Any way to lose fat on legs but NOT gain muscle?
Replies
-
Running kept my legs thin, then I switched to cycling which added muscle, as a runner I was called chicken legs.0
-
I made my muscles too long and this happened
Am I the only one that finds this mildly terrifying?0 -
why do people feel the need to be such *kitten*? obviously there's no way to lengthen muscles but i have heard that stretching, yoga, etc can make them appear more toned and "longer" looking but jesus chill out. i understand wanting to trim leg muscles down. not everyone wants big strong legs that certain sports and workouts can create. cracking jokes at others' expense is just stupid. whether its just not written properly or an uneducated response, i hate seeing people get attacked.
someone please, come back and post something obnoxious about this post now.0 -
why do people feel the need to be such *kitten*? obviously there's no way to lengthen muscles but i have heard that stretching, yoga, etc can make them appear more toned and "longer" looking but jesus chill out. i understand wanting to trim leg muscles down. not everyone wants big strong legs that certain sports and workouts can create. cracking jokes at others' expense is just stupid. whether its just not written properly or an uneducated response, i hate seeing people get attacked.
someone please, come back and post something obnoxious about this post now.
You asked...
I'm kidding, but seriously...no workout is going to increase muscle mass, which is what she's concerned with...as long as she's eating on a calorie deficit. No sport either. I understand that some people inject a large amount of sarcasm while saying this...but that's something you have to deal with on the internet. The message is no less valid for it.0 -
why do people feel the need to be such *kitten*? obviously there's no way to lengthen muscles but i have heard that stretching, yoga, etc can make them appear more toned and "longer" looking but jesus chill out. i understand wanting to trim leg muscles down. not everyone wants big strong legs that certain sports and workouts can create. cracking jokes at others' expense is just stupid. whether its just not written properly or an uneducated response, i hate seeing people get attacked.
someone please, come back and post something obnoxious about this post now.
I think you should make your own post to have people do this instead of hijacking the OP's thread to fight with people because yoga doesn't make legs longer. Just saying. :flowerforyou:0 -
There's obviously no way to actually lengthen them, its supposed to create the perception maybe? I didn't come up with it, the ridiculous magazines that plaster yoga throughout them make that claim.0
-
You should want to strengthen the muscle in your legs. If you have a lot of subcutaneous fat on your thighs, chances are that you also have a lot of intramuscular fat as well. A lot of women think they have muscular legs when what they have is a lot of intramuscular fat. Walking isn't going to do anything to get rid of intramuscular fat. High intensity intervals and strength training do that.
Strength training while eating at a minimal to moderate deficit will help you in this regard. Yes, you need to burn fat overall, but strengthen those underlying muscles, and you'll get better results.
I lost 2 inches on my thighs eating at a slight surplus while "gaining" muscle mass. (In quotes because obviously I gained muscle, but I didn't gain inches in my thighs, just stronger, harder muscle with less intramuscular fat.) I also dropped a pants size while gaining 8 pounds.
If this is what you're wanting to do, then you might want to get busy doing intervals and/or lifting heavy stuff while eating at a slight deficit.0 -
I haven't read the comments but you could always get horribly injured and lose the use of your legs, relegating you to a wheelchair for life. Eat a deficit and not only will you slim down, your leg muscles will atrophy into little twigs...
Or...
You could be grateful for the able body you have been given and treat it well by working to get healthy by eating well and exercising regularly and appreciating the amazing things that having a strong (regardless of muscle size) body enables you to do.0 -
One way ... liposuction0
-
Sorry but walking is an every day thing, so if that was the case your legs (and others) should be bursting from muscle. As as you're losing weight, then that means the resistance is less, so there's NO WAY you're building muscle if that's happening. Muscle is built from progressive overload.Is there any exercise that I could do to lose the fat on my legs but NOT gain muscle? Walking is my main exercise and I know that has alot to do with it. But my legs are not getting any smaller. They are just getting tighter from gaining muscle. Just wondering if someone knows what I could do dfferently. Thanks!
Your genetics is what's causing weight loss from other places first and not your legs. Just continue.
A.C.E. Certified Personal/Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
Gotta disagree with the "long lean muscle" statement. Stretching doesn't lengthen them (meaning from point to point) either. People that look "longer and leaner" have lower body fat and lack muscle size. To achieve this if you have sizable muscles already, is to cause atrophy. And way to do that is to not work out on them and consume very low amounts of protein. Of course, that would also mean that one could invariably gain more fat.General weight loss is key. Whilst losing, walking is good for gentle toning. Slower, long-distance running (rather than short but fast) is good for long and lean muscles, as is yoga. Stretch well and often. I wouldn't rule out squats as these will define your thigh muscles rather than build them, making them look slimmer as a result- just don't add weight when squatting.
To the OP, keep up calorie deficit. They will get smaller over time.
A.C.E. Certified Personal/Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
This. If anything, you're losing it.Trust me, you are not gaining muscle on your legs from walking.
This. I walked about 15 miles a week for several years and my legs were horribly flabby. I'm lifting heavy now to try and fix it.0 -
why do people feel the need to be such *kitten*?
I'm amazed MFP will censor d#ck, but not *kitten*.0 -
Which is why the information should be corrected instead of having people go on a quest of yoga or stretching for a period of time and find out it doesn't work that way.There's obviously no way to actually lengthen them, its supposed to create the perception maybe? I didn't come up with it, the ridiculous magazines that plaster yoga throughout them make that claim.
Yeah there can be less sarcasm, but at the very least the information is correct. That should be the takeaway and not think that there was any personalization from the post.
A.C.E. Certified Personal/Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
I would say change to running... The theory of slow vs fast cardio applies here, since doing a more intense workout can reduce your fat/muscle of the leg whereas slow cardio targets the fat primarily so you'll be left with huge muscular legs ... But you can see how Olympic marathon runners have tiny legs and they train for hours on end daily0
-
Do whatever ballerinas do.
Which I think involves lots of ballet and steep calorie deficits.0 -
I made my muscles too long and this happened
Am I the only one that finds this mildly terrifying?
no, it is pretty creepy! i'm glad i am not in the office on my own right now!
also, sooooooooooooooooooo glad i clicked on this post, comedy GOLD!0 -
I would say change to running... The theory of slow vs fast cardio applies here, since doing a more intense workout can reduce your fat/muscle of the leg whereas slow cardio targets the fat primarily so you'll be left with huge muscular legs ... But you can see how Olympic marathon runners have tiny legs and they train for hours on end daily
Slow cardio targets primarily fat?
Really?
That must be why all these women trudging away on the treadmill day after day, month after month look either the same, or like slightly smaller copies of their old selves, right?
/sigh0 -
First of all, some ppl gain muscle mass very easily, and not the trim and slim kind. I have struggled with that all my life. Body builders may like this but women in general do not. Cardio such as running or aerobics is the best way to trim down the fat on your legs while not bulking up. Add a little bit of toning exercises like leg lifts (no weight added) and this will tighten the already existing muscle making you smaller. Just don't overdo these types of exercises or ever add any weight as it will bulk you up almost immediately if you have this body type. Squats are NOT what you want to do. They will bulk you up if you already have a tendency toward large legs. Try not to eat too much protein either or this can add more muscle when mixed with exercise. Eat less fats, and try to stick with more veggies and lean proteins like chicken and fish, hummus dip, etc. Good luck!0
-
I know you probably know this, but you can spot reduce just the fat on your legs. If you lose weight overrall, the fat will come off your legs at some point though certain body parts show weight loss ahead others.
Out of curiosity, why don't you want muscle gains in your legs? When I started doing squats and lunges regularly, I got definition in my legs, not bulk.
Yes, I know. I was just hoping I was wrong and that there was something else I could. I wouldnt mind the muscle, if my legs were not so huge. I just want them smaller. :grumble:
They are huge because they are fat. I would be more worried about the fat on the belly.0 -
First of all, some ppl gain muscle mass very easily, and not the trim and slim kind. I have struggled with that all my life. Body builders may like this but women in general do not. Cardio such as running or aerobics is the best way to trim down the fat on your legs while not bulking up. Add a little bit of toning exercises like leg lifts (no weight added) and this will tighten the already existing muscle making you smaller. Just don't overdo these types of exercises or ever add any weight as it will bulk you up almost immediately if you have this body type. Squats are NOT what you want to do. They will bulk you up if you already have a tendency toward large legs. Try not to eat too much protein either or this can add more muscle when mixed with exercise. Eat less fats, and try to stick with more veggies and lean proteins like chicken and fish, hummus dip, etc. Good luck!
A whole lot of bad advice right there.0 -
Muscle is more dense then fat, so why wouldn't you want some muscle in your leg? A little leg muscle is sexy.0
-
Spot reduction is a myth.
Yup, had a whole chapter on it in my high school mythology class.
i heard unicorns can spot reduce their horns0 -
Who are these people? People can get heavier easily, but putting on muscle is actually quite hard to do.First of all, some ppl gain muscle mass very easily, and not the trim and slim kind.
If one is in calorie deficit (and not a newbie, returning athlete, or extremely overweight/obese) the chances of adding any muscle is improbable. To add muscle is to add weight, and adding weight (lean mass) doesn't happen in calorie deficit. What you're stating is long time broscience that's been passed around as truth when it isn't.I have struggled with that all my life. Body builders may like this but women in general do not. Cardio such as running or aerobics is the best way to trim down the fat on your legs while not bulking up. Add a little bit of toning exercises like leg lifts (no weight added) and this will tighten the already existing muscle making you smaller. Just don't overdo these types of exercises or ever add any weight as it will bulk you up almost immediately if you have this body type. Squats are NOT what you want to do. They will bulk you up if you already have a tendency toward large legs. Try not to eat too much protein either or this can add more muscle when mixed with exercise. Eat less fats, and try to stick with more veggies and lean proteins like chicken and fish, hummus dip, etc. Good luck!
A.C.E. Certified Personal/Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
to answer the question i'm a thick legged gal and i went from a size 22 pants to size 14 pants by heavy weight lifting with weights.. squats , deadlifts, turkish get ups and by heavy i mean my deadlifts were over my body weight.
and once again i repeat i'm naturally thick legged.
the key is to eat at a slight calorie deficit.
so yeah, start weight lifting. learn the form correctly before increasing weight. look up programs like starting strength, strong lifts and wendler 5-3-1. lift weights like a beast. eat at a deficit and watch your fat melt and dont even waste time with the "gentle toning" stuff. if that stuff worked then just about every woman at the gym would have the body of her dreams0 -
First of all, some ppl gain muscle mass very easily, and not the trim and slim kind. I have struggled with that all my life. Body builders may like this but women in general do not. Cardio such as running or aerobics is the best way to trim down the fat on your legs while not bulking up. Add a little bit of toning exercises like leg lifts (no weight added) and this will tighten the already existing muscle making you smaller. Just don't overdo these types of exercises or ever add any weight as it will bulk you up almost immediately if you have this body type. Squats are NOT what you want to do. They will bulk you up if you already have a tendency toward large legs. Try not to eat too much protein either or this can add more muscle when mixed with exercise. Eat less fats, and try to stick with more veggies and lean proteins like chicken and fish, hummus dip, etc. Good luck!
0 -
First of all, some ppl gain muscle mass very easily, and not the trim and slim kind. I have struggled with that all my life. Body builders may like this but women in general do not. Cardio such as running or aerobics is the best way to trim down the fat on your legs while not bulking up. Add a little bit of toning exercises like leg lifts (no weight added) and this will tighten the already existing muscle making you smaller. Just don't overdo these types of exercises or ever add any weight as it will bulk you up almost immediately if you have this body type. Squats are NOT what you want to do. They will bulk you up if you already have a tendency toward large legs. Try not to eat too much protein either or this can add more muscle when mixed with exercise. Eat less fats, and try to stick with more veggies and lean proteins like chicken and fish, hummus dip, etc. Good luck!
Yah okay. Somebody else trying to scare women away from "muscles". Leg lifts with weights and squats WILL NOT BULK YOU UP IMMEDIATELY
Eating too much protien at a deficet will not add muscle.
wowsers.0 -
why do people feel the need to be such *kitten*? obviously there's no way to lengthen muscles but i have heard that stretching, yoga, etc can make them appear more toned and "longer" looking but jesus chill out. i understand wanting to trim leg muscles down. not everyone wants big strong legs that certain sports and workouts can create. cracking jokes at others' expense is just stupid. whether its just not written properly or an uneducated response, i hate seeing people get attacked.
someone please, come back and post something obnoxious about this post now.
Okay you said to...
*Alert* *Alert*
White knight present to defend someone who posted something that is just not true.
Bullies abound.
btw no name calling in the general forums it goes against the ToS as do personal attacks such as your post...just an FYI.
and
Stop attacking people you hate it when it happens yet here you are doing exactly what you hate...ah pot/kettle/black0 -
I love how "some people gain muscle easily" is such a common belief, yet pro bodybuilders can spend years trying to gain a few pounds of lean muscle.
Also
Muscles have fixed attachment points. Unless you are making your bones longer too, good luck making your muscles longer. They grow or shrink. Hypertrophy or Atrophy. Nothing else.0 -
I made my muscles too long and this happened
Am I the only one that finds this mildly terrifying?
No. It's extremely unsettling
0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions