Welcome to Debate Club! Please be aware that this is a space for respectful debate, and that your ideas will be challenged here. Please remember to critique the argument, not the author.
Eggs are Bad Again
Replies
-
Eggs - doesn't get any "cleaner" than consuming the soul of an unborn despite not having "clean" macros necessarily (opinion)2
-
I need to cut my 3x-a-week breakfast with 2 eggs (no yolk) and bacon. I blame this for my high 174 total cholesterol.2
-
I doubt egg whites cause high cholesterol.
I am not one of the few sensitive to cholesterol in food, and go through periods where I have a dozen eggs a week with no issues (my cholesterol has always been good and got even better when I lost weight).2 -
By medical current standards, you are correct. Except that about 1/3 of heart strokes are in people with total cholesterol ranging 150-200. You almost never see heart strokes in people with total cholesterol below 150. This is where I want to be.3 -
By medical current standards, you are correct. Except that about 1/3 of heart strokes are in people with total cholesterol ranging 150-200. You almost never see heart strokes in people with total cholesterol below 150. This is where I want to be.
A couple of years ago my cholesterol of 139 was flagged on my results as too low... that lab said total cholesterol was supposed to be between 140 and 200. Seems like 140-150 is a very narrow result to be shooting for.2 -
The range shown on my lab test is 120-200.0
-
Three to four eggs a week huh? I eat 3/day. Maybe I should cut back. Just to save some money.0
-
mburgess458 wrote: »
By medical current standards, you are correct. Except that about 1/3 of heart strokes are in people with total cholesterol ranging 150-200. You almost never see heart strokes in people with total cholesterol below 150. This is where I want to be.
A couple of years ago my cholesterol of 139 was flagged on my results as too low... that lab said total cholesterol was supposed to be between 140 and 200. Seems like 140-150 is a very narrow result to be shooting for.
Low cholesterol is where strokes seem to happen.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3299064/2 -
My husband has had a quadruple bypass, a triple bypass, and 6 stents.
His cardiologist told him not to eat more than 2-4 eggs per month. He says that, if you don't have a genetic predisposition to high cholesterol, eggs are perfectly okay. But if you do, then they are not.
3 -
The study also states that the link to eggs being "bad" is often associated with what is eaten with them. Traditional western diets that include eggs often have a fair serving of saturated fat and sodium associated with the eggs (bacon, sausages, steak, fried potatoes, buttered toast etc.).
I eat eggs regularly, usually hard boiled, by themselves or mixed with olive oil based mayonnaise and my blood cholesterol is fine, even though mine is treated with statins due to a genetic condition. I just tend to eat them without saturated fat.3 -
Three to four eggs a week huh? I eat 3/day. Maybe I should cut back. Just to save some money.
I dunno what you pay for eggs. I was getting a dozen for $0.48, they have gone back up to a more typical $0.88/dozen here.
Eggs are one of the cheapest sources of protein and IIRC the most bio available protein to humans.5 -
Not stroke, but a particular kind of stroke, intracerebral hemorrhage. Ischemic stroke is strongly associated with dyslipidemia and statin therapy is still advised as a potential preventative for it:mburgess458 wrote: »
By medical current standards, you are correct. Except that about 1/3 of heart strokes are in people with total cholesterol ranging 150-200. You almost never see heart strokes in people with total cholesterol below 150. This is where I want to be.
A couple of years ago my cholesterol of 139 was flagged on my results as too low... that lab said total cholesterol was supposed to be between 140 and 200. Seems like 140-150 is a very narrow result to be shooting for.
Low cholesterol is where strokes seem to happen.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3299064/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4774119/
Given the relative prevalence of heart attack (not sure what heart stroke is) plus ischemic stroke versus prevalence of ICH, it is probably still a better average health outcome to have a lower cholesterol. It also seems ICH is influenced by blood pressure and low and high BMI, particularly both combined, so tackling those in comparison to trying to have a high cholesterol seems a better preventative.4 -
We have eggs on the dark side
0 -
tbright1965 wrote: »Three to four eggs a week huh? I eat 3/day. Maybe I should cut back. Just to save some money.
I dunno what you pay for eggs. I was getting a dozen for $0.48, they have gone back up to a more typical $0.88/dozen here.
Eggs are one of the cheapest sources of protein and IIRC the most bio available protein to humans.
10 eggs around here cost $5.90 (not organic...)
By far not the cheapest protein source you can find here. I am a smidgen jealous at your prices.3 -
ladyreva78 wrote: »tbright1965 wrote: »Three to four eggs a week huh? I eat 3/day. Maybe I should cut back. Just to save some money.
I dunno what you pay for eggs. I was getting a dozen for $0.48, they have gone back up to a more typical $0.88/dozen here.
Eggs are one of the cheapest sources of protein and IIRC the most bio available protein to humans.
10 eggs around here cost $5.90 (not organic...)
By far not the cheapest protein source you can find here. I am a smidgen jealous at your prices.
Non organic would be about $1.79/dozen here, no discount/special.0 -
Ooooo win-win-win. I feel like we're in Las Vegas.
(Also, a client just brought us homemade chocolate chip cookies and I may have over done it. And they were NOT small either.)1 -
It kills me when these people say that cholesterol in eggs is bad for you buy then go and eat a piece of chicken. Face-to-Palm moment of the day.2
-
Katie0520B wrote: »It kills me when these people say that cholesterol in eggs is bad for you buy then go and eat a piece of chicken. Face-to-Palm moment of the day.
Why? I don't actually buy that dietary cholesterol is bad for most of us, but eggs have way more than chicken (chicken is reasonably low -- 100 g of chicken breast with skin has 64 mg). 2 eggs (also about 100 g) would have fewer calories, but 372 mg of cholesterol, and about 1.2x as much sat fat (2.67 g vs. 3.13 g).
Before you woo: I am not saying eggs are bad for us, I am not convinced that is true at all.4 -
I dare them to come between me and my eggs. I double dog dare them. 😤4
-
The only question I have is -- fried or scrambled ?0
-
"The researchers followed nearly 30,000 adults over three decades and found that eating three or four eggs a week was tied to a 6 percent higher risk of heart disease and an 8 percent risk of dying from any cause. "
So let me get this straight...if i consume 3-4 eggs a week i also have a 8% higher risk of being struck by lightning...or a hit by a car....
i stopped reading this after that, and ate an egg.....................with extra salt.10 -
I eat at least two duck eggs a day - here in the UK, eggs are considered close to a nutritionally optimum food ! My cholsterol was also summarised as 'excellent' last time it was checked.2
-
-
I haven't read everything in this thread. I was eating very junkie for a while and had high cholesterol my last blood test. I cut it back to pretty much a diet of Chicken vegetables rice with occasionally almonds and bananas for snacks. The only thing I'm questioning is my brother-in-law gave me a recipe for a morning omelette that has half a cup of egg whites and one whole egg in it. I don't eat the Omelette every morning, because I don't always have time for breakfast, but The Omelette is the only food I eat for breakfast when I can. Any thoughts or concerns?1
-
I don't see any reason to worry about it.0
-
If we stop eating eggs, the terrorists win.10
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions