohydrate possible in their diet, ignore fiber as an important element in their diet, and end up quitting their diet altogether. In addition to doing all that they end up doing massive amounts of cardio and by the time they are done cutting they loss a lot of muscle.

      Totally agree, I chose a route that is sustainable. Some days I go over 100g other days I go under 70g. I buy lower carb grain choices and limit myself to only 2 servings of grain choices all other carbs are veggie/nuts/etc. I dont plan on counting carbs all my life, so im building menus I love and can eat without worry.

      I have tacos every day and cheese and other things. Its not hard really. Just cook your food from fresh unprocessed choices and you will lose lots of weight.
    • Posts: 137
      If you need advice on a low to no carb (ie. under 20 carbs a day) diet I suggest heading over here.

      http://www.reddit.com/r/keto

      I just don't think you'll get the responses here that you are looking for without setting off panic responses and starting arguments with wanna-be scientists.
    • Posts: 206
      show previous quotes

      Problem with low carb diets and people in general is that they end up doing everything wrong to begin with. They feel crappy and moody all the time, and refuse to take 1-2 days a week to carb load. Some people abolish every carbohydrate possible in their diet, ignore fiber as an important element in their diet, and end up quitting their diet altogether. In addition to doing all that they end up doing massive amounts of cardio and by the time they are done cutting they loss a lot of muscle.
      I don't carb load. That is totally against the way my diet works. If it works for you, great, but I find it much easier to stay in benign dietary ketosis and not be hungry.
    • Posts: 1,000 Member
      show previous quotes

      Exercise has no effect on weight loss. I'll clear this up by saying, there are a few studies "you can look them up" That showed people who exercised with out dietary modification. Lost 2-4bs in a year. The more you exercise the hungerier you get and the more you eat.


      Really? you have to be joking? This cannot be an honest statement...... is it?
    • Posts: 1,000 Member
      show previous quotes

      "Assuming zero carbohydrate intake, during the first 3 weeks of a ketogenic diet a protein
      intake of ~150 grams per day should be sufficient to achieve nitrogen balance. Therefore,
      regardless of bodyweight, the minimum amount of protein which should be consumed during the
      initial three weeks of a ketogenic diet is 150 grams per day."Ketogenic Diet-Lyle Mcdonald pg 56

      Since you're incorrect, i guess this makes everything you have said this far as invalid?

      invalid.jpg
    • Posts: 12,142 Member
      show previous quotes

      "Assuming zero carbohydrate intake, during the first 3 weeks of a ketogenic diet a protein
      intake of ~150 grams per day should be sufficient to achieve nitrogen balance. Therefore,
      regardless of bodyweight, the minimum amount of protein which should be consumed during the
      initial three weeks of a ketogenic diet is 150 grams per day."Ketogenic Diet-Lyle Mcdonald pg 56

      Since you're incorrect, i guess this makes everything you have said this far as invalid?

      You said "studies have concluded" and posted no studies to support your assertion. And if you actually read the OP's post, she said she is doing low carb not no carb.
    • Posts: 976
      Low carb will help you with your weight loss. My advice in the first stages is to stick with MFP goals and alter things as you go along.

      Aim to lose 1-2lbs a week to start.

      If you over think things at the beginning then you will probably give up and go back to square one.
    • Posts: 3,988 Member
      [/quote]

      "Exercise has no effect on weight loss. I'll clear this up by saying, there are a few studies "you can look them up" That showed people who exercised with out dietary modification. Lost 2-4bs in a year. The more you exercise the hungerier you get and the more you eat."
      [/quote]

      You, sir, are extraordinarily deluded. Do you mean to say that increasing my activity level(aka exercising), eating healthier foods and losing over 45 pounds(nine dress sizes) in the last year and a half is all a myth? Whoa...
    • Posts: 3,988 Member
      show previous quotes

      "Exercise has no effect on weight loss. I'll clear this up by saying, there are a few studies "you can look them up" That showed people who exercised with out dietary modification. Lost 2-4bs in a year. The more you exercise the hungerier you get and the more you eat."

      You, sir, are extraordinarily deluded. Do you mean to say that increasing my activity level(aka exercising), eating healthier foods and losing over 45 pounds(nine dress sizes) in the last year and a half is all a myth? Whoa...
      [/quote]

      "eating healthier foods" is dietary modifications. Obviously I am not the deluded one.
      [/quote]

      I still eat many of the "bad junk foods" I used to, just added some healthier stuff to the mix. I feel one of the main reasons I have become more fit and less fat is still due greatly to my increased physical activity.
    • Posts: 737 Member
      ive done the 'no' or very very low carbs beforre.. few times.. but its hard and not realistic for 'regular eating'... esp on the go or just in life.. and yes ive lost weight on it before.. but ive always gained it back because i feel so deprived.. and not even having 'bread' or something after a while.. im sniffing sourdough bread in the isles of the store!!! im now.. since MFP (WEEK 2 NOW) eating what i already like but making it healthier (egg whites/vs eggs) less of goodies/snacks and keeping protein high.. and keeping calories where I need them and exercising every day at least once.. i have 50-80 lbs to loose so theres no way im not gonna have me a damn piece of toast ya know?! lol.. im just over the 'crash' type diets.. how i see 'no/way low carb' diets....:flowerforyou:
    • Posts: 588 Member
      show previous quotes
      I don't carb load. That is totally against the way my diet works. If it works for you, great, but I find it much easier to stay in benign dietary ketosis and not be hungry.

      If you do a lot of strength training then Carb loading while on a no carb/ low carb diet is a must. I personally do vigorous strength training that involves free weights, and conditioning drills. My body would feel too weak if I were to do such activities, and I have experienced this in the past.
    • Posts: 33 Member
      Im pretty low carb almost by default because I'm working out so I try to eat tons of protein and that eats up my cals for the day.

      Cool part is I work in a hospital lab so I can check myself for ketones (through urinalysis) for free. It only took a few days and still I feel normal.

      As an aside it should be used as a way to break through stalls or short-mid term diet, not a lifestyle.
    • Posts: 469 Member
      Sorry, i eat a HIGH carb diet, heheh. Makes me have a ton of energy and I feel great which means I burn a TON of calories. I tired a low carb diet a week ago. It just about killed me so I went back to what works best for me. Love my carbs!
    • Posts: 14,025 Member
      I've recently started eating less carbs and I've found that I feel a lot better than if I kept a higher level in my diet. I ate a lot of carbs last night for dinner and ended up feeling very bloated.
    • Posts: 24
      I don't believe the low carb to no carb (don't even know how that's possible) to be a sustainable diet. Carbs are what your body runs on first, you need them. Not to mention, where is everyone getting their fibre from with the lack of carbohydrates eg fruits and vegetables? No wonder people are so clogged up...
    • Posts: 136
      have you read the book 'the Zone Diet'? or anything on the paleo diet? maybe some useful info for you (us) there :smile:
    • Posts: 98 Member
      bump for later
    • Posts: 136
      how does one RESET their Protein goal? I just typed in my weight goal loss...and system AUTOMATICALLY put that in.


      please advise.!
      :-)
      did you find this yet_ it's manually adjustable under your settings, under the goals category.
    • Posts: 3,161 Member
      Okay, I took a peek at your diary. It appears you are keeping carb grams very low. You had me worried there for a sec.

      You may want to change the title to "low" instead of "no" carbs. :smile:

      Exactly.
    • Posts: 3,161 Member
      I don't believe the low carb to no carb (don't even know how that's possible) to be a sustainable diet. Carbs are what your body runs on first, you need them. Not to mention, where is everyone getting their fibre from with the lack of carbohydrates eg fruits and vegetables? No wonder people are so clogged up...

      A controlled carb (with being on the lower side) is easily sustained.

      Fiber isn't as important when you are eating high fat and eating sufficient water intake because it slides right out. No constipation issues here.

      When I opt for a bit higher carbs (all from fruits, vegetables and sweet potatoes) then I lower my fat intake a bit.

      And carbs are not "necessary". Fat is the preferred fuel for the body to run on. The body is amazing at converting burned fat and protein into the necessary glucose needed.
    • Posts: 2,505 Member
      Why not just eat a healthy, balanced diet? Your body needs carbs.
    • Posts: 129 Member
      i try to stay in the 50 to 60 carb range daily allowing myself 1500 calories-it works for me. I mess up sometimes but i seem to do better on a low carb then a low cal..best of luck to you!
    • Posts: 3,161 Member
      Why not just eat a healthy, balanced diet? Your body needs carbs.

      There is no such thing as an essential carb.

      Why does everyone think we need carbs????? Technically we could be very happy and healthy eating protein and fats. Boring, but it can be done and for some it is very sustainable.

      Personally, I like vegetables and fruits so that is where I get "some" carbs from, but that is it.
    • Posts: 12,142 Member
      show previous quotes

      There is no such thing as an essential carb.

      Why does everyone think we need carbs????? Technically we could be very happy and healthy eating protein and fats. Boring, but it can be done and for some it is very sustainable.

      Personally, I like vegetables and fruits so that is where I get "some" carbs from, but that is it.

      What is glucose?
    • Posts: 1,256 Member
      I eat carbs.. but only fruits veggies and low fat dairy. No grains, breads, or pastas. I have seen tremendous results in fat loss since making the change.
    • Posts: 206
      show previous quotes

      If you do a lot of strength training then Carb loading while on a no carb/ low carb diet is a must. I personally do vigorous strength training that involves free weights, and conditioning drills. My body would feel too weak if I were to do such activities, and I have experienced this in the past.
    • Posts: 3,924 Member
      Why not just eat a healthy, balanced diet? Your body needs carbs.

      http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/nutrition/how-many-carbohydrates-do-you-need.html
    This discussion has been closed.

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register

    Quick Links

    Categories