Ladies...At what height is a guy creepy short to you?

ajaxe432

This thread shows shallowness to a whole new level....For ladies saying they wont date a guy under 5'8 because it makes them uncomfortable.....how old are you????

Would you date a 300-pound woman?

How can you compare this? A person can control the weight, not height:)

This mentality of, "you're shallow if you can't look past appearance," is ridiculous no matter how it's applied.

I can see your point....but the bottom line is being comfortable in your own skin. If their insecure, then I can see why people would feel that way! For me, I do see people for who they are, because I am comfortable in my own skin. Do I have preferance....yes, but I would not object from dating someone who is overweight simply because they are overweight...If they have awesome attributes, then that outweighs the way they look either way:) So yes, I stand by my point it! Its shallow.

_SABOTEUR_

This thread shows shallowness to a whole new level....For ladies saying they wont date a guy under 5'8 because it makes them uncomfortable.....how old are you????

Would you date a 300-pound woman?

How can you compare this? A person can control the weight, not height:)

It's still a shallow criterion. It's still a matter of what you're attracted to.

This mentality of, "you're shallow if you can't look past appearance," is ridiculous no matter how it's applied.

Bottom line is, plenty of short men have found women who love them. So why insult the women who just aren't attracted to that particular feature?

There's a difference between personal preference and referring to someone's height as creepy.

And I'm 6ft5 so I'm not saying this as an overly sensitive short guy.

As far as I can tell, only the OP mentioned height and "creepy." Most of the women who commented on it said they don't find height creepy, no matter what it is. Some just simply stated a preference. That does not make them shallow any more than preferring blue eyes or blond hair.

Or people who won't date people who have children.

I think deal breaker is a term that was thrown around a lot. Deal breaker is something different to preference.

If I said anything below a D cup is a deal breaker?

Or anything darker than honey blonde is a deal breaker?

I'd be pissed if those were the statements being thrown around as well.

It's ridiculous.

MizTerry

Crotch high.

PhearlessPhreaks

I'm 5'6- any guy shorter than me is a no-go. Thankfully my husband is a half inch taller!

rml_16

This thread shows shallowness to a whole new level....For ladies saying they wont date a guy under 5'8 because it makes them uncomfortable.....how old are you????

Would you date a 300-pound woman?

How can you compare this? A person can control the weight, not height:)

This mentality of, "you're shallow if you can't look past appearance," is ridiculous no matter how it's applied.

I can see your point....but the bottom line is being comfortable in your own skin. If their insecure, then I can see why people would feel that way! For me, I do see people for who they are, because I am comfortable in my own skin. Do I have preferance....yes, but I would not object from dating someone who is overweight simply because they are overweight...If they have awesome attributes, then that outweighs the way they look either way:) So yes, I stand by my point it! Its shallow.

OK. But how do you know about their other attributes without having a conversation? And you have to approach that person to have that conversation and what is going to cause you to approach that person?

As far as being honey blond or D-cup breasts being dealbreakers? We may all think they're silly standards, but really, you can't control who or what you're attracted to.

Now, this is coming from someone who has dated men who I wasn't initially attracted to and who I got to know as people, but they are not men I would have approached or flirted with, say, if I saw them across a crowded bar. They just happened to be men I got to know as friends through other venues. Does that make me shallow?

PhearlessPhreaks

At under 5 feet, it's pretty hard to get shorter then me... lol. Though I've found that the shorter guys I've dated have the most problem with my height... go figure...

Maybe because they like taller women? My sister is 5'11, her boyfriend 5'9 and he likes her height. And she even wears heels on occasion!

DamePiglet

Has anyone mentioned the height related issues on the guy's part? I don't care how tall a guy is as long as he's able to be happy with who he is and confident in himself, it's when he has major issues with his own height and brings them up on a daily basis that I find height becomes a problem. I have dated guys who were 5'7"-5'9" and confident and secure in themselves and never told me I can't wear heels or that I'm "too tall" or that they wish I was a "short girl" so I'd look better next to them.....and then I've dated a couple who said all of those things and more because they were the ones who were obsessing over their height... That's when it's an issue for me. Whatever height you are guys, be happy with it lol

There ya go.
If his stature causes personality traits that make you incompatible, then it's the personality / hang ups, not the height, that annoys you.

_SABOTEUR_

This thread shows shallowness to a whole new level....For ladies saying they wont date a guy under 5'8 because it makes them uncomfortable.....how old are you????

Would you date a 300-pound woman?

How can you compare this? A person can control the weight, not height:)

This mentality of, "you're shallow if you can't look past appearance," is ridiculous no matter how it's applied.

I can see your point....but the bottom line is being comfortable in your own skin. If their insecure, then I can see why people would feel that way! For me, I do see people for who they are, because I am comfortable in my own skin. Do I have preferance....yes, but I would not object from dating someone who is overweight simply because they are overweight...If they have awesome attributes, then that outweighs the way they look either way:) So yes, I stand by my point it! Its shallow.

OK. But how do you know about their other attributes without having a conversation? And you have to approach that person to have that conversation and what is going to cause you to approach that person?

As far as being honey blond or D-cup breasts being dealbreakers? We may all think they're silly standards, but really, you can't control who or what you're attracted to.

Now, this is coming from someone who has dated men who I wasn't initially attracted to and who I got to know as people, but they are not men I would have approached or flirted with, say, if I saw them across a crowded bar. They just happened to be men I got to know as friends through other venues. Does that make me shallow?

But, then whatever you weren't attracted to wasn't a deal breaker was it?

greenhudler

I think deal breaker is a term that was thrown around a lot. Deal breaker is something different to preference.

If I said anything below a D cup is a deal breaker?

Or anything darker than honey blonde is a deal breaker?

I'd be pissed if those were the statements being thrown around as well.

It's ridiculous.

This is what I had thought about when I made my comment. Having a preference and saying something is a "deal breaker" are different. I have the *preference* of liking guys with green eyes, but if someone doesn't have green eyes it's not a deal breaker. (Not saying I actually give a crap about eye color haha, just giving an example)

rml_16

This thread shows shallowness to a whole new level....For ladies saying they wont date a guy under 5'8 because it makes them uncomfortable.....how old are you????

Would you date a 300-pound woman?

How can you compare this? A person can control the weight, not height:)

This mentality of, "you're shallow if you can't look past appearance," is ridiculous no matter how it's applied.

I can see your point....but the bottom line is being comfortable in your own skin. If their insecure, then I can see why people would feel that way! For me, I do see people for who they are, because I am comfortable in my own skin. Do I have preferance....yes, but I would not object from dating someone who is overweight simply because they are overweight...If they have awesome attributes, then that outweighs the way they look either way:) So yes, I stand by my point it! Its shallow.

OK. But how do you know about their other attributes without having a conversation? And you have to approach that person to have that conversation and what is going to cause you to approach that person?

As far as being honey blond or D-cup breasts being dealbreakers? We may all think they're silly standards, but really, you can't control who or what you're attracted to.

Now, this is coming from someone who has dated men who I wasn't initially attracted to and who I got to know as people, but they are not men I would have approached or flirted with, say, if I saw them across a crowded bar. They just happened to be men I got to know as friends through other venues. Does that make me shallow?

But, then whatever you weren't attracted to wasn't a deal breaker was it?

It would have been, though, if I hadn't been in a position to get to know that person.

I have a strong feeling that the people who say certain things are dealbreakers would change their minds for the right person IF they had the chance to get to know that person, which doesn't always happen. Everyone thinnks they know what they want.

That said, I don't know that I could be attracted to a short man. Looking back, I think only once have I dated someone shorter than 5'11" and he was still taller than I am (though I'm 5'3", so most men are taller than I am).

I don't find short men creepy or unworthy of love or relationships. I just am not personally attracted to that particular physical attribute. I enjoy feeling small and I wouldn't feel small next to a man my height or shorter.

DamePiglet

Now, this is coming from someone who has dated men who I wasn't initially attracted to and who I got to know as people, but they are not men I would have approached or flirted with, say, if I saw them across a crowded bar. They just happened to be men I got to know as friends through other venues. Does that make me shallow?

This makes you NOT shallow.
Even though you didn't approach them, you judged them on the basis of their character, not your initial evaluation of their appearance.
Many women in here wouldn't do that.

billsica

You people are heightists!
Sorry if we don't all fit into your ideal mold ladies.

If were too short, there are alternatives.

inside_lap

At under 5 feet, it's pretty hard to get shorter then me... lol. Though I've found that the shorter guys I've dated have the most problem with my height... go figure...

Maybe because they like taller women? My sister is 5'11, her boyfriend 5'9 and he likes her height. And she even wears heels on occasion!

Lol! Probably right. The guy I dated that was 5'3" if anything had the BIGGEST issue with my height. Dumped me for a leggy blood that was a ballet dancer (ie THIN and TALL). I think he felt that he SHOULD go out with me since I was one of the girls that was nice to him both before and after he loss a very significant amount of weight. Who knew losing weight would turn him into a butt? No speaking from a bitter place I swear... lol. My hubby is 6 ft. Has no issue with my height . To each their own I guess.

rml_16

Now, this is coming from someone who has dated men who I wasn't initially attracted to and who I got to know as people, but they are not men I would have approached or flirted with, say, if I saw them across a crowded bar. They just happened to be men I got to know as friends through other venues. Does that make me shallow?

This makes you NOT shallow.
Even though you didn't approach them, you judged them on the basis of their character, not your initial evaluation of their appearance.
Many women in here wouldn't do that.

Only because we were thrown together in a way that forced me to get to know them. I would not have taken the time if, say, I saw them on a dating website or in a bar or something.

_SABOTEUR_

This thread shows shallowness to a whole new level....For ladies saying they wont date a guy under 5'8 because it makes them uncomfortable.....how old are you????

Would you date a 300-pound woman?

How can you compare this? A person can control the weight, not height:)

This mentality of, "you're shallow if you can't look past appearance," is ridiculous no matter how it's applied.

I can see your point....but the bottom line is being comfortable in your own skin. If their insecure, then I can see why people would feel that way! For me, I do see people for who they are, because I am comfortable in my own skin. Do I have preferance....yes, but I would not object from dating someone who is overweight simply because they are overweight...If they have awesome attributes, then that outweighs the way they look either way:) So yes, I stand by my point it! Its shallow.

OK. But how do you know about their other attributes without having a conversation? And you have to approach that person to have that conversation and what is going to cause you to approach that person?

As far as being honey blond or D-cup breasts being dealbreakers? We may all think they're silly standards, but really, you can't control who or what you're attracted to.

Now, this is coming from someone who has dated men who I wasn't initially attracted to and who I got to know as people, but they are not men I would have approached or flirted with, say, if I saw them across a crowded bar. They just happened to be men I got to know as friends through other venues. Does that make me shallow?

But, then whatever you weren't attracted to wasn't a deal breaker was it?

It would have been, though, if I hadn't been in a position to get to know that person.

I have a strong feeling that the people who say certain things are dealbreakers would change their minds for the right person IF they had the chance to get to know that person, which doesn't always happen. Everyone thinnks they know what they want.

That said, I don't know that I could be attracted to a short man. Looking back, I think only once have I dated someone shorter than 5'11" and he was still taller than I am (though I'm 5'3", so most men are taller than I am).

I don't find short men creepy or unworthy of love or relationships. I just am not personally attracted to that particular physical attribute. I enjoy feeling small and I wouldn't feel small next to a man my height or shorter.

You can't just make a judgement call on how the MFP masses really think to try and validate your hypothesis.

ajaxe432

This thread shows shallowness to a whole new level....For ladies saying they wont date a guy under 5'8 because it makes them uncomfortable.....how old are you????

Would you date a 300-pound woman?

How can you compare this? A person can control the weight, not height:)

This mentality of, "you're shallow if you can't look past appearance," is ridiculous no matter how it's applied.

I can see your point....but the bottom line is being comfortable in your own skin. If their insecure, then I can see why people would feel that way! For me, I do see people for who they are, because I am comfortable in my own skin. Do I have preferance....yes, but I would not object from dating someone who is overweight simply because they are overweight...If they have awesome attributes, then that outweighs the way they look either way:) So yes, I stand by my point it! Its shallow.

OK. But how do you know about their other attributes without having a conversation? And you have to approach that person to have that conversation and what is going to cause you to approach that person?

As far as being honey blond or D-cup breasts being dealbreakers? We may all think they're silly standards, but really, you can't control who or what you're attracted to.

Now, this is coming from someone who has dated men who I wasn't initially attracted to and who I got to know as people, but they are not men I would have approached or flirted with, say, if I saw them across a crowded bar. They just happened to be men I got to know as friends through other venues. Does that make me shallow?

No, it does not. Simply preferance...but now we are venturing into the realms of "would we talkwith this person first, then consider them a date" is a whole different chat. My orginal post pertained to people saying they were deal breakers without even giving that person a fair shot....which is shallow

rml_16

This thread shows shallowness to a whole new level....For ladies saying they wont date a guy under 5'8 because it makes them uncomfortable.....how old are you????

Would you date a 300-pound woman?

How can you compare this? A person can control the weight, not height:)

This mentality of, "you're shallow if you can't look past appearance," is ridiculous no matter how it's applied.

I can see your point....but the bottom line is being comfortable in your own skin. If their insecure, then I can see why people would feel that way! For me, I do see people for who they are, because I am comfortable in my own skin. Do I have preferance....yes, but I would not object from dating someone who is overweight simply because they are overweight...If they have awesome attributes, then that outweighs the way they look either way:) So yes, I stand by my point it! Its shallow.

OK. But how do you know about their other attributes without having a conversation? And you have to approach that person to have that conversation and what is going to cause you to approach that person?

As far as being honey blond or D-cup breasts being dealbreakers? We may all think they're silly standards, but really, you can't control who or what you're attracted to.

Now, this is coming from someone who has dated men who I wasn't initially attracted to and who I got to know as people, but they are not men I would have approached or flirted with, say, if I saw them across a crowded bar. They just happened to be men I got to know as friends through other venues. Does that make me shallow?

But, then whatever you weren't attracted to wasn't a deal breaker was it?

It would have been, though, if I hadn't been in a position to get to know that person.

I have a strong feeling that the people who say certain things are dealbreakers would change their minds for the right person IF they had the chance to get to know that person, which doesn't always happen. Everyone thinnks they know what they want.

That said, I don't know that I could be attracted to a short man. Looking back, I think only once have I dated someone shorter than 5'11" and he was still taller than I am (though I'm 5'3", so most men are taller than I am).

I don't find short men creepy or unworthy of love or relationships. I just am not personally attracted to that particular physical attribute. I enjoy feeling small and I wouldn't feel small next to a man my height or shorter.

You can't just make a judgement call on how the MFP masses really think to try and validate your hypothesis.

Then maybe all of you calling people shallow for not being attracted to certain people should stop doing that. :flowerforyou:

Sinisterly

Then maybe all of you calling people shallow for not being attracted to certain people should stop doing that. :flowerforyou:

+Like

rml_16

This thread shows shallowness to a whole new level....For ladies saying they wont date a guy under 5'8 because it makes them uncomfortable.....how old are you????

Would you date a 300-pound woman?

How can you compare this? A person can control the weight, not height:)

This mentality of, "you're shallow if you can't look past appearance," is ridiculous no matter how it's applied.

I can see your point....but the bottom line is being comfortable in your own skin. If their insecure, then I can see why people would feel that way! For me, I do see people for who they are, because I am comfortable in my own skin. Do I have preferance....yes, but I would not object from dating someone who is overweight simply because they are overweight...If they have awesome attributes, then that outweighs the way they look either way:) So yes, I stand by my point it! Its shallow.

OK. But how do you know about their other attributes without having a conversation? And you have to approach that person to have that conversation and what is going to cause you to approach that person?

As far as being honey blond or D-cup breasts being dealbreakers? We may all think they're silly standards, but really, you can't control who or what you're attracted to.

Now, this is coming from someone who has dated men who I wasn't initially attracted to and who I got to know as people, but they are not men I would have approached or flirted with, say, if I saw them across a crowded bar. They just happened to be men I got to know as friends through other venues. Does that make me shallow?

No, it does not. Simply preferance...but now we are venturing into the realms of "would we talkwith this person first, then consider them a date" is a whole different chat. My orginal post pertained to people saying they were deal breakers without even giving that person a fair shot....

But ... there is no person. This is ALL hypothetical. There is not a specific man being held up in this thread to be judged. There is not a photo in the OP asking, "Would you talk to this man if he were not short?" We aren't sitting around in a room pointing to a specific person and asking random women if they find his height creepy.

There is no man. There is a hypothetical situation and people are offering their gut instincts. And being called shallow for it.

Sinisterly

Has to be 2+ taller.
Anything else idc about.

And in your case that's how tall in centimers/feet?

Air. Count air.

_SABOTEUR_

This thread shows shallowness to a whole new level....For ladies saying they wont date a guy under 5'8 because it makes them uncomfortable.....how old are you????

Would you date a 300-pound woman?

How can you compare this? A person can control the weight, not height:)

This mentality of, "you're shallow if you can't look past appearance," is ridiculous no matter how it's applied.

I can see your point....but the bottom line is being comfortable in your own skin. If their insecure, then I can see why people would feel that way! For me, I do see people for who they are, because I am comfortable in my own skin. Do I have preferance....yes, but I would not object from dating someone who is overweight simply because they are overweight...If they have awesome attributes, then that outweighs the way they look either way:) So yes, I stand by my point it! Its shallow.

OK. But how do you know about their other attributes without having a conversation? And you have to approach that person to have that conversation and what is going to cause you to approach that person?

As far as being honey blond or D-cup breasts being dealbreakers? We may all think they're silly standards, but really, you can't control who or what you're attracted to.

Now, this is coming from someone who has dated men who I wasn't initially attracted to and who I got to know as people, but they are not men I would have approached or flirted with, say, if I saw them across a crowded bar. They just happened to be men I got to know as friends through other venues. Does that make me shallow?

But, then whatever you weren't attracted to wasn't a deal breaker was it?

It would have been, though, if I hadn't been in a position to get to know that person.

I have a strong feeling that the people who say certain things are dealbreakers would change their minds for the right person IF they had the chance to get to know that person, which doesn't always happen. Everyone thinnks they know what they want.

That said, I don't know that I could be attracted to a short man. Looking back, I think only once have I dated someone shorter than 5'11" and he was still taller than I am (though I'm 5'3", so most men are taller than I am).

I don't find short men creepy or unworthy of love or relationships. I just am not personally attracted to that particular physical attribute. I enjoy feeling small and I wouldn't feel small next to a man my height or shorter.

You can't just make a judgement call on how the MFP masses really think to try and validate your hypothesis.

Then maybe all of you calling people shallow for not being attracted to certain people should stop doing that. :flowerforyou:

That's not even my argument.

But for today I'm done with smashing my head against a brick wall.

Sinisterly

Has to be 2+ taller.
Anything else idc about.

And in your case that's how tall in centimers/feet?

Air. Count air.

Ok, i am 10^99 air, is that tall enough?

Are we counting negatives here? Don't forget fractions.

Sinisterly

Now, are we talking a trampoline or bungee jumping??

Unknown

This content has been removed.

ajaxe432

This thread shows shallowness to a whole new level....For ladies saying they wont date a guy under 5'8 because it makes them uncomfortable.....how old are you????

Would you date a 300-pound woman?

How can you compare this? A person can control the weight, not height:)

This mentality of, "you're shallow if you can't look past appearance," is ridiculous no matter how it's applied.

I can see your point....but the bottom line is being comfortable in your own skin. If their insecure, then I can see why people would feel that way! For me, I do see people for who they are, because I am comfortable in my own skin. Do I have preferance....yes, but I would not object from dating someone who is overweight simply because they are overweight...If they have awesome attributes, then that outweighs the way they look either way:) So yes, I stand by my point it! Its shallow.

OK. But how do you know about their other attributes without having a conversation? And you have to approach that person to have that conversation and what is going to cause you to approach that person?

As far as being honey blond or D-cup breasts being dealbreakers? We may all think they're silly standards, but really, you can't control who or what you're attracted to.

Now, this is coming from someone who has dated men who I wasn't initially attracted to and who I got to know as people, but they are not men I would have approached or flirted with, say, if I saw them across a crowded bar. They just happened to be men I got to know as friends through other venues. Does that make me shallow?

No, it does not. Simply preferance...but now we are venturing into the realms of "would we talkwith this person first, then consider them a date" is a whole different chat. My orginal post pertained to people saying they were deal breakers without even giving that person a fair shot....

But ... there is no person. This is ALL hypothetical. There is not a specific man being held up in this thread to be judged. There is not a photo in the OP asking, "Would you talk to this man if he were not short?" We aren't sitting around in a room pointing to a specific person and asking random women if they find his height creepy.

There is no man. There is a hypothetical situation and people are offering their gut instincts. And being called shallow for it.

Dealbreaker...small body size....amongst other post. This is where my argument lies. Absolute without knowing the facts behind the person. To say I would be suprised would be a lie. I work in the fitness world and see how negative peeps into fitness can be(not all dont get me wrong here)...maybe that is where I sense this from, but in all fairness I could be wrong as I do not know any member here. Thier comments seem very similar to what I hear daily at the gym, and I can see the similarites. Hypothetical, I can not argue with that. I do however still stand by my point!:)

Unknown

This content has been removed.

Sinisterly

I just count +2 on you, will make airjumps to outheight you :P

To get the ideal height for her ideal man, you got to be me..

yea already figured that out by reading the threads here
Well guess i walk on then...

Sorry fella, can't win them all eh. :laugh: Let's have a drink though :drinker:

-noms popcorn and watches-
Mmmkayyy.

rml_16

This thread shows shallowness to a whole new level....For ladies saying they wont date a guy under 5'8 because it makes them uncomfortable.....how old are you????

Would you date a 300-pound woman?

How can you compare this? A person can control the weight, not height:)

This mentality of, "you're shallow if you can't look past appearance," is ridiculous no matter how it's applied.

I can see your point....but the bottom line is being comfortable in your own skin. If their insecure, then I can see why people would feel that way! For me, I do see people for who they are, because I am comfortable in my own skin. Do I have preferance....yes, but I would not object from dating someone who is overweight simply because they are overweight...If they have awesome attributes, then that outweighs the way they look either way:) So yes, I stand by my point it! Its shallow.

OK. But how do you know about their other attributes without having a conversation? And you have to approach that person to have that conversation and what is going to cause you to approach that person?

As far as being honey blond or D-cup breasts being dealbreakers? We may all think they're silly standards, but really, you can't control who or what you're attracted to.

Now, this is coming from someone who has dated men who I wasn't initially attracted to and who I got to know as people, but they are not men I would have approached or flirted with, say, if I saw them across a crowded bar. They just happened to be men I got to know as friends through other venues. Does that make me shallow?

No, it does not. Simply preferance...but now we are venturing into the realms of "would we talkwith this person first, then consider them a date" is a whole different chat. My orginal post pertained to people saying they were deal breakers without even giving that person a fair shot....

But ... there is no person. This is ALL hypothetical. There is not a specific man being held up in this thread to be judged. There is not a photo in the OP asking, "Would you talk to this man if he were not short?" We aren't sitting around in a room pointing to a specific person and asking random women if they find his height creepy.

There is no man. There is a hypothetical situation and people are offering their gut instincts. And being called shallow for it.

Dealbreaker...small body size....amongst other post. This is where my argument lies. Absolute without knowing the facts behind the person. To say I would be suprised would be a lie. I work in the fitness world and see how negative peeps into fitness can be(not all dont get me wrong here)...maybe that is where I sense this from, but in all fairness I could be wrong as I do not know any member here. Thier comments seem very similar to what I hear daily at the gym, and I can see the similarites. Hypothetical, I can not argue with that. I do however still stand by my point!:)

Well, anyone who dismisses a person as a dating prospect based on a physical attribute -- controllable or not -- is then shallow. And therefore, we should all just walk around with our eyes clsoed so as not to be judged for not being physically attracted to any person who might be interested in us.

I won't date men my age or younger. Ever. Never have, unless you count elementary school boyfriends. It is something that is a dealbreaker and something that is out of their control.

So I guess I am, in fact, shallow.

DamePiglet

I've been called out on the forums for being butthurt, and they were right. They challenged me to examine myself, and I actually think that's a good thing.

Sometimes we just challenge one another to be introspective.

running_free_1984

I've been in relationships with people who were taller and shorter and those relationships were not based on height. But the person I'm marrying and fathered my children is 6'4''. In all honesty, yes I like that he is so tall for many reasons. One reason being that I'm 5'7'' and he can reach a whole bunch of stuff that I can't!