Diet Coke vs Water??-- 0 cals vs 0 cals
Replies
-
No, they are not the same. Both may be listed as 0 calories, but there is more to this than just calories.
Sodium:
Water - 0
Diet Coke - 40mg
Total Carbs:
Water - 0
Diet Coke - 0.5g
Caffeine:
Water - 0
Diet Coke - 46mg
While these numbers are not huge, they are there. Diet Coke (and any diet drink) may not have sugar, but they do have an artificial sweetener of some sort, some of which have been tied to cancer-causing ingredients.
And one of the major benefits of water, besides keeping us hydrated, is flushing the body of unwanted and unneeded waste. Our bodies are made to use water for this function, and trying to use other liquids (sodas, coffee, tea) taxes the body's abilities.
I'm not saying don't drink diet sodas. I am saying do not count them in your daily water consumption. Regardless how many diet cokes, coffees, teas, etc you may drink during the day, you will still need at least 8 glasses of pure, clear water. IMHO.0 -
No, they are not the same. Both may be listed as 0 calories, but there is more to this than just calories.
Sodium:
Water - 0
Diet Coke - 40mg
Total Carbs:
Water - 0
Diet Coke - 0.5g
Caffeine:
Water - 0
Diet Coke - 46mg
Trivial.
While these numbers are not huge, they are there. Diet Coke (and any diet drink) may not have sugar, but they do have an artificial sweetener of some sort, some of which have been tied to cancer-causing ingredients.
And one of the major benefits of water, besides keeping us hydrated, is flushing the body of unwanted and unneeded waste. Our bodies are made to use water for this function, and trying to use other liquids (sodas, coffee, tea) taxes the body's abilities.
I'm not saying don't drink diet sodas. I am saying do not count them in your daily water consumption. Regardless how many diet cokes, coffees, teas, etc you may drink during the day, you will still need at least 8 glasses of pure, clear water. IMHO.
None of this is true
0 -
Oh but my water does not contain caffeine a necessary supplement for me each day.. Still 0 calories vs 0 calories though.
I will always enjoy by daily 20 ounces of Diet Cherry Dr. Pepper. Yep I know it has aspartame in it so along with that 20 ounces I drink 60 ounces of water a day. Maybe somewhere in the water drinking I am flushing some of the stuff that makes that dark drink soooo bad for you, or not..
0 -
No, they are not the same. Both may be listed as 0 calories, but there is more to this than just calories.
Sodium:
Water - 0
Diet Coke - 40mg
Total Carbs:
Water - 0
Diet Coke - 0.5g
Caffeine:
Water - 0
Diet Coke - 46mg
While these numbers are not huge, they are there. Diet Coke (and any diet drink) may not have sugar, but they do have an artificial sweetener of some sort, some of which have been tied to cancer-causing ingredients.
And one of the major benefits of water, besides keeping us hydrated, is flushing the body of unwanted and unneeded waste. Our bodies are made to use water for this function, and trying to use other liquids (sodas, coffee, tea) taxes the body's abilities.
I'm not saying don't drink diet sodas. I am saying do not count them in your daily water consumption. Regardless how many diet cokes, coffees, teas, etc you may drink during the day, you will still need at least 8 glasses of pure, clear water. IMHO.
Water does not have 0 sodium unless you filtered it so much all the natural minerals are gone. It has about as much as or more than diet coke depending on the source.
And again, what do you think 99% of diet coke, coffee or tea is made of or how your digestion works?0 -
I hear that diet coke can cause other health risks due to the aspiritane content?0
-
illusionist121 wrote: »I hear that diet coke can cause other health risks due to the aspiritane content?
You heard wrong.
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1308408/why-aspartame-isnt-scary/p1
0 -
illusionist121 wrote: »I hear that diet coke can cause other health risks due to the aspiritane content?
Have you read all the comments in the thread? In particular the links shared many times called "why aspartame isn't scary"?0 -
Read the label. Diet coke isn't actually 0 calories.0
-
thankyou4thevenom wrote: »Read the label. Diet coke isn't actually 0 calories.
<5 per serving, so at the worst 70 calories per gallon.0 -
stevencloser wrote: »thankyou4thevenom wrote: »Read the label. Diet coke isn't actually 0 calories.
<5 per serving, so at the worst 70 calories per gallon.
Yeah I know it's not much but no one else mentioned it and if you drink a lot over the course of a year it can add up.0 -
Mmm diet coke belly fat.0
-
thankyou4thevenom wrote: »stevencloser wrote: »thankyou4thevenom wrote: »Read the label. Diet coke isn't actually 0 calories.
<5 per serving, so at the worst 70 calories per gallon.
Yeah I know it's not much but no one else mentioned it and if you drink a lot over the course of a year it can add up.
I mentioned it in the 7th reply of this thread.0 -
niamibunni wrote: »Mmm diet coke belly fat.
What?0 -
queenliz99 wrote: »niamibunni wrote: »Mmm diet coke belly fat.
What?
I think it was supposed to say "mmmm, wooooo".0 -
queenliz99 wrote: »niamibunni wrote: »Mmm diet coke belly fat.
What?
I think it was supposed to say "mmmm, wooooo".
That is what I thought too. We are on the same page.0 -
BrandyGanus wrote: »rankinsect wrote: »BrandyGanus wrote: »stevencloser wrote: »
https://examine.com/faq/do-artificial-sweeteners-spike-insulin/Interbeing wrote: »There are a lot of reasons not to drink diet sodas, or any sodas on a regular basis. There are a number of peer reviewed studies out now that have shown that artificial sweeteners trigger insulin, which sends your body into fat storage mode and leads to weight gain and is associated with an increased risk of type 2.
Also that's not how weight gain works even.
As does the citric acid in... citrus fruits. Or malic acid from apples. Many fruits are acidic really. Don't hear anyone telling you to stay away from them for your teeth's sake. Because dental hygiene exists.For those that like their smile, the citric acid found in sodas weakens and destroys tooth enamel over time.
Was it? Links? But really, since already your first "there are studies..." thing was wrong I'm not looking forward to it.Researchers have also found that cola intake (all kinds, not just diet) was associated with low bone-mineral density in women, increasing the risk of osteoporosis. And, not to pile on, a recent study conducted by the University of Miami and Columbia University found that diet soda devotees were 43% more likely to have experienced a vascular event than those who drank none.
Cleveland Clinic article that basically says that coffee and soda CAN lower your bone density because people don't drink milk too. Phosphoric acid in sodas (not chicken or certain cheeses) leaches calcium from the bones so you need to balance the sodas with milk or calcium supplements (mainly for women).
National Osteoporosis Foundation article states that high consumption of caffeine can cause bone problems if you do not supplement it with enough calcium. The article also states that phosphoric acid can interfere with calcium absorption, so it recommends moderation with sodas and caffeinated beverages and 1000mg calcium for people under 50 and 1200mg calcium for people over 50.
The American Jounal of Clinical Nutrition states that sodas crowd out other healthier beverages and also contain both caffeine and phosphoric acid which can be deleterious to bone health, especially in women.
The sources have a lot of "might"s and "could"s. A major problem with this type of study is that it's all based on correlation, which won't prove causation. It could be, as posited, that cola drinkers, as a group, consume less milk. It could be that those who never drink cola are more health focused in general, including exercising more. It could be that something in the cola actually promotes osteoporosis. It's just very hard to draw any conclusions from the kinds of studies that have been done.
Yes, that was the point. These are the pitfalls (not drinking enough milk or ingesting too much caffeine) and they should be avoided since the research hasn't definitively shown that sodas cause bone density problems. The person before asked for studies, so I provided them.
Sure, but those are separate considerations. It's like saying a diet of nothing but water and saltine crackers leads to malnutrition and then claiming that this is one of the pitfalls of consuming water because water is so low in nutrients and therefore we all should be careful and watch our water intake. It's a non sequitur.0 -
peter56765 wrote: »BrandyGanus wrote: »rankinsect wrote: »BrandyGanus wrote: »stevencloser wrote: »
https://examine.com/faq/do-artificial-sweeteners-spike-insulin/Interbeing wrote: »There are a lot of reasons not to drink diet sodas, or any sodas on a regular basis. There are a number of peer reviewed studies out now that have shown that artificial sweeteners trigger insulin, which sends your body into fat storage mode and leads to weight gain and is associated with an increased risk of type 2.
Also that's not how weight gain works even.
As does the citric acid in... citrus fruits. Or malic acid from apples. Many fruits are acidic really. Don't hear anyone telling you to stay away from them for your teeth's sake. Because dental hygiene exists.For those that like their smile, the citric acid found in sodas weakens and destroys tooth enamel over time.
Was it? Links? But really, since already your first "there are studies..." thing was wrong I'm not looking forward to it.Researchers have also found that cola intake (all kinds, not just diet) was associated with low bone-mineral density in women, increasing the risk of osteoporosis. And, not to pile on, a recent study conducted by the University of Miami and Columbia University found that diet soda devotees were 43% more likely to have experienced a vascular event than those who drank none.
Cleveland Clinic article that basically says that coffee and soda CAN lower your bone density because people don't drink milk too. Phosphoric acid in sodas (not chicken or certain cheeses) leaches calcium from the bones so you need to balance the sodas with milk or calcium supplements (mainly for women).
National Osteoporosis Foundation article states that high consumption of caffeine can cause bone problems if you do not supplement it with enough calcium. The article also states that phosphoric acid can interfere with calcium absorption, so it recommends moderation with sodas and caffeinated beverages and 1000mg calcium for people under 50 and 1200mg calcium for people over 50.
The American Jounal of Clinical Nutrition states that sodas crowd out other healthier beverages and also contain both caffeine and phosphoric acid which can be deleterious to bone health, especially in women.
The sources have a lot of "might"s and "could"s. A major problem with this type of study is that it's all based on correlation, which won't prove causation. It could be, as posited, that cola drinkers, as a group, consume less milk. It could be that those who never drink cola are more health focused in general, including exercising more. It could be that something in the cola actually promotes osteoporosis. It's just very hard to draw any conclusions from the kinds of studies that have been done.
Yes, that was the point. These are the pitfalls (not drinking enough milk or ingesting too much caffeine) and they should be avoided since the research hasn't definitively shown that sodas cause bone density problems. The person before asked for studies, so I provided them.
Sure, but those are separate considerations. It's like saying a diet of nothing but water and saltine crackers leads to malnutrition and then claiming that this is one of the pitfalls of consuming water because water is so low in nutrients and therefore we all should be careful and watch our water intake. It's a non sequitur.
For what it's worth, I rarely drink milk whether I'm drinking soda or not. I lose my taste for soda now and then and go a few weeks without it, but I'm not guzzling milk in the meantime. There's just nothing about it that appeals to me.0 -
peter56765 wrote: »BrandyGanus wrote: »rankinsect wrote: »BrandyGanus wrote: »stevencloser wrote: »
https://examine.com/faq/do-artificial-sweeteners-spike-insulin/Interbeing wrote: »There are a lot of reasons not to drink diet sodas, or any sodas on a regular basis. There are a number of peer reviewed studies out now that have shown that artificial sweeteners trigger insulin, which sends your body into fat storage mode and leads to weight gain and is associated with an increased risk of type 2.
Also that's not how weight gain works even.
As does the citric acid in... citrus fruits. Or malic acid from apples. Many fruits are acidic really. Don't hear anyone telling you to stay away from them for your teeth's sake. Because dental hygiene exists.For those that like their smile, the citric acid found in sodas weakens and destroys tooth enamel over time.
Was it? Links? But really, since already your first "there are studies..." thing was wrong I'm not looking forward to it.Researchers have also found that cola intake (all kinds, not just diet) was associated with low bone-mineral density in women, increasing the risk of osteoporosis. And, not to pile on, a recent study conducted by the University of Miami and Columbia University found that diet soda devotees were 43% more likely to have experienced a vascular event than those who drank none.
Cleveland Clinic article that basically says that coffee and soda CAN lower your bone density because people don't drink milk too. Phosphoric acid
in sodas (not chicken or certain cheeses) leaches calcium from the bones so you need to balance the sodas with milk or calcium supplements (mainly for women).
National Osteoporosis Foundation article states that high consumption of caffeine can cause bone problems if you do not supplement it with enough calcium. The article also states that phosphoric acid can interfere with calcium absorption, so it recommends moderation with sodas and caffeinated beverages and 1000mg calcium for people under 50 and 1200mg calcium for people over 50.
The American Jounal of Clinical Nutrition states that sodas crowd out other healthier beverages and also contain both caffeine and phosphoric acid which can be deleterious to bone health, especially in women.
The sources have a lot of "might"s and "could"s. A major problem with this type of study is that it's all based on correlation, which won't prove causation. It could be, as posited, that cola drinkers, as a group, consume less milk. It could be that those who never drink cola are more health focused in general, including exercising more. It could be that something in the cola actually promotes osteoporosis. It's just very hard to draw any conclusions from the kinds of studies that have been done.
Yes, that was the point. These are the pitfalls (not drinking enough milk or ingesting too much caffeine) and they should be avoided since the research hasn't definitively shown that sodas cause bone density problems. The person before asked for studies, so I provided them.
Sure, but those are separate considerations. It's like saying a diet of nothing but water and saltine crackers leads to malnutrition and then claiming that this is one of the pitfalls of consuming water because water is so low in nutrients and therefore we all should be careful and watch our water intake. It's a non sequitur.
I've read some similar disclaimers about drinking bottled water vs tap water since bottled water doesn't typically have fluorine added. They're worried we'll all have bad teeth from not drinking enough fluoridated water. That doesn't mean that drinking bottled water is bad for you.
zbakrjc
0 -
stevencloser wrote: »thankyou4thevenom wrote: »Read the label. Diet coke isn't actually 0 calories.
<5 per serving, so at the worst 70 calories per gallon.
Sounds like a challenge. I accept.
0 -
same goes for water vs light beer right? light beer is like 98% water right0
-
robbyf1971 wrote: »same goes for water vs light beer right? light beer is like 98% water right
Didn't realize there were zero calorie light beers.
Alcohol changes the narrative too. The body "sees" alcohol as a poison and will give priority to oxidizing it over other macronutrients.0 -
robbyf1971 wrote: »same goes for water vs light beer right? light beer is like 98% water right
No, because light beer has calories.0 -
just trying to be funny0
-
robbyf1971 wrote: »just trying to be funny
Sorry
. Judging from the way this thread went, there comes a point where you just can't tell anymore! 0 -
I have found my people! *cracks open a diet Coke*0
-
Diet Coke doesn't make me break out in hives. It doesn't give me terrible headaches or heartburn. It doesn't make me eat more (I track my calories) and it doesn't make me more hungry. If it did, I would stop drinking it. I don't drink a ton of it, but when I'm craving sugar and I don't want to blow my calories for the day, it nips my sugar craving in the bud. I also drink lots of water. If I had to live on a desert island and choose only Diet Coke or only water, I would choose water. But I don't live on that island, so cheers!0
-
queenliz99 wrote: »niamibunni wrote: »Mmm diet coke belly fat.
What?
I think she means she likes Diet Coke and belly fat.
0 -
Inorganic phosphates, artificial colorings, chemically produced caffeine, artificial sweeteners...... they may all be benign, but I'll stick with water.0
-
TheBeachgod wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »niamibunni wrote: »Mmm diet coke belly fat.
What?
I think she means she likes Diet Coke and belly fat.
Hmm what a glowing endorsement for Diet Coke...0 -
Christine_72 wrote: »TheBeachgod wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »niamibunni wrote: »Mmm diet coke belly fat.
What?
I think she means she likes Diet Coke and belly fat.
Hmm what a glowing endorsement for Diet Coke...
Yes. Because I'm sure he got that big from (zero-calorie) Diet Coke.
brb photoshopping a fat dude into a picture with kale.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions