Narcissistic or not?
Replies
-
There is nothing wrong with posting those types of pics.0
-
There's little point in posting photos of the same Ferrari over and over. It's not as though the car is going to get more beautiful with time. Not to mention that it's basically a vapid status symbol.
Human beings can and do make progress with their bodies, though. Not to mention that improving one's body is beneficial both socially and for functional performance.
Frequent physique photos**, though, can represent progress that's imperceptible to anyone other than a fellow bodybuilder (or perhaps other fitness enthusiasts used to looking at physique in a technical way).
People just aren't that great at looking at things that they don't have interest/expertise in. Some of my friends know all the car years and models as we drive down the road; I don't reliably know a GM from a Ford. I can pretty reliably identify strangers out in public who are going through cancer treatment, or who've lost substantial weight, but not that many of my friends can do that as readily. You have to know some stuff to perceive certain things.
If your friends don't know a gastrocnemius from a deltoid, they probably can't even see the progress you're (justifiably) proud of.
** I understand that OP didn't post frequent photos, and that his subsequent remarks suggest that his occasional physique photos did in fact get a negative over-reaction from certain of his "friends". I agree that that's more their problem than his. The thread as a whole, though, includes some posts that suggest some people don't think through how things look to people with different values and interests. I'm not saying other people's perceptions should drive all our behavior, but if we want to make some particular impression on people around us, it's worth considering - which is what OP seems to be doing in posting this thread.6 -
I'm a psych major, about to hit grad school... Per my books and classes:
Egotism is normal; it is what drives us to do things that we haven't done before and to get better at things we enjoy. Also, being proud of achievements is perfectly normal.
Narcissistic personality, isn't someone that posts 3000 selfies a day (although that is a sign that the person may be). Narcissistism involves an unreal, inflated and unwillingness to accept critique sense of self.
Examples: person posts selfie showing off physique stating that they love how they look from all thier hard work, and are working out to develop better "
insert body part or ability---." That is normal ego.
A narcissist would never say that anything about them needs work or is flawed in any way. Narcissistic personality disorder sufferers CANNOT see nor accept that they have any flaws. A narcissist would post a selfie and explain how they are perfect, they would also argue with anyone questioning said perfection, including if they are trying to get better...
Hence, if you are wondering if you are a narcissist, you're probably not as that requires a belief that you are not perfect.7 -
I don’t think we are discussing Narcissistic Personality Disorder but the common dictionary and everyday use of the term.
nar·cis·sis·tic
ˌnärsəˈsistik
adjective
having an excessive or erotic interest in oneself and one's physical appearance.
"a narcissistic actress"
synonyms: vain, self-loving, self-admiring, self-absorbed, self-obsessed, conceited, self-centered, self-regarding, egotistic, egotistical, egoistic; informal: full of oneself
"she was never happy in the narcissistic life that her press agent and manager had crafted for her"6 -
Haven't read many of the responses, but as far as this site goes, your photo (along with other obviously fit people, both male & female), may be just the inspiration some one may need to help them be successful in their own goals. I say both thumbs up to anything that gives inspiration to another person!1
-
missysippy930 wrote: »Haven't read many of the responses, but as far as this site goes, your photo (along with other obviously fit people, both male & female), may be just the inspiration some one may need to help them be successful in their own goals. I say both thumbs up to anything that gives inspiration to another person!
The ultimate sign of an inflated ego is the belief that one's self is important or valuable enough to be an inspiration to others.7 -
Enjoy and celebrate your accomplishments, it's that simple.0
-
The "Success Stories" thread here is a perfect place to display your story--people are there looking for examples to model and inspire. If you post selfies too often (what that number is I don't know) you are slipping down the slope toward vanity. Moderation in all things. Pride is one of the seven deadly sins.3
-
I follow lots of fitness models, UFC / MMA folks, nutritional folks, and fashion models on IG. I enjoy it and I don't see anything wrong with it. Seeing others share their workouts, successes and even failures is inspiring to me. But I also enjoy the artistic aspect of photography. I personally have refrained from sharing progress photos there, but I do share my recipes which are largely Vegetarian and health related not all certainly a majority. I do share progress photos here on my news feed when I have a milestone.
The primary reason I do not share my progress photos on FB and IG is that only a handful of my real life friends and family would appreciate them. Most of my friends are musicians or artists, and really have zero interest or clue about my fitness journey. So most would just ignore or not care, but some of those people may actually get super judgemental or snarky about it. I guess I shouldn't care about those peoples opinions but I do.
Either way, I don't think taking photos of yourself is inherently narcissistic. People who are proud of their fitness journey should be allowed to share it without being shamed for it. But it goes beyond that. I have girlfriends who are really into hair dressing, make up and tattoos, they love to get glammed up for the camera and do cool photo shoots. There's nothing wrong with any of that. The real problem lies in the judgemental jerks, who want to shame everyone else for things they are jealous of or simply don't understand.3 -
Easy answer, don't worry what others think.3
-
Isn't that the point of instagram-to post pics? Seems a bit ridiculous for people to visit the site and then negatively label people who use it for it's intended purpose.
Then again that is one of the pitfalls of social media-it is just another avenue for some people to trash other people and try to make themselves feel better.
I shouldn't sweat it; it says everything about their frame of mind and nothing about you because they don't know anything about you in the first place.0 -
To me, physique pictures on general social media accounts, simply for the point of bragging, scream,I don't know, kinda desperate and attention-wh*ring and trashy for lack of a better word. But then I'm in my mid-thirties so that may have changed my perspective, I can see my 20 yo self not seeing anything wrong with it.1
-
I hate seeing people’s half naked gym photos on my regular fb/Instagram feed even though I’m into fitness myself and in good shape. There’s no jealousy involved. Such posts almost always come across as showing off, humble brags, attention seeking, fishing for likes, or any combination above. Find another forum to do so. Like here, bodybuilder.com, reddit, or any other fitness focused platforms.0
-
I hate seeing people’s half naked gym photos on my regular fb/Instagram feed even though I’m into fitness myself and in good shape. There’s no jealousy involved. Such posts almost always come across as showing off, humble brags, attention seeking, fishing for likes, or any combination above. Find another forum to do so. Like here, bodybuilder.com, reddit, or any other fitness focused platforms.
I read somewhere that people dislike others that humblebrag more than people that just outright brag..........come to think of it I do too lol. I had a coworker that would do this, but it was worse because she would humblebrag about all of us like our dept and all of us were the best and most important, lord I would facepalm hard when she would do this, sorry but radiology? We're not saving lives here, just doing our part.0 -
Only place I post any physique pics is on this site since it is about fitness and progress. I rarely take my shirt off in public, or even the beach unless I am going in the water or trying to tan a bit. My fitness is for me, no one else needs to see it.0
-
Posting photos: Not necessarily narcissistic.
Complaining that other people thought your photos were narcissistic--Now that's narcissistic.3 -
I hate seeing people’s half naked gym photos on my regular fb/Instagram feed even though I’m into fitness myself and in good shape. There’s no jealousy involved. Such posts almost always come across as showing off, humble brags, attention seeking, fishing for likes, or any combination above. Find another forum to do so. Like here, bodybuilder.com, reddit, or any other fitness focused platforms.
Some people (like myself as I mentioned) have a separate Instragram for those sort of posts. If people who aren't interested want to follow that one then that is up to them. I follow a lot of bodybuilders and they post progress shots all the time and I enjoy seeing them.
OP at the end of the day many people will judge anything we do, do what you want to do .. I never regret sharing my progress, I may come off a certain way, so be it.1 -
Why do some individuals perceive one to be a tool for posting a physique picture? I am proud of my own progress and most people are supportive. However, some people always think I’m egotistical or arrogant for doing so. Anyone have any thoughts on this?
Why care what others think of you? Be happy and not a tool in life and things will be just fine til you die.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions