THE SKINNY RULES!
Replies
-
8) Learn to read food labels so you know what you are eating.
Does anyone really not know how to read a label? :huh:
I love the misplaced faith in humanity.0 -
So very true, especially home cooking. I remember when I was first married and had a little guy at home, I'd cook at home most of the time. I was thin and had no issues.
Now, being 48, I'm 20 lbs more and am faced with making adjustments to my lifestyle/diet in order not to creep up in weight.0 -
Potatoes eaten with the skin are just LOADED with potassium. Getting the sodium/potassium balance correct is important to your blood pressure and proper muscle function.
People need to stop hating on potatoes! Boiled or baked with butter and salt, and maybe even a bit of sour cream, and they are awesome. But um. Peeled, cut into non potato resembling sticks and deep fried into submission, well, the potato loses it's luster. Just another example of how over processing has taken something that we should view as healthy and turned it into a junk food in everyone's mind.0 -
Most of these are the kind of restrictive, fad stuff that sells books and TV shows but does not support people learning for themselves what works for them....
Some are based on science and good while other are opinions and in the end everyone is different. What is a good long-term strategy for some is not for others.I found a pin of Bob Harper’s 20 “skinny rules.”
The Skinny Rules
1) Drink a large glass of water before every meal - no excuses.
YES 2) Don't drink your calories.
OFTEN 3) Eat protein at every meal or stay hungry and grouchy.
GOOD IDEA 4) Slash your intake of refined flours and grains.
YES - keeps you full and suggested to avoid colon cancer too 5) Eat 30 to 50 grams of fiber a day.
GOOD IDEA 6) Eat apples and berries every single day. Every single day. Single day!
NO SCIENCE TO THIS! 7) No carbs after lunch.
YES 8) Learn to read food labels so you know what you are eating.
HELPFUL YES 9) Stop guessing about portion size and get it right - for good.
IF YOU CAN 10) No more added sweeteners, including artificial ones.
NO SCIENCE TO THIS, WHAT HAPPENED TO MODERATION 11) Get rid of those white potatoes.
GOOD IDEA 12) Make one day a week meatless.
GOOD IDEA BUT AGAIN MODERATION 13) Get rid of fast foods and fried foods.
GOOD IDEA IF IT WORKS FOR YOU 14) Eat a REAL breakfast.
GOOD IDEA IF IT WORKS FOR YOU 15) Make your own food and eat at least ten meals a week from home
NO SCIENCE, ONLY 50% of POPULATION IS AFFECTED BY SALT-HIGH BLOOD PRESSURE 16) Banish high-salt foods.
YES 17) Eat your veggies - JUST DO IT!
GOOD IDEA IF IT WORKS FOR YOU 18) Go to bed hungry!!!
GOOD IDEA IF YOU CAN 19) Sleep right.
PERSONAL WHAT WORKS FOR YOU TO STAY ON TRACK AND NOT RESTRICT 20) Plan one splurge meal a week if you must. .0 -
Bump0
-
Not attacking you - these are not your 'rules' - but most of these are not necessary for weight loss, especially if you are logging your food.
My rules:
Rule 1: Eat at a reasonable calorie deficit with mostly nutritious foods
Rule 2: Hit your macros for body composition (protein) and health (fats) reasons
Rule 3: Strength train
Rule 4: Sleep
Rule 5: Eat ice-cream every night
Sara, once again, for the win.
Mine are:
1) Enjoy the activities you do, have fun - they should carry you forward in life and in health.
2) Eat, eat well, eat often, eat things you deam as good - and maintain a small and reasonable calorie deficit for weight loss.
3) Strength train for body composition - do things outside because the world is vast and challenging and your oyster
4) See 1) and 2) which for me means eat chocolate, ice cream, pate and yummy stuff. Did I mention chocolate?
5) Evaluate yourself, measure things and know what small changes will do to the system. Stay in control even when you let go.
6) Sleep, recuperate, take pauses, use downtime in all things.
I'll add one because while it isn't as apparently important as the others it will have long term impact -
7) protect your micros - you might not know how much or how well you need those small amounts of vitamins and minerals - so get them.0 -
I don't agree with half of these. There is only one "skinny rule"
1. Don't eat more calories than your body uses throughout the day.
Yes, I agree BUT If I don't do #2, 3, 4, 8, especially 9, 13, 14, 15, 17 and 19 then I am going to "eat more calories than my body uses throughout the day". True, I can lose weight eating twinkies as long as I don't go over my calories but I'm going to be really cranky and hungry.0 -
I think a lot of these fall into place with a healthy lifestyle. I still have a carb with dinner, but not a white one. For someone who needs a place to start, taking one of these rules at a time would be a great starting point.0
-
For someone who needs a place to start, taking one of these rules at a time would be a great starting point.
No. If you need a place to start:
1) Eat at a constant calorie level, reduce until yo uget a small and reasonable deficit. Continue. Learn more.
Many of those "rules" are rot for being "skinny".0 -
Stop getting your panties in a knot over this. They are only strategies for people to lose weight. There's reasons people gain in the first place and this guy is only putting forth some useful strategies to use.0
-
Rofl snort. I refuse to give up potatoes. NEFFER!! This list sounds like a recipe for disaster. I mean, basically restrict yourself til you eventually lose it and binge.0
-
I'm a big Bob fan so I was so excited to read this book. I like his thoughts overall but like everyone else, I can't shake the no carbs after lunch!0
-
I think a lot of these fall into place with a healthy lifestyle. I still have a carb with dinner, but not a white one. For someone who needs a place to start, taking one of these rules at a time would be a great starting point.
I agree, I'm sure most of the people on here who are healthy and fit probably already do most of these, maybe they're not calling them rules or punishing themselves over one they might not do but like you said these fall into place with a healthy lifestyle. And definitely for someone starting out who may not know any better or where to start, trying some of these may be a good thing. I think we're a little touchy about the word "rule" lol, how about ideas, tips... Anyway, thought I should mention I don't follow all of these either.0 -
Stop getting your panties in a knot over this. They are only strategies for people to lose weight. There's reasons people gain in the first place and this guy is only putting forth some useful strategies to use.
"Strategies" , well said!0 -
I think there good ideas ,,,,,,0
-
My issue with potatoes is that they are very tasteless unless you dress them up with condiments. That is where you really get the calories. I stay away from them as much as I can. I now eat butternut squash or spaghetti squash. More bang for the buck.
I am at a point in life (48) where the weight started creeping on and I had to take charge. I also drink 40 cal almond milk and canola butter. I'm fighting back now instead of letting the pounds creep on.0 -
I love lists like this because anyone can find a couple new ideas that they haven't experimented with. not everything works for everyone, but everyone can find something that works!0
-
bump! I need to check this out for sure!0
-
I love lists like this because anyone can find a couple new ideas that they haven't experimented with. not everything works for everyone, but everyone can find something that works!
I totally agree and many of us are probably already doing them (to a degree).
You have a very bright outlook!
0 -
My biggest offenders are eating carbs after lunch and eating white rice.0
-
I do none of these.0
-
I found a pin of Bob Harper’s 20 “skinny rules.”
The Skinny Rules
1) Drink a large glass of water before every meal - no excuses. --good idea
2) Don't drink your calories. --meh, i drink SOME.
3) Eat protein at every meal or stay hungry and grouchy. --great idea
4) Slash your intake of refined flours and grains. --good idea
5) Eat 30 to 50 grams of fiber a day. --great idea --not sure why the upper limit is what it is though
6) Eat apples and berries every single day. Every single day. Single day! --meh, not necessary.
7) No carbs after lunch. --bogus. I don't agree.
8) Learn to read food labels so you know what you are eating. --ABSOLUTELY!
9) Stop guessing about portion size and get it right - for good. --ABSOLUTELY!
10) No more added sweeteners, including artificial ones. --no thanks. not for me.
11) Get rid of those white potatoes. --bogus.
12) Make one day a week meatless. --bogus.
13) Get rid of fast foods and fried foods. --bogus. fast food options CAN BE healthy.
14) Eat a REAL breakfast. what's real?
15) Make your own food and eat at least ten meals a week from home. ABSOLUTELY!
16) Banish high-salt foods.--BOGUS.!
17) Eat your veggies - JUST DO IT! --ABSOLUTELY!
18) Go to bed hungry!!! -no thanks. bogus recommendation.
19) Sleep right. -what is right? I agree that sleep is important.
20) Plan one splurge meal a week if you must. . --ABSOLUTELY!0 -
I love lists like this because anyone can find a couple new ideas that they haven't experimented with. not everything works for everyone, but everyone can find something that works!
I agree. not all will work but it's something to consider. I LIKE the list.0 -
Awesome!!!!!! I love it! However, no carbs after Lunch is hard!
Can anyone explain 18) go to bed hungry!...why should I go to bed hungry?0 -
My goal isn't to be "skinny," so I'm free to ignore these and eat white potatoes.
My words exactly!0 -
I don't like any extreme set list of rules. There's a handful of good tips there though. Take a few rules from all the different ones and combine them, that's what I think is the best.0
-
Awesome!!!!!! I love it! However, no carbs after Lunch is hard!
Can anyone explain 18) go to bed hungry!...why should I go to bed hungry?
Yes, "go to bed hungry" just means that you shouldn't snack after dinner. If you eat a filling dinner, you won't be hungry anyway. Don't bring food to bed with you, things like that.0 -
Oh Well..I will never be skinny then. I dont do any of those..
No carbs after lunch??? Go to bed hungry?? No thank you very much0 -
Awesome!!!!!! I love it! However, no carbs after Lunch is hard!
Can anyone explain 18) go to bed hungry!...why should I go to bed hungry?
no carbs after lunch is nonsense and you shouldn't go to bed hungry in my opinion. Those sorts of things increase the odds of becoming a binge eater.0 -
Awesome!!!!!! I love it! However, no carbs after Lunch is hard!
Can anyone explain 18) go to bed hungry!...why should I go to bed hungry?
Yes, "go to bed hungry" just means that you shouldn't snack after dinner. If you eat a filling dinner, you won't be hungry anyway. Don't bring food to bed with you, things like that.
That is not the definition of hungry.
And if you are an evening snacker and you have the calories, what's the problem?0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.5K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions