Whole Egg vs. Egg White

MeganKSchultz

I've been eating one whole egg in the morning but I'm thinking of changing to one egg white because of the calories. I think I've read/heard somewhere that there is a lot of nutrition in the yolk though. Any reason I should keep the yolk?

thesupremeforce

If you're eating the egg for health reasons, there's no reason to drop the yolk. It's the best part. I'm fine with egg whites for certain types of cooking, but since we're talking about one egg per day, I don't see an issue with just eating the entire thing.

hsmaldo

You could certainly keep the whole egg if it's fitting in with your calories. If one egg isn't doing it for you though, you could take that whole egg and add as many egg whites as you wanted. More filling, but fewer calories and still better tasting than just egg whites (in my opinion)

tattygun

I could never throw an egg yolk away. It's sacrilege!

Alexandra289

I would feel so wasteful throwing the yolk away, I've paid for those eggs! Plus. it tastes so good.

meredith1123

Keep the yolk! One wont kill you. I mean if you were eating four a day, i'd say split it up 2 parts yolk, four parts white to avoid too many calories but one egg a day is definitely not an issue!

NumbrsNerd

I have high cholesterol (mostly hereditary), and I don't like egg yolk, so I don't eat them. I eat 3 whites instead of 1 whole egg. 3 jumbo whites have 54 calories and 14 grams of protein (and no cholesterol). 1 whole jumbo egg has 90 calories, 8 grams of protein and 270 grams/mg? (not sure) of cholesterol.

You have to be okay with spending a lot more on eggs though.....since you throw a lot away....

auddii

Depending on the size, one egg is only about 70 calories. Keep the egg whole.

Francl27

I have high cholesterol (mostly hereditary), and I don't like egg yolk, so I don't eat them. I eat 3 whites instead of 1 whole egg. 3 jumbo whites have 54 calories and 14 grams of protein (and no cholesterol). 1 whole jumbo egg has 90 calories, 8 grams of protein and 270 grams/mg? (not sure) of cholesterol.

You have to be okay with spending a lot more on eggs though.....since you throw a lot away....

Cholesterol in eggs is good for you, just FYI. And just buy egg whites in cartons then.

LisaGNV

mmmm.....eggs..... eat the whole thing!!

JenAndSome

I don't think there is enough of a calorie difference to warrant not eating the yolk. If that's why you are considering it, just eat the whole thing.

3laine75

cos everytime you leave the yolk a fairy dies

MorgueBabe

I could never throw an egg yolk away. It's sacrilege!

It's delicious and healthy! There is no reason NOT to eat the egg. Plus separating it is a PITA in the morning.

markstanley666

if your just having the 1 egg id stick to the whole thing. i remember reading something a while as that said the yolk (i believe the vitamin b in it) makes the protein in the egg more bio available to the body. not to mention it tastes good

i say if your having 1 stick with the whole thing if more maybe have 2 yolks and 1 white


http://www.bodybuilding.com/fun/whats-the-big-deal-with-egg-yolks-anyway.html is a good article if you have time to read it

NumbrsNerd

I have high cholesterol (mostly hereditary), and I don't like egg yolk, so I don't eat them. I eat 3 whites instead of 1 whole egg. 3 jumbo whites have 54 calories and 14 grams of protein (and no cholesterol). 1 whole jumbo egg has 90 calories, 8 grams of protein and 270 grams/mg? (not sure) of cholesterol.

You have to be okay with spending a lot more on eggs though.....since you throw a lot away....

Cholesterol in eggs is good for you, just FYI. And just buy egg whites in cartons then.

I have been told that many times - truth is, I've eaten egg whites so long that I prefer them. A whole egg is just gross to me. I'm not a fan of the carton of egg whites/egg beaters either. It's just a personal preference for me.

I don't mind separating my eggs and throwing away the yolk, but I know a lot of people view that as wasteful; hence, the comment about having to be okay with spending more. I don't mind it, but I know some would...

luvinlaurakate

I make a lot of omelettes and use one whole egg and two whites, since I am adding other ingredients as well. When I just make eggs, I stick to the whole thing. As you said, the yolk contains most of the nutrients, so if you cut it out completely you are losing all of that to gain a few calories for the day. I've always felt the trade-off wasn't worth it.

CoachReddy

the yolk is the only good part of the egg.

without the yolk, your body can't absorb the egg white protein nearly as well - the two work in synergy together. If you're concerned about calories, cut them elsewhere, since egg yolks are the MOST nutritious thing you'll put in your body all day long.

MeganKSchultz

I have to say, the whole "don't waste it, eat it" argument is part of the reason I'm fat! I've found it much harder to reduce the sugar in my coffee, and I'm trying to find a way to reduce my breakfast so I have more to work with in the evening.

Afura

I understand the rationale of don't waste it, eat it (My family always had the motto of "never turn down food"...) and trying to change this mentality, but in this instance, getting a good solid breakfast is important. Unless you have worries about cholesterol, eat the whole egg. If 90-ish calories are a deal breaker for your calorie intake, I'd look at what else you're eating to make changes, or put in some extra exercise daily.
Remember, this is about healthy eating and making smart choices for life, not restricting your eating habits until you freak out and binge. You may take my unnecessary creamer from my cold dead hands, I eat healthy in other ways.

CoachReddy

I understand the rationale of don't waste it, eat it (My family always had the motto of "never turn down food"...) and trying to change this mentality, but in this instance, getting a good solid breakfast is important. Unless you have worries about cholesterol, eat the whole egg. If 90-ish calories are a deal breaker for your calorie intake, I'd look at what else you're eating to make changes, or put in some extra exercise daily.
Remember, this is about healthy eating and making smart choices for life, not restricting your eating habits until you freak out and binge. You may take my unnecessary creamer from my cold dead hands, I eat healthy in other ways.

No. Eggs do NOT affect your cholesterol levels. No effect. NONE. Eat them regardless of whether or not you've got high cholesterol.

AmyRhubarb

I eat 2-3 whole XL eggs 4-5 days a week, and have been losing just fine - eggs are good for you!

timeasterday

No. Eggs do NOT affect your cholesterol levels. No effect. NONE. Eat them regardless of whether or not you've got high cholesterol.

Yep - dietary cholesterol and blood serum cholesterol are two very different things.

frenchfacey

Can u bring me ur yolk so i can dip every possible thing including my face into it and eat it?

melaniecheeks

For one egg, to do without the yolk you'd be saving maybe 50 calories. But losing out on a lot of nutrition and taste.

neanderthin

I understand the rationale of don't waste it, eat it (My family always had the motto of "never turn down food"...) and trying to change this mentality, but in this instance, getting a good solid breakfast is important. Unless you have worries about cholesterol, eat the whole egg. If 90-ish calories are a deal breaker for your calorie intake, I'd look at what else you're eating to make changes, or put in some extra exercise daily.
Remember, this is about healthy eating and making smart choices for life, not restricting your eating habits until you freak out and binge. You may take my unnecessary creamer from my cold dead hands, I eat healthy in other ways.

No. Eggs do NOT affect your cholesterol levels. No effect. NONE. Eat them regardless of whether or not you've got high cholesterol.

Yes they do.

CoachReddy

I understand the rationale of don't waste it, eat it (My family always had the motto of "never turn down food"...) and trying to change this mentality, but in this instance, getting a good solid breakfast is important. Unless you have worries about cholesterol, eat the whole egg. If 90-ish calories are a deal breaker for your calorie intake, I'd look at what else you're eating to make changes, or put in some extra exercise daily.
Remember, this is about healthy eating and making smart choices for life, not restricting your eating habits until you freak out and binge. You may take my unnecessary creamer from my cold dead hands, I eat healthy in other ways.

No. Eggs do NOT affect your cholesterol levels. No effect. NONE. Eat them regardless of whether or not you've got high cholesterol.

Yes they do.

facepalm

NumbrsNerd

I have high cholesterol (mostly hereditary), and I don't like egg yolk, so I don't eat them. I eat 3 whites instead of 1 whole egg. 3 jumbo whites have 54 calories and 14 grams of protein (and no cholesterol). 1 whole jumbo egg has 90 calories, 8 grams of protein and 270 grams/mg? (not sure) of cholesterol.

You have to be okay with spending a lot more on eggs though.....since you throw a lot away....

Cholesterol in eggs is good for you, just FYI. And just buy egg whites in cartons then.

I have been told that many times - truth is, I've eaten egg whites so long that I prefer them. A whole egg is just gross to me. I'm not a fan of the carton of egg whites/egg beaters either. It's just a personal preference for me.

I don't mind separating my eggs and throwing away the yolk, but I know a lot of people view that as wasteful; hence, the comment about having to be okay with spending more. I don't mind it, but I know some would...

I'm sorry - I don't want to perpetuate the high cholesterol thing - so I shouldn't have included it in my post! :ohwell: I have heard that eggs don't effect cholesterol - by the time I had heard that, my love of egg whites had already been established!

It REALLY, truly is about personal taste preference for me. I hate egg yolk in hard boiled eggs - eggs over easy are disgusting to me (I eat around the yolk and throw the yolk away) - and I can't stand scrambled eggs unless it's like 1 whole egg to maybe 3 white.

I shouldn't have gone there.... :blushing:

JoanB5

You could certainly keep the whole egg if it's fitting in with your calories. If one egg isn't doing it for you though, you could take that whole egg and add as many egg whites as you wanted. More filling, but fewer calories and still better tasting than just egg whites (in my opinion)

I use one real egg and then buy a liquid container of egg whites, mainly to boost my macros on protein without the extra calories and what may or may not be cholesterol. (See above comments). : )

neanderthin

I understand the rationale of don't waste it, eat it (My family always had the motto of "never turn down food"...) and trying to change this mentality, but in this instance, getting a good solid breakfast is important. Unless you have worries about cholesterol, eat the whole egg. If 90-ish calories are a deal breaker for your calorie intake, I'd look at what else you're eating to make changes, or put in some extra exercise daily.
Remember, this is about healthy eating and making smart choices for life, not restricting your eating habits until you freak out and binge. You may take my unnecessary creamer from my cold dead hands, I eat healthy in other ways.

No. Eggs do NOT affect your cholesterol levels. No effect. NONE. Eat them regardless of whether or not you've got high cholesterol.

Yes they do.

facepalm

Hope you were holding an egg at the time.

CoachReddy

I understand the rationale of don't waste it, eat it (My family always had the motto of "never turn down food"...) and trying to change this mentality, but in this instance, getting a good solid breakfast is important. Unless you have worries about cholesterol, eat the whole egg. If 90-ish calories are a deal breaker for your calorie intake, I'd look at what else you're eating to make changes, or put in some extra exercise daily.
Remember, this is about healthy eating and making smart choices for life, not restricting your eating habits until you freak out and binge. You may take my unnecessary creamer from my cold dead hands, I eat healthy in other ways.

No. Eggs do NOT affect your cholesterol levels. No effect. NONE. Eat them regardless of whether or not you've got high cholesterol.

Yes they do.

facepalm

Hope you were holding an egg at the time.

yep, and i made sure all the cholesterol went directly into my mouth.

nicoleashley_24

I prefer the whole egg because I'm pretty sure I would be a sad, bitter lady if my breakfast was so bland (I need some fat! Lol). But also, I'm a cheapskate and I just couldn't justify wasting half of a perfectly good egg!