We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!
How do you explain death to a child?
Replies
-
Tell him he's not gonna die and you're not either. He's 3.0
-
My parents bought me a goldfish and had me watch Old Yeller.
I'm still traumatized.
This explains so much!!0 -
Isn't that completely normal? I know I'm extremely young and have no experience as a mother but I went through this exact same thing as a child....nothing brings it on. I thought everyone goes through this? Isn't it a just a phase of understanding what death is? As a child you are innocent and completely ignorant to the bad things in the world. The only pain and sorrow you know is bedtime and you're hungry etc. but as you get older and start to realize that life is precious even at a young age with insects and animals....you just start to think. Mine didn't happen that early but as you say he is very bright and I'm assuming his brain just clicked early.
Hope this put your mind at ease a bit.
this part seems important to me in your planned response. don't try to analyze where it "came from" just try to handle it. you've gotten lots of great ideas here from beleivers and non, so i think you have enough to work with. the listed outline was also great for keeping you on track. good luck. (just whatever you do don't say it's like sleeping; the person who said bedtimes will suffer was right.)0 -
My son's father died two & a half years ago and my son was only 6 years old at the time. It was an extremely hard experience for him and me both. I told him that I believed his dad was always watching over him and that he had the best guardian angel ever (however....this may not work for you because of your beliefs). I remember the whole idea of death bothering me so bad as a child and I worried so much about losing my parents and they just never told me anything to make me at peace at all. I worried constantly. Im my mind, children should have to worry about stuff like that. He honestly seems so at peace with death now. He even asked me one day if I would be his gaurdian angel when I died too, just like his dad is. It kind of shocked me for a minute because of the fact that I couldn't even talk about stuff like that when I was his age. Of course I just smiled and gave him the biggest hug and said, of course I will buddy.0
-
You know, I can remember having a conversation with my daughter in the 7th grade (not that long ago) about death and the finality of life and she still freaked out.
Death is a heavy and difficult conversation for a parent at any age of the child.0 -
You have gotten a lot of good advice...I agree with the main points of "keep it simple" and say what you're comfortable saying. I'm sending a link to Mr. Rogers (you may be too young to know who he was) website. I think you'll find it helpful as well.
http://www.fredrogers.org/FRC/par-death.html0 -
. I told him we're not going to die for a very long time and that he doesn't need to worry, but I'm not satisfied with that answer. He asked me again last night when we were going to die, so I know this topic is going to come up again soon.
You're right not to be satisfied with that answer, when I was a kid I had a really similar conversation with my mum, and really, that answer did not help at all. It's still going to happen sooner or later, "not for a very long time" doesn't cut it, and 70+ years isn't something a 3 yr old can imagine. a week is "a very long time" for a 3 yr old...
Ask him what he thinks will happen when a person dies. I was really scared of dying when I was a little kid, because I couldn't conceive of consciousness ending. I was told that you die, your body shuts down, your senses don't work and you get buried in the ground... I visualised that as being trapped in a totally lifeless, senseless body, unable to move. My parents didn't want to discuss any of this in depth with me (I think they were totally uncomfortable with it to be honest), so nothing they said really helped to alleviate my fear. If you start with what he thinks will happen, then you may find he's misunderstood something and that misunderstanding is making him anxious, not the idea of actually dying.
I think you need to give some answers.... even if you tell him a whole range of different afterlife beliefs from different cultures and ask him what he believes, rather than you saying "you just die" (this is meaningless to a child who doesn't really understand what "die" means, and may not be able to conceive of consciousness ending). Let him find his own way of understanding it, even if it isn't what you believe. As he gets older he'll change his beliefs, because you're allowing him to hold his own beliefs, not forcing yours upon him. He'll grow up and learn more as he gets older, and come to a more mature understanding of death in his own time. In the meantime, just help him to not be fearful about it.0 -
http://www.steventrapp.com/dragonfly-story.htm
This poem/story definitely has some religious undertones (or even overtones) but when I was little I found that the imagery helped after my dad died. Granted I was 10 so I understood death at least as well as any ten year old could but I found comfort in the way the poem present death..0 -
Tell him he's not gonna die and you're not either. He's 3.
I don't lie to him. I don't always give him the cold, ugly truth about things and I do make my answers age appropriate, but I wouldn't tell him something that simply is not true.0 -
this is just beautiful. thank you. i may be pushing 30 but i still have fears of death myself...and no kiddies yet...so this gives me not only a perspective for future kiddos but for myself as well. xoxoxoxo.
i'm glad you were helped by this and am proud the author is on my FL. one word of caution though, with a young child as yours you will need to be brief and hit the highlights of whatever answer you choose. I like Be-leakings answer the best so far for your particular situation and age of your child. simple, to the point, honest, and redirects.0 -
I don't have kids, but I have quite a few young ones around that belong to other people, and I've found that they usually have anxiety like this when they get "Grandma went to sleep and isn't going to wake up." They develop anxiety then about going to sleep because sleep now = never waking up. Kids so easily misconstrue things, and they're so literal, it could've been almost anything that triggered it, and he may not have realized he was making the association with anything or couldn't verbalize it. Best to just be honest and talk to him in simple terms that can't be twisted into anything terrifying.0
-
I think it's kind of like the T.V. breaking. The shows are still happening, but you can't see them. All you see is the silent shell of what T.V. is.
Since physics says that energy cannot be created or destroyed, it only changes form; it seems to fit, but in a very simplistic way that even a child can follow.0 -
He even asked me one day if I would be his gaurdian angel when I died too, just like his dad is. It kind of shocked me for a minute because of the fact that I couldn't even talk about stuff like that when I was his age. Of course I just smiled and gave him the biggest hug and said, of course I will buddy.
Awww, tears!!0 -
I don't want to. I'd love to go through life without thinking or worrying about death, but I do. It's just how I'm programmed I guess. I'm overly compassionate and I hurt for people that lose loved ones that I don't even know. I know it's inevitable, but it's still my biggest fear, especially now that I have a child of my own.
maybe you should explore religions and their beleifs about death. it sounds like you are living with more fear than you should. one of the explanations should resonate with you and may offer you some peace of mind, for yourself. then this calm can be relayed onto your child maybe.0 -
I do not remember this at all, but my dad died when I was 2, I guess every time we drove by the funeral home I kept telling my mom that daddy was in there and we should get him. She called the funeral home and he said she could bring me in so I could "look" for my dad. I guess I went into the room where he was for the visitation and saw he wasn't there and left and after that I never brought him up again.
I guess that helped me when I was 2. But like I said I don't remember him or that at all.
The death I remember the most when I was young was my Grandma, she had died when I was 7, but from losing pets I knew when someone or something died, they never came back so to speak.
I would just reassure him that he will have many years and he should enjoy them. Death isn't meant to be scarey, its almost like a new beginning...0 -
You have gotten a lot of good advice...I agree with the main points of "keep it simple" and say what you're comfortable saying. I'm sending a link to Mr. Rogers (you may be too young to know who he was) website. I think you'll find it helpful as well.
http://www.fredrogers.org/FRC/par-death.html
Watched him as a kidthanks!
0 -
I think it's kind of like the T.V. breaking. The shows are still happening, but you can't see them. All you see is the silent shell of what T.V. is.
Since physics says that energy cannot be created or destroyed, it only changes form; it seems to fit, but in a very simplistic way that even a child can follow.
Ooh! I can't wait to say this the next time I'm at church for a wedding or funeral.0 -
0
-
I don't have children of my own but last semester, I took a course on Death and Bereavement for school. Our Professor's focus was on working with children who were experiencing a loss (grieving a parent, sibling, grandparent, friend, etc.). And the one point he put forth over and over and over was that we need to be honest with the child. He actually advocated not using any religious explanations but rather discussing the science and giving factual statements rather than statements of beliefs. He said that most children tend to be very curious about it and interested in the scientific aspects. I guess I would suggest telling your child to ask any questions they want and that you'll answer them as truthfully as you can. There are also a lot of books about death that don't necessarily rely on religion/belief systems to explain death to children so perhaps getting one of those as a means of discussing the subject with your child would help. Anyway, hope that helps if even in the slightest bit!0
-
There is a children's book, "The Fall of Freddie the Leaf," that demonstrates the life cycle by using the seasons and the changes the leaf makes before falling off the tree and dying in the fall. At 3 1/2 I'm not sure he'll get it but it is worth a try. I have used this book in grief counseling with adults. My Chaplain friend has had great experiences using this with children. Best wishes!0
-
I think an honest, but not BRUTALLY honest approach, is the best way to handle it. As long as you assure the child that they are in no danger of dying, I believe teaching them about death is a great thing. Death sucks. First time my son saw me cry was 2 years ago when my dog of 11 years died. I think it taught him LOTS of lessons of how to handle himself if/when death becomes a part of his life someday.0
-
"The Origin of Species" is not an atheist bible so no I would not quote Darwin. I realize you weren't being serious you were just mocking me because I disagreed with you and you don't think there is anything an atheist could say to a child in this situation.
There are a ton of reasons why an atheist should not do as you suggest. Without going into too much detail and in an effort to avoid offending anyone I will attempt to explain with a brief look at why.
If the child were to continue asking questions as children often do the atheist could be hit with a few whoppers really fast.
Where is Heaven?
What is Heaven?
Why Heaven and not some place else?
Does everyone go to Heaven?
Is my dog in Heaven?
If I am not comfortable with lying about Heaven I am definitely not comfortable with lying about Hell. The punitive system of reward and punishment that is outlined in religion basically has Heaven as the carrot and Hell as the stick. For those that believe in this and see it as a good thing there is nothing wrong with that I won't tell another parent how to raise their kid. But as for someone who does not care to pick up the baggage of explaining what Heaven and Hell are to their own child I would think it is not advisable to open that can of worms.0 -
i'm glad you were helped by this and am proud the author is on my FL. one word of caution though, with a young child as yours you will need to be brief and hit the highlights of whatever answer you choose. I like Be-leakings answer the best so far for your particular situation and age of your child. simple, to the point, honest, and redirects.
FYI: i don't have kids. i was talking about how it was helpful to ME...as i'm still somewhat afraid of death. and how it will be helpful in the future as well. yes, i agree--lea's answer about living in the hearts of her child/ren is also to the point without saying anything too descriptive (of either extreme).0 -
I don't have children of my own but last semester, I took a course on Death and Bereavement for school. Our Professor's focus was on working with children who were experiencing a loss (grieving a parent, sibling, grandparent, friend, etc.). And the one point he put forth over and over and over was that we need to be honest with the child. He actually advocated not using any religious explanations but rather discussing the science and giving factual statements rather than statements of beliefs. He said that most children tend to be very curious about it and interested in the scientific aspects. I guess I would suggest telling your child to ask any questions they want and that you'll answer them as truthfully as you can. There are also a lot of books about death that don't necessarily rely on religion/belief systems to explain death to children so perhaps getting one of those as a means of discussing the subject with your child would help. Anyway, hope that helps if even in the slightest bit!
It does! He asks questions constantly and as much as I'd like to say "I don't know!" I don't brush him off and I always answer his questions honestly. That's how they learn, and I love how curious he is.0 -
I do not agree with this answer, no offence to the poster.
I think for a very small child they need to have some answers and reassurance from the parents/carers.
The children will cope better in life if they get answers with choices/options to questions that you may not even know the answer to?
Saying you `do not know` is not reassuring and could cause anxiety.
So the options are saying "I don't know", or making something - anything - up, as long as it is reassuring?
I go for the honesty route myself. If I don't know the answer to a question (any question) from one of my kids, I'll say "I don't know... but how about we look it up?" or "I don't know, but here is what I think...". I'm an atheist, and I don't believe in an afterlife. When this came up with my kids, I used the Circle of Life, as well as "we are made of star stuff".
But just because you are being honest with your kids, it doesn't mean you have to do it a heartless or cold way. Tell them and show them that you love them, and promise that you'll be there for as long as you can, and you plan on it being a very long time.0 -
I think an honest, but not BRUTALLY honest approach, is the best way to handle it. As long as you assure the child that they are in no danger of dying, I believe teaching them about death is a great thing. Death sucks. First time my son saw me cry was 2 years ago when my dog of 11 years died. I think it taught him LOTS of lessons of how to handle himself if/when death becomes a part of his life someday.
I agree 100%!0 -
this is just beautiful. thank you. i may be pushing 30 but i still have fears of death myself...and no kiddies yet...so this gives me not only a perspective for future kiddos but for myself as well. xoxoxoxo.
Oh, thank you!!!
Also, my kids are 6 and almost 9. And they ask a lot of questions, so this was not one big conversation, but a quick summary of many conversations and still many more to go.
And another explanation about why we should not live in fear is because what if the thing we fear never happens, then we will have lived our whole life fearing something that never happened. When bad things happen we will rise to the occasion and deal with it, but it's better to enjoy our lives and enjoy the people that are in our lives.0 -
FYI: i don't have kids. i was talking about how it was helpful to ME...as i'm still somewhat afraid of death. and how it will be helpful in the future as well. yes, i agree--lea's answer about living in the hearts of her child/ren is also to the point without saying anything too descriptive (of either extreme).
oops my mistake i was still thinking of OP's young child when I wrote the words of caution part.0 -
Oh, thank you!!!
Also, my kids are 6 and almost 9. And they ask a lot of questions, so this was not one big conversation, but a quick summary of many conversations and still many more to go.
as I suspected. This BTW is the best way to handle all the heavy topics of parenting.0 -
I don't lie to him. I don't always give him the cold, ugly truth about things and I do make my answers age appropriate, but I wouldn't tell him something that simply is not true.
Do you tell him Santa, the Tooth Fairy, etc isn't real?0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 394.6K Introduce Yourself
- 44K Getting Started
- 260.5K Health and Weight Loss
- 176.1K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.7K Fitness and Exercise
- 444 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153.1K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 4.1K MyFitnessPal Information
- 16 News and Announcements
- 1.3K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.8K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions