Recomposition: Maintaining weight while losing fat
Replies
-
I thought I'd throw in a little 2 cents from an article I wrote recently, just for those who are trawling through the pages and want to find some evidence to support Body Recomposition!
Sometimes it may be hard to see the finish line, so knowing that it is a scientifically backed training and dieting concept might help you regain your motivation and get back on track.
If you are wondering if you are capable of Body Recompositioning, check out the following study-backed categories and see if you fall into any of them:
Overweight (A lil thicc)
If you have significant extra fat, then by training and eating at a deficit you will not only lose fat but build muscle at the same time. This is the result of the excess fat being used as energy to fuel the muscle building process.
A 12-week study by Demling and DeSanti aimed to analyse the effects of a caloric deficit and resistance training in overweight (26% body fat) police officers. The results showed a total fat loss of 9.3 lbs and gained 8.8 lbs fat free mass over those 12 weeks.
Beginner/Novice Lifter (Get them Noob Gains!)
Treuth et al. examined the “effects of strength training on total and regional body composition in older men.” These untrained individuals gained 2kg on average in fat-free mass, while losing 2kg of fat mass over 16 weeks.
Nindl et al. focused on “Regional body composition changes in women after 6 months of periodized physical training.” They found that the untrained women had a 2.2% increase in lean body mass and a 10% decrease in fat mass.
Palumbo et al. researched the “Effect of combined resistance and endurance exercise training on fat loss.” The results showed a 1.2kg gain in Lean Body Mass, and a loss of 1.7kg to 2kg in fat mass.
Detrained Athlete
Zemski et al. note a substantial gain in Fat Free Mass (1.8kg increase) with a significant reduction in Fat Mass (-2.2kg) in elite Rugby players who are coming off a 4 week detraining block.
Ogasawara et al. noted similar findings that individuals who experienced periods of detraining are able to make the same strength gains as those who continuously train. This suggests that the body adapts to training stimulus incredibly quickly and be primed for muscle growth after a period of detraining.
Enhanced/Steroid Users
This category goes without saying, and is an area I am not as familiar with. If you are taking steroids, testosterone replacement, fat burners or some combination of all three, your body will respond accordingly. Feel free to do the research on this one yourself if you’re interested.
If you look at any Body Recomposition articles, these are the four types of trainee that are most suited to gaining muscle and losing fat at the same time.
However, it’s 2021 and the idea of Body Recomposition has been studied for over 20 years. One such researcher and Body Recomposition expert is Chris Barakat, who has become somewhat of an popular figure in the area of Body Recomposition. It is his belief that there is a fifth type of trainee that can benefit:
The “Sub-Optimally Trained Athlete”
Cribb et al. researched the effect of whey protein on trained individuals and found they gained 1.3 kg of Lean Body Mass, minimal change in Fat Mass, and added 20 kg to their Bench Press.
Mackenzie-Shalders et al. in a study of protein distribution in Elite Rugby Players preseason training found 2.7 kg increase in Lean Body Mass over 12 weeks and lost roughly 2 kg of fat.
Rauch et al. Studied collegiate female volleyball players entering into a highly controlled power-training block. The players gained on average 2.7 kg of Lean Body Mass, and lost 2.7 kg of Fat Mass.
So if you're reading this in 2021 with some new Fitness or Body Recomp goals but aren't sure if it's right for you, hopefully this will help you make up your mind!
- Sean
10 -
So, no, I did not maintain my weight while slowly recomping but I did a cut to 180 and then bulked back to 215 pounds. I do have some posts in this thread where I did do that with great results, but this time I did a bulk since about August to a couple of weeks ago. Both of these pictures are me at the same body weight. The scale is just one tool. I am now cutting to see if how much muscle I can hang onto. I'm hoping to be just as lean but 5+ pounds heavier come this summer.
16 -
I started trying to lose weight in September at 180kg and dropped down to 150kg by new years but eating less and lots of cardio. I mainly did cardio and not much weights, I got pretty depressed at how much strength I lost. At 180kg I could bench press 130, deadlift 180kg, and squat 150kg. At 150kg I could barely bench 70, DL 100kg, and squat 80kg.
So I started a weight lifting plan, iv made some gains while still losing weight. I'm almost down to 130kg, can deadlift 150kg, squat 90kg, and bench 90kg. This isn't huge by any means but at least I'm retaining and gaining a little strength while losing significant weight.
Iv still got a chunk of weight to lose, hopefully, I can keep my strength maybe even get stronger.1 -
CameronWhittaker wrote: »I started trying to lose weight in September at 180kg and dropped down to 150kg by new years but eating less and lots of cardio. I mainly did cardio and not much weights, I got pretty depressed at how much strength I lost. At 180kg I could bench press 130, deadlift 180kg, and squat 150kg. At 150kg I could barely bench 70, DL 100kg, and squat 80kg.
So I started a weight lifting plan, iv made some gains while still losing weight. I'm almost down to 130kg, can deadlift 150kg, squat 90kg, and bench 90kg. This isn't huge by any means but at least I'm retaining and gaining a little strength while losing significant weight.
Iv still got a chunk of weight to lose, hopefully, I can keep my strength maybe even get stronger.
Probably should recognize that your prior plan actually made it worse than you seem to realize.
Perhaps to realize fast loss pace is not good.
You lost weight off your body too.
If you still squated and deadlifted exactly the same after you lost 30 kg and it was max - you lost 30 kg of strength in those 2 lifts, right?
Because of not lifting the extra bodyweight now.
Ya, it gets ugly quick when an extreme diet is done.
Even with enough protein and strength training - if you aren't keeping a reasonable deficit - say goodbye to some muscle.
Your strength is holding steady if you are replacing on the bar what you lose on the body, for the lifts that includes the body anyway.
Good job with the bench, and wanting to catch it before it got worse in general.
Some don't and wonder where it all went.5 -
This is all so helpful, so glad I found this thread. I was in prep for a BB show last year and switched over to a bulking/building phase in since May 2020 (when my show was canceled bc of Covid). I hit the top of my bulk in Sep and have maintained since. In prep I followed my coaches macro plan, hit my protein targets and never missed a lift day, but I was so weak, depleted and didn’t look very defined at all (picture on the left). I’m not sure if a meal plan would serve me better next prep, maybe I just didn’t get lean enough, I had been in a deficit at that point for years or maybe I just didn’t have enough of a base. I start my cut again in May but am so scared I’ll lose everything I’ve built, most specifically my strength. In terms of a reasonable deficit to retain strength I would aim for .5 lb loss a week, but to hit a 20 lb loss that would take me 40ish weeks, isn’t being in a deficit that long also harmful when trying to retain? Sorry for the length, I’m already stressed about my upcoming cut 🤣
6 -
jennacole12 wrote: »I start my cut again in May but am so scared I’ll lose everything I’ve built, most specifically my strength. In terms of a reasonable deficit to retain strength I would aim for .5 lb loss a week, but to hit a 20 lb loss that would take me 40ish weeks, isn’t being in a deficit that long also harmful when trying to retain? Sorry for the length, I’m already stressed about my upcoming cut 🤣
Being in a reasonable deficit for a long time is not harmful, that's the point of reasonable, it's not the stress on the body unreasonable would be.
You could have 5 lbs @ 1 lb weekly and be reasonable, until moving to 0.5 lb weekly.
Might benefit from a 1 week diet break at 10 lbs left, and 5 lbs left.
To retain strength - don't drop the weight on the bar.
And increase the weight on the bar for squats & deadlifts by the amount lost off the body.
You'll have to cut frequency or duration, but keep the intensity - ie weight on the bar.
Drop sets, and/or reps, to keep the intensity just as difficult.
Obviously don't expect increases during a deficit, wrong time to increase everything in a diet.
But can maintain.
Weight training to do during fat loss - http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/training/weight-training-for-fat-loss-part-1.html
1 -
jennacole12 wrote: »I start my cut again in May but am so scared I’ll lose everything I’ve built, most specifically my strength. In terms of a reasonable deficit to retain strength I would aim for .5 lb loss a week, but to hit a 20 lb loss that would take me 40ish weeks, isn’t being in a deficit that long also harmful when trying to retain? Sorry for the length, I’m already stressed about my upcoming cut 🤣
Being in a reasonable deficit for a long time is not harmful, that's the point of reasonable, it's not the stress on the body unreasonable would be.
You could have 5 lbs @ 1 lb weekly and be reasonable, until moving to 0.5 lb weekly.
Might benefit from a 1 week diet break at 10 lbs left, and 5 lbs left.
To retain strength - don't drop the weight on the bar.
And increase the weight on the bar for squats & deadlifts by the amount lost off the body.
You'll have to cut frequency or duration, but keep the intensity - ie weight on the bar.
Drop sets, and/or reps, to keep the intensity just as difficult.
Obviously don't expect increases during a deficit, wrong time to increase everything in a diet.
But can maintain.
Weight training to do during fat loss - http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/training/weight-training-for-fat-loss-part-1.html
Thank you so much! I just read the whole thing and found it very helpful, although I may need to read it a few more times to make sure I pulled everything, there’s a lot of info in there. And by cut frequency or duration you mean.... I’d essentially squat the same weight, as my standard working set, but rather than 5 sets of 5 or whatever.... I may have to cut down to 3 sets of 5?0 -
See if this posts0
-
Strange - I've got a post that is pretty simple getting hit by a MFP front end keyword blocker.
0 -
As that article mentions, you can drop 2/3 combined of frequency and volume to maintain, and do something that will increase your daily calorie burn more than lifting in the saved time, so then a reasonable deficit allows you to eat more. That's the metabolic training he references and why.
1 -
Can't get rest of the post showing the math on what 2/3 of 5x5 is.
Argument 1 passed to KeywordBlocker\Library\KeywordContentFilter::matchesWord() must be of the type string, null given, called in /var/www/frontend-d96ce2dcd89ea7/plugins/KeywordBlocker/Library/KeywordContentFilter.php on line 700 -
jennacole12 wrote: »I start my cut again in May but am so scared I’ll lose everything I’ve built, most specifically my strength. In terms of a reasonable deficit to retain strength I would aim for .5 lb loss a week, but to hit a 20 lb loss that would take me 40ish weeks, isn’t being in a deficit that long also harmful when trying to retain? Sorry for the length, I’m already stressed about my upcoming cut 🤣
If you want to get lean enough for a BB show/competition, you will lose strength, no doubt about it, you cannot expect to want to BB, powerlift and do strength type sports at the same time...on a serious fat loss BB depletion phase you will be as weak as....or are you just cutting weight/fat for a weight class competition in strength sports? I gain/maintain strength on most cuts, but I am a strength athlete, not a BB...1 -
Moving this thread up as some people are looking for it. Great thread!3
-
Just found this thread yesterday after a search on building muscle. tremendous amount of info, just started reading through the thread, going to take me a couple of weeks at least. I see it has slowed down recently, but glad I found it. Still a lot I don't understand, but will hopefully pick up along the way. I assume most people have achieved their goals over time. hope there are a few just starting this journey that will tag along. Within 10 lbs of goal weight after 4 months, started weights last month. From what I read to date, appears I was on transition to recomp and did not know it. Body fat still over 20%, muscle mass at 75% according to scales. Eating at a 500 calorie deficit,(1500 total) not adding back in earned spent calories due to walking. Weights 3 times per week and just adjusted up calories by 250 on those days only today. Will see if my weight loss continues by doing this.3
-
bump1
-
@Silvergrizz - I am just starting to look into body recomposition, and was also happy to stumble across so much good information in one place.
I bookmarked this page a few weeks ago but haven’t developed a solid plan yet. Recently, I started working with a personal trainer for 30 minutes twice a week, which involves doing a lot of exercises using resistance bands and my body weight. So, I’m thinking about adding a couple of heavier weight trading days. I’m going to talk with the trainer tomorrow to get some ideas.
It sounds as though you have a consistent routine underway. Good for you and congratulations on your progress!1 -
Body recomp started today very slight calorie deficit hoping to lose some fat and retain as much muscle as possible6
-
I'm 5 lbs away from my goal, and after a lot of reading and thinking about where I'd like to end up, here I am. Bumping my calories a bit is the easy part, but I'm somewhat limited in terms of access to workout equipment so I might have to get creative as things progress. I'm starting from not super strong so I'm good for now though. Looking forward to learning.3
-
Morning, Thought everyone had lost interest in this thread, glad to see a few others with an interest. Thought I would update my progress. Within 3.5 lbs of goal weight now. I was increasing my walking every couple of weeks to the point I was up to about 8 miles per day everyday. I found myself getting more fatigued each day and realized my calorie deficit was reaching over 1500 per day. Adjusted myfitnesspal to start adding exercise calories back into the mix, but keeping a base 500 calorie deficit for the day. Energy increased substantially, felt much better. Body fat hovers between 19 and 20%, while muscle mass is hovering around 75%. Purchased a used Bowflex a couple of weeks ago and started utilizing it versus the weights. Enjoying it much more than weights. did a reset in myfitnesspal on goals and myfitnesspal adjusted base calories to 1650 per day and I upped it 1900 per day on the 3 days I workout, Mon, Wed, Friday. Also made a slight adjustment in Macros to bring carbs back to 40% and Fat and Protein at 30%. Usually manage to stay within 2-3% of goals. Still find it difficult to get enough water in each day, but notice on days I do manage to get 8 glasses a day, I seem to get a better sleep.6
-
So in the 9 days since my first post I increased my calories by 150/ day to leave a 100 calorie deficit for those last 5 lbs to slowly take care of themselves. I increased the weight I was lifting. And I somehow accidentally lost 3 lbs, which is a fair bit more than my usual range of water weight fluctuation. I have no idea what my body is doing!
I gained the weight by overeating chips - like half to three quarters of a bag at a time most days, along with sensible portions of home-cooked healthy meals. Which explains why I'm 5'6", apparently 132 lbs now, and 27-29% body fat. Going by several photo scales since I don't have access to any other way of measuring, but it's pretty consistent between all of them. I'm satiated by protein, so now I need to figure out how to add back the calories in a healthier way to hopefully make my way to 20-23ish% bf with more muscle replacing it. I guess it's time to start experimenting!5 -
This content has been removed.
-
11
-
Thanks for posting! I'd heard about this today since I'm a BBB member, but hadn't gotten the chance to watch it yet.1 -
@psuLemon Thanks so much for posting! I have been at a bit of a crossroads with my training and nutrition and that has really helped give me a sense of direction.0
-
Awesome, thank you. At this point I'm kind of tentatively wandering through some of the recommended resources, feeling a bit intimidated and trying not to overwhelm myself. And lifting some heavy-to-me stuff while doing so.1 -
Not problem. I love his videos. I started following him to help my wife, but i find it overall content very good.1
-
Not problem. I love his videos. I started following him to help my wife, but i find it overall content very good.
Thanks for the post, similarly started following him to advise the Mrs. but had never watched a video with him... he sounds like Norm McDonald, which I wasn't expecting.0 -
Pretty good video on the subject by Jeff Nippard.
(My take on it is that the optimisations mentioned are more aimed at people who are already pretty highly trained and have more lofty goals than most. Although he stresses that it's training that is the driving force he does spend a lot of time on the nutrition side of it, but it's not a one size fits all approach either, which is refreshing.)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M4K0s792wAU 6 -
question, in recomp should you be replacing calories burned after work outs or just stay at slightly under maintenance. newbie0
-
carlolocicero wrote: »question, in recomp should you be replacing calories burned after work outs or just stay at slightly under maintenance. newbie
Recomp means eating at maintenance. No weight change.
Maintenance is what you burn in total.
Is exercise calorie burn part of what you burn in total?
(considering how much could be burned in workouts since you had no comment of what those workouts are - it could be very far from "slightly under" effect)
Suggest reading the post right before yours, and watching the video - you missed a very good post.
And then reading the first 3 pages should get the idea across enough. Not sure how many posts that is, but call it 20.5
https://youtu.be/MpkwtHqtHWU
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions