Why are so many excluding milk from their diet?
Replies
-
rippedhippie wrote: »Humans the only adult animal on the planet that drinks milk...that should tell you something...
You could point to virtually all of our food sources apart from foraging for naturally growing edible plants, and we'd be "the only" animal that does that. You won't catch a wolf sighting down the barrel of a rifle to hunt a deer. You won't catch a moose tilling the fields and planting crops to harvest later, much less selectively breeding crops that have advantageous traits. You won't see a lion pride domesticating a herd of gazelle and keeping them as a sustainable source of meat. You won't see a horse cooking its food to release greater nutrient contents, improve digestibility, or neutralize toxins in the food.0 -
I see that there are lots of good reasons why some people exclude milk from their diets, like allergies/sensitivities, food preferences; caloric priorities, or moral principles.
What I would've asked is "Why are so many - any, really - utterly adamant that the rest of us should exclude milk from our diets?"
(Well, I sort of understand why the moral-principles people advocate that, but understanding that doesn't make it seem any less presumptuous.)0 -
meh. i don't like drinking my calories. If I'm going to have cereal or something I'll use unsweetened almond milk instead0
-
meganjcallaghan wrote: »meh. i don't like drinking my calories. If I'm going to have cereal or something I'll use unsweetened almond milk instead
But... Doesn't that have calories, as well?0 -
ClosetBayesian wrote: »meganjcallaghan wrote: »meh. i don't like drinking my calories. If I'm going to have cereal or something I'll use unsweetened almond milk instead
But... Doesn't that have calories, as well?
sure....but like 25 instead of 100.....if I need to have milk for cereal I'd rather only spend a negligible amount of my calorie budget
0 -
I had to recently stop ingesting any forms of dairy due to the severe abdominal pain 30 minutes after consumption, as in 'I-just-swallowed-a-throwing-star' type pain. For example, tonight I was mixing up a batch of food for the sugar gliders which has yogurt in it. Without thinking, I licked a little bit of vanilla yogurt off the spoon. Bad mistake. Pain in 30 minutes.
Cutting milk out for dieting isn't necessary, IMO.0 -
I don't drink milk, not because I don't like it, more because I stopped eating things like cereal.. I still eat things like yogurt and cheese and other dairy products and I use it for cooking, however if I'm going to drink something I don't drink anything other than smoothies, tea, and water0
-
Actually when I study nutrition in college, our professor told us that the human body was never designed to drink cows milk. And the dairy industry is lying to the general public because calcium that is in milk cannot be digested by the human body. It is marketing ploy. They get away with this because it's true calcium is in milk but they fail to tell the general public that calcium in cow's milk cannot be digested by the human body.0
-
bellabonbons wrote: »Actually when I study nutrition in college, our professor told us that the human body was never designed to drink cows milk. And the dairy industry is lying to the general public because calcium that is in milk cannot be digested by the human body. It is marketing ploy. They get away with this because it's true calcium is in milk but they fail to tell the general public that calcium in cow's milk cannot be digested by the human body.
People say stuff like this all the time but I have a feeling if it was even remotely true it would be common knowledge.
I feel people just like the feeling of being in the minority like they are more enlightened than the masses of uneducated fools.
Any sources other than my professor said so?
But it's obvious our bodies weren't designed for cows milk since there was the millions of years we survived with out domesticating cows.
But that doesn't mean we can't use cows milk or the calcium in it.0 -
bellabonbons wrote: »Actually when I study nutrition in college, our professor told us that the human body was never designed to drink cows milk.
What does this even mean?
I have the gene or genes for lactose persistence, that certainly seems as if my body is suited to drinking milk (I actually don't, but this design argument is so bizarre).And the dairy industry is lying to the general public because calcium that is in milk cannot be digested by the human body.
Apparently so is the Harvard school of public health:
http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/calcium-full-story/#whereThe body gets the calcium it needs in two ways. One is by eating foods or supplements that contain calcium. Good sources include dairy products, which have the highest concentration per serving of highly absorbable calcium, and dark leafy greens or dried beans, which have varying amounts of absorbable calcium. Calcium supplements often contain vitamin D; taking calcium paired with vitamin D seems to be more beneficial for bone health than taking calcium alone.
Or, perhaps, your information is wrong.0 -
bellabonbons wrote: »Actually when I study nutrition in college, our professor told us that the human body was never designed to drink cows milk. And the dairy industry is lying to the general public because calcium that is in milk cannot be digested by the human body. It is marketing ploy. They get away with this because it's true calcium is in milk but they fail to tell the general public that calcium in cow's milk cannot be digested by the human body.
Your professor sounds like a biased individual with an agenda who is using their title of "professor" to push that agenda.
Your professor is wrong and you should take what he/she says with a grain of salt.0 -
rippedhippie wrote: »Humans the only adult animal on the planet that drinks milk...that should tell you something...
Humans also have the most well developed brain of any adult animal on the planet. That should tell you something.0 -
I don't do milk because I'm lactose intolerant, but honestly also because I have just begun to find that drinking another species breast milk is rather gross. Something hit me at one point...would I drink human breast milk or eat human-breast milk made cheese? No...
I should clarify I am not vegan - I still eat meat- but milk just icks me out. It potentially has pus. Eeew.
So do you keep away from eggs too? Or do you like a nice bit of chicken ovulation? Seriously though have you ever looked in to what can go into the every day foods we eat? For instance the silos that house flour/wheat are pretty much impossible to keep clear of rats so there is an acceptable level of rat poop and hair allowed in things like bread as well as yummy ground up insect. Not every peanut in peanut butter is a real peanut of course, it is a freebie added by a rodent. And you can wash that peanut butter sandwich down with a nice glass of freshly pressed juice and insect. Milk should be the least of your worries
0 -
Well, there certainly are a lot of people with lactose intolerance, judging by how many mention it, so it's obvious that from a health point of view dairy products definitely aren't suitable for everyone. Some say consuming dairy negatively affects their skin, for others it's their digestive system that suffers, but many go on to mention the problems improved or disappeared completely when they stopped eating dairy.
Apart from health reasons, I think the main reason to cut dairy from your diet completely is the ethical one. Vegans won't financially support the meat/egg/dairy industries because of bad practices in farming resulting in cruelty and unnecessary suffering inflicted on many farm animals (especially intensively farmed ones) but also because there are plenty of healthy alternative foods available to eat instead.
Whether it's hens, chicks, dairy cows and their calves or animals raised for meat, many of them are denied sometimes even their most basic needs. Since animals are conscious beings (experience hunger, thirst, pain, emotions etc) they deserve at the very least better treatment.
Anyway, here's an amusing little something from vegansidekick.com:
Omnivore: OMG, vegans are so self-righteous! You think you're better than other people.
Vegan: No I don't. I just don't want to harm animals.
Omni: Yeah well, you just do that because you think it makes you right, and then you feel proud of yourself.
Vegan: Er yeah, that's called having a conscience. What's the alternative? Do what I know is harmful and then feel bad about it?
Omni: Yeah.
0 -
TrickyDisco wrote: »Well, there certainly are a lot of people with lactose intolerance, judging by how many mention it, so it's obvious that from a health point of view dairy products definitely aren't suitable for everyone. Some say consuming dairy negatively affects their skin, for others it's their digestive system that suffers, but many go on to mention the problems improved or disappeared completely when they stopped eating dairy.
Apart from health reasons, I think the main reason to cut dairy from your diet completely is the ethical one. Vegans won't financially support the meat/egg/dairy industries because of bad practices in farming resulting in cruelty and unnecessary suffering inflicted on many farm animals (especially intensively farmed ones) but also because there are plenty of healthy alternative foods available to eat instead.
Whether it's hens, chicks, dairy cows and their calves or animals raised for meat, many of them are denied sometimes even their most basic needs. Since animals are conscious beings (experience hunger, thirst, pain, emotions etc) they deserve at the very least better treatment.
Anyway, here's an amusing little something from vegansidekick.com:
Omnivore: OMG, vegans are so self-righteous! You think you're better than other people.
Vegan: No I don't. I just don't want to harm animals.
Omni: Yeah well, you just do that because you think it makes you right, and then you feel proud of yourself.
Vegan: Er yeah, that's called having a conscience. What's the alternative? Do what I know is harmful and then feel bad about it?
Omni: Yeah.
I couldn't care less what anyone else eats, but living creatures are hurt in the farming of plant foods too.0 -
rippedhippie wrote: »Humans the only adult animal on the planet that drinks milk...that should tell you something...
Spoken like a true city kid.
So cats, dogs/wolves/coyotes, raccoons, possums, mice & rats, the occasional ground hog, and even some birds that go ape crazy when you leave out milk don't count as adult animals? Cause I guarantee you if you dump a gallon of milk in a bowl and leave it outside in my neck of the woods, it will be gone the next day, without another human within 100 yards of it.0 -
jofjltncb6 wrote: »rippedhippie wrote: »Humans the only adult animal on the planet that drinks milk...that should tell you something...
We're also the only adult animal on the planet making irrelevant forum comments.
Or who wears clothes.0 -
rippedhippie wrote: »Humans the only adult animal on the planet that drinks milk...that should tell you something...
Wow, that has to be the most ridiculous answer on this thread yet.
"Humans are the only adult animal on the planet that "insert just about anything humans do here". If we didn't do the things humans do, we wouldn't be here, chatting on this fabulous bit of technology. Which is, by the way, yet another thing that only humans do.0 -
MommyL2015 wrote: »rippedhippie wrote: »Humans the only adult animal on the planet that drinks milk...that should tell you something...
Wow, that has to be the most ridiculous answer on this thread yet.
"Humans are the only adult animal on the planet that "insert just about anything humans do here". If we didn't do the things humans do, we wouldn't be here, chatting on this fabulous bit of technology. Which is, by the way, yet another thing that only humans do.
Not true
0 -
jofjltncb6 wrote: »rippedhippie wrote: »Humans the only adult animal on the planet that drinks milk...that should tell you something...
We're also the only adult animal on the planet making irrelevant forum comments.
Or who wears clothes.
Not true. My dog has a sweatshirt that he likes to wear for all of five minutes before freaking out and laying on the floor until someone takes it off him.0 -
I just don't want to drink my calories is all. Unless it is a real drink.0
-
queenliz99 wrote: »MommyL2015 wrote: »rippedhippie wrote: »Humans the only adult animal on the planet that drinks milk...that should tell you something...
Wow, that has to be the most ridiculous answer on this thread yet.
"Humans are the only adult animal on the planet that "insert just about anything humans do here". If we didn't do the things humans do, we wouldn't be here, chatting on this fabulous bit of technology. Which is, by the way, yet another thing that only humans do.
Not true
Yeah, but can it read sheet music? 0 -
Milk does a body good. Cookies do not (enjoyment, yes, health, no). I like the two together. I will have milk but not as much as I would like (I would drink about a half gallon a day if I let myself). Its a great source of protein, calcium and vitamin d. It also has a lot of calories. I try to save it for days when I don't have much of an appetite and need to get my calories up. Some people like it, some don't.0
-
TrickyDisco wrote: »Well, there certainly are a lot of people with lactose intolerance, judging by how many mention it, so it's obvious that from a health point of view dairy products definitely aren't suitable for everyone. Some say consuming dairy negatively affects their skin, for others it's their digestive system that suffers, but many go on to mention the problems improved or disappeared completely when they stopped eating dairy.
Apart from health reasons, I think the main reason to cut dairy from your diet completely is the ethical one. Vegans won't financially support the meat/egg/dairy industries because of bad practices in farming resulting in cruelty and unnecessary suffering inflicted on many farm animals (especially intensively farmed ones) but also because there are plenty of healthy alternative foods available to eat instead.
Whether it's hens, chicks, dairy cows and their calves or animals raised for meat, many of them are denied sometimes even their most basic needs. Since animals are conscious beings (experience hunger, thirst, pain, emotions etc) they deserve at the very least better treatment.
Anyway, here's an amusing little something from vegansidekick.com:
Omnivore: OMG, vegans are so self-righteous! You think you're better than other people.
Vegan: No I don't. I just don't want to harm animals.
Omni: Yeah well, you just do that because you think it makes you right, and then you feel proud of yourself.
Vegan: Er yeah, that's called having a conscience. What's the alternative? Do what I know is harmful and then feel bad about it?
Omni: Yeah.
I know, I know, I know. You told us this already. Many times.0 -
Last 3 to 4 hours energy and keeps me full0
-
With Gnc lean 25 shakes0
-
I excluded it when doing whole30 an discovered it was responsible for a lot of digestive issues so I have no dairy now, I dont miss milk as I have almond milk instead but I really miss greek yoghurt
0 -
bellabonbons wrote: »Actually when I study nutrition in college, our professor told us that the human body was never designed to drink cows milk. And the dairy industry is lying to the general public because calcium that is in milk cannot be digested by the human body. It is marketing ploy. They get away with this because it's true calcium is in milk but they fail to tell the general public that calcium in cow's milk cannot be digested by the human body.
We were not "designed" to do most of the things that we do.
0 -
Need2Exerc1se wrote: »I couldn't care less what anyone else eats, but living creatures are hurt in the farming of plant foods too.
I'm sure you couldn't care less about a lot of things, but since the OP is asking why so many exclude milk and I have what I see as justifiable reasons for excluding it from my own diet, there's my opinion.
Re the plant food farming, vegansidekick says:
While there will be casualties in crop farming and, while vegans would prefer it not to be so, it is the least harmful thing most people can do. To feed animals to the age of slaughter it requires many times more plants to be harvested than if we just ate plants ourselves. You might argue that we could instead just eat exclusively grass-fed animals who do not require grain, but this is entirely impractical. First, most 'grass-fed' animals are not fed 100% grass anyway, and, secondly, it's not sustainable at all to try to feed 7 billion people exclusively on 'grass-fed' meat. There isn't the space available for such a thing, and good luck living exclusively off meat and nothing else.
0 -
I know, I know, I know. You told us this already. Many times.
Ah, resorting to the old 'you keep harping on about this' line now, are we? It's not many times yet, but as and when these subjects arise then, yes, I'll be voicing my opinion along with everyone else's, including the well-repeated ones, because there'll often be someone new interested in reading all our different opinions for the first time. Yours included, don't you agree?
0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions