Cardio
Replies
-
rileysowner wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »Weight is lost by a eating in a caloric deficit, exercise is for health.
This is so not true - not by EATING in a caloric deficit, its by being in a caloric deficit. This site is after all called my FITNESS pal. So sick of seeing that phrase on these forums... sighhhhh
OP - if you want to get yourself in a caloric deficit by exercise alone go for it - its going to be substantially better for your health than starving yourself to get there. But 20 min 3 times a week is not going to burn that much unless you are doing HIIT or some sort of high intensity circuit. You should be doing minimum 20 minutes of exercise every day, even if that's just a 20 min walk.
Whatever. However you want to create a deficit is up to you. Before i started counting calories accurately i tried losing weight by exercising which is hard to do if don't know how many calories you are eating. I was spinning my wheels. 20 years of nothing but I did have excellent health other than being obese.
OP, get accurate with intake and exercise for health and it will add some calories to your day.
What I am getting at is it is not healthy to lose weight simply by eating a calorie deficit.. you will lose weight but that doesn't mean it is healthy. Everyone needs to exercise, every day.
There is nothing intrinsically unhealthy about losing weight without exercise through the use of a moderate deficit. Doing so will improve health markers both in the blood and in terms of things like blood pressure. It is not health to lose using a huge deficit, be it created by eating very low calorie or by exercising hours a day.
I beg to differ. There IS something intrinsically unhealthy about not exercising at all, whether you're Losing, gaining, or maintaining.6 -
queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »Weight is lost by a eating in a caloric deficit, exercise is for health.
This is so not true - not by EATING in a caloric deficit, its by being in a caloric deficit. This site is after all called my FITNESS pal. So sick of seeing that phrase on these forums... sighhhhh
OP - if you want to get yourself in a caloric deficit by exercise alone go for it - its going to be substantially better for your health than starving yourself to get there. But 20 min 3 times a week is not going to burn that much unless you are doing HIIT or some sort of high intensity circuit. You should be doing minimum 20 minutes of exercise every day, even if that's just a 20 min walk.
Whatever. However you want to create a deficit is up to you. Before i started counting calories accurately i tried losing weight by exercising which is hard to do if don't know how many calories you are eating. I was spinning my wheels. 20 years of nothing but I did have excellent health other than being obese.
OP, get accurate with intake and exercise for health and it will add some calories to your day.
What I am getting at is it is not healthy to lose weight simply by eating a calorie deficit.. you will lose weight but that doesn't mean it is healthy. Everyone needs to exercise, every day.
Some can't though.
I don't agree its a matter of priority. And even though there may be a very minute percentage of the world who are that physically disabled that they cannot exercise and I guarantee that they are not on my fitness pal forums.
I agree completely. I don't buy the "can't" thing at all. I was unable to walk for 6 weeks and found work outs I could do to maintain health. I did seated cardio (lots of them can be found online) and I did hand weights. If you can move you can take steps towards fitness.
And some cannot walk at all.
Did you miss the part where I was working out when unable to walk at all? That was my entire point in my post. When I couldn't walk I found ways to remain active despite being limited to my couch.
You think you are the only one who could not walk? Wow, six whole weeks?2 -
queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »Weight is lost by a eating in a caloric deficit, exercise is for health.
This is so not true - not by EATING in a caloric deficit, its by being in a caloric deficit. This site is after all called my FITNESS pal. So sick of seeing that phrase on these forums... sighhhhh
OP - if you want to get yourself in a caloric deficit by exercise alone go for it - its going to be substantially better for your health than starving yourself to get there. But 20 min 3 times a week is not going to burn that much unless you are doing HIIT or some sort of high intensity circuit. You should be doing minimum 20 minutes of exercise every day, even if that's just a 20 min walk.
Whatever. However you want to create a deficit is up to you. Before i started counting calories accurately i tried losing weight by exercising which is hard to do if don't know how many calories you are eating. I was spinning my wheels. 20 years of nothing but I did have excellent health other than being obese.
OP, get accurate with intake and exercise for health and it will add some calories to your day.
What I am getting at is it is not healthy to lose weight simply by eating a calorie deficit.. you will lose weight but that doesn't mean it is healthy. Everyone needs to exercise, every day.
Everyday? What is your definition of "exercise" though. Does chasing my kids or glute activation in the kitchen while I'm cooking count?
Yes! I am not saying everyone needs to go to the gym every day but doing something physical exactly like you mentioned, every day yes.2 -
queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »Weight is lost by a eating in a caloric deficit, exercise is for health.
This is so not true - not by EATING in a caloric deficit, its by being in a caloric deficit. This site is after all called my FITNESS pal. So sick of seeing that phrase on these forums... sighhhhh
OP - if you want to get yourself in a caloric deficit by exercise alone go for it - its going to be substantially better for your health than starving yourself to get there. But 20 min 3 times a week is not going to burn that much unless you are doing HIIT or some sort of high intensity circuit. You should be doing minimum 20 minutes of exercise every day, even if that's just a 20 min walk.
Whatever. However you want to create a deficit is up to you. Before i started counting calories accurately i tried losing weight by exercising which is hard to do if don't know how many calories you are eating. I was spinning my wheels. 20 years of nothing but I did have excellent health other than being obese.
OP, get accurate with intake and exercise for health and it will add some calories to your day.
What I am getting at is it is not healthy to lose weight simply by eating a calorie deficit.. you will lose weight but that doesn't mean it is healthy. Everyone needs to exercise, every day.
Some can't though.
I don't agree its a matter of priority. And even though there may be a very minute percentage of the world who are that physically disabled that they cannot exercise and I guarantee that they are not on my fitness pal forums.
I agree completely. I don't buy the "can't" thing at all. I was unable to walk for 6 weeks and found work outs I could do to maintain health. I did seated cardio (lots of them can be found online) and I did hand weights. If you can move you can take steps towards fitness.
And some cannot walk at all.
Did you miss the part where I was working out when unable to walk at all? That was my entire point in my post. When I couldn't walk I found ways to remain active despite being limited to my couch.
You think you are the only one who could not walk? Wow, six whole weeks?
Wow is right. Lol. You are ignoring the point and out to try and pick a fight. Sorry not interested. The point was, is, and will continue to be that even if you cant walk you can find ways to be active. I did and know others who have worked around disabilities both temporary and permanent.1 -
queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »Weight is lost by a eating in a caloric deficit, exercise is for health.
This is so not true - not by EATING in a caloric deficit, its by being in a caloric deficit. This site is after all called my FITNESS pal. So sick of seeing that phrase on these forums... sighhhhh
OP - if you want to get yourself in a caloric deficit by exercise alone go for it - its going to be substantially better for your health than starving yourself to get there. But 20 min 3 times a week is not going to burn that much unless you are doing HIIT or some sort of high intensity circuit. You should be doing minimum 20 minutes of exercise every day, even if that's just a 20 min walk.
Whatever. However you want to create a deficit is up to you. Before i started counting calories accurately i tried losing weight by exercising which is hard to do if don't know how many calories you are eating. I was spinning my wheels. 20 years of nothing but I did have excellent health other than being obese.
OP, get accurate with intake and exercise for health and it will add some calories to your day.
What I am getting at is it is not healthy to lose weight simply by eating a calorie deficit.. you will lose weight but that doesn't mean it is healthy. Everyone needs to exercise, every day.
Some can't though.
I don't agree its a matter of priority. And even though there may be a very minute percentage of the world who are that physically disabled that they cannot exercise and I guarantee that they are not on my fitness pal forums.
I agree completely. I don't buy the "can't" thing at all. I was unable to walk for 6 weeks and found work outs I could do to maintain health. I did seated cardio (lots of them can be found online) and I did hand weights. If you can move you can take steps towards fitness.
And some cannot walk at all.
Did you miss the part where I was working out when unable to walk at all? That was my entire point in my post. When I couldn't walk I found ways to remain active despite being limited to my couch.
You think you are the only one who could not walk? Wow, six whole weeks?
Wow is right. Lol. You are ignoring the point and out to try and pick a fight. Sorry not interested. The point was, is, and will continue to be that even if you cant walk you can find ways to be active. I did and know others who have worked around disabilities both temporary and permanent.
But everyone's experience with disability and illness are different. Just because you could doesn't mean everyone can.5 -
queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »Weight is lost by a eating in a caloric deficit, exercise is for health.
This is so not true - not by EATING in a caloric deficit, its by being in a caloric deficit. This site is after all called my FITNESS pal. So sick of seeing that phrase on these forums... sighhhhh
OP - if you want to get yourself in a caloric deficit by exercise alone go for it - its going to be substantially better for your health than starving yourself to get there. But 20 min 3 times a week is not going to burn that much unless you are doing HIIT or some sort of high intensity circuit. You should be doing minimum 20 minutes of exercise every day, even if that's just a 20 min walk.
Whatever. However you want to create a deficit is up to you. Before i started counting calories accurately i tried losing weight by exercising which is hard to do if don't know how many calories you are eating. I was spinning my wheels. 20 years of nothing but I did have excellent health other than being obese.
OP, get accurate with intake and exercise for health and it will add some calories to your day.
What I am getting at is it is not healthy to lose weight simply by eating a calorie deficit.. you will lose weight but that doesn't mean it is healthy. Everyone needs to exercise, every day.
Some can't though.
I don't agree its a matter of priority. And even though there may be a very minute percentage of the world who are that physically disabled that they cannot exercise and I guarantee that they are not on my fitness pal forums.
I agree completely. I don't buy the "can't" thing at all. I was unable to walk for 6 weeks and found work outs I could do to maintain health. I did seated cardio (lots of them can be found online) and I did hand weights. If you can move you can take steps towards fitness.
And some cannot walk at all.
Did you miss the part where I was working out when unable to walk at all? That was my entire point in my post. When I couldn't walk I found ways to remain active despite being limited to my couch.
You think you are the only one who could not walk? Wow, six whole weeks?
Wow is right. Lol. You are ignoring the point and out to try and pick a fight. Sorry not interested. The point was, is, and will continue to be that even if you cant walk you can find ways to be active. I did and know others who have worked around disabilities both temporary and permanent.
There are other disabilities than physical ones. Which is a point I tried to make earlier and it was ignored.
FTR, I exercise every day because if I don't, my arthritis has me stiffening up with pain. Now that that's out of the way...
I cannot stand exercise snobbery and elitism. I know that exercise is healthy and good for everyone to strive to do. Some people, however are at places in their lives where they are just not capable of doing it for some reason or another and it is not for any one of us to have an opinion of them because of it.
The prescriptive judgmentalism in this thread is frankly appalling with all the "shoulds".
I'm doing me. It would be nice if everyone else did themselves and let everyone else do themselves individually too. Other people's exercise habits aren't up to any one of us.18 -
queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »Weight is lost by a eating in a caloric deficit, exercise is for health.
This is so not true - not by EATING in a caloric deficit, its by being in a caloric deficit. This site is after all called my FITNESS pal. So sick of seeing that phrase on these forums... sighhhhh
OP - if you want to get yourself in a caloric deficit by exercise alone go for it - its going to be substantially better for your health than starving yourself to get there. But 20 min 3 times a week is not going to burn that much unless you are doing HIIT or some sort of high intensity circuit. You should be doing minimum 20 minutes of exercise every day, even if that's just a 20 min walk.
Whatever. However you want to create a deficit is up to you. Before i started counting calories accurately i tried losing weight by exercising which is hard to do if don't know how many calories you are eating. I was spinning my wheels. 20 years of nothing but I did have excellent health other than being obese.
OP, get accurate with intake and exercise for health and it will add some calories to your day.
What I am getting at is it is not healthy to lose weight simply by eating a calorie deficit.. you will lose weight but that doesn't mean it is healthy. Everyone needs to exercise, every day.
Some can't though.
I don't agree its a matter of priority. And even though there may be a very minute percentage of the world who are that physically disabled that they cannot exercise and I guarantee that they are not on my fitness pal forums.
I agree completely. I don't buy the "can't" thing at all. I was unable to walk for 6 weeks and found work outs I could do to maintain health. I did seated cardio (lots of them can be found online) and I did hand weights. If you can move you can take steps towards fitness.
And some cannot walk at all.
Did you miss the part where I was working out when unable to walk at all? That was my entire point in my post. When I couldn't walk I found ways to remain active despite being limited to my couch.
You think you are the only one who could not walk? Wow, six whole weeks?
Wow is right. Lol. You are ignoring the point and out to try and pick a fight. Sorry not interested. The point was, is, and will continue to be that even if you cant walk you can find ways to be active. I did and know others who have worked around disabilities both temporary and permanent.
Not picking a picking a fight, I'm just saying there are people that cannot exercise.3 -
GottaBurnEmAll wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »Weight is lost by a eating in a caloric deficit, exercise is for health.
This is so not true - not by EATING in a caloric deficit, its by being in a caloric deficit. This site is after all called my FITNESS pal. So sick of seeing that phrase on these forums... sighhhhh
OP - if you want to get yourself in a caloric deficit by exercise alone go for it - its going to be substantially better for your health than starving yourself to get there. But 20 min 3 times a week is not going to burn that much unless you are doing HIIT or some sort of high intensity circuit. You should be doing minimum 20 minutes of exercise every day, even if that's just a 20 min walk.
Whatever. However you want to create a deficit is up to you. Before i started counting calories accurately i tried losing weight by exercising which is hard to do if don't know how many calories you are eating. I was spinning my wheels. 20 years of nothing but I did have excellent health other than being obese.
OP, get accurate with intake and exercise for health and it will add some calories to your day.
What I am getting at is it is not healthy to lose weight simply by eating a calorie deficit.. you will lose weight but that doesn't mean it is healthy. Everyone needs to exercise, every day.
Some can't though.
I don't agree its a matter of priority. And even though there may be a very minute percentage of the world who are that physically disabled that they cannot exercise and I guarantee that they are not on my fitness pal forums.
I agree completely. I don't buy the "can't" thing at all. I was unable to walk for 6 weeks and found work outs I could do to maintain health. I did seated cardio (lots of them can be found online) and I did hand weights. If you can move you can take steps towards fitness.
And some cannot walk at all.
Did you miss the part where I was working out when unable to walk at all? That was my entire point in my post. When I couldn't walk I found ways to remain active despite being limited to my couch.
You think you are the only one who could not walk? Wow, six whole weeks?
Wow is right. Lol. You are ignoring the point and out to try and pick a fight. Sorry not interested. The point was, is, and will continue to be that even if you cant walk you can find ways to be active. I did and know others who have worked around disabilities both temporary and permanent.
There are other disabilities than physical ones. Which is a point I tried to make earlier and it was ignored.
FTR, I exercise every day because if I don't, my arthritis has me stiffening up with pain. Now that that's out of the way...
I cannot stand exercise snobbery and elitism. I know that exercise is healthy and good for everyone. Some people, however are at places in their lives where they are just not capable of doing it for some reason or another and it is not for any one of us to have an opinion of them because of it.
The prescriptive judgmentalism in this thread is frankly appalling with all the "shoulds".
I'm doing me. It would be nice if everyone else did themselves and let everyone else do themselves individually too. Other people's exercise habits aren't up to any one of us.
+1 000 0005 -
For most healthy adults
ETA: This is from the Mayo clinic link. Of course exercise recommendations are for healthy adults.4 -
I am generally in all aspects of life a bit less emotional than your regular female so I see absolutely nothing wrong with simply stating everyone should exercise every day as a fact (?!?!??) and see no "snobbery" associated with that at all. I think you peeps are reading a wee little too far into this whole thread and people are getting extra sensitive (I am probably once again insensitive saying that?!) Damn I dunno, I am out.
Regardless the title of this thread is actually "Cardio" and the OP wants to exercise, so not sure how we got here
Have a fab day I will go somewhere else and continue my exercise policing, I quite like that term
2 -
queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »Weight is lost by a eating in a caloric deficit, exercise is for health.
This is so not true - not by EATING in a caloric deficit, its by being in a caloric deficit. This site is after all called my FITNESS pal. So sick of seeing that phrase on these forums... sighhhhh
OP - if you want to get yourself in a caloric deficit by exercise alone go for it - its going to be substantially better for your health than starving yourself to get there. But 20 min 3 times a week is not going to burn that much unless you are doing HIIT or some sort of high intensity circuit. You should be doing minimum 20 minutes of exercise every day, even if that's just a 20 min walk.
Whatever. However you want to create a deficit is up to you. Before i started counting calories accurately i tried losing weight by exercising which is hard to do if don't know how many calories you are eating. I was spinning my wheels. 20 years of nothing but I did have excellent health other than being obese.
OP, get accurate with intake and exercise for health and it will add some calories to your day.
What I am getting at is it is not healthy to lose weight simply by eating a calorie deficit.. you will lose weight but that doesn't mean it is healthy. Everyone needs to exercise, every day.
Some can't though.
I don't agree its a matter of priority. And even though there may be a very minute percentage of the world who are that physically disabled that they cannot exercise and I guarantee that they are not on my fitness pal forums.
I agree completely. I don't buy the "can't" thing at all. I was unable to walk for 6 weeks and found work outs I could do to maintain health. I did seated cardio (lots of them can be found online) and I did hand weights. If you can move you can take steps towards fitness.
And some cannot walk at all.
Did you miss the part where I was working out when unable to walk at all? That was my entire point in my post. When I couldn't walk I found ways to remain active despite being limited to my couch.
You think you are the only one who could not walk? Wow, six whole weeks?
Wow is right. Lol. You are ignoring the point and out to try and pick a fight. Sorry not interested. The point was, is, and will continue to be that even if you cant walk you can find ways to be active. I did and know others who have worked around disabilities both temporary and permanent.
Not picking a picking a fight, I'm just saying there are people that cannot exercise.
OP is obviously not one of them tho... and that is who we are replying to2 -
queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »Weight is lost by a eating in a caloric deficit, exercise is for health.
This is so not true - not by EATING in a caloric deficit, its by being in a caloric deficit. This site is after all called my FITNESS pal. So sick of seeing that phrase on these forums... sighhhhh
OP - if you want to get yourself in a caloric deficit by exercise alone go for it - its going to be substantially better for your health than starving yourself to get there. But 20 min 3 times a week is not going to burn that much unless you are doing HIIT or some sort of high intensity circuit. You should be doing minimum 20 minutes of exercise every day, even if that's just a 20 min walk.
Whatever. However you want to create a deficit is up to you. Before i started counting calories accurately i tried losing weight by exercising which is hard to do if don't know how many calories you are eating. I was spinning my wheels. 20 years of nothing but I did have excellent health other than being obese.
OP, get accurate with intake and exercise for health and it will add some calories to your day.
What I am getting at is it is not healthy to lose weight simply by eating a calorie deficit.. you will lose weight but that doesn't mean it is healthy. Everyone needs to exercise, every day.
BS. There are those who simply cannot exercise due to illness, extreme obesity or disability and they lose weight just fine. What should they do, eyerolls? Facepalms? At the moment, I am just running a deficit through diet due to babying an illness and injury, but sometimes, I like to split up my deficit between exercise f I feel like eating a little more or actually feel like cardioing that day. I usually just lift.3 -
I am generally in all aspects of life a bit less emotional than your regular female so I see absolutely nothing wrong with simply stating everyone should exercise every day as a fact (?!?!??) and see no "snobbery" associated with that at all. I think you peeps are reading a wee little too far into this whole thread and people are getting extra sensitive (I am probably once again insensitive saying that?!) Damn I dunno, I am out.
Regardless the title of this thread is actually "Cardio" and the OP wants to exercise, so not sure how we got here
Have a fab day I will go somewhere else and continue my exercise policing, I quite like that term
Oh, nice try at a swipe there with that emotional bit, but I'm old enough to be your mother and well past being capable of letting people your age upset me.
Not emotional in the least, just a bit over your attitude telling people what they should be doing.
I had a look back. You were the one who derailed the thread, btw.
Happy policing!
11 -
I am generally in all aspects of life a bit less emotional than your regular female so I see absolutely nothing wrong with simply stating everyone should exercise every day as a fact (?!?!??) and see no "snobbery" associated with that at all. I think you peeps are reading a wee little too far into this whole thread and people are getting extra sensitive (I am probably once again insensitive saying that?!) Damn I dunno, I am out.
Regardless the title of this thread is actually "Cardio" and the OP wants to exercise, so not sure how we got here
Have a fab day I will go somewhere else and continue my exercise policing, I quite like that term
Because you took the OP's concerns, made a judgement and passed that judgement to the entire population. Maybe if you just want it to be about the OP, just address the OP.6 -
GottaBurnEmAll wrote: »I am generally in all aspects of life a bit less emotional than your regular female so I see absolutely nothing wrong with simply stating everyone should exercise every day as a fact (?!?!??) and see no "snobbery" associated with that at all. I think you peeps are reading a wee little too far into this whole thread and people are getting extra sensitive (I am probably once again insensitive saying that?!) Damn I dunno, I am out.
Regardless the title of this thread is actually "Cardio" and the OP wants to exercise, so not sure how we got here
Have a fab day I will go somewhere else and continue my exercise policing, I quite like that term
Oh, nice try at a swipe there with that emotional bit, but I'm old enough to be your mother and well past being capable of letting people your age upset me.
Not emotional in the least, just a bit over your attitude telling people what they should be doing.
Happy policing!
0 to 100 real quick I never tried to upset anyone
sorry if you feel that way! But I believe everyone can voice their opinion on this site, and shouldn't have to be argued every time 5 -
Stating that EVERYONE should exercise everyday is very short sighted. No there definitely are people who can not exercise at all let alone every day.2
-
singingflutelady wrote: »Stating that EVERYONE should exercise everyday is very short sighted. No there definitely are people who can not exercise at all let alone every day.
And I wrote on this thread that I agree there is a population who cant but they are most likely not on this forum...0 -
Not interested in beef with da mamas no more! Why so argumentative ladies -1
-
singingflutelady wrote: »Stating that EVERYONE should exercise everyday is very short sighted. No there definitely are people who can not exercise at all let alone every day.
And I wrote on this thread that I agree there is a population who cant but they are most likely not on this forum...
There are quite a few of us with chronic illnesses in this dorum4 -
For the record, I'm not into exercise shaming either. If you're on MFP at some point I'm sure exercise wasn't a part of your daily life either. So spare me.
OP, to answer your original question, the right amount of cardio is the amount you can and will do consistently. Any amount will help you increase your calorie deficit and improve your overall health.
I wouldn't recommend going from not exercising at all to trying to do an hr of cardio a day, for example. You should start slow doing as much as you can as often as you can, but not so much that you overdo. Without knowing your level of fitness it's impossible to say how much would be too much, but anything in excess of what you are currently doing would be beneficial.2 -
Thank you!! When I was severely underweight and hospitalized for an eating disorder with a feeding tube shoved up my nose, I was forbidden from exercising!! Heck, I was forced to stay in a wheelchair at some point to avoid expending energy. Exercising is an amazing thing, and I love it now but for some it just isn't healthy or helpful.singingflutelady wrote: »Stating that EVERYONE should exercise everyday is very short sighted. No there definitely are people who can not exercise at all let alone every day.
4 -
Cardio is a catch 22 for me. The more i exercise, the more i can eat. But the more i exercise the more i Want to eat, and my appetite usually overtakes my calories burned when i amp up the cardio .
I need to find that nice happy medium where i get maybe a couple hundred extra calories, and stop striving for as many exercise cals as i can humanly handle 7 days a week 365 days a year.1 -
lilolilo920 wrote: »
Thank you!! When I was severely underweight and hospitalized for an eating disorder with a feeding tube shoved up my nose, I was forbidden from exercising!! Heck, I was forced to stay in a wheelchair at some point to avoid expending energy. Exercising is an amazing thing, and I love it now but for some it just isn't healthy or helpful.singingflutelady wrote: »Stating that EVERYONE should exercise everyday is very short sighted. No there definitely are people who can not exercise at all let alone every day.
I didn't have a feeding tube but I was forbidden (for good reason) from exercise too. I also experienced a time when I was in a bad crohn's flare when I had severe malabsorption and anaemia (my serum iron was zero for 8 months, my hemoglobin was 6) also had very low albumin when I was severely underweight and didn't gain even while on tpn (nutrition through a picc line) and high dose Prednisone. The only exercise I could get in was walking to the bathroom. My heart would race and I'd get out of breath while doing nothing because of my anaemia and all my joints hurt. I don't think exercising would have been a good choice at that time.4 -
GottaBurnEmAll wrote: »I am generally in all aspects of life a bit less emotional than your regular female so I see absolutely nothing wrong with simply stating everyone should exercise every day as a fact (?!?!??) and see no "snobbery" associated with that at all. I think you peeps are reading a wee little too far into this whole thread and people are getting extra sensitive (I am probably once again insensitive saying that?!) Damn I dunno, I am out.
Regardless the title of this thread is actually "Cardio" and the OP wants to exercise, so not sure how we got here
Have a fab day I will go somewhere else and continue my exercise policing, I quite like that term
Oh, nice try at a swipe there with that emotional bit, but I'm old enough to be your mother and well past being capable of letting people your age upset me.
Not emotional in the least, just a bit over your attitude telling people what they should be doing.
Happy policing!
0 to 100 real quick I never tried to upset anyone sorry if you feel that way! But I believe everyone can voice their opinion on this site, and shouldn't have to be argued every time
You know, I'd take you a lot more seriously if you stopped commenting on what you perceived my emotional investment in this conversation was. FTR, you're wrong.
Of course everyone has a right to their opinion. Mine disagrees with yours. Not only that, my opinion is that yours and the way you have expressed it is harmful for people who are facing issues like depression, ridiculously packed schedules coupled with stress, and severe physical limitations.6 -
Not interested in beef with da mamas no more! Why so argumentative ladies
You put out a definitive statement. When you make such a statement, it's liable to be met with disagreement. That's the way such things work. If you're not prepared the defend it, the adult thing to do is to back off from it, not to insult the other parties in the conversation and and act like they are inciting drama when you're the one who precipitated it with your absolutist thinking.4 -
queenliz99 wrote: »Weight is lost by a eating in a caloric deficit, exercise is for health.
This is so not true - not by EATING in a caloric deficit, its by being in a caloric deficit. This site is after all called my FITNESS pal. So sick of seeing that phrase on these forums... sighhhhh
OP - if you want to get yourself in a caloric deficit by exercise alone go for it - its going to be substantially better for your health than starving yourself to get there. But 20 min 3 times a week is not going to burn that much unless you are doing HIIT or some sort of high intensity circuit. You should be doing minimum 20 minutes of exercise every day, even if that's just a 20 min walk.
Allow me to refresh your memory.4 -
Um, you do realize if you eat less than you burn, that's a calorie deficit? If you eat the same amount of calories you burn in a day (yes even with exercise) you'll maintain weight? And if you eat more than that you'll gain weight?queenliz99 wrote: »Weight is lost by a eating in a caloric deficit, exercise is for health.
This is so not true - not by EATING in a caloric deficit, its by being in a caloric deficit. This site is after all called my FITNESS pal. So sick of seeing that phrase on these forums... sighhhhh
Again, it doesn't matter how much you burn doing exercise. It matters more on how much you consume.OP - if you want to get yourself in a caloric deficit by exercise alone go for it - its going to be substantially better for your health than starving yourself to get there. But 20 min 3 times a week is not going to burn that much unless you are doing HIIT or some sort of high intensity circuit. You should be doing minimum 20 minutes of exercise every day, even if that's just a 20 min walk.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
1 -
People lose weight all the time without exercise. And the food doesn't have to be whole foods.applesandtapeline wrote: »Wonderful things happen to a body when good, whole food is being eaten, either on maintenance or on caloric deficit. Add some weight training and weightloss is guaranteed, there's more benefit in it than just doing cardio.
But to answer your initial question - 20mins STEADY cardio 3 times a week is not enough for anything. Amp it up to 40mins and see how it goes.
Exercise is still for fitness and health and is great to add while losing weight, but it's not necessary.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
3 -
Losing weight alone decreases risk of health issues with or without exercise, so I emphatically disagree here.queenliz99 wrote: »queenliz99 wrote: »Weight is lost by a eating in a caloric deficit, exercise is for health.
This is so not true - not by EATING in a caloric deficit, its by being in a caloric deficit. This site is after all called my FITNESS pal. So sick of seeing that phrase on these forums... sighhhhh
OP - if you want to get yourself in a caloric deficit by exercise alone go for it - its going to be substantially better for your health than starving yourself to get there. But 20 min 3 times a week is not going to burn that much unless you are doing HIIT or some sort of high intensity circuit. You should be doing minimum 20 minutes of exercise every day, even if that's just a 20 min walk.
Whatever. However you want to create a deficit is up to you. Before i started counting calories accurately i tried losing weight by exercising which is hard to do if don't know how many calories you are eating. I was spinning my wheels. 20 years of nothing but I did have excellent health other than being obese.
OP, get accurate with intake and exercise for health and it will add some calories to your day.
What I am getting at is it is not healthy to lose weight simply by eating a calorie deficit.. you will lose weight but that doesn't mean it is healthy. Everyone needs to exercise, every day.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
5
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions