I get bulky from weights...

jellab

Does this happen to anyone else? I love class/group style workouts. I used to belong to a women's only studio where all we did was body weight (lunges, squats, push ups, boxing) and I looked amazing. Then I bought into this heavy lifting craze and decided to join CrossFit. I loved it! But I got bulky and stalky looking. My clothes fit tighter and I just didn't look as lean or thin. Has this happened to anyone else? I think I may just dump weights and go back to body weight/resistance. Now I'm in between and have no idea what the best workouts are.

I'm short and curvy...maybe that's why?

SpecialSundae

How much were you eating before and after?

BeachIron

You gained weight because of food intake. If you want to look leaner then eat at a deficit and keep training at CrossFit.

jellab

I was eating about the same at both studios. As a matter of fact, I was more conscious of what I ate while doing CrossFit because I followed the Paleo diet.

AlongCame_Molly

Does this happen to anyone else? I love class/group style workouts. I used to belong to a women's only studio where all we did was body weight (lunges, squats, push ups, boxing) and I looked amazing. Then I bought into this heavy lifting craze and decided to join CrossFit. I loved it! But I got bulky and stalky looking. My clothes fit tighter and I just didn't look as lean or thin. Has this happened to anyone else? I think I may just dump weights and go back to body weight/resistance. Now I'm in between and have no idea what the best workouts are.

I'm short and curvy...maybe that's why?

Stalky means long and thin, like a corn or beanstalk. ...Did you mean to say "stocky"? Because the two words actually have opposite meanings...

jellab

Yep, stocky. Not a word I use often. Definitely not long and thin. Thanks.

BeachIron

What you ate isn't the issue. It's how much. You can gain weight eating perfectly clean and you can lose weight eating Twinkies or other junk. CrossFit is intense and it will increase your appetite so if you are not carefully tracking your calories I can imagine you could have gained weight simply because of the hunger.

That said, you can gain muscle mass and lose fat while eating around maintenance if you're new to training. If you think you look bulky then again, the answer is not to blame your training regime, but to eat at a deficit to strip off the excess fat.

Unknown

This content has been removed.

ummommyme

I don't think you will find many people on MFP who will say it's not your food. But everyone is wired differently. So you may just put on muscle easier because of your genetics. I say if bodyweight workouts were working great for you then go back to that. Just because everyone on here says you have to lift heavy does not mean it works for everyone. Good luck to you!

SwimBikeRunMama

I tend to bulk up, too. I have learned that I can't really do strength training more than once a week. I am still very toned, but losing the fat.

PhattiPhat

A friend of mine has been doing Crossfit for about 10 mos but in the last few months she has been looking "bulky". She didn't always look that way, and I do suspect it's her diet. She also switched switched to Paleo around that time and from what she tells me, they don't count cals. *shrugs* What do I know, I count cals and lift too, I'm not "bulky".

whierd

Yeah, you look soooo bulky.

Joehenny

Do you even?

Gwen_B

I lift weights.. I make sure I do more reps and lighter weight so I don't end up bulky. So my arms are solid yet slimmer than they have ever been.

anemoneprose

i think you should do resistance training to the extent that that promotes general health/strength/bone density etc (so at least the minimum generally recommended guidelines, like, mayo clinic, acsm, etc).

other than that, do what makes you feel/look good, whatever that means to you.

KimLee76

I have been experimenting with strength training for the past couple of months as I am nearing my "soft" weight goal.

For me, the bulking seemed to do with fatigue. Whether it was a heavier weight for fewer reps or a lighter weight for more reps, if I pumped until my muscle were fatigued, that area bulked. (By heavier and lighter, I am certainly not suggesting that a lot of reps with a 1 lb weight will bulk the same as a few reps with a 70 lb. weight.) So for now, I'm doing less work with ab machines than the others and focusing more pilates attention on that region to help lengthen those muscles.

The current issue I'm working on is imbalance. My hamstrings (back of thighs) are developing at a faster rate than my quadriceps (front of thighs). Even though my hamstrings are abnormally tight lol I'd say, they are apparently naturally stronger. This means that I have to use the lighter weight I can handle on the leg extension machine (quads) as a guide for the weight I use on the leg curl machine (hams). I can already see a difference from my side view.

The reason I told you all that is to say you can see what's going on with your body better than anyone in here. If you see that you are bulking up from the weights and your clothes are getting tighter and you're eating the same then that's what is happening to you.

froeschli

2 questions:

1. are you eating back exercise calories?
2. do you rely on MFP for calories burned?

if both of those are answered with "yes" then it's very possible you are exceeding your calorie goal, since MFP is very generous with calories burned for strength training.
i log my lifting (NROL4W) as 'calisthenics, vigorous effort', and MFP gives me double the number than my HRM - yes, i know HRM's are not all that accurate when it comes to calories burned during strength training, but that's quite some difference to be aware of.

with me, in 5 weeks of lifting, i've put on a pound, gained 1 inch around my shoulders, lost one around my hips. but admittedly, i don't count calories all that precisely :blushing: - which is something i have to get back to doing properly if i want to achieve results within the forseeable future...

shutupandlift13

What you ate isn't the issue. It's how much. You can gain weight eating perfectly clean and you can lose weight eating Twinkies or other junk. CrossFit is intense and it will increase your appetite so if you are not carefully tracking your calories I can imagine you could have gained weight simply because of the hunger.

That said, you can gain muscle mass and lose fat while eating around maintenance if you're new to training. If you think you look bulky then again, the answer is not to blame your training regime, but to eat at a deficit to strip off the excess fat.

Bingo, and as a woman, good luck seeing noticeable gains in muscle mass while not consciously bulking.... and also good luck gaining muscle mass with CrossFit in general, its not the most efficient way to do it because of the extremely varied training and lack of consistent direct heavy lifting.

miadhail

Diet aside, since mostly everyone's pushing for that reasoning (which by the way is probably true since, in order to get bulky - i hope from increasing muscle mass and not fat - you need to be eating at a surplus)

Maybe, do more reps with relatively lighter weights? Just to maintain muscle. Instead of increasing heavy weights with slow reps?

amruden

Show me a photo of what you think is "bulky"

I love lifting. Heavy and Low reps.
Dropping body fat percentages and pant sizes.

After a good season, my jeans are tight for 2 days. As my muscles repair, and hold water.
This is normal.

It is not mass.

vjohn04

:noway: :noway: :noway:

Weightlifting is not making you bulky. As others have said.... Check your caloric intake.

Momjogger

You should do what makes you happy and makes you look good! I kickbox and zumba and cycle and take interval strength classes and run. I am not a fan of crossfit <sorry crossftters> and the women that I see doing it ARE on the bulkier side. I am sure they are super fit and strong and like how they look/feel. It is all about what You want for yourself.

LiftAllThePizzas

So for now, I'm doing less work with ab machines than the others and focusing more pilates attention on that region to help lengthen those muscles.

FYI pilates does not lengthen muscles.

BusyRaeNOTBusty

What time period are we talking? Are you sure it's not just swelling and water retention?

What is the scale doing? Are your measurements increasing. I'd like to see pictures of before and after this "bulk".




Basically it's very difficult to gain a significant amount of muscle, especially for women, especially on a diet.

rick_po

You need to have a hefty calorie surplus to gain even one pound of muscle. 3500 calories, give or take. And a lot of those excess calories must come from protein.

If you're getting bulky muscles lifting weights, you're eating a whole lot of extra calories.

There's a very short term "pump" right after a hard workout. But that should go away in an hour or so.

Momjogger

So for now, I'm doing less work with ab machines than the others and focusing more pilates attention on that region to help lengthen those muscles.

FYI pilates does not lengthen muscles.

Pilates DOES claim to strengthen AND lengthen muscles.

lin7604

so how does one figure out a proper amount of cals, when i have no idea how many i burn lifting? this confuses me HUGE! I started lifting doing clx ( chalean exteme ) and i am starting my 3rd month of it and still haven't really have noticeable results. I thought i was eating at a 10-15 % deficit, but i have no idea if i am eating too much or not enough and that is why i am not getting results?

00sarah

Ohmuhgaw, me too! Look how stocky and hulk-ish I am! Halp!

whierd

So for now, I'm doing less work with ab machines than the others and focusing more pilates attention on that region to help lengthen those muscles.

FYI pilates does not lengthen muscles.

Pilates DOES claim to strengthen AND lengthen muscles.

How do you lengthen muscles without lengthening the bone?

Mind. Blown.

shutupandlift13

So for now, I'm doing less work with ab machines than the others and focusing more pilates attention on that region to help lengthen those muscles.

FYI pilates does not lengthen muscles.

Pilates DOES claim to strengthen AND lengthen muscles.

LOL... how about Pilates increases flexibility... its not lengthening anything.

Achrya

Well crap. All lifting seems to do for me is make me smaller. Am I doing it wrong? Maybe less deadlifts and more crossfit?