Skip to content
  • Register
    • We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

    Milk Vs. Water

    135

    Replies

    • Posts: 4,899 Member
      show previous quotes
      And don't forget vegetables. Plants don't grow just so that people can eat them.

      Save the carrots. Eat a cow.
    • Posts: 17,857 Member
      show previous quotes


      You have been misinformed.
      Please do inform us then.
    • Posts: 16,913 Member
      show previous quotes

      Save the carrots. Eat a cow.

      My policy in a nutshell.

      But not an actual nutshell.

      Because nuts are gross.
    • Posts: 354
      show previous quotes

      You're back?

      I am!
    • Posts: 16,356 Member
      show previous quotes

      Save the carrots. Eat a cow.
      Agreed. Carrots don't poop all over everything, have tongues that extend into their nostrils for easier cleaning and don't expel 60 second long farts.
    • Posts: 17,857 Member
      Water is not milk, coffee, soda, vegetables....yes it may be in those things but it does not can not replace water.
      Then how did I survive for years at a time without drinking the "water" that I supposedly cannot live without? Am I a wizard?
    • Unknown
      Unknown
      This content has been removed.
    • Posts: 108 Member
      Considering that I've been drinking milk multiple times a day for more than two decades (as long as I can remember I have drank multiple glasses a day, milk is a very popular daily beverage in rural South Africa), if it dehydrated you or did not adequately hydrate you, I would be dead by now, as there have been periods of time where I drank nothing but milk for hydration for months on end.

      Milk is fantastic, there's obviously the protein, and then it also has a decent amount of carbs in it, which is absolutely necessary for a good bulk, along with a relatively decent amount of calories depending on what kind you get (I always drink 2%).

      Even on a cut milk works pretty well, as it's fairly filling.
      Milk is just a very easy "shortcut" bodybuilding food, although I don't like calling it that because to me it's always been a staple. I also don't get how anyone can ever drink a protein shake without milk, drinking whey with water is like putting water in your cereal, it's gross, and as this thread would call it, unnatural.

      EDIT: I say this as someone who has been a gymnast for close to ten years now, I've absolutely needed to be tiny but also subsist on a diet that would give me adequate energy and in certain cases, muscle building potential, milk has always been on of the easiest ways to make it work. In highschool I weighed a lean 135 pounds and was shredded as hell. I still drank several glasses a day.
    • Posts: 187 Member
      Personally try to avoid milk as often as I can. It's unnatural for us to drink the milk of another animal, but as long as you aren't lactose intolerant it really shouldn't be a problem. Moderation is key. I drink almond milk. Skim milk only on cheat days. There are many other "wheys" to get your protein (see what I did there).

      Good point. I will now start substituting cows blood for cows milk.
    • Posts: 17,857 Member
      so if one was marooned on an island with no fresh water source, no way to distill water from the sea, and an unlimited supply of beer they would die of dehydration by drinking the beer?
      No, because they would be able to use the empties to build a makeshift raft and float back to the mainland.
    • Posts: 354
      show previous quotes
      Then how did I survive for years at a time without drinking the "water" that I supposedly cannot live without? Am I a wizard?
      images?q=tbn:ANd9GcR-Vp_tGQ54DC3nSc0dz6bfk4Ohy8QpdaDynDdLDE_SF4Q5eBJtTA
    • Posts: 417 Member
      so if one was marooned on an island with no fresh water source, no way to distill water from the sea, and an unlimited supply of beer they would die of dehydration by drinking the beer?

      I volunteer to test this immediately.
    • Posts: 111 Member
      All I know is, looking back on my life, when I stopped drinking milk, my health began to deteriorate... Yes, I never drank water growing up, only drank tons of whole milk...Stopped in my 20's... I was always known for my really, thick, very strong, shiny, long, curly hair and my amazingly, long beautiful and strong, indestructable, nails. Milk was the ONLY thing that I had changed, because I thought it wasn't cool or adult enough, to drink anymore. Stupid. ( My hair and nails are NOTHING now, compared to what they used to be. I used up all of my "reserves"...lol... ) Milk was the only variable. The milk back then, didn't have all the hormones in it either, so it was maybe healthier. I know it is more expensive, but maybe, you can supplement with organic milk once in a while, too, with your regular milk drinking... to keep it even healthier. ) : ) I vote yes to milk! :drinker: p.s. Yes, I was super healthy, too. Never got sick... :happy:
      OH!!! I stopped drinking as much milk as I used to when I started on this health journey. My nails are HORRIBLE!!! This makes sense! I never had issues before. Hmmmm....Think I'll add some milk back to my diet. But in moderation of course. It does spike my blood sugars a bit. :) Thanks for the revelation.
    • Posts: 16,913 Member
      Wait wait wait.

      Skim milk...on cheat days?

      Worst cheat days ever?
    • Posts: 17,857 Member
      Okay anyone corrects me, I'm not claming for be a scientist or an expert of any kind. But here is my arguement on the whole milk vs. Water thing

      Now from what I could imagine, there are more than one type of milk. And depending on the amount of "stuff" you add in your milk, it may make the milk to be more concentrated than your body cells (hypertonic). As a result, water from your cells could be drawn OUT in order to dilute the extra cellular environment. And you get DEhydrated.

      Well. Okay. That's my hypothesis. I don't like milk but at the same time I admit that milk isn't bad for the human by any mean. And yes it is perfectly natural to eat/drink other animal's nutritional products, because we aren't cannibals. Just want to throw out a POSSIBLE explanation to his madness.
      And the babies eat/drink nothing but milk, how do you explain their existence?
    • Posts: 122
      I never really thought that I would have to defend water intake.

      But clearly I'm stupid and don't know how to read so I'll just exit now.

      Have a fantastic day :)
    • Posts: 111 Member
      show previous quotes

      Save the carrots. Eat a cow.

      LOL!!!! OH MY WORD!!!! LOL!!!! :laugh:
    • Posts: 3,049 Member
      I never really thought that I would have to defend water intake.

      But clearly I'm stupid and don't know how to read so I'll just exit now.

      Have a fantastic day :)
      You said it, not us! :flowerforyou:
    • Posts: 3,927 Member
      i get a two-fer in this one! ok - stick with me:

      childhood obesity for political gains - religious eating - free space - other liquids vs water - milk for baby cows

      BINGO!!!!!!!!
    • Posts: 16,356 Member
      I never really thought that I would have to defend water intake.

      But clearly I'm stupid and don't know how to read so I'll just exit now.

      Have a fantastic day :)

      Too bad you never actually defended anything.

      The rest was said by you.

      You have a fantabulous day was well. Go knowledge!
    • Posts: 37
      Personally try to avoid milk as often as I can. It's unnatural for us to drink the milk of another animal, but as long as you aren't lactose intolerant it really shouldn't be a problem. Moderation is key. I drink almond milk. Skim milk only on cheat days. There are many other "wheys" to get your protein (see what I did there).

      Whaaaaaaaa???? So, it would be PERFECTLY "natural" for a 40 year old man to drink his mother's breast milk still?? Your definition of natural is not doing it for me. Nice try though...

      Pretty sure people have been drinking milk for thousands of years without issues (barring the allergic minority)...carry on!!
    • Posts: 1,142 Member
      If you are trying to bulk up, throw some Whey Protein in the milk. I use Whey Isolate with Almond Milk as I'm trying to loose weight.
    • Posts: 4,899 Member
      show previous quotes

      I volunteer to test this immediately.

      In for science
    • Posts: 16,356 Member
      Wait wait wait.

      Skim milk...on cheat days?

      Worst cheat days ever?

      DownloadedFile_zps2f760a05.jpeg
    • Posts: 7,166 Member
      I actually greatly prefer skim milk to whole or even 2%. My oldest daughter is the same. We go through 4 gallons of milk every week or two at my house, two skim and two 2% for the little ones.
    • Posts: 34,415 Member
      I never really thought that I would have to defend water intake.

      But clearly I'm stupid and don't know how to read so I'll just exit now.

      Have a fantastic day :)

      [goldenflounce.gif]
    • Posts: 16,913 Member
      I never really thought that I would have to defend water intake.

      But clearly I'm stupid and don't know how to read so I'll just exit now.

      Have a fantastic day :)

      "I have been proven wrong with my own copy-pasta so, rather than admit that, try to learn something, and be graceful I'm gonna try to get snarky and flounce. Good Day. I SAID GOOD DAY."
    • Posts: 16,913 Member
      I actually greatly prefer skim milk to whole or even 2%. My oldest daughter is the same. We go through 4 gallons of milk every week or two at my house, two skim and two 2% for the little ones.

      Skim milk tastes like water. :sick:
    • Posts: 34,415 Member
      i get a two-fer in this one! ok - stick with me:

      childhood obesity for political gains - religious eating - free space - other liquids vs water - milk for baby cows

      BINGO!!!!!!!!

      DAMMIT! I just needed "detoxifying cleanse" which is almost as easy as "free".

      Okay, new game starts in 3 minutes...(7:00p GMT).

      Good luck everyone!
    • Posts: 32,662 Member
      Wait wait wait.

      Skim milk...on cheat days?

      Worst cheat days ever?

      HA!
    This discussion has been closed.

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register

    Quick Links

    Categories