Cottage cheese intake
Replies
-
GottaBurnEmAll wrote: »Serious answer: as long as sodium isn't a concern, eat as much as fits in your calorie goals without excluding other nutritious foods like vegetables.
Cottage cheese is delicious.
With no snacks (cookies, chips, etc.) in the house, last night I mindlessly ate almost the whole 16 oz container of cottage cheese.
I was only going to have a spoonful. Fortunately, I'm still within my calorie goal. However, up .2 lbs this morning from the sodium. Yes - I was over my sodium goal.
I don't know if sodium can make difference in weight but what I found is just 100 gram cottage cheese added to my daily diet got me 4.5 kg of muscles in a week time. As I take fats percentage and muscles percentage weekly.lost around 3.5 kg of fats. Waist is one inch down
I wonder if it really works like that or it was with me only?
It's very difficult to believe the bolded part. First, it's difficult to accurately measure your body muscle content. If you were using an electrical impedance measuring device, you could get this range of readings within the same day simply due to your varying levels of hydration that day. Such a device is no more accurate or reliable if used each day or each week. Don't draw conclusions about food intake based on an electrical impedance body fat measuring device. If your body was adding muscle, you can detect it by lifting heavier objects. Even so, lifting a heavier object one day than you could lift a week earlier give you no numerically precise number to describe your bodily muscle mass change.0 -
GottaBurnEmAll wrote: »Serious answer: as long as sodium isn't a concern, eat as much as fits in your calorie goals without excluding other nutritious foods like vegetables.
Cottage cheese is delicious.
With no snacks (cookies, chips, etc.) in the house, last night I mindlessly ate almost the whole 16 oz container of cottage cheese. I was only going to have a spoonful. Fortunately, I'm still within my calorie goal. However, up .2 lbs this morning from the sodium. Yes - I was over my sodium goal.
I don't know if sodium can make difference in weight but what I found is just 100 gram cottage cheese added to my daily diet got me 4.5 kg of muscles in a week time. As I take fats percentage and muscles percentage weekly.lost around 3.5 kg of fats. Waist is one inch down
I wonder if it really works like that or it was with me only?
You couldn't have gained 4.5 lbs of muscle even on steroids!! In optimum conditions a man can gain about 2 lbs per month. It's water weight.2 -
GottaBurnEmAll wrote: »Serious answer: as long as sodium isn't a concern, eat as much as fits in your calorie goals without excluding other nutritious foods like vegetables.
Cottage cheese is delicious.
With no snacks (cookies, chips, etc.) in the house, last night I mindlessly ate almost the whole 16 oz container of cottage cheese. I was only going to have a spoonful. Fortunately, I'm still within my calorie goal. However, up .2 lbs this morning from the sodium. Yes - I was over my sodium goal.
I don't know if sodium can make difference in weight but what I found is just 100 gram cottage cheese added to my daily diet got me 4.5 kg of muscles in a week time. As I take fats percentage and muscles percentage weekly.lost around 3.5 kg of fats. Waist is one inch down
I wonder if it really works like that or it was with me only?
You couldn't have gained 4.5 lbs of muscle even on steroids!! In optimum conditions a man can gain about 2 lbs per month. It's water weight.
May be it is not possible but what I think is the mixture of juices I am drinking thrice daily may be helping me gaining muscles
I am drinking a mixture of juice of garlic ginger lemon apple cider vinegar
It seems this mixture is not only helping on losing body fats but also gaining muscles
I have body composition weighing machine.it tells body fats percentage muscles percentage water percentage etc
I have been using this machine since March.9 -
Those body composition weighing machines are not in any way accurate.3
-
GottaBurnEmAll wrote: »Serious answer: as long as sodium isn't a concern, eat as much as fits in your calorie goals without excluding other nutritious foods like vegetables.
Cottage cheese is delicious.
With no snacks (cookies, chips, etc.) in the house, last night I mindlessly ate almost the whole 16 oz container of cottage cheese. I was only going to have a spoonful. Fortunately, I'm still within my calorie goal. However, up .2 lbs this morning from the sodium. Yes - I was over my sodium goal.
I don't know if sodium can make difference in weight but what I found is just 100 gram cottage cheese added to my daily diet got me 4.5 kg of muscles in a week time. As I take fats percentage and muscles percentage weekly.lost around 3.5 kg of fats. Waist is one inch down
I wonder if it really works like that or it was with me only?
You couldn't have gained 4.5 lbs of muscle even on steroids!! In optimum conditions a man can gain about 2 lbs per month. It's water weight.
May be it is not possible but what I think is the mixture of juices I am drinking thrice daily may be helping me gaining muscles
I am drinking a mixture of juice of garlic ginger lemon apple cider vinegar
It seems this mixture is not only helping on losing body fats but also gaining muscles
I have body composition weighing machine.it tells body fats percentage muscles percentage water percentage etc
I have been using this machine since March.
I am going to correct myself, THIS is the bizarrest claim I have ever seen on MFP! Protein helps to build muscles not a concoction of garlic, ginger, lemon, apple and cider vinegar, I don't care how many times a day you drink it! Bet it tastes foul too!2 -
GottaBurnEmAll wrote: »Serious answer: as long as sodium isn't a concern, eat as much as fits in your calorie goals without excluding other nutritious foods like vegetables.
Cottage cheese is delicious.
With no snacks (cookies, chips, etc.) in the house, last night I mindlessly ate almost the whole 16 oz container of cottage cheese. I was only going to have a spoonful. Fortunately, I'm still within my calorie goal. However, up .2 lbs this morning from the sodium. Yes - I was over my sodium goal.
I don't know if sodium can make difference in weight but what I found is just 100 gram cottage cheese added to my daily diet got me 4.5 kg of muscles in a week time. As I take fats percentage and muscles percentage weekly.lost around 3.5 kg of fats. Waist is one inch down
I wonder if it really works like that or it was with me only?
You couldn't have gained 4.5 lbs of muscle even on steroids!! In optimum conditions a man can gain about 2 lbs per month. It's water weight.
May be it is not possible but what I think is the mixture of juices I am drinking thrice daily may be helping me gaining muscles
I am drinking a mixture of juice of garlic ginger lemon apple cider vinegar
It seems this mixture is not only helping on losing body fats but also gaining muscles
I have body composition weighing machine.it tells body fats percentage muscles percentage water percentage etc
I have been using this machine since March.
Nope! :noway:0 -
GottaBurnEmAll wrote: »Serious answer: as long as sodium isn't a concern, eat as much as fits in your calorie goals without excluding other nutritious foods like vegetables.
Cottage cheese is delicious.
With no snacks (cookies, chips, etc.) in the house, last night I mindlessly ate almost the whole 16 oz container of cottage cheese. I was only going to have a spoonful. Fortunately, I'm still within my calorie goal. However, up .2 lbs this morning from the sodium. Yes - I was over my sodium goal.
I don't know if sodium can make difference in weight but what I found is just 100 gram cottage cheese added to my daily diet got me 4.5 kg of muscles in a week time. As I take fats percentage and muscles percentage weekly.lost around 3.5 kg of fats. Waist is one inch down
I wonder if it really works like that or it was with me only?
You couldn't have gained 4.5 lbs of muscle even on steroids!! In optimum conditions a man can gain about 2 lbs per month. It's water weight.
May be it is not possible but what I think is the mixture of juices I am drinking thrice daily may be helping me gaining muscles
I am drinking a mixture of juice of garlic ginger lemon apple cider vinegar
It seems this mixture is not only helping on losing body fats but also gaining muscles
I have body composition weighing machine.it tells body fats percentage muscles percentage water percentage etc
I have been using this machine since March.
I am going to correct myself, THIS is the bizarrest claim I have ever seen on MFP! Protein helps to build muscles not a concoction of garlic, ginger, lemon, apple and cider vinegar, I don't care how many times a day you drink it! Bet it tastes foul too!
You ate right
I think now on I should keep screen shots of my weight I need to know what makes these changes
As I am on calorie deficit this week I just changed my diet to higher protein less carbs
Anyways thanks and I will try to update three changes here so you people can advice me1 -
This content has been removed.
-
JeromeBarry1 wrote: »GottaBurnEmAll wrote: »Serious answer: as long as sodium isn't a concern, eat as much as fits in your calorie goals without excluding other nutritious foods like vegetables.
Cottage cheese is delicious.
With no snacks (cookies, chips, etc.) in the house, last night I mindlessly ate almost the whole 16 oz container of cottage cheese. I was only going to have a spoonful. Fortunately, I'm still within my calorie goal. However, up .2 lbs this morning from the sodium. Yes - I was over my sodium goal.
I don't know if sodium can make difference in weight but what I found is just 100 gram cottage cheese added to my daily diet got me 4.5 kg of muscles in a week time. As I take fats percentage and muscles percentage weekly.lost around 3.5 kg of fats. Waist is one inch down
I wonder if it really works like that or it was with me only?
It's very difficult to believe the bolded part. First, it's difficult to accurately measure your body muscle content. If you were using an electrical impedance measuring device, you could get this range of readings within the same day simply due to your varying levels of hydration that day. Such a device is no more accurate or reliable if used each day or each week. Don't draw conclusions about food intake based on an electrical impedance body fat measuring device. If your body was adding muscle, you can detect it by lifting heavier objects. Even so, lifting a heavier object one day than you could lift a week earlier give you no numerically precise number to describe your bodily muscle mass change.
Even that (bolded) is no sure sign. Much of the strength gain in new exercisers is neuromuscular adaptation (things like fiber recruitment), not addition of new muscle mass. Strength gains, even quite surprising ones, can be very achievable fairly quickly, but mass gain is sloooooow.
I've had exactly this argument in the forums with women who insisted they gained substantial muscle while in a deficit, from some fairly moderate exercise routines, because they became able to lift heavier weights. Nope.
(P.S. Not saying no one, of any age, of any starting weight, of any sex, never gained any amount of muscle, in a deficit of any extent. May be true, but either way, that's outside my knowledge. Previous arguments were with women in 30s/40s, not starting from morbidly obese, claiming multi-pound muscle gains in a few months, with a sensible but not aggressive training schedule, while in a decent calorie deficit. NopeNopeNope.)
2 -
JeromeBarry1 wrote: »GottaBurnEmAll wrote: »Serious answer: as long as sodium isn't a concern, eat as much as fits in your calorie goals without excluding other nutritious foods like vegetables.
Cottage cheese is delicious.
With no snacks (cookies, chips, etc.) in the house, last night I mindlessly ate almost the whole 16 oz container of cottage cheese. I was only going to have a spoonful. Fortunately, I'm still within my calorie goal. However, up .2 lbs this morning from the sodium. Yes - I was over my sodium goal.
I don't know if sodium can make difference in weight but what I found is just 100 gram cottage cheese added to my daily diet got me 4.5 kg of muscles in a week time. As I take fats percentage and muscles percentage weekly.lost around 3.5 kg of fats. Waist is one inch down
I wonder if it really works like that or it was with me only?
It's very difficult to believe the bolded part. First, it's difficult to accurately measure your body muscle content. If you were using an electrical impedance measuring device, you could get this range of readings within the same day simply due to your varying levels of hydration that day. Such a device is no more accurate or reliable if used each day or each week. Don't draw conclusions about food intake based on an electrical impedance body fat measuring device. If your body was adding muscle, you can detect it by lifting heavier objects. Even so, lifting a heavier object one day than you could lift a week earlier give you no numerically precise number to describe your bodily muscle mass change.
Even that (bolded) is no sure sign. Much of the strength gain in new exercisers is neuromuscular adaptation (things like fiber recruitment), not addition of new muscle mass. Strength gains, even quite surprising ones, can be very achievable fairly quickly, but mass gain is sloooooow.
I've had exactly this argument in the forums with women who insisted they gained substantial muscle while in a deficit, from some fairly moderate exercise routines, because they became able to lift heavier weights. Nope.
(P.S. Not saying no one, of any age, of any starting weight, of any sex, never gained any amount of muscle, in a deficit of any extent. May be true, but either way, that's outside my knowledge. Previous arguments were with women in 30s/40s, not starting from morbidly obese, claiming multi-pound muscle gains in a few months, with a sensible but not aggressive training schedule, while in a decent calorie deficit. NopeNopeNope.)
Thanks for the advice
I will monitor it closely and will post details after a couple of weeks
Let's see1 -
JeromeBarry1 wrote: »GottaBurnEmAll wrote: »Serious answer: as long as sodium isn't a concern, eat as much as fits in your calorie goals without excluding other nutritious foods like vegetables.
Cottage cheese is delicious.
With no snacks (cookies, chips, etc.) in the house, last night I mindlessly ate almost the whole 16 oz container of cottage cheese. I was only going to have a spoonful. Fortunately, I'm still within my calorie goal. However, up .2 lbs this morning from the sodium. Yes - I was over my sodium goal.
I don't know if sodium can make difference in weight but what I found is just 100 gram cottage cheese added to my daily diet got me 4.5 kg of muscles in a week time. As I take fats percentage and muscles percentage weekly.lost around 3.5 kg of fats. Waist is one inch down
I wonder if it really works like that or it was with me only?
It's very difficult to believe the bolded part. First, it's difficult to accurately measure your body muscle content. If you were using an electrical impedance measuring device, you could get this range of readings within the same day simply due to your varying levels of hydration that day. Such a device is no more accurate or reliable if used each day or each week. Don't draw conclusions about food intake based on an electrical impedance body fat measuring device. If your body was adding muscle, you can detect it by lifting heavier objects. Even so, lifting a heavier object one day than you could lift a week earlier give you no numerically precise number to describe your bodily muscle mass change.
Even that (bolded) is no sure sign. Much of the strength gain in new exercisers is neuromuscular adaptation (things like fiber recruitment), not addition of new muscle mass. Strength gains, even quite surprising ones, can be very achievable fairly quickly, but mass gain is sloooooow.
I've had exactly this argument in the forums with women who insisted they gained substantial muscle while in a deficit, from some fairly moderate exercise routines, because they became able to lift heavier weights. Nope.
(P.S. Not saying no one, of any age, of any starting weight, of any sex, never gained any amount of muscle, in a deficit of any extent. May be true, but either way, that's outside my knowledge. Previous arguments were with women in 30s/40s, not starting from morbidly obese, claiming multi-pound muscle gains in a few months, with a sensible but not aggressive training schedule, while in a decent calorie deficit. NopeNopeNope.)
Thanks for the advice
I will monitor it closely and will post details after a couple of weeks
Let's see
The question is how will you monitor it. Short of a baseline dexa scan or hydrostatic body composition test with a follow up one later, you won't really know whether you have gained muscle mass or not. You will just see some kind of fluctuation that could be any number of things and will mostly likely be water weight. A bio-impedance scale can't be counted on at all except as a overall trend over time. Any one reading can be an outlier and mean nothing useful.2 -
Water weight1
-
JeromeBarry1 wrote: »GottaBurnEmAll wrote: »Serious answer: as long as sodium isn't a concern, eat as much as fits in your calorie goals without excluding other nutritious foods like vegetables.
Cottage cheese is delicious.
With no snacks (cookies, chips, etc.) in the house, last night I mindlessly ate almost the whole 16 oz container of cottage cheese. I was only going to have a spoonful. Fortunately, I'm still within my calorie goal. However, up .2 lbs this morning from the sodium. Yes - I was over my sodium goal.
I don't know if sodium can make difference in weight but what I found is just 100 gram cottage cheese added to my daily diet got me 4.5 kg of muscles in a week time. As I take fats percentage and muscles percentage weekly.lost around 3.5 kg of fats. Waist is one inch down
I wonder if it really works like that or it was with me only?
It's very difficult to believe the bolded part. First, it's difficult to accurately measure your body muscle content. If you were using an electrical impedance measuring device, you could get this range of readings within the same day simply due to your varying levels of hydration that day. Such a device is no more accurate or reliable if used each day or each week. Don't draw conclusions about food intake based on an electrical impedance body fat measuring device. If your body was adding muscle, you can detect it by lifting heavier objects. Even so, lifting a heavier object one day than you could lift a week earlier give you no numerically precise number to describe your bodily muscle mass change.
Even that (bolded) is no sure sign. Much of the strength gain in new exercisers is neuromuscular adaptation (things like fiber recruitment), not addition of new muscle mass. Strength gains, even quite surprising ones, can be very achievable fairly quickly, but mass gain is sloooooow.
I've had exactly this argument in the forums with women who insisted they gained substantial muscle while in a deficit, from some fairly moderate exercise routines, because they became able to lift heavier weights. Nope.
(P.S. Not saying no one, of any age, of any starting weight, of any sex, never gained any amount of muscle, in a deficit of any extent. May be true, but either way, that's outside my knowledge. Previous arguments were with women in 30s/40s, not starting from morbidly obese, claiming multi-pound muscle gains in a few months, with a sensible but not aggressive training schedule, while in a decent calorie deficit. NopeNopeNope.)
Thanks for the advice
I will monitor it closely and will post details after a couple of weeks
Let's see
The question is how will you monitor it. Short of a baseline dexa scan or hydrostatic body composition test with a follow up one later, you won't really know whether you have gained muscle mass or not. You will just see some kind of fluctuation that could be any number of things and will mostly likely be water weight. A bio-impedance scale can't be counted on at all except as a overall trend over time. Any one reading can be an outlier and mean nothing useful.
I have ordered another machine from another company will use both to see the difference if the results differ means I will have to find another way off results are same mean all is fine1 -
Those things are inaccurate to the point of being a gimmick. You gained nothing even vaguely like 4.5kg of muscle in a week. A bodybuilder would only hope to gain even 1/20th of that in a week.
Are you even lifting weights? There is not a food or drink in the universe that will make you gain muscle unless you're living heavy weights.3 -
JeromeBarry1 wrote: »GottaBurnEmAll wrote: »Serious answer: as long as sodium isn't a concern, eat as much as fits in your calorie goals without excluding other nutritious foods like vegetables.
Cottage cheese is delicious.
With no snacks (cookies, chips, etc.) in the house, last night I mindlessly ate almost the whole 16 oz container of cottage cheese. I was only going to have a spoonful. Fortunately, I'm still within my calorie goal. However, up .2 lbs this morning from the sodium. Yes - I was over my sodium goal.
I don't know if sodium can make difference in weight but what I found is just 100 gram cottage cheese added to my daily diet got me 4.5 kg of muscles in a week time. As I take fats percentage and muscles percentage weekly.lost around 3.5 kg of fats. Waist is one inch down
I wonder if it really works like that or it was with me only?
It's very difficult to believe the bolded part. First, it's difficult to accurately measure your body muscle content. If you were using an electrical impedance measuring device, you could get this range of readings within the same day simply due to your varying levels of hydration that day. Such a device is no more accurate or reliable if used each day or each week. Don't draw conclusions about food intake based on an electrical impedance body fat measuring device. If your body was adding muscle, you can detect it by lifting heavier objects. Even so, lifting a heavier object one day than you could lift a week earlier give you no numerically precise number to describe your bodily muscle mass change.
Even that (bolded) is no sure sign. Much of the strength gain in new exercisers is neuromuscular adaptation (things like fiber recruitment), not addition of new muscle mass. Strength gains, even quite surprising ones, can be very achievable fairly quickly, but mass gain is sloooooow.
I've had exactly this argument in the forums with women who insisted they gained substantial muscle while in a deficit, from some fairly moderate exercise routines, because they became able to lift heavier weights. Nope.
(P.S. Not saying no one, of any age, of any starting weight, of any sex, never gained any amount of muscle, in a deficit of any extent. May be true, but either way, that's outside my knowledge. Previous arguments were with women in 30s/40s, not starting from morbidly obese, claiming multi-pound muscle gains in a few months, with a sensible but not aggressive training schedule, while in a decent calorie deficit. NopeNopeNope.)
Thanks for the advice
I will monitor it closely and will post details after a couple of weeks
Let's see
The question is how will you monitor it. Short of a baseline dexa scan or hydrostatic body composition test with a follow up one later, you won't really know whether you have gained muscle mass or not. You will just see some kind of fluctuation that could be any number of things and will mostly likely be water weight. A bio-impedance scale can't be counted on at all except as a overall trend over time. Any one reading can be an outlier and mean nothing useful.
I have ordered another machine from another company will use both to see the difference if the results differ means I will have to find another way off results are same mean all is fine
If it is bio-impedance like the one you have they will likely give similar results. The most accurate way to test body fat are the ones I detailed in my post. This would be done at a university or para-medical facility. There are not really any other accurate technologies and certainly not anything that can be ordered for home use.
The next best is a caliper test performed by someone trained to do it properly. Possibly at your gym or another locally this would be available. I hate to see you waste money on machines that won't give you a true picture.2
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.5K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions