limetree683 wrote: » Yup. The tone of the replies to this is pretty much the same as for any one else who dares asks a question. Rigger - everyone is different. I have been sugar free for a month now because I find it much easier to cut stuff out completely rather than eat in moderation. I don't have sugar cravings at all, and in fact just today I had my first taste of refined sugar in over 30 days and it just didn't taste that good anymore, hence I don't see such denial as being part of my downfall. Just because denial of food is an issue for *you* doesn't mean it is for everyone. And this isn't about help, it's about the condescending tone and so-called 'tough-love' I constantly see from the 'survivors' 'veterans' and 'fighters' here. Already others have implied she is lazy and ignorant. Nice.
_dracarys_ wrote: » Please come back in 6 months and let us know if you're still sugar free...
navyrigger46 wrote: » Why do I feel like this is on the verge of spawning another "mean people" thread? I don't see this condescension you're seeing. And I don't see it in other threads unless people really take their ignorance to a higher level of stupid and then insist on defending it in the face of facts. This is about help, no matter what you think. We, (the veterans) are speaking from experience, we have been there, done that, and seen the numerous members who have failed and come back. The fact that you don't have a problem cutting out foods, well, good for you. If that's sustainable, great, for the vast majority of people it is not. White knight all you want, but the fact that you see a tone and get defensive just tells me that you know, and the OP knows that we are right, but are too stubborn to give it up. Rigger
jenniwylie33 wrote: » ^^ and that's from cycle one, not the second or third, where other foods are worked back in. pretty maintainable as far as I can tell.
limetree683 wrote: » navyrigger46 wrote: » Why do I feel like this is on the verge of spawning another "mean people" thread? I don't see this condescension you're seeing. And I don't see it in other threads unless people really take their ignorance to a higher level of stupid and then insist on defending it in the face of facts. This is about help, no matter what you think. We, (the veterans) are speaking from experience, we have been there, done that, and seen the numerous members who have failed and come back. The fact that you don't have a problem cutting out foods, well, good for you. If that's sustainable, great, for the vast majority of people it is not. White knight all you want, but the fact that you see a tone and get defensive just tells me that you know, and the OP knows that we are right, but are too stubborn to give it up. Rigger Ah. So there have been multiple 'mean people' threads in the past? So I'm not the only one who sees a tone? And yet these threads keep coming. Oh well, they must all have been by stupid/ignorant/stubborn people who refused to see the wisdom of being talked down to, or being called lazy and stupid in an effort to change their eating habits. OP stated clearly she was trying to re-learn healthy eating habits. She didn't need to be asked if she was a dirt-bike and needed a kick-start. Also, why are you presuming to tell her what will be her down-fall (which coincidentally is your down-fall)? I'm not getting defensive by the way. I've got nothing to defend. And you can call it white knight-ing all you want, but I'm just calling it like I see it.
jenniwylie33 wrote: » I love that it's forcing me to try new recipes. So ridiculous, considering my house hold is NOT picky - they'll eat anything, and yet we'd been relying on a few staple meals, instead of building healthier options. Now that we're doing that, everyone loves supper time more. So silly.
jenniwylie33 wrote: » I absolutely agree that eating in moderation is key. I am not currently disciplined enough to do that, which is why I wanted something with more structure, and work up to eating in moderation. Clearly what I WAS eating, wasn't working, so I wanted a plan, and a change. This is what I chose.
jenniwylie33 wrote: » Me too. I don't eat "some chips" I eat ALL THE CHIPS. It's not right. I need to fix it.
booksandchocolate12 wrote: » I had never even heard of this diet before reading this thread, so bear with me. The way I understand it, there is no logging, no counting, no tracking, is that right? You eat from a certain group of foods, then add more foods as time goes on? And there are no set portion sizes, or do you just eat "to satisfaction"? It kind of reminds me of the South Beach Diet. I did that for a while a long time ago, when it was just a book (no website, no membership, etc.). I did well on it at first, and found it to be a healthy diet. But eventually it caught up with me, and I'll tell you why. I have no idea what it means to eat "to satisfaction". I have no off switch, and I eat very fast. Before I know it, I have plowed right through "satisfied" and well on into "stuffed". That's why I need to count (be it calories, "points" or whatever) and log everything. That's the only way I know that I'm eating the right amount. Hopefully one day I'll learn to slow down, learn to listen to my body and know that I'm "just full enough". But I'm not there yet. And it seems that with a diet like the 17 Day Diet, you have to have that skill set to succeed. I wish you good luck with your weight loss!
rabbitjb wrote: » What happens on day 18? I don't believe in fad, packaged up to market, diets just eat to a calorie defecit - job done!
jenniwylie33 wrote: » Ok guys, quit raining on my parade please! I'm making a lifestyle change from eating on the run, and having very unbalanced meals, to eating fruits and veggies, and high protein. I did not ask "would you like to slam my new diet choice?" I asked "Is anyone doing the 17 day diet, or interested in starting? I have just started, and love it - but I'm looking for some like-minded people to keep the enthusiasm going with !"
ingridehikwe wrote: » And eating at the right time....I think that was a BIG one, eating at the right time.