INTERMITTENT FASTING - A LIFESTYLE MAKEOVER
Replies
-
Wheelhouse15 wrote: »JustaJoe00 wrote: »Looks like the woman that started this thread is using a different name or is no longer on the site......way to go....
Her profile is still here so I'm not sure I'm tracking you.
She also asked a question as recently as last night or this morning, and received a number of helpful (IMO) answers.0 -
lemurcat12 wrote: »Wheelhouse15 wrote: »JustaJoe00 wrote: »Looks like the woman that started this thread is using a different name or is no longer on the site......way to go....
Her profile is still here so I'm not sure I'm tracking you.
She also asked a question as recently as last night or this morning, and received a number of helpful (IMO) answers.
Maybe we didn't scare her off after all.2 -
Wheelhouse15 wrote: »For those who don't rate IF and generally feel cico is the only thing that matters, what are your thoughts on pre workout/post workout meals?
Alan Aragon covers that quite a bit in his work and has shown that there is no difference in meal timings. The window for protein synthesis elevation is rather long, about 24-48 hours. A lot of people feel better eating before and/or after a workout so it's up to you if you choice to or not.
I haven't looked into his work, I shall. Have you tried IF and been unsuccessful with it or saw no difference from what you're currently doing?0 -
Yeah. You can eat once a day or several smaller meals a day. I tried 6 small meals a day and was miserable. I eat 2 larger meals and am happy. Other people like to graze and hate to eat in a small window of time. Everyone is different
0 -
Wheelhouse15 wrote: »
I wasn't planning on changing my ways. It works like a treat and I can get away with different forns of eating vs spreading my meals out. That's just how my body works, we're all different. Whatever one sees the best results with I also say stick with that. There's multiple ways to get to the same destination.0 -
Wheelhouse15 wrote: »For those who don't rate IF and generally feel cico is the only thing that matters, what are your thoughts on pre workout/post workout meals?
Alan Aragon covers that quite a bit in his work and has shown that there is no difference in meal timings. The window for protein synthesis elevation is rather long, about 24-48 hours. A lot of people feel better eating before and/or after a workout so it's up to you if you choice to or not.
I haven't looked into his work, I shall. Have you tried IF and been unsuccessful with it or saw no difference from what you're currently doing?
I did it for a couple months but just never really enjoyed it nor found any particular benefit for me personally. I like having a more open eating schedule and never really got into the groove of it.2 -
This is why I like IFing. For me I did it for PCOS because a lot of information stated it could improve symptoms of PCOS. I didn't want to be medicated so I thought why not try it? It has helped with my cycle, my cycle is a lot more regular. I find it easier to lose weight, I'm eating about 1600 calories and losing. I find it less stressful, I eat about 500-600 for lunch, 600-700 for dinner then a small dessert. It works for me, it wasn't easy at first but being realistic any change to your diet can be difficult. But for me this was a lot easier and it fits in with my life...4
-
GaleHawkins wrote: »GottaBurnEmAll wrote: »How can you sayGaleHawkins wrote: »The doctor was only addressing over eating of carbs and proteins as to increasing cancer risks.
Then in the next sentence contradict it and say:He did not say eating carbs and protein increased cancer risk.
And why are we supposed to believe this single doctor when he says:He said over eating of fats did not increase cancer risks.
Since all the reputable science links the *overeating* that leads to obesity of *anything* with several forms of cancer. I can post links to reputable studies, not just a youtube link to one random doctor to back this up.
Thanks for doing so when you find the research.
Here's a small start. I'm in the middle of cooking dinner.
http://www.obesity.org/obesity/resources/facts-about-obesity/cancer-obesity
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3773450/
1 -
Yeah. You can eat once a day or several smaller meals a day. I tried 6 small meals a day and was miserable. I eat 2 larger meals and am happy. Other people like to graze and hate to eat in a small window of time. Everyone is different
I don't think anyone here actually eats the typical "6 small meals" a day tho, it's borderline ridiculous eating that frequently. I generally eat 2/3 times a day myself too. Just over a shorter time period.0 -
Yeah. You can eat once a day or several smaller meals a day. I tried 6 small meals a day and was miserable. I eat 2 larger meals and am happy. Other people like to graze and hate to eat in a small window of time. Everyone is different
I don't think anyone here actually eats the typical "6 small meals" a day tho, it's borderline ridiculous eating that frequently. I generally eat 2/3 times a day myself too. Just over a shorter time period.
I 16:8 and tend to graze during it. I start to feel full quickly and just like eating that way. I have 3-4 small meals and a snack during my window.1 -
Wheelhouse15 wrote: »Wheelhouse15 wrote: »For those who don't rate IF and generally feel cico is the only thing that matters, what are your thoughts on pre workout/post workout meals?
Alan Aragon covers that quite a bit in his work and has shown that there is no difference in meal timings. The window for protein synthesis elevation is rather long, about 24-48 hours. A lot of people feel better eating before and/or after a workout so it's up to you if you choice to or not.
I haven't looked into his work, I shall. Have you tried IF and been unsuccessful with it or saw no difference from what you're currently doing?
I did it for a couple months but just never really enjoyed it nor found any particular benefit for me personally. I like having a more open eating schedule and never really got into the groove of it.
Clearly a breakfast man then lol. It's been a hot minute since I've ate before even 12 pm. The hunger just isn't there that early.0 -
Yeah. You can eat once a day or several smaller meals a day. I tried 6 small meals a day and was miserable. I eat 2 larger meals and am happy. Other people like to graze and hate to eat in a small window of time. Everyone is different
I don't think anyone here actually eats the typical "6 small meals" a day tho, it's borderline ridiculous eating that frequently. I generally eat 2/3 times a day myself too. Just over a shorter time period.
Oh, you need to hang around the bros more lol. There are a lot of 6 meal a day guys in the bodybuilding community.
1 -
JustaJoe00 wrote: »Looks like the woman that started this thread is using a different name or is no longer on the site......way to go....
Not sure how to post to direct comments but giving this a go - here I am and still reading with interest. Not sure why that would bother you even if I wasn't though?12 -
ChristinaOne21 wrote: »JustaJoe00 wrote: »Looks like the woman that started this thread is using a different name or is no longer on the site......way to go....
Not sure how to post to direct comments but giving this a go - here I am and still reading with interest. Not sure why that would bother you even if I wasn't though?
So whatcha think of all this back and forth?!?! LOL1 -
Wheelhouse15 wrote: »Yeah. You can eat once a day or several smaller meals a day. I tried 6 small meals a day and was miserable. I eat 2 larger meals and am happy. Other people like to graze and hate to eat in a small window of time. Everyone is different
I don't think anyone here actually eats the typical "6 small meals" a day tho, it's borderline ridiculous eating that frequently. I generally eat 2/3 times a day myself too. Just over a shorter time period.
Oh, you need to hang around the bros more lol. There are a lot of 6 meal a day guys in the bodybuilding community.
Lol, I'm good. My prehistoric days with things fitness are well and truly over. I do it my way now.2 -
16:8 here and I eat damn near the entire 8 hours it feels like.2
-
Thank you so much for all of your responses – what a great community and loving the debates too. I have copied the four or so answers to my last questions into a doc to refer to, as it will be really useful to keep me on track and has made things so much clearer for me. Thanks guys and girls for your time and explanations.
So I now understand there are dozens of different types of diets and eating schedules out there, but to reach my own personal goal post and win the weight loss battle, I just need to make sure I am at a calorie deficit in line with how much exercise I do.
IF is definitely helping me keep the calories down - on most days - so it works for me, but may not for everybody.
And to maintain healthiness I should eat a nutrient rich, balanced diet, but not beat myself up for having the occasional 'bad' junk food (like wine, pork belly pizza and curly fries last night) as today I will get back on track with more 'good' foods. I will add bacon to my poached eggs and spinach today, so I am introducing more fat and protein.
I have also read on another post that no foods should be considered 'bad' so long as you are sticking within your calories. However I am not sure I agree with that, as most of the additives that go into processed foods are considered bad here for a myriad of health reasons, so I will try to stick to eating 'clean foods' as much as possible.
Thank you for the advice on coffee too. I’ll keep to my black coffee whilst fasting, as I like the taste now and would rather keep butter for later with food, and coconut oil for mixing with turmeric and doing 'teeth pulling' (It really does seem to make teeth whiter and gums healthier
I am concerned the coffee might be leading to more water retention though....
I also know what macros are now, so thank you for making that easy to understand.
According to my MFP food chart diary every time I eat something high in protein it ups my fat intake, so I am always way over the recommended daily intake. My carbs and fat are always over and my protein, sodium and sugar are always under. I am not sure how to work out the percentages, however I now understand that maintaining my calories-in is probably more important at this stage than trying to balance everything else perfectly.
This is the formula that MFP has put up for me after putting in my weight and height.
SW: 103.40 kg - 227.95 lbs
Height: 173 – 5.7 ft
GW: 70kgs - 154.32 lbs
Daily Goal 1200 kcal
Carbs 90 g
Protein 120 g
Fat 40 g
Sodium 2,300 mg
Sugar 45g
Anyway thanks for bearing with a newcomer to the whole weight and health tracking thing. I have really appreciated the helpful feedback and support
Christina9 -
I inadvertently fast once every so often. I will not eat for a day and it seems to do some interesting things for my diet. First of all, I tend to lose around 2 pounds, and if I was stalled before hand, the pace picks right back up. I am to a point now where when the day happens, I don't even miss the food.4
-
ChristinaOne21 wrote: »
This is the formula that MFP has put up for me after putting in my weight and height.
SW: 103.40 kg - 227.95 lbs
Height: 173 – 5.7 ft
GW: 70kgs - 154.32 lbs
Daily Goal 1200 kcal
Carbs 90 g
Protein 120 g
Fat 40 g
Sodium 2,300 mg
Sugar 45g
Christina
For your height and weight that is not enough calories!!! 1200 is too little. Your BMR is 1800 calories. I'm not sure how you have come to the number of 1200?
0 -
The_Original_Beauty wrote: »ChristinaOne21 wrote: »
This is the formula that MFP has put up for me after putting in my weight and height.
SW: 103.40 kg - 227.95 lbs
Height: 173 – 5.7 ft
GW: 70kgs - 154.32 lbs
Daily Goal 1200 kcal
Carbs 90 g
Protein 120 g
Fat 40 g
Sodium 2,300 mg
Sugar 45g
Christina
For your height and weight that is not enough calories!!! 1200 is too little. Your BMR is 1800 calories. I'm not sure how you have come to the number of 1200?
I agree, OP have you just taken that number yourself? I don't believe MFP would give that to you but I could be wrong.0 -
If she put a weight loss goal of 2 lbs a week it might have. Even with IF, I couldn't do 1200.
I wouldn't last a week.1 -
I inadvertently fast once every so often. I will not eat for a day and it seems to do some interesting things for my diet. First of all, I tend to lose around 2 pounds, and if I was stalled before hand, the pace picks right back up. I am to a point now where when the day happens, I don't even miss the food.
The two pounds will mostly be glycogen depletion and associated water loss and a small amount of fat and likely some muscle too. It takes about 3500 calories to burn a pound of fat and 2500 to burn a pound of muscle off. Depending on your activity and weight you'll probably burn 2400 to 3000 or so calories a day and you can metabolize about 66 calories per pound of fat per day.
One thing you probably did was get rid of excess water retention to get your weight moving down again.0 -
ChristinaOne21 wrote: »Thank you so much for all of your responses – what a great community and loving the debates too. I have copied the four or so answers to my last questions into a doc to refer to, as it will be really useful to keep me on track and has made things so much clearer for me. Thanks guys and girls for your time and explanations.
So I now understand there are dozens of different types of diets and eating schedules out there, but to reach my own personal goal post and win the weight loss battle, I just need to make sure I am at a calorie deficit in line with how much exercise I do.
IF is definitely helping me keep the calories down - on most days - so it works for me, but may not for everybody.
And to maintain healthiness I should eat a nutrient rich, balanced diet, but not beat myself up for having the occasional 'bad' junk food (like wine, pork belly pizza and curly fries last night) as today I will get back on track with more 'good' foods. I will add bacon to my poached eggs and spinach today, so I am introducing more fat and protein.
I have also read on another post that no foods should be considered 'bad' so long as you are sticking within your calories. However I am not sure I agree with that, as most of the additives that go into processed foods are considered bad here for a myriad of health reasons, so I will try to stick to eating 'clean foods' as much as possible.
Thank you for the advice on coffee too. I’ll keep to my black coffee whilst fasting, as I like the taste now and would rather keep butter for later with food, and coconut oil for mixing with turmeric and doing 'teeth pulling' (It really does seem to make teeth whiter and gums healthier
I am concerned the coffee might be leading to more water retention though....
I also know what macros are now, so thank you for making that easy to understand.
According to my MFP food chart diary every time I eat something high in protein it ups my fat intake, so I am always way over the recommended daily intake. My carbs and fat are always over and my protein, sodium and sugar are always under. I am not sure how to work out the percentages, however I now understand that maintaining my calories-in is probably more important at this stage than trying to balance everything else perfectly.
This is the formula that MFP has put up for me after putting in my weight and height.
SW: 103.40 kg - 227.95 lbs
Height: 173 – 5.7 ft
GW: 70kgs - 154.32 lbs
Daily Goal 1200 kcal
Carbs 90 g
Protein 120 g
Fat 40 g
Sodium 2,300 mg
Sugar 45g
Anyway thanks for bearing with a newcomer to the whole weight and health tracking thing. I have really appreciated the helpful feedback and support
Christina
Sounds like you are off to a good start. Tweaking my numbers went on for a while but I was always high calorie so it was like 6 weeks before I lost the first pound by I got my pain managed OK in the first 30 days and that has been my only goal for changing my way of eating (WOE). The foods that are bad for my pain levels and weight are highly processed carbs in my case so I have left them off for the past two years and am down 50 pounds as a side effect.
As I became non obese and blood work has greatly improved the way I eat has self modified from time to time which is normal.
Keep up your efforts and the results will continue to follow. Best of success and welcome to MFP forums. You are a self thinker it seems so I think you will be just fine. No other will know our own body and its needs the way we do if we make that our goal.1 -
Wheelhouse15 wrote: »The_Original_Beauty wrote: »ChristinaOne21 wrote: »
This is the formula that MFP has put up for me after putting in my weight and height.
SW: 103.40 kg - 227.95 lbs
Height: 173 – 5.7 ft
GW: 70kgs - 154.32 lbs
Daily Goal 1200 kcal
Carbs 90 g
Protein 120 g
Fat 40 g
Sodium 2,300 mg
Sugar 45g
Christina
For your height and weight that is not enough calories!!! 1200 is too little. Your BMR is 1800 calories. I'm not sure how you have come to the number of 1200?
I agree, OP have you just taken that number yourself? I don't believe MFP would give that to you but I could be wrong.
Me either even with 2lb loss!!! I was near her starting weight and for 2lb loss I was at 1800 calories?
0 -
frankiesgirlie wrote: »If she put a weight loss goal of 2 lbs a week it might have. Even with IF, I couldn't do 1200.
I wouldn't last a week.
My stomach just kicked me when I thought about 1200 cals per day.
3 -
She's literally an inch shorter than me and within 5-10 lbs of my goal weight. When I've had less to lose, crash dieting worked, but not for serious weight loss. She's obviously marketing.
I've maxed 1200 calories per day, with a goal of 1000 net, and burned an average 600 in exercise, and I've lost 14lbs my first month. So from 212 to 198 lbs. And a lot of that time was muscle building, which made the scale stick. I'm nowhere near my goal, and this kind of restriction isn't for everyone, but then again I'm making no recommendations and not participating in direct sales.
If you must Google, only use studies from .gov sites, or from peer reviewed, validated journals, and understand the statistical analysis and methods used in the study. Or buy her schtick. But honestly, fasting at an inch taller at that weight, I'd lose 10lbs just sleeping for 2 weeks.0 -
jessilynmelendez wrote: »She's literally an inch shorter than me and within 5-10 lbs of my goal weight. When I've had less to lose, crash dieting worked, but not for serious weight loss. She's obviously marketing.
I've maxed 1200 calories per day, with a goal of 1000 net, and burned an average 600 in exercise, and I've lost 14lbs my first month. So from 212 to 198 lbs. And a lot of that time was muscle building, which made the scale stick. I'm nowhere near my goal, and this kind of restriction isn't for everyone, but then again I'm making no recommendations and not participating in direct sales.
If you must Google, only use studies from .gov sites, or from peer reviewed, validated journals, and understand the statistical analysis and methods used in the study. Or buy her schtick. But honestly, fasting at an inch taller at that weight, I'd lose 10lbs just sleeping for 2 weeks.
Sorry, you didn't gain enough muscle while losing fat to stick the scale. The reality is that with that serious of deficit you didn't gain any muscle at all and actually lost some. You should get a DEXA and chart the progress and you'll see what you are really losing on such a steep deficit.8 -
jessilynmelendez wrote: »She's literally an inch shorter than me and within 5-10 lbs of my goal weight. When I've had less to lose, crash dieting worked, but not for serious weight loss. She's obviously marketing.
I've maxed 1200 calories per day, with a goal of 1000 net, and burned an average 600 in exercise, and I've lost 14lbs my first month. So from 212 to 198 lbs. And a lot of that time was muscle building, which made the scale stick. I'm nowhere near my goal, and this kind of restriction isn't for everyone, but then again I'm making no recommendations and not participating in direct sales.
If you must Google, only use studies from .gov sites, or from peer reviewed, validated journals, and understand the statistical analysis and methods used in the study. Or buy her schtick. But honestly, fasting at an inch taller at that weight, I'd lose 10lbs just sleeping for 2 weeks.
You'll be losing muscle running such a large deficit, not building/gaining any. Water retention due to a new workout regime would be the more likely of cause of the scale sticking.4 -
The_Original_Beauty wrote: »ChristinaOne21 wrote: »
This is the formula that MFP has put up for me after putting in my weight and height.
SW: 103.40 kg - 227.95 lbs
Height: 173 – 5.7 ft
GW: 70kgs - 154.32 lbs
Daily Goal 1200 kcal
Carbs 90 g
Protein 120 g
Fat 40 g
Sodium 2,300 mg
Sugar 45g
Christina
For your height and weight that is not enough calories!!! 1200 is too little. Your BMR is 1800 calories. I'm not sure how you have come to the number of 1200?
@Original_Beauty Did you plug her numbers into MFP?1 -
The_Original_Beauty wrote: »ChristinaOne21 wrote: »
This is the formula that MFP has put up for me after putting in my weight and height.
SW: 103.40 kg - 227.95 lbs
Height: 173 – 5.7 ft
GW: 70kgs - 154.32 lbs
Daily Goal 1200 kcal
Carbs 90 g
Protein 120 g
Fat 40 g
Sodium 2,300 mg
Sugar 45g
Christina
For your height and weight that is not enough calories!!! 1200 is too little. Your BMR is 1800 calories. I'm not sure how you have come to the number of 1200?
@Original_Beauty Did you plug her numbers into MFP?
@DebSozo
Her stats were pretty much the same as mine but a little taller. I just did it on MFP and her BMR is 1780?1
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions