I only eat dinner...good or bad?
Replies
-
..................1200 net then there is no way to get that in 1 meal.........
I can most easily get 1,200 calories in one sitting, which is primarily why I'm here...I used to get around 1,000 + calories per meal 3x daily.
OP...my body burns 1,880 calories if I'm doing nothing...literally, if I was in a coma my body would burn 1,880 calories and the doctors would feed me that through a tube. So long as you are meeting your net calorie goal for the day and not miserable eating only once per day, I don't see a problem. At 1,880 calories per day that means I burn 78.34 calories per hour on average...or 1.31 calories per minute...I don't think my metabolism cares or knows what time it is when I eat...it's going to burn 1,880 calories regardless of whether I eat once per day or 5 times per day.
Personally, I couldn't do it...I'm a 5x per day eater now, otherwise I tend to binge and/or overfill my plate at meal times.0 -
When you don't eat all day, your body thinks you're starving so it goes into fat storage mode. I don't like to eat breakfast either so I started drinking a protein shake and now it's routine. Food first thing kickstarts your metabolism for the day.
Exactly what she said!!! It is horrible, I know because that is what I use to do. Eat ONE meal a day is the worse thing you can do for yourself. It is a struggle to get in the habit of eating more. Just prepackage some snacks atleast to start.0 -
Some days I'll have six meals, sometimes I'll have two. It depends on my schedule, how I'm feeling, etc. As long as I meet all my daily goals, I don't care. Some days I don't even have a "meal", just like 8 snacks. Mmm, snacks.0
-
As long as your diet is nutritionally sound, you are getting a minimum of 1200 k/cal, and you aren't tempted to reduce your intake further, you should be fine.0
-
When you don't eat all day, your body thinks you're starving so it goes into fat storage mode. I don't like to eat breakfast either so I started drinking a protein shake and now it's routine. Food first thing kickstarts your metabolism for the day.
Exactly what she said!!! It is horrible, I know because that is what I use to do. Eat ONE meal a day is the worse thing you can do for yourself. It is a struggle to get in the habit of eating more. Just prepackage some snacks atleast to start.
Eating once a day is only bad if you either snack because you are only eating once or fill that meal with too much crap.
Your metabolism doesn't need to be kickstarted. It is constantly working all day, all night regardless... unless you go days without giving it enough food.0 -
When you don't eat all day, your body thinks you're starving so it goes into fat storage mode. I don't like to eat breakfast either so I started drinking a protein shake and now it's routine. Food first thing kickstarts your metabolism for the day.
Exactly what she said!!! It is horrible, I know because that is what I use to do. Eat ONE meal a day is the worse thing you can do for yourself. It is a struggle to get in the habit of eating more. Just prepackage some snacks atleast to start.
No....just no! It's not "Exactly what she said"!!! That information is incorrect!!!!! It is all about personal preference and lifestyle! Meal timing is of no importance!0 -
When you don't eat all day, your body thinks you're starving so it goes into fat storage mode. I don't like to eat breakfast either so I started drinking a protein shake and now it's routine. Food first thing kickstarts your metabolism for the day.
It takes 72 hours of not eating for the body to even consider it's in starvation.
exactly. i really wish people would stop repeating bad information. You will be fine.0 -
it really depends on how you distribute your calorie intake for the day. if you've already consumed your intake for the day then definitely you will be forced not to eat dinner.
best practice probably is to head start and plan your meal for the day. by then, you'll get a visualizatiion of what you will consume and edit them as the day goes by. apples, boiled eggs are some of the food i take and makes me feel full and with very minimal calories.
avoid bread, rice and other carbs so you can play better with your calorie intake.0 -
when you are asleep, you metabolism is resting, so when you wake up it needs to be fed so that it can work for you. Not eating breakfast isn't terrible, but only eating 1200 calories at one time? Not good at all. Think about it, your metabolism is slow to no all day because it does not have what it needs and then suddenly you not only feed it, you knock it down with a big meal and then you expect it to work efficiently to burn the calories and not store fat after you've starved it all day long. Then, you're going to go work out and tax your body even more; after eating you need a lot of energy to digest your meal, especially a big one. Doing a work out you are calling on your boy to send energy to the muscles--can you see how that can be a problem? But then again if it's working for you, it's your choice.0
-
I have eaten like this for last 2 years and lost 4 stone, just joined here for some motivation to get last stone and a bit off. I find if i eat breakfast im starving by 11am and cranky and then keep on eating, while fasting till 4pm during the day food is the last thing on my mind. I have a meal when i get in and a piece of fruit if needed in the evening, it works for me. food during the day makes me sluggish and bloated. Its whatever works for your body. Just dont take away my coffee!!0
-
I haven't weighed myself in over a week but yes, I've lost about 15 pounds since August. I don't really keep track of when I eat breakfast and when I don't but lately I haven't been eating til dinner. I guess I'm just worried that if I eat during the day I'll be so hungry at night that I'll just pig out. Losing weight in college is seriously harder than it sounds because everything is buffet styled and I have terrible foods to choose from. Thankfully, I've mostly managed to stay away from the bad stuff. Also...if you don't allow yourself to eat at least some foods that you like once in a while, you're more likely to cheat and binge. this isn't scientific, it's common sense. So when I only eat dinner I feel better knowing that if I happen to eat something that's less than completely healthy, as long as I'm under 1200 calories for the day then I don't hate myself for it. I'm sure a lot of people losing weight have a problem with feeling guilty no matter what they eat. Well that's me.
If you eat the correct things during the day, you won't feel like your starving by dinner. Protein keeps you full. If you try eating something during the day I would suggest portable protein snacks like nuts or protein bars. Not eating all day won't put your body into starvation but it does keep your metabolism lower. If you want to raise your metabolism then you need to eat every few hours.0 -
I am trying to loose 25 pounds. And For that I have to eat 1200 calories and same with me, when I eat a healthy food all throughout the day, I just get of them and want to eat tasty food, and the next morn I hv no energy to run my *kitten* off. So I decided to eat only dinner. The next morning I have so much energy to do stuff, and I feel lighter and awesome and not worry about my weight gain or food.0
-
What do you eat if you're eating 1200 calories in one sitting? I'm not trying to be snarky or rude, I'm just genuinely curious to what a 1200 meal for you consists of.0
-
I kind of wish I could still eat 1200 calories all at once. But, that was so 2011. Anyway, I don't think it's bad to do that. I just can't anymore because I have been gradually changing what I eat over the last couple of years and now it's drastically different. It's easy for me to eat that many calories in bread and cheese (pizza) or whatever. But, now I eat a lot of foods that are high in fiber, I am pushing it to eat 700 in a meal.
So, if it works for you I am rooting for you. Whatever works as long as it fits your macros. But, if it does stop working then I wouldn't make a drastic change. Maybe have one smallish meal in the day and save 900 for whatever meal you need to feel the most full.0 -
What do you eat if you're eating 1200 calories in one sitting? I'm not trying to be snarky or rude, I'm just genuinely curious to what a 1200 meal for you consists of.
I also want to know. I get SO full even eating 500 calories of proteins, carbs and healthy fat in 1 meal, let alone 1,200. I don't see how you can eat a healthy balanced meal in 1 sitting that is 1,200 cals.0 -
I can eat way more that 1200 calories of HEALTHY FOOD at once.0
-
Maybe if you can't eat in the morning/afternoon make yourself a great fruit smoothie/skimmed-milk shake?
That might help avoid putting your body into starvation and may help speed up your metabolism.0 -
You don't need to eat breakfast to kick start your metabolism. That's Just what the breakfast cereal companies want you to believe. If you eat your calories and hit your macros in one sitting, you don't find yourself hungry then you have nothing to worry about.
I never eat breakfast anymore. I eat all of my calories in an 8 hour window more or less, I have tons of energy. I'm getting stronger at the gym and I'm losing weight at 1.5 to 2.5 pounds a weak.
I don't know when I've ever felt better in my life.
This is all pretty much correct. I eat 1-2 meals a day, and when I do eat 2 they're about 4-5 hours apart, depending on what time I get off work. I'm losing about 4 pounds a week now that I've started IPOARM, simply by watching my calorie intake.0 -
I joined this site just to respond to this topic. I've lost 30 pounds and kept it off for years by waiting until the late afternoon to start eating. My experience is just like Annemarie's a few posts above this. It took me about a week to get used to not eating in the day. Then after about a month, I wasn't eating as much in the evening, probably due to my shrinking belly. For me it works GANGBUSTERS, and I never feel deprived.
https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10151311850825988&set=pb.521610987.-2207520000.1368034725.&type=3&theater0 -
0
-
You don't need to eat breakfast to kick start your metabolism. That's Just what the breakfast cereal companies want you to believe. If you eat your calories and hit your macros in one sitting, you don't find yourself hungry then you have nothing to worry about.
I never eat breakfast anymore. I eat all of my calories in an 8 hour window more or less, I have tons of energy. I'm getting stronger at the gym and I'm losing weight at 1.5 to 2.5 pounds a weak.
I don't know when I've ever felt better in my life.
^^ He is absolutely right luv. Losing weight and being healthy starts with the mind. If you are happy and are in a healthy plan you can stick with and not feel deprived then keep at it. I lost over a 100 lbs and kept over 100 of it off even two years later. I change things up frequently and am very happy. It has to do with cals in vs cals out and make sure your are feeding your body properly so it doesn't feel deprived and start storing. good luck and keep it healthy :flowerforyou:0 -
If you get your calories and macros in one sitting it's fine. Your body can handle not eating for 23 hours just fine. It won't go into stravation mode, because it is not starving. If you don't get your calories for a few days, then you start starvation.0
-
Nothing wrong with one meal a day. Alot of the fasts are like that. I would eat my meal earlier in the day tho. Like lunch or in between lunch and dinner.0
-
Many people do it, it's called intermittent fasting. Just be sure your body is getting enough protein and you'll be fine. Your body can only process about 20-30 grams of protein an hour, maybe if you could break dinner up into two meals and a snack spread over 4 hours, that would be great.
But if eating during dinner hours is working for you, why on earth would you stop? No body loses weight the same, nobody gains weight the same, so why do people believe that the approach to weight loss has to be the same?0 -
I eat breakfast after a day when I've lifted hard or otherwise exerted myself significantly. Otherwise, I don't eat until noon.
I've lost 26 lbs so far, feel great, Dr says things are great and to not change a thing, and I'm getting significantly stronger lifting (have gone from repping 225 three times when I started this to seven times, just last night, for instance. Doesn't seem like I'm losing any muscle to speak of).
Now, obviously the details of everything else determine whether you'll have success or not (deficits, macros, etc), but how often you eat is not a factor at all, for me. Sometimes I eat 4 or 5 times a day, sometimes 2. Just depends on the day and my needs. I eat more often near heavy workouts than resting days.
A lot depends on how well your hunger is controlled and I think that varies a ton for a particular eating plan between people. Agree with the poster who made the point to be sure you're getting plenty of protein - that's a major point for me. But make no mistake, I'm not on Atkins and haven't counted the first carb. They are naturally limited to some extent just by virtue of having a caloric deficit and being vigilant to have enough protein, but I definitely don't count them per se.0 -
Now that's the OP has reduced her calories to the 800 level, one meal a day and is too busy to eat, is an ideal formula considering she at 1400 calories ate 2 meals.....yup makes perfect sense.0
-
Eating one meal a day isn't good or bad...its just the way you eat. Intermittent Fasting is what you're doing and it isn't for everyone. Some people like grazing all day and feel better doing it. I for sure hate grazing. I would do that and always felt hungry and lethargic and was more likely to opt for poor food choices. I have been eating one square meal a day and don't feel hungry all the time, I don't have cravings throughout the day, and feel more alert. I do get sleepy after my meal but I eat late by conventional standards. I feel "Thanksgiving full" and want to go into a food coma. 7:30pm-9:30pm is my feeding window. IF is great for fat loss because you allow your body to burn energy from your glycogen stores (fat) before burning energy from the food you just ate. I have read numerous articles supporting Intermittent Fasting for not just weight loss but, Longevity, better health, and just good ol' convenience.
weather you decide to eat 6 meals a day or 1 meal a day, just make sure your calories are coming from good whole food sources and not empty calories. Pretty basic.0 -
Let your own body tell you what its comfort level is. I f you listen to all the "experts" out there you will make your self crazy. For every guideline, theory, and suggestion they propose, another school of thought comes along comes along and totally contradicts everything the first group said.
I don't care what anybody tells me, if I'm not hungry at a particular time of day, I'm not going force myself to eat-Period! I will also not allow any diet "guru" to dictate what I eat. We all realize that an egg white omelet with veggies or a bowl of steel cut oatmeal with berries and walnuts is healthier than a huge white flour bagel smothered with cream cheese. But how long is a diet going to last if I'm just eating what I believe is healthy and avoiding all the foods I really love and desire? What's the point? It won't be long before I miss my favorite foods so much I'll be ready to eat Brooklyn.
So my point is that it may be better to eat when we are truly hungry and to eat what we truly like in moderation until we satisfy that junger. Each and every time I've tried a very low carb diet I failed miserably and wound up bingeing on everything in sight when I went off it. But when I started having a bagel with peanut butter in the morning, I loved my diet. I looked forward to getting up in the morning, and I actually enjoyed my protein and veggie lunches and dinners. I went on to lose a great deal of weight and kept it off.0 -
"Kickstarting metabolism" is a myth. Eat when you want. your body doesn't really care what the clock says.0
-
Now that's the OP has reduced her calories to the 800 level, one meal a day and is too busy to eat, is an ideal formula considering she at 1400 calories ate 2 meals.....yup makes perfect sense.
800 calories?
Ok, OP, eat when you want, but friggin' EAT!!!!!!!!! 800 calories is a enough for an infant, maybe, not an adult.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions