Is Your State Making You Fat???

1ConcreteGirl

I've been doing a lot of research lately into what exactly causes this huge obesity epidemic. So many people these days are overweight and you know that it cannot just be due to thyroids and lack of desire. Almost all the overweight people I know say they want to lose weight! AND YET THEY DON'T.

So I went into research mode, and I found some seriously shocking things. For instance, the states with the highest amount of pollution and smog are almost exactly the same as the states with the highest rates of obesity. Check out this science:





There are a few exceptions, but overall, the areas are really similar and this discovery is seriously ground breaking, I know that most of my friends have never considered moving to get away from obesity-causing pollutants, but I have been telling everyone about this since I discovered it.

So what about it? Do you live in a state that is making you fat? If you do, would you consider moving?

Cliffslosinit

I live in California and yes I am considering moving anyway.

SteelySunshine

Moving to a less polluted state combined with eating less and moving more will very likely result in weight loss.

pastryari

I'm in San Francisco, we're about to ban happy meals. Bye bye, obesity! We're about to be the skinniest state, EVAR.


Edit: Cause typo. :grumble:

justal313

It's not about location, it's about culture. And I'm pretty sure there aren't roaming bands of Paula Deans all over Georgia shoving butter down everyone's throats. You can make good or bad choices anywhere and if you really want to take charge of your life you can better your situation and maybe ask for help if you need it...

bethanylaugh

this is a good point, light correlation always means causation

Cr01502

This is absolutely groundbreaking. It also tends to explain why countries like France and Germany are beginning to see a rise in obesity as well. They're finally catching up to our technology and are using more pollutants and are therefore getting more obese!

Also the states that seem to be more liberal, and therefore more environmentally friendly, seem to have less pollution and therefore less obesity.

bcattoes

I think living in a rural moutainous area that doesn't allow for things like walking or biking to the store, work, etc. doesn't help, but since I lived in this area and was not fat for decades so I don't suppose it would make sense to start blaming the state now. I stopped exercising regularly and continued to eat as though I were. That's what made me fat.

DirtyTrickster

Yes!

Pennsylvania filled me full of butter and sugar for 30 years and forced me not to exercise!

Babs1076

Perhaps clean healthy air encourages people to get outdoors more, doing physical activity.

MissMormie

It's very good of you to look into reason that are making people fat. However, you'd need to do some further research to prove that the two are linked, and that in fact the air pollution is causing the obesity (and not the obese people taking a car causing pollution for example). There are also a number of reasons which could cause both, or it might be coincidence. You might want to look at specific area's. For example, are people who live next to the freeway fatter than those who live further away?

I'm not saying you're wrong, I'm just saying that your research so far does not warrant saying that air pollution (let alone your state) is making you fat. It'd be very premature to move before doing further research.

zillah73

I actually moved from San Francisco to New Orleans and LOST weight – I am proof that you alone are in control of your health and weight, not your state.

szarlotka717

California (my home state) is a big exception - high overall pollution but low overall obesity. Pollution levels in CA also vary greatly by region - the Bay Area is typically better than the Central Valley. I am less familiar with regional obesity rates in CA, so I'd want to see regional pollution v. obesity stats.

wineplease

I'd rather be fat and live in Texas than thin and live in any of those other places.

Kidding (only slightly), but I wouldn't leave Texas based on this.

mamabisme

DARN YOU FLORIDA! It's all your fault!!! ::shaking fist::

Seriously, though. correlation =/= causation.

MG_Fit

Damn it ... Looks like I'm doomed.Should I start working our harder/longer, so the ratio of workout / pollution is greater?

I guess I could move...Montana looks promising.

jacksonpt

I've been doing a lot of research lately into what exactly causes this huge obesity epidemic. So many people these days are overweight and you know that it cannot just be due to thyroids and lack of desire. Almost all the overweight people I know say they want to lose weight! AND YET THEY DON'T.

A lot of people want to lose weight, they just don't want to badly enough to actually do it.

I want a better job, just not enough take the risk of leaving my current job. It's not a lack of desire, it's just insufficient desire.


But more to you're research... ****in A... finally something NY has right.

iulia_maddie

You should move to Canada Naomi. In my bedroom. There's no obesity in my bedroom.

Isakizza

Yeah I don't need another reason to blame my weight problem on, lol.
I'm where I am for only one reason, my own choices in living a not so good lifestyle.

I live in SoCal... I tend to see a lot of active people out here.




Created by MyFitnessPal.com - Free Weight Loss Tools

Calliope610

this is a good point, light correlation always means causation

QFT

Does this mean I can eat anything I want to as long as I live in a "clean" state. Who knew smog and pollution made me fat, not the calories I ate?

OkieinMinny

Im in MN - we all "bulk" up over the winter and "lean" out in the summer because we have to soak up all the Vitamin D we can - apparently Im staying bulky based on this years weather

quiltlovinlisa

Edited because I thought I was quoting someone and I wasn't. So what I said didn't make sense.

springs47

It's not about location, it's about culture. And I'm pretty sure there aren't roaming bands of Paula Deans all over Georgia shoving butter down everyone's throats. You can make good or bad choices anywhere and if you really want to take charge of your life you can better your situation and maybe ask for help if you need it...

Everyone knows about the wild Paula Deans.
You can spray them with I Can't Believe Its Not Butter....just aim for the eyes.

MireyGal76

my first thought is this...

NO.

If I am fat, it is because I am making me fat.

yes, there is cause and effect... but when it comes down to it... only I am to blame for my current state. I take full responsibility.
but I am Canadian... so maybe it doesn't apply.

GracefulDancer4Christ

the state has nothing to do with it its a cultural thing. the choice to be fat or not is up to the individual. for I eat according to who the people overseas eat in Russia I went in 1997 they eat much less then America does. I try to model that method.

MizTerry

Quitting smoking after 32 years contributed to me being fat, but I'm glad you asked.

No one forced food down my throat. I did it allllllll on my own, thank you very much.

bethanylaugh

plus some of these states are gigantic... pollution in LA is not making its way to northern CA, nor is pollution in NYC getting to Buffalo.

1ConcreteGirl

I actually moved from San Francisco to New Orleans and LOST weight – I am proof that you alone are in control of your health and weight, not your state.

Wow, congratulations! how did you do it?

Your story might be helpful to people who are living in states that are making them fat!

pastryari

You should move to Canada Naomi. In my bedroom. There's no obesity in my bedroom.

She's mine.

jacksonpt

my first thought is this...

NO.

If I am fat, it is because I am making me fat.

yes, there is cause and effect... but when it comes down to it... only I am to blame for my current state. I take full responsibility.
but I am Canadian... so maybe it doesn't apply.

Yea, we don't do that in the states.

BigBrunette

I think I would have gotten fat no matter what state I lived in. Just like I'm gonna get healthy no matter what state I live in. For me, it comes down to my personal choices about eating and exercising, not my geographic location.