MEN...WE NEED YOUR HELP!

azQmaster

From the left

5,2,1,3,4

tjradd73

Pic 1 5
Pic 2 4
Pic 3 1
Pic 4 4
Pic 5 3


Why do you ask?

I think women have a very false sense of what men want...and apparently I was right!!

jackpotclown

2,3,1,4,5

JNick77

4-1-3-2-5

Tara, my 1 and 2 were very close.

Random_Name

On the only scale that matters: Yes/No

The only "Yes" is Elisha Cuthbert.

The second closest to a "Yes" would be Marilyn Monroe, but only if I was waiting for the cable guy or the plumber so I had a four hour window to kill. Also, she would have to be alive because I have a rule about screwing the dead now.

EmpressOfJudgment

I find it strange that a few men are ranking both 1 and 5 real high. I would think if you liked one, you'd hate the other.

bregalad5

I find it strange that a few men are ranking both 1 and 5 real high. I would think if you liked one, you'd hate the other.

Actually, they're ranking them low. 1 = hot, 5 = not hot

Random_Name

I find it strange that a few men are ranking both 1 and 5 real high. I would think if you liked one, you'd hate the other.

5 is *least* desirable.

CrzyAte

Pic 1 5
Pic 2 4
Pic 3 1
Pic 4 4
Pic 5 3


Why do you ask?

I think women have a very false sense of what men want...and apparently I was right!!

I agree if we refrased this to say Women what do you think men would want it would probabaly 2,1,3,4,5.

bregalad5

Pic 1 5
Pic 2 4
Pic 3 1
Pic 4 4
Pic 5 3


Why do you ask?

I think women have a very false sense of what men want...and apparently I was right!!

I agree if we refrased this to say Women what do you think men would want it would probabaly 2,1,3,4,5.

I'd probably say 3, 1, 2, 4, 5 just because I constantly hear guys talking about how they think they'll break really super skinny girls.

0PhAtDaDdY

2 4 1 3 5

mommared53

MEN!! a few ladies and I are having a discussion on this topic...PLEASE rate these ladies from 1 to 5!!! 1 having the hottest body and 5 having the least hottest body!! thanks

My son doesn't go on MFP but I showed him the pics last night so I'm showing his vote.

Pics 3 and 4 tied for 1st place.

Pic 5 was 2nd place. He had actually chosen her first but he didn't like the fake red hair and the tattoo so that knocked her down to 2nd place.

Pic 2 was 3rd place.

Pic 1 he wasn't attracted to at all.

Edited to take out the last statement. He wasn't trying to be mean but some women can't help being that skinny.

_Ben

31245

tjradd73

4-1-3-2-5

Tara, my 1 and 2 were very close.

I like 2 then 3....4 is a bit chubby...I I can say that from where I came from!!!

BellySoonGone

It is so refreshing to see that men on here are not shallow !! I like the fact that most on here like the lady with more meat on her bones than the skinny stick , I think number 3 and 4 are the best !!!
# 1 is too skinny
# 2 is nice
# 3 is PERFECT
# 4 again nice all american size woman who is comfy in the skin she is in which makes her super sexy !
# 5 I have a n issure with the hair. now if her hair was different and the picture was takenm with a little more class Im sure it would rate high!

totally disagree.

#2 is by far the best one - she has no competition in that line-up

dannylives

By the way. Who is the girl in pic #4?

datguy2011

From left to right: 4, 2, 1, 3, 5.

tjradd73

It is so refreshing to see that men on here are not shallow !! I like the fact that most on here like the lady with more meat on her bones than the skinny stick , I think number 3 and 4 are the best !!!
# 1 is too skinny
# 2 is nice
# 3 is PERFECT
# 4 again nice all american size woman who is comfy in the skin she is in which makes her super sexy !
# 5 I have a n issure with the hair. now if her hair was different and the picture was takenm with a little more class Im sure it would rate high!

totally disagree.

#2 is by far the best one - she has no competition in that line-up

I AGREE!!! That's what I am shootin for!

I am actually very surprised that 3 is so close to being #1, compared to 2?! MM was a size 14 afterall....which is today's avg woman!

minmatt

MM was a size 14 then....which today is more like a 6 or 8.

mrandolph69

Left to right:

4 1 2 3 5

tjradd73

MM was a size 14 then....which today is more like a 6 or 8.

REALLY?! I didn't know that!!! you could never tell from this pic of her. tho..she looks a TODAYS 14 for sure!!!

Lauren8239

By the way. Who is the girl in pic #4?

I believe that is Crystal Renn. She's a plus-sized model. Unfortunately she has lost all her weight and become skinny.

minmatt

Yeah I know! I thought the same thing!

EmpressOfJudgment

I believe that is Crystal Renn. She's a plus-sized model. Unfortunately she has lost all her weight and become skinny.

Probably because she wanted to make real money. :-/

HMonsterX

From left to right:

4,2,1,3,5.

To me, the 3rd pic is my idea of a perfect woman shape.

IMO.

HMonsterX

Anyone want to rate me? You have to look at my pics since I can't post them on this thing due to work honest opinions are always nice

Well, Red really is your colour!

Need to see you standing up to give a full assessment though

aj_rock

From left to right:

5, 1, 2, 3, 5

Too far to either side is gross. This really isn't a fair comparison between these models though.

momof8munchkins

I'm not a man or gay..but I thought I'd put my 2 cents in.. this thread is depressing that one of the most famous sex symbols of all time- MM did not win hands down because she had more meat on her bones than today's super models. and since I am closer in size to the last pic(minus the hair, blue lipstick and tattoo). :brokenheart: :bigsmile: sigh..going to cry cause I feel fat and unattractive now lol

jennajava

In order from left to right:


4 1 2 3 5

this is hilarious. my hubby always tells me "too skinny" isn't attractive (he says kyra knightley (sp?) is too skinny) and i never believe him...but now i guess i do!

shiggyshane

for me 3, 4, 2, 5, 1