Opinions / Experiance on Low Carb, High Fat, Moderate Protein Diet
dancafc1995
Posts: 25 Member
Hi guys so this is my first week at being on a Low carb mod protein high fat diet, according to the scales i have lost around 2 pounds so i know something is going correctly. I honestly do not have a lot of weight to lose as i am 19 years old, 5 foot 9, 158 pounds, im really doing this as i want to shed a bit of belly fat but also change my diet to one that i can sustain and make myself healthier in the long term. This first week has not gone to bad, i seem to be filling up a lot quick on High fat, Moderate protein and Low Carb, Before this week by the time i reached around 2000-2300 calories i would be hungry for more sweets, biscuits, that sort of thing, but now its like my body knows when it is naturally full. An example of the sorts of foods a have been eating are -
Steaks, Lean meats, Eggs, Fish such as Sardines or Tuna, Full fat mayonnaise, Peanut Butter, Almonds, Walnuts, and Vegetables and salads such as Tomatoes, Iceberg lettuce, Cucumber, Carrots, that sort of thing. Most days i try to keep my carb intake anywhere from 20g to 50g of carbs, Fat usually is around 90g - 120g a day and protein is around 150g - 180g a day. So what do you think guys? is this diet working for any of you, can you give me any tips?, i would appreciate any feedback thanks, Dan
also my diary is open.
Steaks, Lean meats, Eggs, Fish such as Sardines or Tuna, Full fat mayonnaise, Peanut Butter, Almonds, Walnuts, and Vegetables and salads such as Tomatoes, Iceberg lettuce, Cucumber, Carrots, that sort of thing. Most days i try to keep my carb intake anywhere from 20g to 50g of carbs, Fat usually is around 90g - 120g a day and protein is around 150g - 180g a day. So what do you think guys? is this diet working for any of you, can you give me any tips?, i would appreciate any feedback thanks, Dan
also my diary is open. 0
Replies
-
I've been at keto-level for 5 mo. (20g net carbs)
If you have trouble, you might want to lower protein and raise fat. As in switch your protein and fat ranges. But if what you are doing right now is working for you, leave it be for awhile longer. Changes may take 2 weeks for you to get enough info to tell if the tweak is working.
Make sure you get enough electrolytes. Your workout performance will suffer if you don't. And you will generally feel run-down.
And remember, calories do count.
I'm not sure whether or not your aim is just low-carb or ketosis but you might want to check out the low-carb or keto groups here. They've got some knowledgeable folks.
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/group/1143-keto
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/group/394-low-carber-daily-forum-the-group
0 -
don't get me wrong, I love nuts -
but, I need to warn you that most nuts break down into Omega 6 fats (not the good omega 3) - so be really careful not to rely on them as a daily protein/fat source. if you do, it may be detrimental to your cholesterol readings over the long-term.
having a meat and oil source in every meal will help with hunger, stick to healthy oils - grass fed butter, olive oil, coconut oil, avocado oil...
noticed the lack of breakfast - is this the norm? ... if you start the day nourished, you might not need to snack on nuts so much to get you through to the other meals.
Nothing wrong with adding in eggs, canadian bacon, real bacon and dozens of other protein and fat sources to kickstart the day and energize you.0 -
This type of diet isn't something I can try. I'm supposed to go low fat. But if your doctor approves, then you should stick with it! Good luck!0
-
My experience has been this: I drop a nice amount of weight...8-ish pounds...and then it all just comes to a grinding halt unless I then reduce my calories too. For me, no matter how low-carb I go, calories do still ultimately count.
Everyone's different, though. My BIL lost something like 40 lbs. low-carbing. He gained it back when he went off the wagon, but then again, that's pretty much true of any eating plan/diet...you go off the wagon and the weight comes back.0 -
Do you think i could remain in ketosis eating around 20g to sometimes 50g a day?. im around 160 pounds and only want to lose 3 to maybe 5 pounds. When i achieve my goal i will consistently eat around 50g carbs a day0
-
well, I guess I need to ask the reason why you're interested in ketosis? Usually people think of that type of carb restriction because they have gross amounts of fat to lose. In your situation, it seems to be a bit overkill. If you take up a good weight-training routine, you'll tone and show muscles in no time, without having to go through the difficulties of keeping to such a restricted carb level.0
-
I also hesitate to tell anyone to eat ketosis levels unless a last resort. Take into account how many people went the Atkins diet route lost tons of weight, and then as soon as they added carbs back, the weight fell on them like crazy.
I'm not saying low carb is bad, but when you go to the low ketosis levels, it's very difficult to come out of that type of restricted type diet and not gain. and, for a 5 lb fat loss, totally not worth that future battle.
why not start your low carb process with 100 carbs, with no grains, and no processed foods. See how your body reacts to it - and, if you don't lose in a few weeks - then consider a stricter regimen.
-0 -
vegetables and good nutrition is your ultimate friend. the protein/fat parts are just to help with satiety and offer control mechanisms for cravings.
Nutritious= good
healthy=good
control=good
Ketosis - for someone who does not need to lose weight, (obese people) - possibly ok. It doesn't make sense to use this method if you're already close to your ideal weight...0 -
dancafc1995 wrote: »Do you think i could remain in ketosis eating around 20g to sometimes 50g a day?. im around 160 pounds and only want to lose 3 to maybe 5 pounds. When i achieve my goal i will consistently eat around 50g carbs a day
It depends. Some people can but when I used to be on an LC board, it seemed like the majority had to be at 40g or under, with a fair percentage needing 25g or under to get/stay in ketosis.
0 -
RoseyDgirl wrote: »I also hesitate to tell anyone to eat ketosis levels unless a last resort. Take into account how many people went the Atkins diet route lost tons of weight, and then as soon as they added carbs back, the weight fell on them like crazy.
I'm not saying low carb is bad, but when you go to the low ketosis levels, it's very difficult to come out of that type of restricted type diet and not gain. and, for a 5 lb fat loss, totally not worth that future battle.
why not start your low carb process with 100 carbs, with no grains, and no processed foods. See how your body reacts to it - and, if you don't lose in a few weeks - then consider a stricter regimen.
-
That's because they are eating too many calories, not because they started eating too many carbs.0 -
dancafc1995 wrote: »Do you think i could remain in ketosis eating around 20g to sometimes 50g a day?. im around 160 pounds and only want to lose 3 to maybe 5 pounds. When i achieve my goal i will consistently eat around 50g carbs a day
It depends. Some people can but when I used to be on an LC board, it seemed like the majority had to be at 40g or under, with a fair percentage needing 25g or under to get/stay in ketosis.
I agree. I don't do as well when I fluctuate my carbs too high personally. You'll have to figure your personal threshold. But that meams keeping them consistantly low for 1 to 2 weeks to get there in the first place. I don't recommend raising it until after that time.
0 -
dancafc1995 wrote: »So what do you think guys? is this diet working for any of you, can you give me any tips?, i would appreciate any feedback thanks, Dan also my diary is open.
It has worked really well for me. I've dropped about 30 pounds and am within a normal weight for my height. Recently, I did my annual labs. My doctor said she wished her other patients had the same great labs. A1C was superb. LDL/HDL/triglycerides were amazingly good. They were so solidly in the range you want to be in. I have never had triglycerides that low (60) or HDL (good cholesterol) that high or a blood sugar average that low (5.0).
I wouldn't test right after you start keto. It takes a while for your body to stabilize on this, so test after you've been on it for several months or you'll get wacky results.
I match my exercise intensity to how many carbs I've had. If I had too many carbs (I eat about 30 grams a day) then I up the intensity of my workout.0 -
I've been eating this way for years, and it's worked great for general health.
Why is your protein so high? Unless you're a juicing pro-bodybuilder, I'm pretty sure that's not doing much for you.
0 -
I have heard a lot about the low-carb high-fat diet. I've hit a frustrating plateau on a general low-calorie diet while exercising 5 days a week, and I'm willing to try a different approach like this one. Any feedback on how this has gone for others would be greatly appreciated! Also, does this diet cause high cholesterol or any other issues? Thanks!0
-
melissagb1016 wrote: »I have heard a lot about the low-carb high-fat diet. I've hit a frustrating plateau on a general low-calorie diet while exercising 5 days a week, and I'm willing to try a different approach like this one. Any feedback on how this has gone for others would be greatly appreciated! Also, does this diet cause high cholesterol or any other issues? Thanks!
And to OP as well:
I have done 5 % carbs/ 65 % fats/ 30 % protein . It took me 3 days for my body to get into ketosis. I lasted a full 1.5 weeks lol
Cholesterol is variable but for the most part, most people on keto say that it either decreases or says the same. A study here shows decrease : http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19641727
Keep in mind, you will be consuming foods high in HDL and low in LDL. LDL levels are what you should worry about.
I felt lethargic, and sickly the duration of this diet. My gym performance suffered greatly without carbs, however a lot of people swear by it after the induction phase. I didn't make it that far lol.
What I dislike is if you are used to eating carbs, which are usually dense foods, fats are not as satiating as you can consume one tablespoon of olive oil and that would be a good 200 or so calories vs a bowl of oatmeal with the same amount of calories.
If you exercise frequently, it may be hard without carbs as they are your body's main source of energy.
I feel like any diet can produce almost the same results without such a drastic change in lifestyle. Keto empties out your stores of glycogen which in turn decreases water weight, giving the illusion of increased weight loss.
-1 -
I did it - way back when
Lost weight easily with minimal fuss
Put it all back on in an amazingly short time when I started to eat carbs again and then put on even more weight
So if you're not sticking to this for life - be extremely careful when you reintroduce your carbs0 -
@melissa
well been there
lost 33kg on atkins and tried nutritional ketosis for 3 months but lost nothing anymore..
I also wrote to Tim Noakes and he said I should try a higher protein amount which I am doing now and therefore I also lowered kcal.... so seems to work
try that.. "banting" can also be higher protein.. several bodybuilders said to me higher protein is better cause ketosis isnt necessary for fat loss and the body has to use fat from your body itself.. if you just feed fat externally your body will use less or nothing from itself0 -
Great to hear all your stories.
I was very skeptical with this LCHF diet until I went on it and continually investigated its claims. I have been on it since Friday 14th November 2014. My current weight is 97.8kg down from 100kg.
I felt very lethargic in my 2-3 weeks, sometimes called "Atkins Flu" (similar to zSandman describes). Took 4 days of training off and slept. Cramping in the stomach and constipation. One day I ate my usual diet of high carbs (hoping to improve the constipation and lethargy) and felt a little better but learnt more about the Diet, finding out that I had the "Atkins Flu" from the Atkins Diet.
My vitals that I have been measuring have improved (yet to have regular blood analysis) including my Blood Pressure has improving low risk safe limits (128/73 HR40). I have had hypertension most of my life (sporting one at that) and have been taking meds for it for quite a long time (>10 years) due to my father also suffering the same. My BP has never been this good.
I am a relatively very tall large active paddler training for the Australian National Dragon Boat "Auroras" team to compete in the World Championships in August 2015. My coach before I secured my selection said he wanted me to be 95kg and have a six-pack and I was only a borderline selection. For more than 6 months leading up to the 3 day intensive selection trials on the 1st November 2014 I set MFP to 93kg goal weight starting at 104kg. Followed it religiously occasionally just going over my calorie count. During the selection camp I only got to down to just over 100kgs weight. The MFP calorie in and calories out stopped working for me? This meant my body weight bench marks tests were going to be hard as testing is based on lifting your bodyweight on Pull Ups, Bench press, situps, beep test and Paddling in a TK1 adapted kayak boat. I luckily made the the team and so my target is still to get to the 93kg weight soon and to have that 6-pack.
My doubts about the LCHF have been overcome with continuous research. I discovered that there are political reasons why the last 30 years of medical and health advice has deemed FAT the villain and the Carbohydrates as the healthy option. I have totally reversed my thinking, now with my nutrition pie chart report being dominated by villain red with a dash of blue carbohydrate. Most notable is that I don't feel the need to snack even when I am training twice a day 3 times a week and once eery other day. I have more energy and enjoy the fatty meals of scrambled eggs, bacon with all the fat, nuts, full cream milk, berries yogurt, cream, cappuccinos with a tsp of Stevia. Baked a New York Style Cheesecake for my wife's birthday, the cauliflower rice is interesting, cheese and butter on my vegetables.
Originally saw the diet on an Australia science program called
"Catalyst - LOW CARB DIET FAT OR FICTION" Thursday, 13 November 2014 http://www.abc.net.au/catalyst/stories/4126228.htm.
Other resources that have cemented my thoughts and belief are
ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT LOW CARB HIGH FAT
http://www.peterbrukner.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/All-you-need-to-know-about-LCHF1.pdf
BOOKS
The Art and Science of Low Carbohydrate Performance by Jeff Volek & Stephen Phinney
zSandman - I recommend this one for you as an athlete.
Why We Get Fat: And What to Do about It by Gary Taubes
I Quit Sugar for Life by Sarah Wilson
MOVIES
Cereal Killers http://www.cerealkillersmovie.com Highly recommended that you watch this first
Fat Head www.fathead-‐movie.com
YOUTUBE VIDEOS
Tim Noakes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5IYVIdztWWs&feature=youtu.be&desktop_uri=%2Fwatch%3F
v%3D5IYVIdztWWs%26feature%3Dyoutu.be&app=desktop
Grant Schofield http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j9Ovfw7mKR0
Gary Taubes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lDneyrETR2o
David Perlmutter “Grain Brain” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w2c2Oq-‐Pi2o
Wiliam Davis “Wheat Belly” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UbBURnqYVzw
Jeff Volek http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GC1vMBRFiwE
Peter Brukner http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JMuD4Z-‐Oxys
Peter Attia – diabetes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UMhLBPPtlrY
Robert Lustig–sugar
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-‐oM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m8dWNbEscOw
Mary Vernon http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kaquSijXJkQ
I need somebody to show me some resources to despute my findings as I'm quite convinced otherwise.
Cheers
Succeeding to date LCHF dieter and MFP user0 -
Pete Evans?foxyplayon wrote: »Great to hear all your stories.
I was very skeptical with this LCHF diet until I went on it and continually investigated its claims. I have been on it since Friday 14th November 2014. My current weight is 97.8kg down from 100kg.
I felt very lethargic in my 2-3 weeks, sometimes called "Atkins Flu" (similar to zSandman describes). Took 4 days of training off and slept. Cramping in the stomach and constipation. One day I ate my usual diet of high carbs (hoping to improve the constipation and lethargy) and felt a little better but learnt more about the Diet, finding out that I had the "Atkins Flu" from the Atkins Diet.
My vitals that I have been measuring have improved (yet to have regular blood analysis) including my Blood Pressure has improving low risk safe limits (128/73 HR40). I have had hypertension most of my life (sporting one at that) and have been taking meds for it for quite a long time (>10 years) due to my father also suffering the same. My BP has never been this good.
I am a relatively very tall large active paddler training for the Australian National Dragon Boat "Auroras" team to compete in the World Championships in August 2015. My coach before I secured my selection said he wanted me to be 95kg and have a six-pack and I was only a borderline selection. For more than 6 months leading up to the 3 day intensive selection trials on the 1st November 2014 I set MFP to 93kg goal weight starting at 104kg. Followed it religiously occasionally just going over my calorie count. During the selection camp I only got to down to just over 100kgs weight. The MFP calorie in and calories out stopped working for me? This meant my body weight bench marks tests were going to be hard as testing is based on lifting your bodyweight on Pull Ups, Bench press, situps, beep test and Paddling in a TK1 adapted kayak boat. I luckily made the the team and so my target is still to get to the 93kg weight soon and to have that 6-pack.
My doubts about the LCHF have been overcome with continuous research. I discovered that there are political reasons why the last 30 years of medical and health advice has deemed FAT the villain and the Carbohydrates as the healthy option. I have totally reversed my thinking, now with my nutrition pie chart report being dominated by villain red with a dash of blue carbohydrate. Most notable is that I don't feel the need to snack even when I am training twice a day 3 times a week and once eery other day. I have more energy and enjoy the fatty meals of scrambled eggs, bacon with all the fat, nuts, full cream milk, berries yogurt, cream, cappuccinos with a tsp of Stevia. Baked a New York Style Cheesecake for my wife's birthday, the cauliflower rice is interesting, cheese and butter on my vegetables.
Originally saw the diet on an Australia science program called
"Catalyst - LOW CARB DIET FAT OR FICTION" Thursday, 13 November 2014 http://www.abc.net.au/catalyst/stories/4126228.htm.
Other resources that have cemented my thoughts and belief are
ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT LOW CARB HIGH FAT
http://www.peterbrukner.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/All-you-need-to-know-about-LCHF1.pdf
BOOKS
The Art and Science of Low Carbohydrate Performance by Jeff Volek & Stephen Phinney
zSandman - I recommend this one for you as an athlete.
Why We Get Fat: And What to Do about It by Gary Taubes
I Quit Sugar for Life by Sarah Wilson
MOVIES
Cereal Killers http://www.cerealkillersmovie.com Highly recommended that you watch this first
Fat Head www.fathead-‐movie.com
YOUTUBE VIDEOS
Tim Noakes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5IYVIdztWWs&feature=youtu.be&desktop_uri=%2Fwatch%3F
v%3D5IYVIdztWWs%26feature%3Dyoutu.be&app=desktop
Grant Schofield http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j9Ovfw7mKR0
Gary Taubes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lDneyrETR2o
David Perlmutter “Grain Brain” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w2c2Oq-‐Pi2o
Wiliam Davis “Wheat Belly” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UbBURnqYVzw
Jeff Volek http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GC1vMBRFiwE
Peter Brukner http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JMuD4Z-‐Oxys
Peter Attia – diabetes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UMhLBPPtlrY
Robert Lustig–sugar
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-‐oM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m8dWNbEscOw
Mary Vernon http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kaquSijXJkQ
I need somebody to show me some resources to despute my findings as I'm quite convinced otherwise.
Cheers
Succeeding to date LCHF dieter and MFP user
Lol...sorry but this sounds like the stuff he peddles. Grain brain, wheat belly, I quit sugar, Lustig, etc.
When I'm on my laptop, and not iPad, I'll post some evidence to the contrary...unless someone beats me to it.
0 -
melissagb1016 wrote: »I have heard a lot about the low-carb high-fat diet. I've hit a frustrating plateau on a general low-calorie diet while exercising 5 days a week, and I'm willing to try a different approach like this one. Any feedback on how this has gone for others would be greatly appreciated! Also, does this diet cause high cholesterol or any other issues? Thanks!
And to OP as well:
I have done 5 % carbs/ 65 % fats/ 30 % protein . It took me 3 days for my body to get into ketosis. I lasted a full 1.5 weeks lol
Cholesterol is variable but for the most part, most people on keto say that it either decreases or says the same. A study here shows decrease : http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19641727
Keep in mind, you will be consuming foods high in HDL and low in LDL. LDL levels are what you should worry about.
I felt lethargic, and sickly the duration of this diet. My gym performance suffered greatly without carbs, however a lot of people swear by it after the induction phase. I didn't make it that far lol.
What I dislike is if you are used to eating carbs, which are usually dense foods, fats are not as satiating as you can consume one tablespoon of olive oil and that would be a good 200 or so calories vs a bowl of oatmeal with the same amount of calories.
If you exercise frequently, it may be hard without carbs as they are your body's main source of energy.
I feel like any diet can produce almost the same results without such a drastic change in lifestyle. Keto empties out your stores of glycogen which in turn decreases water weight, giving the illusion of increased weight loss.
No diet is for everyone. I've lost almost 70lbs doing Keto (I would say that about 5lbs was water weight), have loads of energy, exercise 5 times a week with no difficulty, and find the food very satisfying. It has decreased pain and chronic fatigue. I struggled for 17 years trying to do less "drastic" plans (ie simple calorie counting) and continually failed. For whatever reason, my body is very happy with this drastic plan. I didn't even have enough of a Keto-flu to bother mentioning. 3 days and I felt great and started working out. I find it very sustainable. But we are all different. Low-carb wasn't for you. That's ok. That doesn't mean that it doesn't work well for others. Simple, less drastic plans work well for many, but they also fail for many. I don't think it matters how you get there, as long as it improves your health and you do get there and stay there.0 -
Charlottesometimes23 wrote: »
Pete Evans?foxyplayon wrote: »Great to hear all your stories.
I was very skeptical with this LCHF diet until I went on it and continually investigated its claims. I have been on it since Friday 14th November 2014. My current weight is 97.8kg down from 100kg.
I felt very lethargic in my 2-3 weeks, sometimes called "Atkins Flu" (similar to zSandman describes). Took 4 days of training off and slept. Cramping in the stomach and constipation. One day I ate my usual diet of high carbs (hoping to improve the constipation and lethargy) and felt a little better but learnt more about the Diet, finding out that I had the "Atkins Flu" from the Atkins Diet.
My vitals that I have been measuring have improved (yet to have regular blood analysis) including my Blood Pressure has improving low risk safe limits (128/73 HR40). I have had hypertension most of my life (sporting one at that) and have been taking meds for it for quite a long time (>10 years) due to my father also suffering the same. My BP has never been this good.
I am a relatively very tall large active paddler training for the Australian National Dragon Boat "Auroras" team to compete in the World Championships in August 2015. My coach before I secured my selection said he wanted me to be 95kg and have a six-pack and I was only a borderline selection. For more than 6 months leading up to the 3 day intensive selection trials on the 1st November 2014 I set MFP to 93kg goal weight starting at 104kg. Followed it religiously occasionally just going over my calorie count. During the selection camp I only got to down to just over 100kgs weight. The MFP calorie in and calories out stopped working for me? This meant my body weight bench marks tests were going to be hard as testing is based on lifting your bodyweight on Pull Ups, Bench press, situps, beep test and Paddling in a TK1 adapted kayak boat. I luckily made the the team and so my target is still to get to the 93kg weight soon and to have that 6-pack.
My doubts about the LCHF have been overcome with continuous research. I discovered that there are political reasons why the last 30 years of medical and health advice has deemed FAT the villain and the Carbohydrates as the healthy option. I have totally reversed my thinking, now with my nutrition pie chart report being dominated by villain red with a dash of blue carbohydrate. Most notable is that I don't feel the need to snack even when I am training twice a day 3 times a week and once eery other day. I have more energy and enjoy the fatty meals of scrambled eggs, bacon with all the fat, nuts, full cream milk, berries yogurt, cream, cappuccinos with a tsp of Stevia. Baked a New York Style Cheesecake for my wife's birthday, the cauliflower rice is interesting, cheese and butter on my vegetables.
Originally saw the diet on an Australia science program called
"Catalyst - LOW CARB DIET FAT OR FICTION" Thursday, 13 November 2014 http://www.abc.net.au/catalyst/stories/4126228.htm.
Other resources that have cemented my thoughts and belief are
ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT LOW CARB HIGH FAT
http://www.peterbrukner.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/All-you-need-to-know-about-LCHF1.pdf
BOOKS
The Art and Science of Low Carbohydrate Performance by Jeff Volek & Stephen Phinney
zSandman - I recommend this one for you as an athlete.
Why We Get Fat: And What to Do about It by Gary Taubes
I Quit Sugar for Life by Sarah Wilson
MOVIES
Cereal Killers http://www.cerealkillersmovie.com Highly recommended that you watch this first
Fat Head www.fathead-‐movie.com
YOUTUBE VIDEOS
Tim Noakes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5IYVIdztWWs&feature=youtu.be&desktop_uri=%2Fwatch%3F
v%3D5IYVIdztWWs%26feature%3Dyoutu.be&app=desktop
Grant Schofield http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j9Ovfw7mKR0
Gary Taubes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lDneyrETR2o
David Perlmutter “Grain Brain” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w2c2Oq-‐Pi2o
Wiliam Davis “Wheat Belly” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UbBURnqYVzw
Jeff Volek http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GC1vMBRFiwE
Peter Brukner http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JMuD4Z-‐Oxys
Peter Attia – diabetes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UMhLBPPtlrY
Robert Lustig–sugar
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-‐oM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m8dWNbEscOw
Mary Vernon http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kaquSijXJkQ
I need somebody to show me some resources to despute my findings as I'm quite convinced otherwise.
Cheers
Succeeding to date LCHF dieter and MFP user
Lol...sorry but this sounds like the stuff he peddles. Grain brain, wheat belly, I quit sugar, Lustig, etc.
When I'm on my laptop, and not iPad, I'll post some evidence to the contrary...unless someone beats me to it.
What's to dispute? He is healthy and performing well. Nobody's saying ketogenic diets are the only one or the best one. It's one road among many roads leading to health.0 -
baconslave wrote: »Charlottesometimes23 wrote: »
Pete Evans?foxyplayon wrote: »Great to hear all your stories.
I was very skeptical with this LCHF diet until I went on it and continually investigated its claims. I have been on it since Friday 14th November 2014. My current weight is 97.8kg down from 100kg.
I felt very lethargic in my 2-3 weeks, sometimes called "Atkins Flu" (similar to zSandman describes). Took 4 days of training off and slept. Cramping in the stomach and constipation. One day I ate my usual diet of high carbs (hoping to improve the constipation and lethargy) and felt a little better but learnt more about the Diet, finding out that I had the "Atkins Flu" from the Atkins Diet.
My vitals that I have been measuring have improved (yet to have regular blood analysis) including my Blood Pressure has improving low risk safe limits (128/73 HR40). I have had hypertension most of my life (sporting one at that) and have been taking meds for it for quite a long time (>10 years) due to my father also suffering the same. My BP has never been this good.
I am a relatively very tall large active paddler training for the Australian National Dragon Boat "Auroras" team to compete in the World Championships in August 2015. My coach before I secured my selection said he wanted me to be 95kg and have a six-pack and I was only a borderline selection. For more than 6 months leading up to the 3 day intensive selection trials on the 1st November 2014 I set MFP to 93kg goal weight starting at 104kg. Followed it religiously occasionally just going over my calorie count. During the selection camp I only got to down to just over 100kgs weight. The MFP calorie in and calories out stopped working for me? This meant my body weight bench marks tests were going to be hard as testing is based on lifting your bodyweight on Pull Ups, Bench press, situps, beep test and Paddling in a TK1 adapted kayak boat. I luckily made the the team and so my target is still to get to the 93kg weight soon and to have that 6-pack.
My doubts about the LCHF have been overcome with continuous research. I discovered that there are political reasons why the last 30 years of medical and health advice has deemed FAT the villain and the Carbohydrates as the healthy option. I have totally reversed my thinking, now with my nutrition pie chart report being dominated by villain red with a dash of blue carbohydrate. Most notable is that I don't feel the need to snack even when I am training twice a day 3 times a week and once eery other day. I have more energy and enjoy the fatty meals of scrambled eggs, bacon with all the fat, nuts, full cream milk, berries yogurt, cream, cappuccinos with a tsp of Stevia. Baked a New York Style Cheesecake for my wife's birthday, the cauliflower rice is interesting, cheese and butter on my vegetables.
Originally saw the diet on an Australia science program called
"Catalyst - LOW CARB DIET FAT OR FICTION" Thursday, 13 November 2014 http://www.abc.net.au/catalyst/stories/4126228.htm.
Other resources that have cemented my thoughts and belief are
ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT LOW CARB HIGH FAT
http://www.peterbrukner.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/All-you-need-to-know-about-LCHF1.pdf
BOOKS
The Art and Science of Low Carbohydrate Performance by Jeff Volek & Stephen Phinney
zSandman - I recommend this one for you as an athlete.
Why We Get Fat: And What to Do about It by Gary Taubes
I Quit Sugar for Life by Sarah Wilson
MOVIES
Cereal Killers http://www.cerealkillersmovie.com Highly recommended that you watch this first
Fat Head www.fathead-‐movie.com
YOUTUBE VIDEOS
Tim Noakes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5IYVIdztWWs&feature=youtu.be&desktop_uri=%2Fwatch%3F
v%3D5IYVIdztWWs%26feature%3Dyoutu.be&app=desktop
Grant Schofield http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j9Ovfw7mKR0
Gary Taubes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lDneyrETR2o
David Perlmutter “Grain Brain” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w2c2Oq-‐Pi2o
Wiliam Davis “Wheat Belly” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UbBURnqYVzw
Jeff Volek http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GC1vMBRFiwE
Peter Brukner http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JMuD4Z-‐Oxys
Peter Attia – diabetes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UMhLBPPtlrY
Robert Lustig–sugar
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-‐oM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m8dWNbEscOw
Mary Vernon http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kaquSijXJkQ
I need somebody to show me some resources to despute my findings as I'm quite convinced otherwise.
Cheers
Succeeding to date LCHF dieter and MFP user
Lol...sorry but this sounds like the stuff he peddles. Grain brain, wheat belly, I quit sugar, Lustig, etc.
When I'm on my laptop, and not iPad, I'll post some evidence to the contrary...unless someone beats me to it.
What's to dispute? He is healthy and performing well. Nobody's saying ketogenic diets are the only one or the best one. It's one road among many roads leading to health.
As a fellow Australian with an Australian perspective, it is clear that he has been influenced by a recent controversial Catalyst program and Pete Evans, a Paleo celeb chef who regularly makes a twit of himself due to his lack of nutrition knowledge and conspiracy theories. His readings are full of what could be considered pseudoscience (eg. I Quit Sugar) and he appeared open to other perspectives. Do you have a problem with a balanced perspective?
-1 -
foxyplayon wrote: »Great to hear all your stories.
I was very skeptical with this LCHF diet until I went on it and continually investigated its claims. I have been on it since Friday 14th November 2014. My current weight is 97.8kg down from 100kg.
I felt very lethargic in my 2-3 weeks, sometimes called "Atkins Flu" (similar to zSandman describes). Took 4 days of training off and slept. Cramping in the stomach and constipation. One day I ate my usual diet of high carbs (hoping to improve the constipation and lethargy) and felt a little better but learnt more about the Diet, finding out that I had the "Atkins Flu" from the Atkins Diet.
My vitals that I have been measuring have improved (yet to have regular blood analysis) including my Blood Pressure has improving low risk safe limits (128/73 HR40). I have had hypertension most of my life (sporting one at that) and have been taking meds for it for quite a long time (>10 years) due to my father also suffering the same. My BP has never been this good.
I am a relatively very tall large active paddler training for the Australian National Dragon Boat "Auroras" team to compete in the World Championships in August 2015. My coach before I secured my selection said he wanted me to be 95kg and have a six-pack and I was only a borderline selection. For more than 6 months leading up to the 3 day intensive selection trials on the 1st November 2014 I set MFP to 93kg goal weight starting at 104kg. Followed it religiously occasionally just going over my calorie count. During the selection camp I only got to down to just over 100kgs weight. The MFP calorie in and calories out stopped working for me? This meant my body weight bench marks tests were going to be hard as testing is based on lifting your bodyweight on Pull Ups, Bench press, situps, beep test and Paddling in a TK1 adapted kayak boat. I luckily made the the team and so my target is still to get to the 93kg weight soon and to have that 6-pack.
My doubts about the LCHF have been overcome with continuous research. I discovered that there are political reasons why the last 30 years of medical and health advice has deemed FAT the villain and the Carbohydrates as the healthy option. I have totally reversed my thinking, now with my nutrition pie chart report being dominated by villain red with a dash of blue carbohydrate. Most notable is that I don't feel the need to snack even when I am training twice a day 3 times a week and once eery other day. I have more energy and enjoy the fatty meals of scrambled eggs, bacon with all the fat, nuts, full cream milk, berries yogurt, cream, cappuccinos with a tsp of Stevia. Baked a New York Style Cheesecake for my wife's birthday, the cauliflower rice is interesting, cheese and butter on my vegetables.
Originally saw the diet on an Australia science program called
"Catalyst - LOW CARB DIET FAT OR FICTION" Thursday, 13 November 2014 http://www.abc.net.au/catalyst/stories/4126228.htm.
Other resources that have cemented my thoughts and belief are
ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT LOW CARB HIGH FAT
http://www.peterbrukner.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/All-you-need-to-know-about-LCHF1.pdf
BOOKS
The Art and Science of Low Carbohydrate Performance by Jeff Volek & Stephen Phinney
zSandman - I recommend this one for you as an athlete.
Why We Get Fat: And What to Do about It by Gary Taubes
I Quit Sugar for Life by Sarah Wilson
MOVIES
Cereal Killers http://www.cerealkillersmovie.com Highly recommended that you watch this first
Fat Head www.fathead-‐movie.com
YOUTUBE VIDEOS
Tim Noakes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5IYVIdztWWs&feature=youtu.be&desktop_uri=%2Fwatch%3F
v%3D5IYVIdztWWs%26feature%3Dyoutu.be&app=desktop
Grant Schofield http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j9Ovfw7mKR0
Gary Taubes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lDneyrETR2o
David Perlmutter “Grain Brain” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w2c2Oq-‐Pi2o
Wiliam Davis “Wheat Belly” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UbBURnqYVzw
Jeff Volek http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GC1vMBRFiwE
Peter Brukner http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JMuD4Z-‐Oxys
Peter Attia – diabetes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UMhLBPPtlrY
Robert Lustig–sugar
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-‐oM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m8dWNbEscOw
Mary Vernon http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kaquSijXJkQ
I need somebody to show me some resources to despute my findings as I'm quite convinced otherwise.
Cheers
Succeeding to date LCHF dieter and MFP user
If you are interested in reading other perspectives, thinkingnutrition.com.au/ written by Tim Crowe an Associate Professor in Nutrition in the School of Exercise and Nutrition Sciences at Deakin University in Melbourne and Accredited Practising Dietitian is excellent IMO.
0 -
Charlottesometimes23 wrote: »baconslave wrote: »Charlottesometimes23 wrote: »
Pete Evans?foxyplayon wrote: »Great to hear all your stories.
I was very skeptical with this LCHF diet until I went on it and continually investigated its claims. I have been on it since Friday 14th November 2014. My current weight is 97.8kg down from 100kg.
I felt very lethargic in my 2-3 weeks, sometimes called "Atkins Flu" (similar to zSandman describes). Took 4 days of training off and slept. Cramping in the stomach and constipation. One day I ate my usual diet of high carbs (hoping to improve the constipation and lethargy) and felt a little better but learnt more about the Diet, finding out that I had the "Atkins Flu" from the Atkins Diet.
My vitals that I have been measuring have improved (yet to have regular blood analysis) including my Blood Pressure has improving low risk safe limits (128/73 HR40). I have had hypertension most of my life (sporting one at that) and have been taking meds for it for quite a long time (>10 years) due to my father also suffering the same. My BP has never been this good.
I am a relatively very tall large active paddler training for the Australian National Dragon Boat "Auroras" team to compete in the World Championships in August 2015. My coach before I secured my selection said he wanted me to be 95kg and have a six-pack and I was only a borderline selection. For more than 6 months leading up to the 3 day intensive selection trials on the 1st November 2014 I set MFP to 93kg goal weight starting at 104kg. Followed it religiously occasionally just going over my calorie count. During the selection camp I only got to down to just over 100kgs weight. The MFP calorie in and calories out stopped working for me? This meant my body weight bench marks tests were going to be hard as testing is based on lifting your bodyweight on Pull Ups, Bench press, situps, beep test and Paddling in a TK1 adapted kayak boat. I luckily made the the team and so my target is still to get to the 93kg weight soon and to have that 6-pack.
My doubts about the LCHF have been overcome with continuous research. I discovered that there are political reasons why the last 30 years of medical and health advice has deemed FAT the villain and the Carbohydrates as the healthy option. I have totally reversed my thinking, now with my nutrition pie chart report being dominated by villain red with a dash of blue carbohydrate. Most notable is that I don't feel the need to snack even when I am training twice a day 3 times a week and once eery other day. I have more energy and enjoy the fatty meals of scrambled eggs, bacon with all the fat, nuts, full cream milk, berries yogurt, cream, cappuccinos with a tsp of Stevia. Baked a New York Style Cheesecake for my wife's birthday, the cauliflower rice is interesting, cheese and butter on my vegetables.
Originally saw the diet on an Australia science program called
"Catalyst - LOW CARB DIET FAT OR FICTION" Thursday, 13 November 2014 http://www.abc.net.au/catalyst/stories/4126228.htm.
Other resources that have cemented my thoughts and belief are
ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT LOW CARB HIGH FAT
http://www.peterbrukner.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/All-you-need-to-know-about-LCHF1.pdf
BOOKS
The Art and Science of Low Carbohydrate Performance by Jeff Volek & Stephen Phinney
zSandman - I recommend this one for you as an athlete.
Why We Get Fat: And What to Do about It by Gary Taubes
I Quit Sugar for Life by Sarah Wilson
MOVIES
Cereal Killers http://www.cerealkillersmovie.com Highly recommended that you watch this first
Fat Head www.fathead-‐movie.com
YOUTUBE VIDEOS
Tim Noakes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5IYVIdztWWs&feature=youtu.be&desktop_uri=%2Fwatch%3F
v%3D5IYVIdztWWs%26feature%3Dyoutu.be&app=desktop
Grant Schofield http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j9Ovfw7mKR0
Gary Taubes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lDneyrETR2o
David Perlmutter “Grain Brain” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w2c2Oq-‐Pi2o
Wiliam Davis “Wheat Belly” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UbBURnqYVzw
Jeff Volek http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GC1vMBRFiwE
Peter Brukner http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JMuD4Z-‐Oxys
Peter Attia – diabetes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UMhLBPPtlrY
Robert Lustig–sugar
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-‐oM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m8dWNbEscOw
Mary Vernon http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kaquSijXJkQ
I need somebody to show me some resources to despute my findings as I'm quite convinced otherwise.
Cheers
Succeeding to date LCHF dieter and MFP user
Lol...sorry but this sounds like the stuff he peddles. Grain brain, wheat belly, I quit sugar, Lustig, etc.
When I'm on my laptop, and not iPad, I'll post some evidence to the contrary...unless someone beats me to it.
What's to dispute? He is healthy and performing well. Nobody's saying ketogenic diets are the only one or the best one. It's one road among many roads leading to health.
As a fellow Australian with an Australian perspective, it is clear that he has been influenced by a recent controversial Catalyst program and Pete Evans, a Paleo celeb chef who regularly makes a twit of himself due to his lack of nutrition knowledge. His readings are full of what could be considered pseudoscience (eg. I Quit Sugar) and he appeared open to other perspectives. Do you have a problem with a balanced perspective?
Nope.0 -
I don't know but your protein sounds high not moderate to me. There should be a percentage thing going on. % calories from carbs, % cals from fat and % cals from protein. If your protein is more than your fat, then you are doing high protein.
Secondly you should understand that protein will be converted to energy if there is insufficient fat to meet the needs of your body.
You should not eat more protein than you actually need because this is overworking the kidneys and if following this regimen in the longterm could lead to kidney problems. So protein must be sensible. Find out how much is recommended for men. this should apply to all of us whether on low carb or not. That's the base line. If you are doing a lot of exercise, then you can increase your protein intake. But try to follow guidelines on this. With that said, in the beginning of your low carb experience, i have understood that a bit higher protein is required until your body is producing ketones. this is about fuelling the brain.
When not on low carb, the body uses carbs for fuel. When you start low carb, your brain suddenly loses its main fuel source. This needs to be addressed with a bit more protein until you body starts producing ketones. When your body is producing ketones, these will fuel your brain. You can feel it if your brain is underfed. You will feel mentally sluggish, tired and a bit stupid if you are trying to do anything that requires mental effort, and possibly other symptoms.
Personally i found it hard to eat only 40-50grams of carbs a day at the 2 week mark because of the restrictions on food choices. If you find the same thing, you can increase your carbs. but you should do it gradually if you don't want to throw yourself out of ketosis and then following the atkins protocol is probably the best idea.
You can get into ketosis by not going so low as 20-50g. It just takes longer. If your only aim is to lose fat, then there's absolutely no reason why you can't be eating at much higher carbs than you currently are. I can assure that if the only carbs you eat are vegetables with a little fruit, you will not have the sugar cravings you had before and you will find it fairly easy to stay on this regime if you are enjoying your food choices.
My first try with low carb was at 100 carbs a day and i really enjoyed it. If i was you, i would go to around 80carbs. And if you are not happy with it, then reduce or increase your carbs.
Finally for the long term you should understand the value and importance of fibre in your diet. If you are eating a real low carb level, you are not getting enough fibre. Watch this show: catalyst - gut reaction on you tube. its very good and enlightening. There's a whole big project going on in america which deals with this subject. If i was american, i'd get involved. Look up gut flora on wikipedia.
Calories still matter on low carb. The main benefit is that it helps you manage your appetite. AFter this experience, if you come of it, continue to avoid the refined sugars you are doing on low carb. These are the main problems with food cravings. Mood is another one.
I like the site by phlaunt.com she has a good macro and calorie calculator.0 -
Charlotte, its ok to put the other side, but as someone who was a huge skeptic on low carb for most of the year and then decided to have a go to satisfy my curiosity, i would suggest at least reading some of those links above. To me it doesn't matter if not all elements of the arguments are tight. But there are useful things to learn from having a low carb experience.
I have noticed its often the case that when someone is promoting a diet they will say things that grate, the arguments often seem exaggerated and details left out. I think its because of the limitations of the medium. There may be some silly things said, that doesn't mean the whole package should be ignored.
But i do think that people who vigorously try to debunk the project should read some of the stuff the advocates are writing rather than just what expert opponents say because they have an agenda too. Everyone does. Its worth doing the reading and testing for yourself. There's a lot of people even in the science and diet community who are vigorously defending the status quo and you can tell from what they are saying that they haven't read very deeply. e.g. lately an article by Dr Karl.0 -
If you are interested in reading other perspectives, thinkingnutrition.com.au/ written by Tim Crowe an Associate Professor in Nutrition in the School of Exercise and Nutrition Sciences at Deakin University in Melbourne and Accredited Practising Dietitian is excellent IMO.
[/quote]
Thanks Charlotte I went straight to the site and discovered a different perspective. Investigating again. One paper that caught my eye was "One diet to rule them all"thinkingnutrition.com.au/best-diet-for-health/
Conclusion
The evidence for Optimal eating is associated with increased life expectancy, dramatic reduction in lifetime risk of all chronic disease, and amelioration of gene expression.
ANSWER
A dietary pattern that is made up of mostly unprocessed plant foods and which is low in highly processed foods and sugar consistently comes out on top in offering the best long-term health. There is no one food or food group that deserves demonising. A dietary pattern is a flexible way of eating, not a set of rules that has to be followed to the letter of the law.
NOTE
It definitely wasn't Pete Evans that made me look into it. It was the Australian team Doctor Dr Peter Brukner and Shane Watson. My main concerns was the eating of a high fat diet
would make me fat and give me a heart attack. I used Dr Peter Brukner's ideas and blog to get me started.
ALL YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT LOW CARB HIGH FAT
http://www.peterbrukner.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/All-you-need-to-know-about-LCHF1.pdf
I was only genuinely interested in Pete Evans for some recipe ideas - he is more Paleo chef which is slightly different to LCHF. There's heaps of websites with LCHF recipe ideas.
Being a trained environmental scientist and science teacher I tried to look into the science behind things. Trying to get through the reading is impossible let alone decipher the Fact from Sociology of scientific knowledge from Scammers to just those wanting to take your money. I am now the guinea pig of my own experiment. Myth busting is in my blood.
Thanks for the further discussion Good people. I continue the experiment.
0 -
Patttience wrote: »Charlotte, its ok to put the other side, but as someone who was a huge skeptic on low carb for most of the year and then decided to have a go to satisfy my curiosity, i would suggest at least reading some of those links above. To me it doesn't matter if not all elements of the arguments are tight. But there are useful things to learn from having a low carb experience.
I have noticed its often the case that when someone is promoting a diet they will say things that grate, the arguments often seem exaggerated and details left out. I think its because of the limitations of the medium. There may be some silly things said, that doesn't mean the whole package should be ignored.
But i do think that people who vigorously try to debunk the project should read some of the stuff the advocates are writing rather than just what expert opponents say because they have an agenda too. Everyone does. Its worth doing the reading and testing for yourself. There's a lot of people even in the science and diet community who are vigorously defending the status quo and you can tell from what they are saying that they haven't read very deeply. e.g. lately an article by Dr Karl.
I'm not a low carb skeptic. I understand that it works for some people. I find however, that some of the proponents of the approach, such as Pete Evans, are almost cult-like in their evangelical inability to see another perspective. That, along with the fear-mongering and conspiracy theories that they propose, rings alarm bells to me. It's not black and white, as suggested by the low carb evangelists. It's reasonable to consider different perspectives, which is what I was proposing with regards to foxyplayon's post.
I have read part of I Quit Sugar (terrible pseudoscience), and although I missed the Catalyst show on low carb diets, I have read the full transcript from the show. I have seen Lustig's "the Bitter Truth" on youtube and I follow Pete Evans shenanigans. I'm not sure why you assumed I spoke out of ignorance. Have you had a look at the blog I linked?
Anyway, thanks for OK'ing my attempt at linking some reading that may provide some balance....geez......I thought I read the word 'opinions' in the OP.
0 -
Just try it and see how you feel.
Personally when I was dieting to lose weight, I found going low fat didn't make me feel too good. I'd see a lot of people dieting and regularly eating 40g of fat or less.. but that just wasn't for me. I kept my protein the same, dropped my carbs a good bit, upped my fats to a minimum of 80g, and felt a lot better.0 -
I go for moderate fat, moderate protein, moderate carb. That way I can eat what I like best, which is everything
Excessive protein will be treated as energy, either burned or stored. That seems like waste to me. Carb and fat is cheap and just as delicious as protein. 0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions