Holding the handrails on treadmill?
Replies
-
I'd venture to say he cares because he is a distance runner, and majority of his thoughts revolve around how to be a better runner. While running, he probably noticed a few people doing this. Because he does not regularly workout at a gym/on a treadmill he was/is actually curious as to why some people choose to hold the railings. For someone who runs/walks outside 300+ days a year, it is a bit strange to see someone running and hanging onto a machine. He's probably just wondering why as it's something he knows nothing about.Ok I have to ask.... Why do you care?0 -
There's a guy at work that does this. He holds on for dear life while attempting to sustain 9 MPH. His gait is so messed up, and his feet hit the deck so heavily and unevenly that it seriously hurts to watch. And he's gasping for air the whole time. It's something you'd see on youtube with about 2 million views.
I'd love to say something to him, but I'm not the type to offer unsolicited advice.0 -
How about let people work out how they want to and mind your own business? Walking and hanging on is better than sitting on the sofa watching TV.0
-
I guess I am just one of those people that goes to the gym to work out and really don't pay attention to other people. (except when they don't wipe down machines after they are done!!)
I'd venture to say he cares because he is a distance runner, and majority of his thoughts revolve around how to be a better runner. While running, he probably noticed a few people doing this. Because he does not regularly workout at a gym/on a treadmill he was/is actually curious as to why some people choose to hold the railings. For someone who runs/walks outside 300+ days a year, it is a bit strange to see someone running and hanging onto a machine. He's probably just wondering why as it's something he knows nothing about.Ok I have to ask.... Why do you care?
:-)0 -
I guess I am just one of those people that goes to the gym to work out and really don't pay attention to other people. (except when they don't wipe down machines after they are done!!)
I'd venture to say he cares because he is a distance runner, and majority of his thoughts revolve around how to be a better runner. While running, he probably noticed a few people doing this. Because he does not regularly workout at a gym/on a treadmill he was/is actually curious as to why some people choose to hold the railings. For someone who runs/walks outside 300+ days a year, it is a bit strange to see someone running and hanging onto a machine. He's probably just wondering why as it's something he knows nothing about.Ok I have to ask.... Why do you care?
:-)
The day you'll do 6 miles and + on a dreadmill because you can't run outside as you usually do, you'll get SO bored that you'll watch other people around as there is nothing better to do!
People grip the bars for 30 minutes then say they burned 300 calories doing their workout and eat those calories back then wonder why they don't lose weight... (It's because you didn't had a real 300 calories workout lady!)...
I wondered if there was a reason for it too.. I learned by watching them there isn't...0 -
So, I've noticed a few runners / walkers at the gym who constantly hold the handrails or the "handlebars" on the treadmill as they workout. Some of them seem to be hanging on with almost a death grip. Others seem to be bearing weight using the handrails. I'm talking about doing this constantly for a 20-30 minute workout.
Honest question: Why would you do this?
I saw this the other day and wondered what this person was doing. I get the fear factor of a treadmill, but going that slow there really isn't much concern about getting hurt.
And really, I live in FLA so don't get the treadmill anyway. Get out the door and out on the roads people. Treadmills are lame.0 -
I have a balance issue which flairs up now and then so most of the time I don't need the rail but sometimes I do, sometimes I just need to touch it for a second to get my balance back on check and sometimes I hold it to see what my heart rate is. I see a lot of older people holding on to the rail, I see a lot of new people hold onto the rails because it does take some time to get your balance right on them. Whatever reason people have for holding them is quite irrelevant in the big scheme of things, they're all exercising which is the most important.0
-
I do this as I have balance issues - I have swimmer's ear and a couple of MS related signs (not strong enough to be classified as MS so far - thank God)
Holding onto the handrail by one hand (I only hold on with my right) helps me find my centre of gravity and balance.
I dont think I have a deathgrip on them and I definately not doing this as weight-bearing - more just to hold for a few minutes-not the whole session just when I feel I no longer have my balance or paying attention to other things (such as the newscast I am watching)..unfortulnately my brain cannot handle balancing at the same time of doing something else so I need something to hold onto. I also hold the rails when going downstairs on a staircase - any staircase even if it is only 4-5steps.
Same for me. I have to hold on or I trip and fall easily. I do have MS and it is a battle for me to keep moving as it is let alone walk or run on something that moves under me. I don't dare walk onto a dock or anything without rails that is narrow or not steady or I fall easily. I suggest you do your thing and let others do theirs. How do you know they don't have a hip or leg problem causing them to hold on or distribute their weight a little bit?0 -
If you are afraid of falling, slow down! You are going to burn more calories if you keep your arms moving too. You are only cheating yourself!0
-
I sense the OP is feeling superior to those who use the treadmill, as opposed to his running in the dark in cold weather. Seriously there could be any number of reasons to hold the bars on the treadmill from safety to comfort, from balance to joint issues, to just because it's there.
(not sarcasm) I really hope the OP never has any of the health and/or age issues that would ever make him hold onto the bars himself, may he be forever young and healthy.0 -
They gotta start some where! Might be a trust issue with the machines too..0
-
That's a possibility, but it doesn't explain the death grip. Same for those suggesting "balance." I'm afraid I will probably never understand treadmills. I'm planning on a run in the dark, in 7-degree-fahrenheit temps tomorrow.Is that where the sensors for the heart rate monitor are? I've seen people keep their hands on when they are trying to stay within a particular HR zone.
7 degrees fahrenheit huh? Wow, it's warm where you live. I'd be outside too.0 -
The reason I do it is because it keeps track of your heart rate. If they are holding it and there is metal under their hands that is probably what is going on.0
-
I hold on! I'm very unbalanced and terrified of falling off the treadmill lol I never even thought about it bothering anyone.
Well apparently you and I are annoying the OP and we need to stop it lol. Guess we should just fall on our faces and suck it up.
0 -
Just yesterday I got a treadmill, when I started using it, at first I held on to the handrails until the got the feel of it, and got used to the pace. After that I let go, I'm doing C25K on it, (started today). The C25K plan requires things like jogging for 60 seconds and then walking for 90 seconds, and continuing to alternate throughout the workout... I hold on with one hand while I change the speed up or down until I adjust to the new pace again because I don't want to lose my balance and fall.
The whole reason I am using the treadmill instead of doing this outside is because I have a bad ankle and foot and need a level surface to run on, my foot and ankle can handle running, but they can't handle stepping in potholes, tripping over rocks, slipping on ice or mud, or any other common hazard on the trails near my house. The treadmill is safer for me right now, until I've lost more weight and have become conditioned to the running, and to keep it safer, anytime I feel like I could possibly lose my balance, I either hold on or at least let my hands "hover" over the rails so I can grab on if I need to.
Some people have balance issues, or an unsteady gate, some may see the handrails and assume that they are there because you are supposed to hold on to them.0 -
It's easier. If you feel you need to do that though, you should reduce something- speed, incline, what ever- it's better to swing your arms...0
-
Well I am probably going to be hated for saying this but I do that. I dont bear weight on the rails but I do hold on the majority of the time. I have weak ankles, really weak ankles that pop while I walk so I just dont want to fall on my *kitten* in front of everyone. I fall enough all the other times and have the bruises to prove it, elliptical I am fine, but anything I have to actually move the placement of my feet, yeah all bad0
-
I have balance/sense issues. Personally I should be the one moving- not the floor. The lack of control scares me but sometimes it's the only thing open.
It isn't a balance thing that slowing down will help. Endmondo and runkeeper have tracked me going faster outside.0 -
I sometimes place one hand on the treadmill for balance when I'm running. I'm not holding on to it, not placing any weight through it, just steadying myself. Why? Because I have an ongoing muscle injury in my shoulder and neck that pinches a nerve and effects my balance. Some days it's not bad and I run without touching the treadmill. Some days it's worse and I kind of want to make sure that I don't fall. My PT at the gym actually told me to use the railing to steady myself when I need to.
To answer the question of why I run - because I'm actually quite fit. I can't get my HR up high enough if I just walk on the treadmill, even walking very fast, and I can't put on a steep incline because I can't keep my balance without holding on to it. Actually holding onto the treadmill then aggravates my injury. I have limited choice for cardio because of this stupid injury, and running is pretty much my best option. That, and stationary bike, which I also use. I do run outside sometimes, but it's summer here in Australia and gets very hot. It's also school holidays until the end of this month and there's a safety factor if I run outside in the evenings by myself when I don't have kids to look after.
It might look silly if people are holding on, but I assume that there's a reason for it rather than judge how anybody does their cardio.0 -
Sometimes I use the treadmill after I lift as my 'cool down' or to finish fatiguing my legs.
Sometimes, I hold onto the handrails and hold up some of my bodyweight to stretch.
Sometimes I'll have the treadmill going REALLY slow and take great big strides, almost like lunges to stretch.
I don't care about the calorie burn or if you think I'm going to slow or holding on or even if you think I look stupid.
Maybe I do it just to annoy you.0 -
I use them just because I don't know what to do with my hands/arms... I'm not really "holding on", just resting my hands on them. I run so far up on the tread that if I swing my arms, I whack my hands on the railings and hurt myself. I've tried running further back on the tread, but then I feel like I'm going to fly off the back.
To each their own.0 -
Yeah, I fell once...wasn't fun. FuNNY, yes. Fun...not so much.0
-
I sense the OP is feeling superior to those who use the treadmill, as opposed to his running in the dark in cold weather. Seriously there could be any number of reasons to hold the bars on the treadmill from safety to comfort, from balance to joint issues, to just because it's there.
(not sarcasm) I really hope the OP never has any of the health and/or age issues that would ever make him hold onto the bars himself, may he be forever young and healthy.
exactly . i've used the handrails because i was recovering from a sprained ankle and didnt want to walk with a cane and wasnt able to get to a pool.0 -
So, I've noticed a few runners / walkers at the gym who constantly hold the handrails or the "handlebars" on the treadmill as they workout. Some of them seem to be hanging on with almost a death grip. Others seem to be bearing weight using the handrails. I'm talking about doing this constantly for a 20-30 minute workout.
Honest question: Why would you do this?
They're at the gym doing their thing, so who cares how they do it? As long as they're not hurting themselves or hurting someone else, it doesn't matter.0 -
Handrails arn't designed to be held throughout a workout. They are there for safety. Use them and you're cheating yourself.
Yes, up to a 25% reduction in your workout benefits (source Goodlife gym posters)0 -
I guess I am just one of those people that goes to the gym to work out and really don't pay attention to other people. (except when they don't wipe down machines after they are done!!)
I'd venture to say he cares because he is a distance runner, and majority of his thoughts revolve around how to be a better runner. While running, he probably noticed a few people doing this. Because he does not regularly workout at a gym/on a treadmill he was/is actually curious as to why some people choose to hold the railings. For someone who runs/walks outside 300+ days a year, it is a bit strange to see someone running and hanging onto a machine. He's probably just wondering why as it's something he knows nothing about.Ok I have to ask.... Why do you care?
:-)
The day you'll do 6 miles and + on a dreadmill because you can't run outside as you usually do, you'll get SO bored that you'll watch other people around as there is nothing better to do!
People grip the bars for 30 minutes then say they burned 300 calories doing their workout and eat those calories back then wonder why they don't lose weight... (It's because you didn't had a real 300 calories workout lady!)...
I wondered if there was a reason for it too.. I learned by watching them there isn't...
Guess I am not there yet...I only did 5.75 on the dreadmill today...oh yeah, that's right...I was the only one in gym! ;-(0 -
umm any number of reasons. At least they're trying :grumble:0
-
Handrails arn't designed to be held throughout a workout. They are there for safety. Use them and you're cheating yourself.
Yes, up to a 25% reduction in your workout benefits (source Goodlife gym posters)
0 -
Handrails arn't designed to be held throughout a workout. They are there for safety. Use them and you're cheating yourself.
Yes, up to a 25% reduction in your workout benefits (source Goodlife gym posters)
Even if I am getting 25% less of a workout by resting my hands on the rails
it's 75% more than if I stayed at home and sat on the couch. According to my math calculations that's not cheating myself AT ALL!!! Yay to all of us who are getting out and TRYING!!!!!0 -
They are cheating on the exercise. The only time I've needed to support myself is when I trying to change the speed from 9 (sprint for me) to 4 (fast walk) when doing HIIT training.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions