How much weight loss to see a noticeable difference!?
Replies
-
BodyByButter wrote: »Curious - did you go off the depression meds by yourself or suddenly, or did your doctor step you down gradually?
I came off them gradually because my dr could see how unhappy I was by the weight gain - she even prescribed me Orlestat because I had gotten so big, but I didn't take it, it's not healthy and I wanted to do things the proper way and dieting gave me something to focus on xo
0 -
BodyByButter wrote: »Curious - did you go off the depression meds by yourself or suddenly, or did your doctor step you down gradually?
I came off them gradually because my dr could see how unhappy I was by the weight gain - she even prescribed me Orlestat because I had gotten so big, but I didn't take it, it's not healthy and I wanted to do things the proper way and dieting gave me something to focus on xo
That's good!
0 -
When you lose slowly and your friends and family see your everyday... well they won't notice. Even at 42lbs. Now try meeting someone who you haven't seen in 2 years - they WILL notice, I promise.
For me, I noticed a difference at 20lbs and at 30lbs people said something. They may have noticed before that, but it's sort of rude to say to someone 'have you lost weight?', it's much easier to say 'you've definitely lost weight!' and for that to happen... it took 30lbs.
Measurements and photographs are a great way - other than the scale - to track your progress. Look at an old photo and you're bound to see a difference! RE clothes sizes, I was wearing TIGHT size 20 trousers when I started, so it took me 40lbs to drop to a size 18 - but like I said, people I only saw occasionally noticed and said something before that.
RE your weight loss goals, honey you're a NORMAL, thin-thin-thin size, maybe even a little UNDERweight. Maybe your boy 'friend' has issues of his own if he didn't want you wearing that dress in public. Get that dress out the closet right now and put it on, then go out somewhere with a different friend and see what kind of reaction you get. You'll have fun + you'll get a million complements. Just go be you!0 -
Hi all, I know everyone is different, but how much weight do you think one would need to lose for other people to really notice that you've lost weight? I've lost a total of 3stone so far (aka 42lbs - going from 154lbs to 112lbs) and my family, friends and colleagues haven't noticed!! I don't think I look much different and I'm still a uk clothes size 12-14....I don't get it??
Wow, amazing result! Congratz! I knew sometimes if ppl always meet u everyday they dont realize changes on ur body, But it must be so weird that they didnt realized u lose weight, in fact you lose so many like 42 lbs! Must be so much difference...
0 -
I lost 65 pounds and couldn't tell the difference because I was to big. Still wear the same clothes, and still look the same. Don't look like I've lost a single pound to me. No one noticed, guess it depends on your body type to see weight loss. It takes me several several several pounds to lose for people to notice my weight lose.0
-
I've lost 20 pounds but haven't dropped a size. My clothes are definitely more loose, though.
I'm a US 14. My co-worker, who weighs the same as I do (we are both 5'4" and weigh 163) is a US 8.
She is much broader than I am through the shoulders and ribcage even though my boobs are bigger than hers, and she is straight as a board from her waist to her knees, while I have a well-defined waist and much bigger hips. She's a classic rectangle shape and I am a classic hourglass shape.
I was amazed to find out that we were the same weight but 4 clothing sizes different.
OP, you look fantastic in all your pictures. No reason to feel ugly or fat. I agree with everyone who is suggesting you see a therapist for eating disorder issues.0 -
I'm guessing your brain has not caught up and you have lost weight and sizes but your mind makes you believe it hasn't.
There is no really way for you to have lost over 42lbs and not have lost a clothing size.0 -
arditarose wrote: »GiveMeCoffee wrote: »arditarose wrote: »Brand sizing in the uk is different between stores, brands and ranges
I simply can't believe at your stats you are a uk 12, I'm 4 inches taller,weigh 168 and am a uk 10-12
I think you have body dysmporphia, you have a BMI of 19.2, a target of the lowest possible healthy range BMI at 18.5, your profile pic looks extremely thin and you need to get outside, objective help
This. Something is off. I'm 5'4" and 139 and even a UK 12 (US 10??) would be big on me.
Please don't lose any more weight. Do you have any photos to compare?
What's off is she really needs to get with her therapist, she's stopped taking her depression meds from her profile
And this.
You look beautiful in all 3 photos. You likely cannot see this truth due to body dysmorphia. Please see a therapist or at least join a support group. You are (and were!) a beautiful young woman.
Why not consider Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy (CBT)? Also, you may wish to take the BDD quiz below to see if you are at risk for Body Dysmorphic Disorder.
Please take care of your spirit, and find some help.
http://www.adaa.org/finding-help/treatment/therapy
http://www.rhodeislandhospital.org/services/body-dysmorphic-disorder-program/questionnaires/screening-questionnaire-for-adults-do-I-have-BDD.html0 -
You are thin!
You absolutely don't need to lose any more weight
Set your calories at maintenance, or slightly above, go to the gym and start a heavy lifting programme, add in a little cardio and get yourself fit and strong
With that comes inner confidence, which is the only thing you need.
You need to be able to strut girl...you are beautiful and so caught up in not being good enough that you don't realise quite how much you have already.
Strength in the body can help you get stronger in the mind
0 -
I have wider shoulders and hips and people around me do not seem to notice if I put weight on/ lose weight either.
It's not about being skinny, it's about being healthy. The "eatwell plate", 1/3 of veggies + 1/3 proteins + 1/3 healthy fats and carbs, drink plenty of water and daily exercise, should be our goal.0 -
So back to the OP and when others notice. They really don't if they live/work with you if you do it right. It comes off slow ...it is amazing how people who haven't seen you will notice a lot. Next, freakin' clothing sizes. Just buy what fits, looks great, and makes you feel great. There are several posts on how stupid clothing manufacturers can't get these standardized.0
-
When I was younger, I lost a bunch of weight because I became quite ill. Then several years ago I lost weight in a healthy way, lots of muscle, great shape. I was 10lbs heavier when I lost it the healthy way and wore 2 pants sizes smaller. Work on some muscle.0
-
As said near the begining of this thread, your weight is fine, but, espescially after seeing the photos of you, you would probably benifit from doing some weight bearing/bodyweight exercises to help re-shape your body.
People will not notice your weight loss if they are seeing you every day and you are wearing the same clothes.
I completely understand the party dress, I go on cruises and the dresses that looked good on me the first week look awful the 2nd week with only 3-4lb water weight gain, so for you, if you were a little bloated on the night you were wearing the dress, it probably wouldn't have looked as good as the day you bought it.
And yes one can see the weight difference in the photos.
Lift things that are heavy, for you, then make them heavier. It really will help.
Cheers, h.0 -
Ok I've just taken a waist measurement and I have gained an inch since December 1st 2014 despite having lost 9lbs! I feel physically sick...I'm definitely not losing any weight here, I'm clearly losing muscle only! I distraught after all my hard work, I think I'm going to ask my doctor for his advice and see if I can join an NHS weight watcher type programme because clearly I can't do anything successfully by myself! This is so frustraighting and disheartening. All that hard work for nothing. Thanks for your in put though guys and congrats to you all for managing to do so well and look fantastic xxx0
-
Ok I've just taken a waist measurement and I have gained an inch since December 1st 2014 despite having lost 9lbs! I feel physically sick...I'm definitely not losing any weight here, I'm clearly losing muscle only! I distraught after all my hard work, I think I'm going to ask my doctor for his advice and see if I can join an NHS weight watcher type programme because clearly I can't do anything successfully by myself! This is so frustraighting and disheartening. All that hard work for nothing. Thanks for your in put though guys and congrats to you all for managing to do so well and look fantastic xxx
There is no way your Dr is going to send you anywhere to lose weight, if they do they should be struck off! Please get help about your body image, you are not fat and do not need to lose weight!!!0 -
Ok I've just taken a waist measurement and I have gained an inch since December 1st 2014 despite having lost 9lbs! I feel physically sick...I'm definitely not losing any weight here, I'm clearly losing muscle only! I distraught after all my hard work, I think I'm going to ask my doctor for his advice and see if I can join an NHS weight watcher type programme because clearly I can't do anything successfully by myself! This is so frustraighting and disheartening. All that hard work for nothing. Thanks for your in put though guys and congrats to you all for managing to do so well and look fantastic xxx
Don't be disheartened. You lost a lot of weight and you look beautiful. You can still work on your physique! But I hope you work on your self-esteem and attitude too. Both are a challenge, I know.0 -
Ok I've just taken a waist measurement and I have gained an inch since December 1st 2014 despite having lost 9lbs! I feel physically sick...I'm definitely not losing any weight here, I'm clearly losing muscle only! I distraught after all my hard work, I think I'm going to ask my doctor for his advice and see if I can join an NHS weight watcher type programme because clearly I can't do anything successfully by myself! This is so frustraighting and disheartening. All that hard work for nothing. Thanks for your in put though guys and congrats to you all for managing to do so well and look fantastic xxx
I doubt you gained an inch. I'm more/less bloated depending on time of the day. I'm guessing my measurement fluctuates. Measuring yourself is also very prone to human error.
You really need to give yourself a break. Based on those pictures, you look fantastic.0 -
Ok I've just taken a waist measurement and I have gained an inch since December 1st 2014 despite having lost 9lbs! I feel physically sick...I'm definitely not losing any weight here, I'm clearly losing muscle only! I distraught after all my hard work, I think I'm going to ask my doctor for his advice and see if I can join an NHS weight watcher type programme because clearly I can't do anything successfully by myself! This is so frustraighting and disheartening. All that hard work for nothing. Thanks for your in put though guys and congrats to you all for managing to do so well and look fantastic xxx
I doubt you gained an inch. I'm more/less bloated depending on time of the day. I'm guessing my measurement fluctuates. It's also very prone to human error.
You really need to give yourself a break. Based on those pictures, you look fantastic.
Right. The other night I ate 7 rice cakes and drank two glasses of tea and for some reason decided to measure my waist. An inch bigger. I had no idea measurements could fluctuate like that. But it was back to normal in the morning.0 -
Even if all of that 9 lb weight loss was due to muscle loss, you would not gain an inch unless you then went on to gain pounds in fat. I just highly doubt this happened between December and now when the scale weight went down.0
-
Ok I've just taken a waist measurement and I have gained an inch since December 1st 2014 despite having lost 9lbs! I feel physically sick...I'm definitely not losing any weight here, I'm clearly losing muscle only! I distraught after all my hard work, I think I'm going to ask my doctor for his advice and see if I can join an NHS weight watcher type programme because clearly I can't do anything successfully by myself! This is so frustraighting and disheartening. All that hard work for nothing. Thanks for your in put though guys and congrats to you all for managing to do so well and look fantastic xxx
Couldn't you ask to switch to a different anti depressant? I was scared about putting on weight and my doctor prescribed me one that doesn't cause weight gain as a side effect (or at least it is very uncommon for it to do so). They shouldn't have taken you off altogether if the underlying problem behind your depression wasn't solved.0 -
YOU HAVE A BMI OF 19
And a disordered eating problem
Yes see a doctor, but for help with your ED
Because your life can be so much better than this ..it's an illness and you need to fight it
And the next person who offers you weight loss advice simply hasn't read the thread...0 -
YOU HAVE A BMI OF 19
And a disordered eating problem
Yes see a doctor, but for help with your ED
Because your life can be so much better than this ..it's an illness and you need to fight it
And the next person who offers you weight loss advice simply hasn't read the thread...
I don't have an eating disorder, I eat healthy meals and occasionally treat myself to a bag of crisps or a Small chocolate bar as a special treat on the weekend - I don't believe in deprivation of treats as that's more likely to cause you to fall off the wagon and have a binge
0 -
That is a GREAT idea!Ok I've just taken a waist measurement and I have gained an inch since December 1st 2014 despite having lost 9lbs! I feel physically sick...I'm definitely not losing any weight here, I'm clearly losing muscle only! I distraught after all my hard work, I think I'm going to ask my doctor for his advice and see if I can join an NHS weight watcher type programme because clearly I can't do anything successfully by myself! This is so frustraighting and disheartening. All that hard work for nothing. Thanks for your in put though guys and congrats to you all for managing to do so well and look fantastic xxx
I've known what BDD was for a long time. I'm good at listening and understand things people tell me (it's not hard if you just listen, lol.). So, I've understood BDD for a long time. Now that I've lost weight, I kind of identify with it and I think a huge issue with BDD is trust.
I don't see what other people see. Maybe I can't trust my eyes. They don't see eighty pounds of weight loss. Thirty, maybe forty, but NOT 80. Scale doesn't lie, though. I'm down 80 pounds. Other people go on about it, but maybe I can't trust them because people do tend to make you out as prettier, thinner, better than you are. Most of us do that for our friends. But the BMI doesn't lie and it's waaaay down, so I cannot be seeing me correctly.
Since I cannot trust others and I can't trust myself, I tend to figure I'm somewhere in the middle of what they say they see and what I see. But I don't know.
The doctor is really the only person I trust to give it to me straight. That's his damn job, to tell me how fat I am and what to do to get healthier. He falls somewhere between what other people say and what I see, which backs up what I was thinking.
If I get to the point where the doctor, the BMI and other people are saying, "Don't lose anymore!" and I find myself thinking, "But I don't look good enough," I will know I have a BDD issue and wait for my eyes & brain to catch up with my body.
A lot of people who lose have some degree of BDD and have to wait for their eyes & brain to catch up with their body.
I try to do what I've told others to do - look twice in the mirror. Stand there nekkid and look at you like you always do, "OMG, my hideous thighs. Jesus, this lumpy, gross stomach. My poor boobs..." whatever you think, lol, you're too young to say, "My poor boobs," but go ahead and do all your nasty self-talk that you do. Now, look yourself in the eye.
Then close your eyes, and open them again, looking yourself in the eye. Don't focus on any spot, keep looking yourself in the eye, but take a good peripheral glimpse at the shape without looking at individual fat pockets. Now a quick overall look without stopping to see "my disgusting thighs." Look at the parts you didn't bother with the first time. That will give you a better view. Say a few good things. Even if you don't believe them, say them to yourself. Even if it's, "My wrists look pretty good! I like that curve there." Again, even if you don't believe it, say it. I am doing it. I'm taking my advice (which I don't always do, lol) and practicing what I preach. It is helping me. No lie.
Train your brain! Get it out of the habit of thinking only nasty things. Train it to think some good things, too. If you have to force it, at first, so be it. You can do that!
Every day, two looks. Then quit being obsessive about your body and concentrate on your life the rest of the day. Wait until the next morning to say nasty things to yourself.
It's not terrible advice. Give it a try. Won't cost a damn thing and nobody will even know.
0 -
YOU HAVE A BMI OF 19
And a disordered eating problem
Yes see a doctor, but for help with your ED
Because your life can be so much better than this ..it's an illness and you need to fight it
And the next person who offers you weight loss advice simply hasn't read the thread...
Agreed. Although you've since taken your pictures down, 112 is thin on most everyone-- you definitely don't need to lose another stone. I bet what's going on is more of a perception issue. Please talk to someone you trust and take care of yourself.0 -
YOU HAVE A BMI OF 19
And a disordered eating problem
Yes see a doctor, but for help with your ED
Because your life can be so much better than this ..it's an illness and you need to fight it
And the next person who offers you weight loss advice simply hasn't read the thread...
I don't have an eating disorder, I eat healthy meals and occasionally treat myself to a bag of crisps or a Small chocolate bar as a special treat on the weekend - I don't believe in deprivation of treats as that's more likely to cause you to fall off the wagon and have a binge
Yes sweetheart you do, you are thinking in a disordered fashion about your body, your self-esteem and your need to lose weight,when it is clear to everyone that you are very close to the lowest healthy weight range.
Your self-hatred is sad and unneccesary. This is about your sense of self, your psyche and not your body .
You need help to get happy and confident and love your life0 -
EXERCISE.
This has nothing to do with your weight and all to do with your body shape.
Lift things that are heavy for you, then lift things that are a bit heavier etc. etc., or do body weight exercises. You want to re-shape; not lose weight.
Keep eating at maintenance.0 -
middlehaitch wrote: »EXERCISE.
This has nothing to do with your weight and all to do with your body shape.
Lift things that are heavy for you, then lift things that are a bit heavier etc. etc., or do body weight exercises. You want to re-shape; not lose weight.
Keep eating at maintenance.
but she looks fine as she is now. this implies that she doesn't, which just isn't true. her self-loathing is not warranted as it is.0 -
I think we all have a problem with our appearance to some extent otherwise we wouldn't be here trying to lose weight (granted some of you may be doing it for health but can you honestly say you were happy at your old weight?) - you don't have an eating disorder and neither do I. I'm just confused and upset as to why after all my hard work and 3stone loss, I am still a UK size 12 and body measurements remain the same xxx 0
-
I think we all have a problem with our appearance to some extent otherwise we wouldn't be here trying to lose weight (granted some of you may be doing it for health but can you honestly say you were happy at your old weight?) - you don't have an eating disorder and neither do I. I'm just confused and upset as to why after all my hard work and 3stone loss, I am still a UK size 12 and body measurements remain the same xxx
yeah, i don't think you have an eating disorder based on what you've stated. you haven't said much about how many calories you're consuming though, so i can't really say.0 -
I don't really like my body either at 105 pounds. not liking your body does not equate to eating disorder though. that would require issues with food, not just your body.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions