HOW DO YOU EAT SO MUCH PROTEIN?!
Replies
-
I focus on my protein level and the rest falls into place.. well.. no i miss fats a lot, but carbs and protein are good.
I eat cottage cheese, yogurt, cheese, milk , usually 1 scoop of protein powder, spinach, broccoli, 10-16 oz meat. tuna on salads egg and egg whites together.
If you need to increase protein you just need to focus on that macro. I'm not an expert on the math, but if you are under in protein you have to be over in something else.. so look at where you are over and swap that for something high in protein.
My goal is 160, but i usually get more then that. and miss my fat macro.
^^^^^^
This is the way I do it, protein first, then fat and then carbs. I ignore MFPs scaled protein levels though. As a fish eating vegie most of my protein (usually 150-160 gms per day) come from shakes, I try and eat fish and quorn but I need to hammer the protein powder to get the levels up0 -
Why do you think the protein HAS to be that high? Just go for 1g/lb. IIFYM calculator isn't the secret to weight loss, calorie deficit is.
The protein macros I use are similar, but I'm 163lbs, powerlift, and cut on about 500 cal/day more. I have no problem meeting my #'s and they could be lower, as in 163g, but I also ENJOY eating that much protein. If a diet doesn't "work" for you, it won't last. Drop the protein and add more carbs, if you see a difference other than some possible water retention intially, then bump protein back up.
Well I am going for fat loss and muscle gain and I weight 165 and lift heavy weights also. I could definitely hit 165g a day no problem. I use the IIFYM calculator because from what I understand IIFYM is designed to help you meet your individual goals. I am going to recalculate though. Last week my macros were different and the diet was working for me really well. I will see about doing 165g a day instead. Thanks
you're still higher than you need to be at 165g. you're confusing bodyweight and LBM in the calculations. for protein, what matters is the amount of LBM. eating extra protein can't hurt (unless you have a medical issue), but it's wasted once you meet your body's actual needs for the day.
So my protein should be 123g a day if my BMI is 25% ..?
Here is a lean body mass calculator
http://www.healthstatus.com/calculate/lean-body-mass
I am not sure of its accuracy but it is better than me guessing I'm sure0 -
Change it to aim for 130-160G. Increase carbs, don't deprive yourself and everything becomes a lot easier. (I'd probably drop the fat to around 20% of total cals)0
-
Are you sure you haven't accidentally used male values on the calculator?
(if it doesn't have an option to choose male/female, it's going to be waaaaaaay overestimating for you, anyway)
I just re-did it checking off male and then tried again with female ... the results were the same. I think you solved the mystery lol this calculator doesn't differentiate0 -
Why do you think the protein HAS to be that high? Just go for 1g/lb. IIFYM calculator isn't the secret to weight loss, calorie deficit is.
The protein macros I use are similar, but I'm 163lbs, powerlift, and cut on about 500 cal/day more. I have no problem meeting my #'s and they could be lower, as in 163g, but I also ENJOY eating that much protein. If a diet doesn't "work" for you, it won't last. Drop the protein and add more carbs, if you see a difference other than some possible water retention intially, then bump protein back up.
Well I am going for fat loss and muscle gain and I weight 165 and lift heavy weights also. I could definitely hit 165g a day no problem. I use the IIFYM calculator because from what I understand IIFYM is designed to help you meet your individual goals. I am going to recalculate though. Last week my macros were different and the diet was working for me really well. I will see about doing 165g a day instead. Thanks
you're still higher than you need to be at 165g. you're confusing bodyweight and LBM in the calculations. for protein, what matters is the amount of LBM. eating extra protein can't hurt (unless you have a medical issue), but it's wasted once you meet your body's actual needs for the day.
So my protein should be 123g a day if my BMI is 25% ..?
i don't think BMI correlates to BF% that directly...
you can estimate your BF% using this picture and then use that number % for the calculations. it's close enough. you don't have to be exactly accurate since your protein goal is a daily minimum anyway.
0 -
Why do you think the protein HAS to be that high? Just go for 1g/lb. IIFYM calculator isn't the secret to weight loss, calorie deficit is.
The protein macros I use are similar, but I'm 163lbs, powerlift, and cut on about 500 cal/day more. I have no problem meeting my #'s and they could be lower, as in 163g, but I also ENJOY eating that much protein. If a diet doesn't "work" for you, it won't last. Drop the protein and add more carbs, if you see a difference other than some possible water retention intially, then bump protein back up.
Well I am going for fat loss and muscle gain and I weight 165 and lift heavy weights also. I could definitely hit 165g a day no problem. I use the IIFYM calculator because from what I understand IIFYM is designed to help you meet your individual goals. I am going to recalculate though. Last week my macros were different and the diet was working for me really well. I will see about doing 165g a day instead. Thanks
you're still higher than you need to be at 165g. you're confusing bodyweight and LBM in the calculations. for protein, what matters is the amount of LBM. eating extra protein can't hurt (unless you have a medical issue), but it's wasted once you meet your body's actual needs for the day.
So my protein should be 123g a day if my BMI is 25% ..?
are you thinking of body fat percentage or BMI? they are two totally different things. if your body fat percentage is 25%, multiply your total weight by .75 to get your LBM and protein goal.0 -
Change it to aim for 130-160G. Increase carbs, don't deprive yourself and everything becomes a lot easier. (I'd probably drop the fat to around 20% of total cals)
I just recalculated using 1g of protein per lb of lean body mass and everything you just said basically came up as my numbers. Thank you!0 -
Beans are great- lentils, pintos, black beans... All are both high in fiber and protein-- just mind the sodium if you're buying them canned. They'll also give you crazy gas for a minute, but hey...0
-
That is a lot of protein. I'm a 6'1" male and my target is only 165 grams/day.
Thats how I feel! I feel like something might be wrong. I'm a 5'8 female at 165 pounds and I workout about 3 or 4 times a week with heavy weights and play basketball once a week. I can do 165g's but 208 is killing me!
.0 -
Why do you think the protein HAS to be that high? Just go for 1g/lb. IIFYM calculator isn't the secret to weight loss, calorie deficit is.
The protein macros I use are similar, but I'm 163lbs, powerlift, and cut on about 500 cal/day more. I have no problem meeting my #'s and they could be lower, as in 163g, but I also ENJOY eating that much protein. If a diet doesn't "work" for you, it won't last. Drop the protein and add more carbs, if you see a difference other than some possible water retention intially, then bump protein back up.
I can see why the OP said this BUT there is research which shows that if you keep your protein level high and cut the carbs instead you will drop less lean body mass and conversely more fat so while it is true a calorie deficit is what is needed to shift weight it comes down to your macros as to what bit of you is reducing. This doesn't mean no carbs of course, it just means enough protein :-)0 -
This may be a really dumb question, but what's protein coffee? I'm a vegetarian too and trying to gain weight, and it's a constant struggle to come near my protein goal. I have no idea how I'd even get near 208g. I'm looking through your diary to get some new ideas!0
-
That is a lot of protein. I'm a 6'1" male and my target is only 165 grams/day.
Thats how I feel! I feel like something might be wrong. I'm a 5'8 female at 165 pounds and I workout about 3 or 4 times a week with heavy weights and play basketball once a week. I can do 165g's but 208 is killing me!
The amount of protein to set as a goal is entirely up to you. If you aren't comfortable with the current number, go ahead and change it.
I also find that the way MFP adjusts the goals as you add exercise into your day is...non-ideal. I meet my protein/fat goals in my base calories, and anything extra from exercise I want as mostly carbs. But MFP doesn't have that flexibility, so it keeps up the targets for all macros. So I just ignore it. 0 -
This may be a really dumb question, but what's protein coffee? I'm a vegetarian too and trying to gain weight, and it's a constant struggle to come near my protein goal. I have no idea how I'd even get near 208g. I'm looking through your diary to get some new ideas!
I'd assume it's protein powder mixed in with coffee in some way or form.0 -
I eat 2 pounds of greek yogurt per week0
-
Why do you think the protein HAS to be that high? Just go for 1g/lb. IIFYM calculator isn't the secret to weight loss, calorie deficit is.
The protein macros I use are similar, but I'm 163lbs, powerlift, and cut on about 500 cal/day more. I have no problem meeting my #'s and they could be lower, as in 163g, but I also ENJOY eating that much protein. If a diet doesn't "work" for you, it won't last. Drop the protein and add more carbs, if you see a difference other than some possible water retention intially, then bump protein back up.
Well I am going for fat loss and muscle gain and I weight 165 and lift heavy weights also. I could definitely hit 165g a day no problem. I use the IIFYM calculator because from what I understand IIFYM is designed to help you meet your individual goals. I am going to recalculate though. Last week my macros were different and the diet was working for me really well. I will see about doing 165g a day instead. Thanks
you're still higher than you need to be at 165g. you're confusing bodyweight and LBM in the calculations. for protein, what matters is the amount of LBM. eating extra protein can't hurt (unless you have a medical issue), but it's wasted once you meet your body's actual needs for the day.
So my protein should be 123g a day if my BMI is 25% ..?
i don't think BMI correlates to BF% that directly...
you can estimate your BF% using this picture and then use that number % for the calculations. it's close enough. you don't have to be exactly accurate since your protein goal is a daily minimum anyway.
but protien levels should be calculated of Lean body mass not %fat. I think there is more to lean body mass than total mass - fat but I may be mistaken0 -
I eat 2 pounds of greek yogurt per week
fromage frais is also really high in protein :-)0 -
I can see why the OP said this BUT there is research which shows that if you keep your protein level high and cut the carbs instead you will drop less lean body mass and conversely more fat...
That's not "will", that's "may". And the protein level the OP is talking about is already waaaaaaay past "high".
A common guideline for lean mass retention is 1g per pound of fat-free mass. For the OP, that could be anything from 50-100g less than her current target.0 -
Why do you think the protein HAS to be that high? Just go for 1g/lb. IIFYM calculator isn't the secret to weight loss, calorie deficit is.
The protein macros I use are similar, but I'm 163lbs, powerlift, and cut on about 500 cal/day more. I have no problem meeting my #'s and they could be lower, as in 163g, but I also ENJOY eating that much protein. If a diet doesn't "work" for you, it won't last. Drop the protein and add more carbs, if you see a difference other than some possible water retention intially, then bump protein back up.
Well I am going for fat loss and muscle gain and I weight 165 and lift heavy weights also. I could definitely hit 165g a day no problem. I use the IIFYM calculator because from what I understand IIFYM is designed to help you meet your individual goals. I am going to recalculate though. Last week my macros were different and the diet was working for me really well. I will see about doing 165g a day instead. Thanks
you're still higher than you need to be at 165g. you're confusing bodyweight and LBM in the calculations. for protein, what matters is the amount of LBM. eating extra protein can't hurt (unless you have a medical issue), but it's wasted once you meet your body's actual needs for the day.
So my protein should be 123g a day if my BMI is 25% ..?
i don't think BMI correlates to BF% that directly...
you can estimate your BF% using this picture and then use that number % for the calculations. it's close enough. you don't have to be exactly accurate since your protein goal is a daily minimum anyway.
Ok so I would say I'm at a BF% of about 27% I am terrible at math that picture is very helpful lol0 -
This may be a really dumb question, but what's protein coffee? I'm a vegetarian too and trying to gain weight, and it's a constant struggle to come near my protein goal. I have no idea how I'd even get near 208g. I'm looking through your diary to get some new ideas!
I'd assume it's protein powder mixed in with coffee in some way or form.
He got it ^
I mix my powder with a little bit of cool water (a very little bit, just to mix it up) and then heat up my coffee and add it in (if it is boiling hot it will turn your protein coffee into protein pudding disgustingness. But if you do it right it tastes great and is a good replacement for coffee creamer and sugar 0 -
But there's a practical limit to how much protein you can eat and still stay within your calorie limit, and this is coming from someone who *does* eat 1 g/lb. of total body weight, not LBM. I can't cut any more carbs, or my training will suffer. For me, 35/40/25 C/P/F is the ratio that seems to work best for me. I think everybody has to find what ratio works best for them.Why do you think the protein HAS to be that high? Just go for 1g/lb. IIFYM calculator isn't the secret to weight loss, calorie deficit is.
The protein macros I use are similar, but I'm 163lbs, powerlift, and cut on about 500 cal/day more. I have no problem meeting my #'s and they could be lower, as in 163g, but I also ENJOY eating that much protein. If a diet doesn't "work" for you, it won't last. Drop the protein and add more carbs, if you see a difference other than some possible water retention intially, then bump protein back up.
I can see why the OP said this BUT there is research which shows that if you keep your protein level high and cut the carbs instead you will drop less lean body mass and conversely more fat so while it is true a calorie deficit is what is needed to shift weight it comes down to your macros as to what bit of you is reducing. This doesn't mean no carbs of course, it just means enough protein :-)0 -
This may be a really dumb question, but what's protein coffee? I'm a vegetarian too and trying to gain weight, and it's a constant struggle to come near my protein goal. I have no idea how I'd even get near 208g. I'm looking through your diary to get some new ideas!
I hope my diary helps although I am not sure if you are a pure vegetarian as I am not. I eat fish and eggs which make up most of my protein for the day.0 -
But there's a practical limit to how much protein you can eat and still stay within your calorie limit, and this is coming from someone who *does* eat 1 g/lb. of total body weight, not LBM. I can't cut any more carbs, or my training will suffer. For me, 35/40/25 C/P/F is the ratio that seems to work best for me. I think everybody has to find what ratio works best for them.Why do you think the protein HAS to be that high? Just go for 1g/lb. IIFYM calculator isn't the secret to weight loss, calorie deficit is.
The protein macros I use are similar, but I'm 163lbs, powerlift, and cut on about 500 cal/day more. I have no problem meeting my #'s and they could be lower, as in 163g, but I also ENJOY eating that much protein. If a diet doesn't "work" for you, it won't last. Drop the protein and add more carbs, if you see a difference other than some possible water retention intially, then bump protein back up.
I can see why the OP said this BUT there is research which shows that if you keep your protein level high and cut the carbs instead you will drop less lean body mass and conversely more fat so while it is true a calorie deficit is what is needed to shift weight it comes down to your macros as to what bit of you is reducing. This doesn't mean no carbs of course, it just means enough protein :-)
35/40/25 is doable for me but I guess I will have to do trial and error until I figure out what is right. I am just a little nervous that if I put the wrong percentages I'll end up losing muscle and gaining fat0 -
bump0
-
If you eat bread, there's a bread called P28 that has 14g protein per slice (28g for 2 slices). The slices are huge, one slice is easily the equivalent of two slices of regular bread. It's a bit more expensive but an easy way to help hit your protein goals.0
-
but protien levels should be calculated of Lean body mass not %fat. I think there is more to lean body mass than total mass - fat but I may be mistaken
LBM = (100% - BF%) x bodyweight0 -
If you eat bread, there's a bread called P28 that has 14g protein per slice (28g for 2 slices). The slices are huge, one slice is easily the equivalent of two slices of regular bread. It's a bit more expensive but an easy way to help hit your protein goals.
omg I've heard of that stuff and I am so curious as to where on this beautiful earth I can find it!! it looks awesome!0 -
Hey guys so I took all of your advice and came up with some new numbers. My calories are 1757 still but now my C/P/F is 132/154/68
That actually sounds too easy and too good to be true. What do you guys think??0 -
Hey guys so I took all of your advice and came up with some new numbers. My calories are 1757 still but now my C/P/F is 132/154/68
That actually sounds too easy and too good to be true. What do you guys think??
Looks good to me. A lot easier and cheaper, too.0 -
Hey guys so I took all of your advice and came up with some new numbers. My calories are 1757 still but now my C/P/F is 132/154/68
That actually sounds too easy and too good to be true. What do you guys think??
Looks good to me. A lot easier and cheaper, too.
Definitely. Thanks a lot! Tomorrow will be much better haha0 -
Try adding in some Almonds - but don't go over 20/day. That should help with Proteins for snacks, etc during the day without killing your carb count.
Almonds. Are. Not. A. Good. Source. Of. Protein.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions