"I don't want to be too thin" - a "fat" people thing to say?
Replies
-
What I would consider too thin.
I think both ladies are healthy and they both look great, I just like the first one better. I don't really have any explanation for it beyond preference. *shrug*
I can't view the second picture at work, but the lady on the top picture is too skinny in my opinion.
"The lady"?! THAT'S SHAKIRA.
Who the f** is Shakira? I doubt that she's an athlete.0 -
"The lady"?! THAT'S SHAKIRA.
The only woman on earth for whom the camera doesn't add 10lbs, because her hips don't lie
:laugh: You crack me up.0 -
IMO there is a fine line between healthy and sickly looking. For me, at 5'6 and an large frame, anything below 145 looks terrible.
well, I'm not sure about that. I kinda agree with web md's ranges for heights and weights.0 -
I hate it when people give out the wrong definition of "curves". No matter how much you weigh, your curves will stay the same. If you're an hourglass then it will stay the same whether you're fat or thin. Its not about the weight but its how you built.I dont think its an excuss. I think people (women in general) look better with some weight on them (curves). It don't have to be alot of weight. But being too skinny is not attractive.
Rolls of FAT =/= CURVY0 -
Someone else pointed this out, and I'm jumping on it. When women say they don't want to "lose their curves" and get "too thin," I think it's because "curves" are the only things they felt positive about for their body image. The big boobs or butt than their men loved? Those are at risk of disappearing, even though overall appearance would improve.
It's like priding yourself on your long hair--sure, it gets matted easily, snarly, and may be in horrible health... but it's so long, and someone liked it! So when you lose weight, and the boobs and butt go quickly... yeah, you were overweight, those boobs and butt were contributing to an unhealthy weight.... but someone liked it!
I would say "NOT TRUE!" My best feature has always been my eyes. When I was weighing 135, it was my legs, but my hips have been curvy since I was 12. Curvy is a shape, not a size.
Lol, do you not understand "examples." The topic is, "Why do people say this/feel this?" Clearly you're not in that demographic if you weren't saying, "Wow, I don't want to be too thin, because I have great eyes." Reading comprehension & context: you're doing it wrong. Nice job reading other posts, too!
Well apparently, I am retarded. I still think your comment is ridiculous. :ohwell:
:laugh:
You don't understand it then
At least you're cognizant enough to admit your mental failings (too bad you have to go the route of using "retarded").
I can say that because I have high confidence and self-esteem, plus a high IQ. It's called a joke. (joke are also subjective)
:laugh: :laugh:0 -
Who wants to be "too" anything?
I want to be too sexy for this shirt, so sexy it hurts.
"too sexy" and "too rich" are both desirable0 -
"too thin" to me means emaciated or death camp looking. Like you belong in a commercial for a christain charity to feed the hungry. As long as it falls under physically "healthy", I say go for it. but then again, i say don't do drugs, don't smoke, don't play in traffic always practice safe sex and brush your teeth freq to combat gingivitis. healthy = happy.
i was a overly thin drug doing smoker at one point. so this is my "new leaf" perspective. to feel healthy "clean" and good.
its doing marvelous things for mah happys.
Again, one chick's opinion. Opinions are a dime a dozen.
Agreed, the sunken eyes, drawn face not a good look. Good for you turning over a new leaf. That is huge!
THANKS! :flowerforyou:0 -
What I would consider too thin.
I think both ladies are healthy and they both look great, I just like the first one better. I don't really have any explanation for it beyond preference. *shrug*
I can't view the second picture at work, but the lady on the top picture is too skinny in my opinion.
"The lady"?! THAT'S SHAKIRA.
Who the f** is Shakira? I doubt that she's an athlete.
She is a singer and she also dance a lot. She does awsome belly dance. SHe is actually very active.0 -
I used to say that for several reasons.
1. Not enough confidence in myself
2. Not enough willingness to do change my diet and lifestyle to get the results I really want
3. I was convinced my genes were preventing me from achieving my goal weight.
4. Not enough good information about nutrition
5. I was making excuses for why I was my size
That being said, there is a difference in being "too thin" and fit. I want to be fit, which also means at a healthy weight.0 -
So when you say "I don't want to be skinny/too thin" what are you implying? Are you saying you don't find thin attractive or are you simply saying it because you don't believe you can reach a certain weight or is it just an excuse? Like you're heavy and you'd probably like to be that weight but are too lazy to actually work for it?
I don't want rib bones showing is what I mean ... to each their own, but for me, I want to look healthy and fit
so when I say I don't want to be to thin, I am "implying" I don't want to look unhealthy and sick0 -
What I would consider too thin.
I think both ladies are healthy and they both look great, I just like the first one better. I don't really have any explanation for it beyond preference. *shrug*
I can't view the second picture at work, but the lady on the top picture is too skinny in my opinion.
"The lady"?! THAT'S SHAKIRA.
Who the f** is Shakira? I doubt that she's an athlete.
She's a highly accomplished belly dancer, actually, and has a fantastic body.0 -
I hate it when people give out the wrong definition of "curves". No matter how much you weigh, your curves will stay the same. If you're an hourglass then it will stay the same whether you're fat or thin. Its not about the weight but its how you built.I dont think its an excuss. I think people (women in general) look better with some weight on them (curves). It don't have to be alot of weight. But being too skinny is not attractive.
Rolls of FAT =/= CURVY
Not so cut and dry. Right now I have hips and boobs that add curve and shape to my body. The smaller size I get the smaller my cup size and a surprise to me and people who always knew me with curvy hips, I actually have a more "up and down" look to my hips. Not curvy at all.0 -
I don't want to be skinny or be "too thin". This is not a "fat person" or "lazy" thing to say. This is coming from a veteran who use to be quite into weight lifting and wants to be fit and muscular again. I have never been "skinny". When I was 16 I started weight lifting seriously. Though I never got to bodybuilding standards I was quite toned (a little large even) and very strong by the time I got to bootcamp and maintained that for quite sometime. I'd like to reclaim that body and I simply can't do that as some bony waif. So for anyone who thinks that saying "I don't want to be too thin" is just some lazy fat person cop out...think again. Tone and muscle mass takes a lot of work.0
-
I can't view the second picture at work, but the lady on the top picture is too skinny in my opinion.
So healthy looking human is too skinny? This perfectly illustrates my point that what we consider normal has shifted....
No, it prove the subjective nature of the discussion. I don't think she looks healthy.
Serious question, what does not look healthy? simply looking at how her face is filled out and not sunken says that she has a healthy % of body fat. Also, do not get me wrong, there is a "too skinny" but in my opinion that is a long way from it.0 -
Similar to that, I have a lot of people say to me "You were already thin, you didn't really need to lose" or "You didn't really need to lose much".
Well, at 5'3", 159lbs back in Jan 2012, I had 32% body fat and BMI of 28 which is at the top range of Overweight ( 10lbs away from being obese)
Since then I've lost 24lbs, have a body fat of 23.7% and a BMI of 24. I'm healthy, but people tell me they didn't think I needed to lose weight. The "before" me was unhealthy but the view of what's "thin" is all realivte I guess. That size was okay for some people but it wasn't okay for me.0 -
It only means that you're not really curvy & what you had are just rolls of fat. What I mean is that a real curvy woman won't lose her curves even after she loses weight. Unfortunately many people don't understand it.
I hate it when people give out the wrong definition of "curves". No matter how much you weigh, your curves will stay the same. If you're an hourglass then it will stay the same whether you're fat or thin. Its not about the weight but its how you built.I dont think its an excuss. I think people (women in general) look better with some weight on them (curves). It don't have to be alot of weight. But being too skinny is not attractive.
Rolls of FAT =/= CURVY
Not so cut and dry. Right now I have hips and boobs that add curve and shape to my body. The smaller size I get the smaller my cup size and a surprise to me and people who always knew me with curvy hips, I actually have a more "up and down" look to my hips. Not curvy at all.0 -
Here's a better shot of her abs:
0 -
Yes, your curves will stay the same if you have that type of framed body. However, there is a point, at least for me where I looked curvy and sickly at the same time. At 130 and 5'2" my collarbone stuck out a LOT I was about a 34 A but wore a 7/9 in jeans...my butt,hips,and,thighs stayed curvy like the pear shape that I am..But I looked SICK and I had a flat stomach, so not rolls of FAT like you say. The BMI measurement would put 5'2" and 130 at a healthy BMI..with 136.7 at the weight that I would be considered healthy right before overweight. I don't think that is true. For the frame I am, and the way I have looked in the past...a healthy weight would be barely 136, more 145-155 and I'd still be considered overweight according to BMI. So like a post said it definitely "depends on the individual."
I hate it when people give out the wrong definition of "curves". No matter how much you weigh, your curves will stay the same. If you're an hourglass then it will stay the same whether you're fat or thin. Its not about the weight but its how you built.I dont think its an excuss. I think people (women in general) look better with some weight on them (curves). It don't have to be alot of weight. But being too skinny is not attractive.
Rolls of FAT =/= CURVY0 -
I want to look like the chicks on star trek. what the crap happened to that figure anyway? the hourglass gals use to be everywhere! did they give to many away before this gen came and we are just sol? i blame microwaves.
thats ok, when I'm rich I'll buy bigger boobs.0 -
For me, I have found myself saying that my goal when this is all said and done is "not to be skinny". There is absolutely nothing wrong with someone, including me, being thin, but this overall journey for me is about becoming healthy, fit, and being able to maintain a weight that is comfortable to me and where my body seems to feel comfortable. Plus, thinking of a weight that would make me "skinny" is a lot farther to go than my goal weight at this point, which will still be overweight. But for now, it's something for me to strive for that I think I will be happy with, and once I get there, who knows where I'll go!0
-
I think it is realative. I'm 5'1 and since I have been 18 I've been every weight from 220-down to 95...I personally look best at a trim/toned 150-130 below 130 and I start looking sick, even though that is considered a healthy weight for me..below 120 and I start just looking imo gross...To me its all about your own personal image.0
-
I want to look like the chicks on star trek. what the crap happened to that figure anyway? the hourglass gals use to be everywhere! did they give to many away before this gen came and we are just sol? i blame microwaves.
thats ok, when I'm rich I'll buy bigger boobs.
8% of the female population is a true hourglass. Back in the 1950s and 1960s, women wore corsets to achieve that look.
Watch Mad Men. January Jones looks like an hourglass when she's in Betty Draper costume, but if you look at photos of her on the Net, she is not an hourglass. She looks great, but her waist is not that small in proportion to her hips without the corset.0 -
When I say I don't want to be too skinny, it means I don't want my ribs poking out so clearly you can see them easily, my stomache isn't going in, My hip bones aren't jutting out, etc. It's definitely not a lazy thing for me. My real goal that I want to be at is 135. But I'm going to try for 120 because I want to see what that looks on me, and it's the lower end of what I should be at. Once I get there I might decide that no, I need to put a bit of fat back on, or at least muscle. But I will see once I get down to that weight. I might even decide to go a bit lower, it will depend on what I look like when I get there. 0
-
It only means that you're not really curvy & what you had are just rolls of fat. What I mean is that a real curvy woman won't lose her curves even after she loses weight. Unfortunately many people don't understand it.
I hate it when people give out the wrong definition of "curves". No matter how much you weigh, your curves will stay the same. If you're an hourglass then it will stay the same whether you're fat or thin. Its not about the weight but its how you built.I dont think its an excuss. I think people (women in general) look better with some weight on them (curves). It don't have to be alot of weight. But being too skinny is not attractive.
Rolls of FAT =/= CURVY
Not so cut and dry. Right now I have hips and boobs that add curve and shape to my body. The smaller size I get the smaller my cup size and a surprise to me and people who always knew me with curvy hips, I actually have a more "up and down" look to my hips. Not curvy at all.
Having fat on your hips and boobs are "rolls of fat'?0 -
It only means that you're not really curvy & what you had are just rolls of fat. What I mean is that a real curvy woman won't lose her curves even after she loses weight. Unfortunately many people don't understand it.
I hate it when people give out the wrong definition of "curves". No matter how much you weigh, your curves will stay the same. If you're an hourglass then it will stay the same whether you're fat or thin. Its not about the weight but its how you built.I dont think its an excuss. I think people (women in general) look better with some weight on them (curves). It don't have to be alot of weight. But being too skinny is not attractive.
Rolls of FAT =/= CURVY
Not so cut and dry. Right now I have hips and boobs that add curve and shape to my body. The smaller size I get the smaller my cup size and a surprise to me and people who always knew me with curvy hips, I actually have a more "up and down" look to my hips. Not curvy at all.
Having hips and boobs are "rolls of fat'?
I know, right? I will keep my "rolls of fat" then, because I LIKE hips and boobs. Mmmmmmmmm, boobs
0 -
I really think that a good part of this is observation of "normal". I live in a midwestern (USA) college town. When I go to the university rec center (The Gym), the average person there appears to be healthy and moderately to extensively muscular. When I go into town or the student commons, the average person has little to no muscular definition and has excess body fat. I am still 30 pounds over my goal weight which would just barely take me out of the "Overweight" BMI category. Friends of mine have told me that losing another 30 pounds is stupid and that I would look like a famine survivor. Whats really happening is that I am being compared to the average appearance of the area - Given the large "Jiggle Factor" of the populace, I would appear to be a starving street rat. This is a sad state of affairs where obese and unhealthy is the norm. I believe that BMI is a good rough estimate of appropriate body weight ideals as long as there is a decent amount of lean muscle in the composition. Sleek is good. Muffin Top is not...0
-
I've never been "fat" (I was on the borderline of overweight when I decided to do something about it). However, when I was in high school, I was healthy, energetic--and 117 pounds at 5'4". That was fine then, but I would never want to be that skinny now. I have no doubt that I could achieve it again, but looking back at myself, I looked like a little girl. No curves, no muscles... easily blown away in a gust of wind. I think I was pretty then, but it would not be pretty on the me that I am now.
So when I say I don't want to be too skinny, I'm saying that I want to be strong and healthy, whatever that implies--not lose weight simply to lose weight.0 -
What I would consider too thin.
I think both ladies are healthy and they both look great, I just like the first one better. I don't really have any explanation for it beyond preference. *shrug*
I can't view the second picture at work, but the lady on the top picture is too skinny in my opinion.
"The lady"?! THAT'S SHAKIRA.
Who the f** is Shakira? I doubt that she's an athlete.
She is a singer and she also dance a lot. She does awsome belly dance. SHe is actually very active.
Ahh...that explains it. No wonder I never heard of her. I'm not into belly dancing.
0 -
What I would consider too thin.
I think both ladies are healthy and they both look great, I just like the first one better. I don't really have any explanation for it beyond preference. *shrug*
I can't view the second picture at work, but the lady on the top picture is too skinny in my opinion.
"The lady"?! THAT'S SHAKIRA.
Who the f** is Shakira? I doubt that she's an athlete.
She is a singer and she also dance a lot. She does awsome belly dance. SHe is actually very active.
Ahh...that explains it. No wonder I never heard of her. I'm not into belly dancing.
She's a well-known singer, too. I doubt you have never heard her songs.0 -
For me, saying I don't want to be "too thin" is just that. I've been "too thin". I started out at 300 lbs and lost down to 115, and a size 0/2. I believed there was no such thing as too thin, or too rich. :-) My doctors reinforced that by saying the exact phrasing I just used. But you know what happened? I could see my ribs and the bones in chest. I had no butt. I couldn't lay on my side on the bed because my hip bones pressing into the mattress hurt. My estrogen levels dropped so much that I started having night sweats, just like I was going through menopause. I was exhausted all the time and passing out at 8pm on the couch. My hair started falling out. My periods disappeared. My triglycerides went up.
For me, now, that is TOO thin. I've managed to gain a healthy weight back and am now a size 6. I'm working on getting stronger. I still have that "last" five pounds I want to get off, but for me, I think I have to realize that I'll ALWAYS want to lose another 5, and I have to be careful.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions