Favorite Protein Bar?
Replies
-
Heads up for any vegans, vegetarians, and/or people who do not wish to consume dairy/lactose, soy, or gluten out there. I bought a D's Naturals Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip bar last time I went to GNC. I do not have any of the above dietary requirements; the bar simply looked tasty to me and the nutritional facts were spot on when it comes to what I'm looking for in a protein bar. It was honestly one of the better protein bars I've had. So much so that I went to their website and ordered a sampler pack of the four protein bar flavors and both flavors of their protein almond fluffbutter.
I also picked up the Muscletech Mission1 bars in Cookies & Cream, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, and Chocolate Brownie. I've only tried the cookie dough one thus far and I wasn't really impressed. It was better after I microwaved it, but it was tougher than Quest, Combat Crunch, and Fit Elite in texture. I also picked up a GNC Puregde Protein Bar in Rich Chocolate Cake. It wasn't terrible, but it also needed to be microwaved for a while since it was extremely hard in texture.0 -
The Quest bars are the best I've found so far. The protein source is high quality (stay away from soy.) They have a good amount of both protein and fiber. Net carbs is usually in the 3-6 grams range.
I have found other bars that were tempting until I read the ingredients closely. Soy protein & sugar are valid grounds to exclude a particular brand in my opinion. Many are little more that a marketing ploy to sell candy bars.0 -
The equivalent to the girl scout thin mint cookie - Balance bar in the mint crunch flavor! They're amazing! The macros on them are perfect and I usually buy in bulk when they go on sale for 79 cents each! You can't beat that. Word of warning though, do NOT try any other flavor, they're terrible, haha.
Honestly it's the only bar I'll buy now, who doesn't want a healthy girl scout cookie ?!0 -
Oh I forgot to mention I do also love Larry and Lenny's protein cookies. I literally have a box of each of the like, fifteen flavors. A little high calorie but I mean, what do you expect with an actual cookie? I usually will eat half of one because they're gigantic anyway.
They're delicious and on sale you can get a box of 12 for $17.990 -
Oh I forgot to mention I do also love Larry and Lenny's protein cookies. I literally have a box of each of the like, fifteen flavors. A little high calorie but I mean, what do you expect with an actual cookie? I usually will eat half of one because they're gigantic anyway.
They're delicious and on sale you can get a box of 12 for $17.99
www.vitaminshoppe.com has a special 30% off sale on Lenny & Larry's cookies & brownies going on now. The cookies were around $13.00 & the Brownies were around $17.00 per box.
Not sure how long the sale will last. I am thinking maybe just until tonight.0 -
arditarose wrote: »annette_15 wrote: »How has nobody mentioned Combat Crunch bars yet? Those are the new kids on the block imo
Ditto.
I broke up with Quest. Combat Crunch is my new favorite. Decent on the calorie to protein ratio and delicious. The birthday cake one is so cool. If you put it in the microwave for literally only 6-7 seconds it's amazing, the inside is kind of doughy/cakey
I wish GNC would get more boxes of the Birthday Cake flavor! Every time I have a coupon or need some more bars they never have any or at the most one or two bars.0 -
PeachyCarol wrote: »PeachyCarol wrote: »Noreenmarie1234 wrote: »PeachyCarol wrote: »Noreenmarie1234 wrote: »Noreenmarie1234 wrote: »DO NOT TRY QUEST BARS, they had a formula change are now disgusting. It was very recently they did this, so every good thing you've heard is about the old recipe. The new ones are horrid.
Well, this is simply an opinion of yours. Certainly worth sharing, but I happen to really like the quest bars, and only just started eating them two weeks ago so they might be this new formula and I enjoy them. They fit my goals calorie and carb wise, and I like the choc peanut butter, double choc chunk, and white choc raspberry the best so far! I had the cinnamon roll flavor but didnt enjoy it as much as the others. I have yet to try the lemon cheescake I think it was, that looks like it could handle my toughest cravings for sweets!
They wont be for everyone but they're my personal favorite and recommend them to my own friends
It just sucks because they USED to be amazing and incredible and the best tasting protein bar around. If you never tried them before the formula change you won't understand. No one I knew who used to religiously eat the old bars still likes them after the change. I guess it's the type of thing where if you never had the chance to taste the amazing flavor they once were you don't know what your missing.
Cosigned.
My Vita Fiber got here today. I've got ideas to experiment on my own concoctions.
Let me know how they turn out! I actually am wishing some small company will start making the old formula under a different name or something very similar. I would buy those lol
If you have a Trader Joe's nearby, they have all those unsweetened freeze-dried fruits that will be good for using in the bars. I'm going there today to stock up on them. I want to make a bar with coconut and pineapple in it!
If you can buy Lorann oils near you, they are great for adding flavour and you only need about 1/16 tsp per bar. I make a raspberry white chocolate with the Lorann raspberry oil and a few white chocolate chips. The butterscotch oil and about 7g of chopped walnuts is awesome too. Dark cocoa powder is good for making brownie bars with organic cocoa nibs or dark chocolate mini chips for crunch with few calories.
I'll look on Amazon, thanks! I've already made some peanut butter bars with peanut butter protein powder and pb2 and they are terrific. Next time I'm adding chocolate chips. I'm sorry I didn't start making my own sooner. It's dead simple.
Once I get through the stash of protein bars I've just bought I'll have to try to make my own.
How much is the Vita Syrup?0 -
kellyjellybellyjelly wrote: »arditarose wrote: »annette_15 wrote: »How has nobody mentioned Combat Crunch bars yet? Those are the new kids on the block imo
Ditto.
I broke up with Quest. Combat Crunch is my new favorite. Decent on the calorie to protein ratio and delicious. The birthday cake one is so cool. If you put it in the microwave for literally only 6-7 seconds it's amazing, the inside is kind of doughy/cakey
I wish GNC would get more boxes of the Birthday Cake flavor! Every time I have a coupon or need some more bars they never have any or at the most one or two bars.
I find that most stores don't keep a good stock of the Combat bars. There's either nothing choclately (I don't care for cinnamon bun) or they're out of the chocolate cake or birthday cake. The birthday cake is so surprisingly good and I normally don't like vanilla.0 -
I wish I could eat the Lenny and Larry's. I mean, I'm bulking and those are still high calorie for me
0 -
Oh I forgot to mention I do also love Larry and Lenny's protein cookies. I literally have a box of each of the like, fifteen flavors. A little high calorie but I mean, what do you expect with an actual cookie? I usually will eat half of one because they're gigantic anyway.
They're delicious and on sale you can get a box of 12 for $17.99
Not to scare you but, if you didn't know, half a cookie is a serving size...0 -
Quest bars, definitely!0
-
I recently found some called Simply Protein Whey bars...my favorite flavors (so far) are chocolate mint and coconut.0
-
arditarose wrote: »kellyjellybellyjelly wrote: »arditarose wrote: »annette_15 wrote: »How has nobody mentioned Combat Crunch bars yet? Those are the new kids on the block imo
Ditto.
I broke up with Quest. Combat Crunch is my new favorite. Decent on the calorie to protein ratio and delicious. The birthday cake one is so cool. If you put it in the microwave for literally only 6-7 seconds it's amazing, the inside is kind of doughy/cakey
I wish GNC would get more boxes of the Birthday Cake flavor! Every time I have a coupon or need some more bars they never have any or at the most one or two bars.
I find that most stores don't keep a good stock of the Combat bars. There's either nothing choclately (I don't care for cinnamon bun) or they're out of the chocolate cake or birthday cake. The birthday cake is so surprisingly good and I normally don't like vanilla.
GNC online has boxes of Combat boxes of Bars buy two get one free.0 -
There are new ones out there called Power Crunch. The peanut butter cream is actually to die for. They're called wafers, and they are almost like eating a kitkat. I can get them at Walmart, and they're fabulous.0
-
Quest Nutrition is working on their recipes and sending out samples to test groups. Hopefully they are able to fix the taste without compromising the calorie to protein ratio. Its cyber Monday and I want to stock up but my favorites Chocolate Chunk and Chocolate Peanut Butter are not worth it anymore:( I told myself once I'm done with my products with sucralose I will only do stevia or no sweetner which only leaves cinnamon roll and banana nut muffin which are ok. I need CHOCOLATE!0
-
besee_2000 wrote: »Quest Nutrition is working on their recipes and sending out samples to test groups. Hopefully they are able to fix the taste without compromising the calorie to protein ratio. Its cyber Monday and I want to stock up but my favorites Chocolate Chunk and Chocolate Peanut Butter are not worth it anymore:( I told myself once I'm done with my products with sucralose I will only do stevia or no sweetner which only leaves cinnamon roll and banana nut muffin which are ok. I need CHOCOLATE!
lol I saw they posted something about having a sale on Facebook. I mentioned something about not bothering because of the new formula thinking I'd be the only one but there were pages and pages of responses that were like "no thanks".
So they are really re-working the formula again?
0 -
kellyjellybellyjelly wrote: »arditarose wrote: »kellyjellybellyjelly wrote: »arditarose wrote: »annette_15 wrote: »How has nobody mentioned Combat Crunch bars yet? Those are the new kids on the block imo
Ditto.
I broke up with Quest. Combat Crunch is my new favorite. Decent on the calorie to protein ratio and delicious. The birthday cake one is so cool. If you put it in the microwave for literally only 6-7 seconds it's amazing, the inside is kind of doughy/cakey
I wish GNC would get more boxes of the Birthday Cake flavor! Every time I have a coupon or need some more bars they never have any or at the most one or two bars.
I find that most stores don't keep a good stock of the Combat bars. There's either nothing choclately (I don't care for cinnamon bun) or they're out of the chocolate cake or birthday cake. The birthday cake is so surprisingly good and I normally don't like vanilla.
GNC online has boxes of Combat boxes of Bars buy two get one free.
I tend to buy them one at a time because I have issues keeping them in the house with me. I'm working on moderation but tend to fail a bit too often.
0 -
They "accidently" sent an email asking for top favorites and will send 2 free boxes. There was a follow-up email that it was sent to all and should have been only to the beta groups. I also follow Dr. Sarah Solomon (fitness model) and she posted a video testing a re-reformulated Cookie Dough. She seemed pretty pleased. It gives me hope.arditarose wrote: »
So they are really re-working the formula again?
0 -
besee_2000 wrote: »
They "accidently" sent an email asking for top favorites and will send 2 free boxes. There was a follow-up email that it was sent to all and should have been only to the beta groups. I also follow Dr. Sarah Solomon (fitness model) and she posted a video testing a re-reformulated Cookie Dough. She seemed pretty pleased. It gives me hope.arditarose wrote: »
So they are really re-working the formula again?
Well, I can't wait then because even after the supposedly "horrible" new formula, I haven't found protein bars that can hold a candle to the taste and texture of Quest bars. Fit Elite, Mission1 Muscletech, and Combat Crunch were all gross. Only the Chocolate Cookie Dough Combat Crunch was good, the rest were sickeningly sweet with that bar coating. The only other protein bars I've enjoyed thus far are the D's Naturals No Cow vegan protein bars.0 -
Fit Elite, Mission1 Muscletech, and Combat Crunch were all gross. Only the Chocolate Cookie Dough Combat Crunch was good, the rest were sickeningly sweet with that bar coating. The only other protein bars I've enjoyed thus far are the D's Naturals No Cow vegan protein bars.
I'm sad to hear Mission1 didn't turn out to be the Quest replacements I was hoping. I haven't tried them yet and was looking to get the chocolate one because its the only one without sugar. I haven't tried the others because they don't fall into one of my other requirements. Maybe too many calories, not enough protein, sugar or sucralose sweetner, pricier, etc. Taste had been a plus with quest also low carb. I could make my own but they don't match to the old Chocolate Chunk.
I did ponder on the D's Naturals though. I think I wanted to research them first though.
0 -
besee_2000 wrote: »
They "accidently" sent an email asking for top favorites and will send 2 free boxes. There was a follow-up email that it was sent to all and should have been only to the beta groups. I also follow Dr. Sarah Solomon (fitness model) and she posted a video testing a re-reformulated Cookie Dough. She seemed pretty pleased. It gives me hope.arditarose wrote: »
So they are really re-working the formula again?
Well, I can't wait then because even after the supposedly "horrible" new formula, I haven't found protein bars that can hold a candle to the taste and texture of Quest bars. Fit Elite, Mission1 Muscletech, and Combat Crunch were all gross. Only the Chocolate Cookie Dough Combat Crunch was good, the rest were sickeningly sweet with that bar coating. The only other protein bars I've enjoyed thus far are the D's Naturals No Cow vegan protein bars.
I sampled a vegan bar the other day that was quite good. I was just curious and found it too high calorie...Wish I could remember what it was! Pretty sure it wasn't the No Cow0 -
arditarose wrote: »besee_2000 wrote: »
They "accidently" sent an email asking for top favorites and will send 2 free boxes. There was a follow-up email that it was sent to all and should have been only to the beta groups. I also follow Dr. Sarah Solomon (fitness model) and she posted a video testing a re-reformulated Cookie Dough. She seemed pretty pleased. It gives me hope.arditarose wrote: »
So they are really re-working the formula again?
Well, I can't wait then because even after the supposedly "horrible" new formula, I haven't found protein bars that can hold a candle to the taste and texture of Quest bars. Fit Elite, Mission1 Muscletech, and Combat Crunch were all gross. Only the Chocolate Cookie Dough Combat Crunch was good, the rest were sickeningly sweet with that bar coating. The only other protein bars I've enjoyed thus far are the D's Naturals No Cow vegan protein bars.
I sampled a vegan bar the other day that was quite good. I was just curious and found it too high calorie...Wish I could remember what it was! Pretty sure it wasn't the No Cow
Now I'm curious too! It definitely wasn't the no cow because those are pretty much identical to Quest nutrition wise except they have a bit less fat. The nutrition profile is what made me pick one up to begin with before I ordered a sampler pack to try all of their products. Their fluffbutter tastes amazing mixed into plain greek yogurt!0 -
I eat Quest bars for the nutrient not so much the taste. If I was looking for great taste I sure wouldn't be eating ANY protein bar.0
-
I like Think Thin bars. Not cheap but I enjoy the brownie crunch ones with milk.0
-
I love the power crunch bars. The salted caramel is great and so is the mint chocolate.0
-
arditarose wrote: »besee_2000 wrote: »
They "accidently" sent an email asking for top favorites and will send 2 free boxes. There was a follow-up email that it was sent to all and should have been only to the beta groups. I also follow Dr. Sarah Solomon (fitness model) and she posted a video testing a re-reformulated Cookie Dough. She seemed pretty pleased. It gives me hope.arditarose wrote: »
So they are really re-working the formula again?
Well, I can't wait then because even after the supposedly "horrible" new formula, I haven't found protein bars that can hold a candle to the taste and texture of Quest bars. Fit Elite, Mission1 Muscletech, and Combat Crunch were all gross. Only the Chocolate Cookie Dough Combat Crunch was good, the rest were sickeningly sweet with that bar coating. The only other protein bars I've enjoyed thus far are the D's Naturals No Cow vegan protein bars.
I sampled a vegan bar the other day that was quite good. I was just curious and found it too high calorie...Wish I could remember what it was! Pretty sure it wasn't the No Cow
Now I'm curious too! It definitely wasn't the no cow because those are pretty much identical to Quest nutrition wise except they have a bit less fat. The nutrition profile is what made me pick one up to begin with before I ordered a sampler pack to try all of their products. Their fluffbutter tastes amazing mixed into plain greek yogurt!
Interesting. Usually the vegan type of bars I see are higher in calories/lower in protein. If I see these I'll give them a try. I'll remember to post here once I find the name of the other bar. It really was very good.0 -
tmartin19710 wrote: »I love the power crunch bars. The salted caramel is great and so is the mint chocolate.
I just ate my first protein bar. It was a Power Crunch Salted Caramel and I loved it. My question is "what makes a GOOO protein bar? By that I mean how many calories, how much protein, how much carbohydrates and how much fat is considered appropriate.0 -
arditarose wrote: »besee_2000 wrote: »
They "accidently" sent an email asking for top favorites and will send 2 free boxes. There was a follow-up email that it was sent to all and should have been only to the beta groups. I also follow Dr. Sarah Solomon (fitness model) and she posted a video testing a re-reformulated Cookie Dough. She seemed pretty pleased. It gives me hope.arditarose wrote: »
So they are really re-working the formula again?
Well, I can't wait then because even after the supposedly "horrible" new formula, I haven't found protein bars that can hold a candle to the taste and texture of Quest bars. Fit Elite, Mission1 Muscletech, and Combat Crunch were all gross. Only the Chocolate Cookie Dough Combat Crunch was good, the rest were sickeningly sweet with that bar coating. The only other protein bars I've enjoyed thus far are the D's Naturals No Cow vegan protein bars.
I sampled a vegan bar the other day that was quite good. I was just curious and found it too high calorie...Wish I could remember what it was! Pretty sure it wasn't the No Cow
Now I'm curious too! It definitely wasn't the no cow because those are pretty much identical to Quest nutrition wise except they have a bit less fat. The nutrition profile is what made me pick one up to begin with before I ordered a sampler pack to try all of their products. Their fluffbutter tastes amazing mixed into plain greek yogurt!
The No Cow bar tasted pretty good (I think I tried Raspberry), but at first it had a weird flavor to it. It almost tasted like it was harvested out of the ground.0 -
besee_2000 wrote: »
They "accidently" sent an email asking for top favorites and will send 2 free boxes. There was a follow-up email that it was sent to all and should have been only to the beta groups. I also follow Dr. Sarah Solomon (fitness model) and she posted a video testing a re-reformulated Cookie Dough. She seemed pretty pleased. It gives me hope.arditarose wrote: »
So they are really re-working the formula again?
Well, I can't wait then because even after the supposedly "horrible" new formula, I haven't found protein bars that can hold a candle to the taste and texture of Quest bars. Fit Elite, Mission1 Muscletech, and Combat Crunch were all gross. Only the Chocolate Cookie Dough Combat Crunch was good, the rest were sickeningly sweet with that bar coating. The only other protein bars I've enjoyed thus far are the D's Naturals No Cow vegan protein bars.
Fit Elite has to be one of the worst protein bars I've ever tried. My sister said it reminded her of Laffy Taffy.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions