Do you post "gym selfies?"
Replies
-
nuttynanners wrote: »I have an anonymous Instagram account on which I sometimes share post-workout selfies. I use my IG fitness account as sort of an illustrated supplement to MFP. There's a whole community of people on IG similar to MFP, with an added visual element.
It may be a little narcissistic, but I think that a lot of the gym selfies I see on the fitness community of IG are all about fostering hard work and self care, much like MFP.
Same here. I post a daily gym selfie on IG, and it gives me a confidence boost. I can see the progress as I scroll through all the pics.0 -
I don't post selfies too often. I do post clips of my workout though. Does that mean I'm extra narcissistic?0
-
This content has been removed.
-
Please do not cease or desist.LolBroScience wrote: »I don't post selfies too often. I do post clips of my workout though. Does that mean I'm extra narcissistic?
0 -
Based upon the opinions of most of the users who have posted, it seems they do not feel the Brunel University in London study does not hold true and narcissism is not prevalent in those who post 'gym selfies' on social media sites. Great discussion!0
-
Based upon the opinions of most of the users who have posted, it seems they do not feel the Brunel University in London study does not hold true and narcissism is not prevalent in those who post 'gym selfies' on social media sites. Great discussion!
Me thinks the study should be re-titled "Group of DYEL's conduct study on personal jealousy - Haters gonna hate."0 -
I think it is all relative - it depends on who is doing the defining (which camp one is on). I have a feeling soon enough they will do a study on people that do not post/take selfies, accompanied by a defining word for them
0 -
LolBroScience wrote: »Based upon the opinions of most of the users who have posted, it seems they do not feel the Brunel University in London study does not hold true and narcissism is not prevalent in those who post 'gym selfies' on social media sites. Great discussion!
Me thinks the study should be re-titled "Group of DYEL's conduct study on personal jealousy - Haters gonna hate."
Hahahaha quite amusing, however the study is performed in a objective manner as is all scholarly work. I doubt the motivations for the study are based upon emotional responses0 -
I see you have very little experience with studies.0
-
Is the selfie situationally appropriate? On this site, yes. On FB? Maybe not so much. I think that question has bearing on the conclusion I would come to one way or the other. That being said, my gym doesn't allow cameras, so, no selfies for me.0
-
ElizabethKalmbach wrote: »Is the selfie situationally appropriate? On this site, yes. On FB? Maybe not so much. I think that question has bearing on the conclusion I would come to one way or the other. That being said, my gym doesn't allow cameras, so, no selfies for me.
Just out of curiosity, why does your gym not allow cameras? An oddly specific policy I might add.0 -
ElizabethKalmbach wrote: »Is the selfie situationally appropriate? On this site, yes. On FB? Maybe not so much. I think that question has bearing on the conclusion I would come to one way or the other. That being said, my gym doesn't allow cameras, so, no selfies for me.
Just out of curiosity, why does your gym not allow cameras? An oddly specific policy I might add.
It's common at a lot of commercial gyms actually0 -
ElizabethKalmbach wrote: »Is the selfie situationally appropriate? On this site, yes. On FB? Maybe not so much. I think that question has bearing on the conclusion I would come to one way or the other. That being said, my gym doesn't allow cameras, so, no selfies for me.
Just out of curiosity, why does your gym not allow cameras? An oddly specific policy I might add.
I see you have very little experience with gyms, as well.0 -
LolBroScience wrote: »ElizabethKalmbach wrote: »Is the selfie situationally appropriate? On this site, yes. On FB? Maybe not so much. I think that question has bearing on the conclusion I would come to one way or the other. That being said, my gym doesn't allow cameras, so, no selfies for me.
Just out of curiosity, why does your gym not allow cameras? An oddly specific policy I might add.
It's common at a lot of commercial gyms actually
I do not usually go to gyms or know much about them, so my knowledge on their policies is fairly limited.0 -
It's not that unusual, really. My gyms are a part of a State University, so I always figured it was just a way for them to reduce headaches and shenanigans. I've never really needed to prove to anyone but my insurance provider that I was at the gym anyway, and just swiping my ID at the door does that.0
-
ElizabethKalmbach wrote: »Is the selfie situationally appropriate? On this site, yes. On FB? Maybe not so much. I think that question has bearing on the conclusion I would come to one way or the other. That being said, my gym doesn't allow cameras, so, no selfies for me.
Just out of curiosity, why does your gym not allow cameras? An oddly specific policy I might add.
I see you have very little experience with gyms, as well.
I find your posts irrelevant to the discussion and frankly distasteful, I would like to ask you to please cease any further negative comments. Thank you.0 -
ElizabethKalmbach wrote: »Is the selfie situationally appropriate? On this site, yes. On FB? Maybe not so much. I think that question has bearing on the conclusion I would come to one way or the other. That being said, my gym doesn't allow cameras, so, no selfies for me.
Just out of curiosity, why does your gym not allow cameras? An oddly specific policy I might add.
I see you have very little experience with gyms, as well.
I find your posts irrelevant to the discussion and frankly distasteful, I would like to ask you to please cease any further negative comments. Thank you.
You did start a topic to link people to a blog that doesn't really say anything that references a study nobody can access. Then you haven't actually contributed much of anything to the discussion, so I can see why people would poke fun at you.0 -
They're actually quite relevant.
First post of mine: it doesn't matter what anyone thinks of others posting gym selfies.
Second post of mine: studies are often started because someone has an emotional investment in the subject.
Third post of mine: confirmed by you later, that you don't know basic rules of most gyms.
I give your trolling a 3/10.0 -
thesupremeforce wrote: »ElizabethKalmbach wrote: »Is the selfie situationally appropriate? On this site, yes. On FB? Maybe not so much. I think that question has bearing on the conclusion I would come to one way or the other. That being said, my gym doesn't allow cameras, so, no selfies for me.
Just out of curiosity, why does your gym not allow cameras? An oddly specific policy I might add.
I see you have very little experience with gyms, as well.
I find your posts irrelevant to the discussion and frankly distasteful, I would like to ask you to please cease any further negative comments. Thank you.
You did start a topic to link people to a blog that doesn't really say anything that references a study nobody can access. Then you haven't actually contributed much of anything to the discussion, so I can see why people would poke fun at you.
My dear sir, I've been a catalyst for intelligent discussion. My contribution has been that of a third person stand point.0 -
Didn't you know? If you are fit, you're supposed to be ashamed of that progress. You should not share it on Facebook, because that would be narcissistic. You should not post status updates of successes in the gym or progress made. That is braggery.
However... If you are volunteering at your child's school - THAT is FB worthy. Because that shows you are a good parent. Or if you make a delicious meal. You should post THOSE pics. Or, you can always feel free to post a meme about how you are NOT fit or beautiful, that you have curves and focus on your family. Those are acceptable.
But posting pictures that show you may have a nice physique? Despicable. Heaven forbid someone feels that you are telling them that you are a better at parenting er... cooking er... taking care of yourself. You may come across as having a better family life er... cooking skills er... body than them. And that's clearly wrong.
ETA: Oh and don't forget vacation photos... those are perfect photos to post. No one will ever think that you are posting those because you're richer than them, or have better opportunities. Everyone wants to see your posts of your world travels. But not your running route... or your new work out clothes. Fancy shoes? yes... Runners no.
Clear... right?0 -
LolBroScience wrote: »I don't post selfies too often. I do post clips of my workout though. Does that mean I'm extra narcissistic?
I need to start doing this, so I can see my form....especially on squats.
Hard to get a good idea on your form doing a squat and trying to watch in a mirror.
0 -
They're actually quite relevant.
First post of mine: it doesn't matter what anyone thinks of others posting gym selfies.
Second post of mine: studies are often started because someone has an emotional investment in the subject.
Third post of mine: confirmed by you later, that you don't know basic rules of most gyms.
I give your trolling a 3/10.
My point for your second claim is a scientific experiment should not have emotional variables that may skew the data.
Your third claim is claim was correct but by chance not by the evidence presented.
But by the nature of your posts they are to discourage me which I assure you they do not, but have hindered the ability of reasonable discussion. Please, end this behavior.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
asflatasapancake wrote: »MireyGal76 wrote: »Didn't you know? If you are fit, you're supposed to be ashamed of that progress. You should not share it on Facebook, because that would be narcissistic. You should not post status updates of successes in the gym or progress made. That is braggery.
However... If you are volunteering at your child's school - THAT is FB worthy. Because that shows you are a good parent. Or if you make a delicious meal. You should post THOSE pics. Or, you can always feel free to post a meme about how you are NOT fit or beautiful, that you have curves and focus on your family. Those are acceptable.
But posting pictures that show you may have a nice physique? Despicable. Heaven forbid someone feels that you are telling them that you are a better at parenting er... cooking er... taking care of yourself. You may come across as having a better family life er... cooking skills er... body than them. And that's clearly wrong.
Damn girl! Remind me not to piss you off! Lovely work, by the way. I did post a troll pic on page 2 too. Of course, I also posted a picture of a women getting pelted with hot dogs, so, what do I know?
haha... this is a sensitive topic for me. I am bombarded daily on FB with the articles that say it's ok to be overweight, to celebrate your body and who you are... to "rock those curves" and yet it is abundantly clear that ONLY applies if you are overweight... because god forbid you even HINT at being in shape, or going to the gym. You must be a bad mother / sacrificing your family if you are.0 -
Re: point 2: they often do. That's why studies are peer-reviewed. To make sure the science is correct and not swayed by external circumstances.
The fact that you can't handle criticism is your problem. On the off chance that you're not just a Friday Troll, I'll advise you to think more about what you're trying to say/do. Create better threads and discussions. And actually try taking a stance. Your posts in this thread scream troll, as you haven't expressed any opinions - rather, tried to play "gotcha" with a couple of posters.0 -
MireyGal76 wrote: »Didn't you know? If you are fit, you're supposed to be ashamed of that progress. You should not share it on Facebook, because that would be narcissistic. You should not post status updates of successes in the gym or progress made. That is braggery.
However... If you are volunteering at your child's school - THAT is FB worthy. Because that shows you are a good parent. Or if you make a delicious meal. You should post THOSE pics. Or, you can always feel free to post a meme about how you are NOT fit or beautiful, that you have curves and focus on your family. Those are acceptable.
But posting pictures that show you may have a nice physique? Despicable. Heaven forbid someone feels that you are telling them that you are a better at parenting er... cooking er... taking care of yourself. You may come across as having a better family life er... cooking skills er... body than them. And that's clearly wrong.
ETA: Oh and don't forget vacation photos... those are perfect photos to post. No one will ever think that you are posting those because you're richer than them, or have better opportunities. Everyone wants to see your posts of your world travels. But not your running route... or your new work out clothes. Fancy shoes? yes... Runners no.
Clear... right?
This refers back to the previous question:
If one is already proud of their accomplishment, regardless of what it is, by posting for a public audience to see, does that constitute as 'narcissistic'?0 -
MireyGal76 wrote: »asflatasapancake wrote: »MireyGal76 wrote: »Didn't you know? If you are fit, you're supposed to be ashamed of that progress. You should not share it on Facebook, because that would be narcissistic. You should not post status updates of successes in the gym or progress made. That is braggery.
However... If you are volunteering at your child's school - THAT is FB worthy. Because that shows you are a good parent. Or if you make a delicious meal. You should post THOSE pics. Or, you can always feel free to post a meme about how you are NOT fit or beautiful, that you have curves and focus on your family. Those are acceptable.
But posting pictures that show you may have a nice physique? Despicable. Heaven forbid someone feels that you are telling them that you are a better at parenting er... cooking er... taking care of yourself. You may come across as having a better family life er... cooking skills er... body than them. And that's clearly wrong.
Damn girl! Remind me not to piss you off! Lovely work, by the way. I did post a troll pic on page 2 too. Of course, I also posted a picture of a women getting pelted with hot dogs, so, what do I know?
haha... this is a sensitive topic for me. I am bombarded daily on FB with the articles that say it's ok to be overweight, to celebrate your body and who you are... to "rock those curves" and yet it is abundantly clear that ONLY applies if you are overweight... because god forbid you even HINT at being in shape, or going to the gym. You must be a bad mother / sacrificing your family if you are.
I have noticed and thought that as well....
But luckily a lot of friends on FB are into working out and lifting and stuff.....so I see more of that, than I do of what you see.
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
MireyGal76 wrote: »Didn't you know? If you are fit, you're supposed to be ashamed of that progress. You should not share it on Facebook, because that would be narcissistic. You should not post status updates of successes in the gym or progress made. That is braggery.
However... If you are volunteering at your child's school - THAT is FB worthy. Because that shows you are a good parent. Or if you make a delicious meal. You should post THOSE pics. Or, you can always feel free to post a meme about how you are NOT fit or beautiful, that you have curves and focus on your family. Those are acceptable.
But posting pictures that show you may have a nice physique? Despicable. Heaven forbid someone feels that you are telling them that you are a better at parenting er... cooking er... taking care of yourself. You may come across as having a better family life er... cooking skills er... body than them. And that's clearly wrong.
ETA: Oh and don't forget vacation photos... those are perfect photos to post. No one will ever think that you are posting those because you're richer than them, or have better opportunities. Everyone wants to see your posts of your world travels. But not your running route... or your new work out clothes. Fancy shoes? yes... Runners no.
Clear... right?
This refers back to the previous question:
If one is already proud of their accomplishment, regardless of what it is, by posting for a public audience to see, does that constitute as 'narcissistic'?
Possibly, yes. Or they're being social.
Are you being narcissistic by posting a study which allows you to showcase your advanced intellect?0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions