do people make comments on what you eat?

I get more of the "Why are you not eating". But I have a feeling that day is coming.

Yes I get it a lot - particularly at work. The tutting and finger wagging and knowing sideway glances! You're doing this right in my opinion - it's a lifestyle not a diet. Slow but sure is much more likely to become a lifelong habit than depriving yourself and missing out on nice meals with friends and the odd bit of chocolate. I log everything I eat and it's not often I go over. I've lost 42llb since January this year and I'm very happy with that. Good luck :-)

I've recently had ppl say to me "you need some weight on you" or "have a doughnut". Ironic since it was having the doughnuts that made me put the weight on in the first place.

Well, my SO is always asking "what are you eating now?" and "You're eating AGAIN?" I just smile and nod and eat anyway. I eat about 6 times a day but he doesn't see me do that during the week at work. I figure if I'm the one doing the lifestyle change and if eating often does what it needs to do, then I'm doing it.

I think most people have skewed ideas about dieting and exercise and project their inabilities to control portions onto people who can. The word "dieting" has a bad rap, but in my own mind, it just means being conscious about what my diet consists of.

What exactly does eating often "need to do?"

Yes people do. With me, it's usually questions about how can I have a Starbucks every day and still lose weight. Then they make a face when I tell them all I do is count calories, kinda like they don't believe me. Oh well.........

People haven't commented about my diary. I eat 'crap' and love it. I just make sure my body is properly nourished. If I give up stuff I like, this may lead to pigging out due to self deprivation. I'm not on a weight loss diet, I'm on a lifetime diet, hence I have to eat in a manner that will sustain my life, happiness and mental and physical stability. With that being said, people who do not know my non restrictive eating patterns will be amazed when they see me eating foods that in their eyes do not match the type of body I have. I've surprised people at work, waiters and waitresses alike. It is fun educating people this way...

Outside of MFP people don't make comments about my eating habits. They know better...:grumble:

MY MFP's friends are awesome and so are their comments.

I get it the other way around quite a lot! For example, the other day I was eating one of my favourite snacks -- a rice cake with peanut butter, banana, and cinnamon. A friend of mine was having a cupcake and was all, "Ooooh, you're always so healthy! We need to get some cake into you!" And I was just thinking ... no, you don't. We need to get my rice cake with peanut butter, banana, and cinnamon into me because it's exactly what I feel like at the moment and it's freaking delicious and honestly, your cupcake doesn't look tempting at all.

I mean, I like chocolate and cake and all things dessert-y, but I just don't *crave* them enough to want to eat them every day. Maybe I'm lucky that I genuinely like a lot of foods that people perceive as "healthy". I will eat cottage cheese straight out of the tub, get excited about carrot sticks, and eat blueberries like candy. And I promise I don't eat food that I don't enjoy just to be "good". I certainly don't feel as if I'm depriving myself if I say no to an average-looking cupcake. (If it's a really decadent and delicious cupcake, though ... now that's a different story! )

On MFP I have never gotten anything but helpful comments about my eating habits... thanks you guys :flowerforyou:

Outside of MFP people are all over the map.

There really is no winning.

I am not a super "clean" eater but if I pass on the fast food or pizza etc even once in a while some people act like I have some kind of horrible ED... same if I eat 2-3 slices of pizza instead of 4 or 5... or if I eat 2 burgers from a drive through but don't also have a large fries or onion rings. The exact same people will then look at me cross eyed if I have a tiny serving of ice cream or something.

People don't know what they don't know and when it comes to health, fitness, weight loss, etc, they often really really really believe they do know even when they don't.

I just take it all with a grain of salt. I know what I am doing and have support from others on here that do too, I focus on that.

No one has made any comments about what I'm eating. Why would they?

I'm not trying to hide my eating habits, but I certainly didn't advertise that I was trying to lose weight - why invite that kind of scrutiny?

Today was my first day of truly putting forth effort into losing weight and I didn't even make it to lunch time before someone noticed. I ate lunch, went to deliver a home-cooked meal to my grandfather, and immediately him and two of my family members berated me for walking (it was a ten minute walk) in the cold and wind. Then, since they were cooking their own meal, I was told no less than six times in less than ten minutes to "Grab some food and eat!" I politely declined until it became too much and I finally let out an exasperated "Guys! I'm not hungry!" which immediately had everyone berating me for being 'disrespectful and rude.' I'm really determined to lose this weight though so even though they all glared at me I didn't touch a single morsel. For dinner, my husband made a comment about how I was eating everything out of measuring cups which I just passed off as me liking small cute dishes. He's gullible so, for now, he believes me. It'll be hard doing this without support but I am determined!

My friends are very supportive and don't say things about what I eat. One of the things I get that is weird is when we are going over to someone's house for dinner they'll ask me if they fix such and such will I be able to have it on my diet. I just can't seem to convince people that I don't really eat special foods. I just count my calories and if I occasionally go over, so be it. I don't indulge in foods that have little benefit often, but I do indulge in them. If I'm going to have a piece of cake or pie, it must be exceptionally good or I recent using my calories on it. My husband has quit asking if I can have something. His favorite night time snack is popcorn. He used to say can you have popcorn. Now he just asks if I want some. So if I have the calories and feel like a snack I join him, if not I don't and he's good with that.

I've been at this since the 2nd week of January this year and I've lost 56 pounds, I really feel good about that. I little bit over a pound a week. Seems like I'm on schedule to me.

My friends haven't really said anything negative about my diary.

Sometimes they are curious about an off-the-wall food but no negativity.

I think it may have something to do with certain people's personalities more than with what you are eating.

happily no. Unless its someone who knows my results so far teasing a bit I have no haters. I love that I am surrounded by supporters. The other day someone told me o looked gteat and asked how I did it. I told her about MFP and almost slapped myself when I told her I still had 20 to go thinking "here it comes; she's going to say you don't need to do that and criticize you" but she simply repeated, "well, you look great". It felt amazing.

Well...if people commenting here on what you eat bothers someone, there is something you can do about that, isn't there?