Where does the low carb group hang out?
loridebacker
Posts: 24 Member
I've been put on a low carb diet for health reasons. Is there a place on mfp that low carbers hang?
0
Replies
-
I'm curious. What "health reasons" would require someone to have to go low carb. I've never heard of an illness that required that before0
-
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/group/394-low-carber-daily-forum-the-lcd-group
Hope to see you there!
Pedi
0 -
loridebacker wrote: »I've been put on a low carb diet for health reasons. Is there a place on mfp that low carbers hang?
Here you go!
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/group/394-low-carber-daily-forum-the-lcd-group0 -
Jake
DM, insulin resisitance, PCOS are a few of illnesses that are treated with low carb.0 -
-
ladymiseryali wrote: »
If you have general low carb questions, you can ask on the boards, but for more specific answers, that group that was linked I hear is quite active and helpful (not being a low-carbber myself I can't personally vouch for it).-2 -
Facebook has some closed groups u can join, they are awesome and so many people have lost tons of weight.. and everyone doesn't understand low carb can be very good...it doesn't mean no carbs and only protein..Check it out become a member..
LCHF Low carb High fat AND LOW CARB AND LOSING!!!!0 -
Hi there! You can add me! I only want to spread loverade:) also there are many reasons one medically needs to do low carb. I do for pcos. It is also (keto specific) recommended for cancer. But anywhoo love to chat with ya:)0
-
Jake
DM, insulin resisitance, PCOS are a few of illnesses that are treated with low carb.
There is that group yes but be forewarned there are lots there who do not believe you need to count calories to lose weight...just carbs.
If you are on a low carb diet for health reasons good luck and perhaps check into getting an appointment with a dietician (registered) to get more education on the topic.0 -
May I ask what health issue you have (feel free to tell me no). It's just "health issues" can be so vague, so it hard to give specific advice.
Just be aware, if you want to lose weight, regardless of low carbs, you need to be in a calorie deficit.0 -
JakeBrownVB wrote: »I'm curious. What "health reasons" would require someone to have to go low carb. I've never heard of an illness that required that before
Hosimotos (thyroid) insulin resistant and prediabetes. Believe it or not, not everyone can just eat whatever as long as below your calories burn.0 -
Jake
DM, insulin resisitance, PCOS are a few of illnesses that are treated with low carb.
There is that group yes but be forewarned there are lots there who do not believe you need to count calories to lose weight...just carbs.
If you are on a low carb diet for health reasons good luck and perhaps check into getting an appointment with a dietician (registered) to get more education on the topic.
Does CICO no longer work if I don't actually count the calories going into my body?0 -
mantium999 wrote: »baconslave wrote: »mantium999 wrote: »I would also suggest seeking a group that is open to discussion, and not kept private for the purpose of reducing "dissenters".
Actually, the group was open from it's beginning in 2011until yesterday. Olivia and the site admins made it private yesterday while they are looking into all the rumors flying around. We have no control over that until they are finished what they are doing. If you have a problem with this, Olivia would be the one to talk to about it. She has made it clear that discussing objections to a group and its activities is not an appropriate conversation for the forum.
Wan't objecting to a group.Making a suggestion that, with regard to any topic, learning is often best accomplished when all sides are free to discuss and provide information. The group in question currently does not, so, until that is resolved, I think the OP would do well to seek alternatives. The only suggestions given to the OP are a private MFP group, and a closed Facebook group.
Can't disagree with the bolded statement.
I don't think humans are quite there yet for certain topics, unfortunately.
0 -
ladymiseryali wrote: »ladymiseryali wrote: »ceoverturf wrote: »ladymiseryali wrote: »
Perhaps if you didn't play the victim in literally every post you make, you might get more respect.
If you have general low carb questions, you can ask on the boards, but for more specific answers, that group that was linked I hear is quite active and helpful (not being a low-carbber myself I can't personally vouch for it).
Um, where have i played the victim exactly? I answer questions and warn those who eat the same way that there will be criticism because THERE ALWAYS IS. That's NOT playing a victim.
you said "unfortunately, we don't get much love here" = playing the victim card.
and if the sentiment in the LC group about the main forums is any indicator, it sounds we don't get much love over there either...
I'm stating a fact. Low carb is under constant criticism on the main forums. And none of that, nor any of you, are mentioned in the group.
I usually see debate and questioning around the REASONS for doing low-carb.0 -
loridebacker wrote: »I've been put on a low carb diet for health reasons. Is there a place on mfp that low carbers hang?
The meat counter
0 -
isulo_kura wrote: »loridebacker wrote: »I've been put on a low carb diet for health reasons. Is there a place on mfp that low carbers hang?
The meat counter
LOL! Yup.0 -
baconslave wrote: »mantium999 wrote: »baconslave wrote: »mantium999 wrote: »I would also suggest seeking a group that is open to discussion, and not kept private for the purpose of reducing "dissenters".
Actually, the group was open from it's beginning in 2011until yesterday. Olivia and the site admins made it private yesterday while they are looking into all the rumors flying around. We have no control over that until they are finished what they are doing. If you have a problem with this, Olivia would be the one to talk to about it. She has made it clear that discussing objections to a group and its activities is not an appropriate conversation for the forum.
Wan't objecting to a group.Making a suggestion that, with regard to any topic, learning is often best accomplished when all sides are free to discuss and provide information. The group in question currently does not, so, until that is resolved, I think the OP would do well to seek alternatives. The only suggestions given to the OP are a private MFP group, and a closed Facebook group.
Can't disagree with the bolded statement.
I don't think humans are quite there yet for certain topics, unfortunately.
Agreed. Though if lurkers gain a new knowledge or lightbulb moment by watching the chaos, than the chaos provided a benefit. Sometimes an argument need not be settled between two parties for a third party to learn something. I learned a lot about how to interpret supporting facts by watching how those facts are debated here. So, while often repetitive, I say let the disputes continue.0 -
JakeBrownVB wrote: »I'm curious. What "health reasons" would require someone to have to go low carb. I've never heard of an illness that required that before
Hypoglycemia
Hyperinsulinemia
Insulin resistance/metabolic syndrome
Diabetes
Shall I go on?
ETA: These conditions do not REQUIRE low carb but help significantly.0 -
loridebacker wrote: »JakeBrownVB wrote: »I'm curious. What "health reasons" would require someone to have to go low carb. I've never heard of an illness that required that before
Hosimotos (thyroid) insulin resistant and prediabetes. Believe it or not, not everyone can just eat whatever as long as below your calories burn.
it's not a requirement for those.
http://www.diabetesforecast.org/2011/mar/are-carbs-the-enemy.html?referrer=https://www.google.ca/
http://www.diabetes.co.uk/diabetes-and-carbohydrate-diets.html
My brother is a diabetic and his specialist never once recommended low carb for him...ever ever.
My sister in law has thyroid issues...never once was she told by her specialist to go low carb.0 -
loridebacker wrote: »Also why all the rude remarks? Geez.....not looking for advise. Just looking for fellow low carb(not no carb) people. And btw not everyone processes food the same, just sayin.loridebacker wrote: »Also why all the rude remarks? Geez.....not looking for advise. Just looking for fellow low carb(not no carb) people. And btw not everyone processes food the same, just sayin.
You stepped into the middle of a shitstorm that has nothing to do with you, and had no way of knowing was going on. Some people seem to think they're at war, because interent forums are serious business. It'll blow over eventually. Meanwhile, use the group linked at the top. You can get more info in these, too, though you may not want to go full keto unless it helps you:
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/group/1143-keto
http://www.reddit.com/r/keto
The general guidelines are the same, just different ratios of carbs. You can still use all the recipes, too.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
565 North Clinton Drive, Milwaukee, WI
Lots of low carb love here.
Jk
See a nutritionist. Most of the time it is free on health plans for the first visit. Just sayin.0 -
loridebacker wrote: »Also why all the rude remarks? Geez.....not looking for advise. Just looking for fellow low carb(not no carb) people. And btw not everyone processes food the same, just sayin.
Absent of health issues, humans do process food the same way. I know you said you do have a medical condition, soy at makes things a bit different. I asked for the actual conditions because that can make a difference on advice. For example if you are diabetic, you will need a different approach than someone who has IBS triggered by certain carbs, etc.0 -
loridebacker wrote: »JakeBrownVB wrote: »I'm curious. What "health reasons" would require someone to have to go low carb. I've never heard of an illness that required that before
Hosimotos (thyroid) insulin resistant and prediabetes. Believe it or not, not everyone can just eat whatever as long as below your calories burn.
it's not a requirement for those.
http://www.diabetesforecast.org/2011/mar/are-carbs-the-enemy.html?referrer=https://www.google.ca/
http://www.diabetes.co.uk/diabetes-and-carbohydrate-diets.html
My brother is a diabetic and his specialist never once recommended low carb for him...ever ever.
My sister in law has thyroid issues...never once was she told by her specialist to go low carb.
Maybe it works for hers. Not me. I know hard to believe that not everyone is built the same. Go figure.
You do what feels good for you and since I have changed the way I eat I feel 100% better. So back off.-1 -
sophiasmom0914 wrote: »Wow why are people so rude on here?
I've literally just joined and it so sad to see some people on here being negative to others.
Like stfu and mind your own weight loss. If you don't agree then who cares? Move on, don't make stupid comments.
And yet you are here being negative to others? Like someone else said, you might want to follow your own advice. Just a thought.
-1 -
ceoverturf wrote: »angellll12 wrote: »sophiasmom0914 wrote: »Wow why are people so rude on here?
I've literally just joined and it so sad to see some people on here being negative to others.
Like stfu and mind your own weight loss. If you don't agree then who cares? Move on, don't make stupid comments.
I've noticed that too. And it's always by the same people you'll notice them, just block them. I came to the conclusion that this is where they get their kicks.
We have a block feature now?
used to..it was great...seems to have disappeared tho.loridebacker wrote: »loridebacker wrote: »JakeBrownVB wrote: »I'm curious. What "health reasons" would require someone to have to go low carb. I've never heard of an illness that required that before
Hosimotos (thyroid) insulin resistant and prediabetes. Believe it or not, not everyone can just eat whatever as long as below your calories burn.
it's not a requirement for those.
http://www.diabetesforecast.org/2011/mar/are-carbs-the-enemy.html?referrer=https://www.google.ca/
http://www.diabetes.co.uk/diabetes-and-carbohydrate-diets.html
My brother is a diabetic and his specialist never once recommended low carb for him...ever ever.
My sister in law has thyroid issues...never once was she told by her specialist to go low carb.
Maybe it works for hers. Not me. I know hard to believe that not everyone is built the same. Go figure.
You do what feels good for you and since I have changed the way I eat I feel 100% better. So back off.
back off???? wow why so angry....
just pointing out it's not a requirement for diabetes or thyroid issues...
Glad you feel better0 -
ladymiseryali wrote: »ladymiseryali wrote: »ceoverturf wrote: »ladymiseryali wrote: »
Perhaps if you didn't play the victim in literally every post you make, you might get more respect.
If you have general low carb questions, you can ask on the boards, but for more specific answers, that group that was linked I hear is quite active and helpful (not being a low-carbber myself I can't personally vouch for it).
Um, where have i played the victim exactly? I answer questions and warn those who eat the same way that there will be criticism because THERE ALWAYS IS. That's NOT playing a victim.
you said "unfortunately, we don't get much love here" = playing the victim card.
and if the sentiment in the LC group about the main forums is any indicator, it sounds we don't get much love over there either...
I'm stating a fact. Low carb is under constant criticism on the main forums. And none of that, nor any of you, are mentioned in the group.
no its not...
The only LC'ers getting criticized are the ones claiming that CICO does not apply to Low Carb or the ones claiming LC is the only one true way.0 -
loridebacker wrote: »loridebacker wrote: »JakeBrownVB wrote: »I'm curious. What "health reasons" would require someone to have to go low carb. I've never heard of an illness that required that before
Hosimotos (thyroid) insulin resistant and prediabetes. Believe it or not, not everyone can just eat whatever as long as below your calories burn.
it's not a requirement for those.
http://www.diabetesforecast.org/2011/mar/are-carbs-the-enemy.html?referrer=https://www.google.ca/
http://www.diabetes.co.uk/diabetes-and-carbohydrate-diets.html
My brother is a diabetic and his specialist never once recommended low carb for him...ever ever.
My sister in law has thyroid issues...never once was she told by her specialist to go low carb.
Maybe it works for hers. Not me. I know hard to believe that not everyone is built the same. Go figure.
You do what feels good for you and since I have changed the way I eat I feel 100% better. So back off.
I retract my previous comment. It seems you are not looking for information and are content with what you are doing. Modern medicine is always evolving. Who knows, you might just find something that will make you feel 200% better. But you have to lower your shields first, and not tell someone who posted a possible relevant link to your condition to "back off", without even looking into the info provided.-1 -
Not a requirement for all but for some. My point. Not everyone is the same....
Thanks and yes I feel much better!:)0 -
Why are people being so rude
not even adressing ops questions. Well I don't think low carbers are well recieved on here. Cant we just spread love and drink the keto coffee? Ill make u some its fantabulous:)
Love peace and yes chicken g r ease
0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions