settings~2lb per week weight loss
JagerLewis
Posts: 427 Member
In my settings, it asks how much I'd like to lose a week. I checked the box of 2lbs a week. Though it will only give me a "projected weight loss" of 1.4lbs per week. How can I change this??? If I wanted to lose 1.5lbs a week, I would have checked that box. :noway: My calorie goal is set at 1200 so I don't really think I should go lower. Any advice would be appreciated!!
0
Replies
-
Go back into your settings and change it to 1 lb a week, a more realistic goal for you.0
-
Thank you. I figured if mfp has all of my info (weight, activity, goals, etc.) They wouldn't give "unrealistic goals" I'm not going to scale back if I only lose 1-2lbs a week now..I'd freak out if I get to a stand still!In order to make a calorie deficit of 1000 calories per day (necessary for a two pound per week weight loss), MFP would have to recommend a calorie amount lower than 1200, which it will not do because it is difficult to get adequate nutrients and preserve muscle mass on a caloric intake that low. You are choosing too aggressive a weight loss for your needs (not wants, needs). The reason the option is there to choose a more aggressive weight loss is because there are people who are actually overweight or obese, and it may be healthy for them to lose so aggressively.
Thus, you are correct. You shouldn't go any lower. There's nothing to "change" unless you scale it back to 1 pound a week, which is a decent idea (alhtough I do sympathize, you are not the only person who wants the weight gone NOW).
0 -
2 lbs is very realistic for me. Not sure why you think it's not.Go back into your settings and change it to 1 lb a week, a more realistic goal for you.0 -
2 lbs is very realistic for me. Not sure why you think it's not.Go back into your settings and change it to 1 lb a week, a more realistic goal for you.
because you don't have more than 75 lbs to lose.0 -
I wasn't aware anyone could see my current weight! Maybe it's ESP...Hmm....
2 lbs is very realistic for me. Not sure why you think it's not.Go back into your settings and change it to 1 lb a week, a more realistic goal for you.
because you don't have more than 75 lbs to lose.0 -
2 lbs is very realistic for me. Not sure why you think it's not.Go back into your settings and change it to 1 lb a week, a more realistic goal for you.
Because it isn't. With the amount of weight you have to lose, you don't want to create too large a calorie deficit. As you've seen, you can't eat 800 a day!0 -
your ticker says 56? :ohwell:0
-
If that is a current photo of you then you don't have much to lose (take that as the compliment it is meant to be). So losing 2 lbs a week is only unrealistic in the fact that to lose 2 lbs a week you would not get enough calories. Hope that makes sense. We all have the same struggles whether you have 5 lbs to lose or 100. Good luck to you!0
-
My ticker is set as how many lbs lost....Not set at a goal.your ticker says 56? :ohwell:0 -
Thank you...but this is a photo when I started putting weight on..a little over a year ago. .I want to get to that and smaller.If that is a current photo of you then you don't have much to lose (take that as the compliment it is meant to be). So losing 2 lbs a week is only unrealistic in the fact that to lose 2 lbs a week you would not get enough calories. Hope that makes sense. We all have the same struggles whether you have 5 lbs to lose or 100. Good luck to you!0 -
Your ticker says 10 pounds lost with a goal of 56.0
-
My ticker is set as how many lbs lost....Not set at a goal.your ticker says 56? :ohwell:
Actually, your ticker says 10 lb lost with a total goal of 56 lbs. Which means you have 46lbs left to lose until you get to the goal you entered.
If you want to be all snarky about the advice you're getting, that's fine. You can manually set your goal to whatever cals you want and let us know how it goes.0 -
Your ticker says 10 pounds lost with a goal of 56.
It does not say goal..I have it set so no one can see my weight at any point. It just shows how many lbs lost.The ticker doesn't know if I have 10, 50, or 100 lbs to lose.....It just shows progress.0 -
Your ticker says 10 pounds lost with a goal of 56.
It does not say goal..I have it set so no one can see my weight at any point. It just shows how many lbs lost.The ticker doesn't know if I have 10, 50, or 100 lbs to lose.....It just shows progress.
This is your ticker:
Clearly states 10lbs lost with a goal of 56. Good grief.
ETA: If you want accurate advice when you post these types of threads, providing detailed information is necessary, so it's actually a *good* thing that your ticker shows you have ~46lbs to go (it would actually be helpful to know your actual weight, height, activity level, etc too). I would also agree that 2lbs/week is overly ambitious. Can it be done? Sure. But there's a good chance you're going to be very unhappy in the process, because you will not be feeding your body enough.0 -
Your ticker says 10 pounds lost with a goal of 56.
It does not say goal..I have it set so no one can see my weight at any point. It just shows how many lbs lost.The ticker doesn't know if I have 10, 50, or 100 lbs to lose.....It just shows progress.
during set up, you said you wanted to weigh a certain amount so, your ticker is reflecting the amount of pounds you would need to lose to get to your goal...0 -
CLEARLY does not say goal!!! When I lose 56, the ticker will show more to lose!! Why is everyone so nasty here? It gives MFP a bad rap! :grumble:Your ticker says 10 pounds lost with a goal of 56.
It does not say goal..I have it set so no one can see my weight at any point. It just shows how many lbs lost.The ticker doesn't know if I have 10, 50, or 100 lbs to lose.....It just shows progress.
This is your ticker:
Clearly states 10lbs lost with a goal of 56. Good grief.0 -
Are we the only ones who can see that?? LOLYour ticker says 10 pounds lost with a goal of 56.
It does not say goal..I have it set so no one can see my weight at any point. It just shows how many lbs lost.The ticker doesn't know if I have 10, 50, or 100 lbs to lose.....It just shows progress.
This is your ticker:
Clearly states 10lbs lost with a goal of 56. Good grief.
OP, you're getting some good advice here - you'll stand a much better chance of reaching your goals and keeping the weight off if you go about it the right way. We all want to lose the weight as quickly as possible, but having too aggressive a goal leads to too low a calorie goal, which generally leads to burn out, "falling off the wagon", and yo-yo dieting.
Slow and steady!0 -
CLEARLY does not say goal!!! When I lose 56, the ticker will show more to lose!! Why is everyone so nasty here? It gives MFP a bad rap! :grumble:Your ticker says 10 pounds lost with a goal of 56.
It does not say goal..I have it set so no one can see my weight at any point. It just shows how many lbs lost.The ticker doesn't know if I have 10, 50, or 100 lbs to lose.....It just shows progress.
This is your ticker:
Clearly states 10lbs lost with a goal of 56. Good grief.
The current goal you have set up is to lose 56lbs- which is why it's at the end of your ticker.
In other words, the number at the end of the ticker is the *current* goal you've set. That may not be your ending goal (ie; you may want to lose MORE than 56lbs) but that's not what's showing up currently. Additionally, it will NOT show more to lose unless you manually update your goal.
No one is being nasty- we're trying to explain how the ticker works, and you are choosing to fight us on it.
Looks like you quoted me before I posted my edit on my previous post. I also added this:
"ETA: If you want accurate advice when you post these types of threads, providing detailed information is necessary, so it's actually a *good* thing that your ticker shows you have ~46lbs to go (it would actually be helpful to know your actual weight, height, activity level, etc too). I would also agree that 2lbs/week is overly ambitious. Can it be done? Sure. But there's a good chance you're going to be very unhappy in the process, because you will not be feeding your body enough."
Edited for typo.0 -
Put very simply... Why ask for good advice... and you've been given some very good advice IMO... if you are going to totally disregard it? People on here are trying to help you... flippant replies will not help you... maybe a change in attitude will !!!0
-
The only nastiness I'm seein' is your posts. :flowerforyou:CLEARLY does not say goal!!! When I lose 56, the ticker will show more to lose!! Why is everyone so nasty here? It gives MFP a bad rap! :grumble:
Possible case of the hangries here?0 -
How YOUR ticker is set up is set for a goal. MINE is not. Am I the only bright one here? :huh: I have been doing EVERYTHING right. Nothing MFP hasn't set for me.
Are we the only ones who can see that?? LOLYour ticker says 10 pounds lost with a goal of 56.
It does not say goal..I have it set so no one can see my weight at any point. It just shows how many lbs lost.The ticker doesn't know if I have 10, 50, or 100 lbs to lose.....It just shows progress.
This is your ticker:
Clearly states 10lbs lost with a goal of 56. Good grief.
OP, you're getting some good advice here - you'll stand a much better chance of reaching your goals and keeping the weight off if you go about it the right way. We all want to lose the weight as quickly as possible, but having too aggressive a goal leads to too low a calorie goal, which generally leads to burn out, "falling off the wagon", and yo-yo dieting.
Slow and steady!0 -
CLEARLY does not say goal!!! When I lose 56, the ticker will show more to lose!! Why is everyone so nasty here? It gives MFP a bad rap! :grumble:Your ticker says 10 pounds lost with a goal of 56.
It does not say goal..I have it set so no one can see my weight at any point. It just shows how many lbs lost.The ticker doesn't know if I have 10, 50, or 100 lbs to lose.....It just shows progress.
This is your ticker:
Clearly states 10lbs lost with a goal of 56. Good grief.
If you lie to the Goal Wizard, it's going to give you faulty calories to eat and faulty calories for exercise.
Carry on with your bad self.0 -
How YOUR ticker is set up is set for a goal. MINE is not. Am I the only bright one here? :huh: I have been doing EVERYTHING right. Nothing MFP hasn't set for me.
Are we the only ones who can see that?? LOLYour ticker says 10 pounds lost with a goal of 56.
It does not say goal..I have it set so no one can see my weight at any point. It just shows how many lbs lost.The ticker doesn't know if I have 10, 50, or 100 lbs to lose.....It just shows progress.
This is your ticker:
Clearly states 10lbs lost with a goal of 56. Good grief.
OP, you're getting some good advice here - you'll stand a much better chance of reaching your goals and keeping the weight off if you go about it the right way. We all want to lose the weight as quickly as possible, but having too aggressive a goal leads to too low a calorie goal, which generally leads to burn out, "falling off the wagon", and yo-yo dieting.
Slow and steady!
You realize our tickers are set up in a similar fashion, right? Meaning we BOTH set it up to show how many pounds we've lost so far, on the way to our goal. The only difference is the bottom of my ticker shows weight, whereas yours displays pounds lost.
ETA: You ARE seeing the 56lbs on the bottom right hand corner of your ticker, right? I'm realizing you might be overlooking that part. :flowerforyou:0 -
The numbers on the bottom are based on the goal weight you entered. If I were to change mine to my goal weight lost the last number would say 125lbs, because with a SW of 260lbs - GW of 135lbs = 125lbs. So according to your ticker, you have lost 10lbs and your goal was set to lose 56lbs. It won't change when you reach the 56lbs lost mark unless you lower your goal weight.0
-
ya know? Garbage in...... 0
-
MFP is only as good as the information you give it.
How YOUR ticker is set up is set for a goal. MINE is not. Am I the only bright one here? :huh: I have been doing EVERYTHING right. Nothing MFP hasn't set for me.
Are we the only ones who can see that?? LOLYour ticker says 10 pounds lost with a goal of 56.
It does not say goal..I have it set so no one can see my weight at any point. It just shows how many lbs lost.The ticker doesn't know if I have 10, 50, or 100 lbs to lose.....It just shows progress.
This is your ticker:
Clearly states 10lbs lost with a goal of 56. Good grief.
OP, you're getting some good advice here - you'll stand a much better chance of reaching your goals and keeping the weight off if you go about it the right way. We all want to lose the weight as quickly as possible, but having too aggressive a goal leads to too low a calorie goal, which generally leads to burn out, "falling off the wagon", and yo-yo dieting.
Slow and steady!
And my goodness - why are you so angry?? Have a cookie.
As for the ticker - I'm still going with what I said about 2lbs a week being too aggressive FOR YOUR CURRENT GOAL AS SHOWN ON YOUR BLOODY TICKER THAT WE CAN ALL SEE.
If you want more thorough advice, which I'm guessing you don't based on your previous posts in this topic, give us more info as to what your long term goals are, as well as exercise habits, height, current weight, age, etc.
Otherwise, have a nice day. I think I'mma go have me a cookie. Sheesh.0 -
Isn't it usually best to aim for 1lb a week? I have a lot to lose, but I thought it was healthier to take it slowly. Either way, good luck with you goals.0
-
Came here to offer help.
Saw OPs responses to previous posters offering help
Realized that some people don't know how to accept help
I'm outta here
0 -
I'm right behind ya.Came here to offer help.
Saw OPs responses to previous posters offering help
Realized that some people don't know how to accept help
I'm outta here0 -
CLEARLY does not say goal!!! When I lose 56, the ticker will show more to lose!! Why is everyone so nasty here? It gives MFP a bad rap! :grumble:Your ticker says 10 pounds lost with a goal of 56.
It does not say goal..I have it set so no one can see my weight at any point. It just shows how many lbs lost.The ticker doesn't know if I have 10, 50, or 100 lbs to lose.....It just shows progress.
This is your ticker:
Clearly states 10lbs lost with a goal of 56. Good grief.
If you lie to the Goal Wizard, it's going to give you faulty calories to eat and faulty calories for exercise.
Carry on with your bad self.
This.
Also you clearly don't want my advice, so best of luck with all your health and fitness goals.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions