Isagenix, Science or Woo?
jenathp
Posts: 92 Member
I have two soon to be sister in laws who SWEAR by (and one of them sells in the pyramid scheme) Isagenix and the whole platform. Once has claimed MIRACLES in her life and they really want me to 'get on board' and "believe in the miracles".
I've done SOME research but it's hard to find anything real since it's so heavily marketed by the pyramid scheme people...
So, what's the consensus Woo or Science?
I've done SOME research but it's hard to find anything real since it's so heavily marketed by the pyramid scheme people...
So, what's the consensus Woo or Science?
0
Replies
-
I'm looking at the website and I see a lot of dubious claims.
What "impurities," exactly, is it going to get rid of?
Why are the vitamins in their shakes any different than the vitamins you could get from food or cheaper supplements?
How is it going to boost your metabolism?
How will it improve your ingestion?
It makes a lot of claims for the product that seem to be related specifically to ingredients (example, it doesn't have anything special that will help you retain muscle, that's just the whey protein in the shakes -- which you can get for much, much less).
When I'm looking at products that make promises, one thing I find helpful is to ask myself HOW the product is going to do these things. If the answer isn't clear, or if the way it will accomplish this is something I can do for much cheaper, I stay away.0 -
My vote is for Woo.
It kinda sounds like a cult.0 -
My thoughts would be woo. Just from a quick google.
If it seems too good to be true, then it probably is.
My Dr told me once "if there was a pill/potion/powder/thingie that created sustainable weight loss then there would be no fat people"
You don't need to spend money on anything except a food scale. Weigh your foods. Log accurately. Follow your guidelines and you're laughing
0 -
I vote woo. You're losing weight from the calorie deficit created by the plan, not the miracle products that are pushed on the consumer. The products are severely overpriced as well.0
-
Woo0
-
While it will work if you follow the plan, the general consensus would be that 99% of their claims are woo.0
-
-
I have yet to see a thread in the Success Stories titled "ISAGENIX IS HOW I LOST ALL MY WEIGHT AND KEPT IT OFF!"0
-
My personal opinion is it is mostly hype. Yes you will most likely lose weight because you are restricting calories but you could do that without their products. I did try their shakes because a friend sells them and they are pretty tasty. I like a protein shake in the morning when running out of the house to get the kid and husband to school and work on time then me to the gym. Makes for a quick breakfast. I probably won't get isagenix because the cost is kind of ridiculous for what I want it for.0
-
Expensive, culty woo. As jane says above, they make a lot of claims with very little substance and claim to do a lot of things which simply don't make sense. Can it help you lose weight? Sure. But so can a calorie deficit. Will you feel better after losing weight? Most likely, most overweight people do. If you had a vitamin deficiency and weren't feeling at your peak, and the vitamins in the Isagenix fixed it, would you feel better? Most likely. But you could just take a muti. You see where this is going.
Other claims, like getting rid of toxins and boosting metabolism are just straight up crap.
It isn't a miracle product and can't do anything you can't do for yourself without buying into the hype. It's a money maker.0 -
It probably works. Anything that helps you cut your calories will work! You needn't pay for some specific product in order to cut your calories, though.
Personally, I prefer healthy food and watching my calories. There is no way I'd pay for powders or shakes...but I know people who drink the shakes and like to do things that way.
It's just a personal preference - how do you want to lose your weight?
If the company says that the product is eliminating toxins, they're just flat-out lying. I wouldn't trust anything they said after that.0 -
It probably works. Anything that helps you cut your calories will work! You needn't pay for some specific product in order to cut your calories, though.
Personally, I prefer healthy food and watching my calories. There is no way I'd pay for powders or shakes...but I know people who drink the shakes and like to do things that way.
It's just a personal preference - how do you want to lose your weight?
But OP isn't asking if it will work as just as well as any calorie deficit plan. OP is specifically asking if it is a "miracle" and if the claims made for the product are based in science. That isn't personal preference. Just based on the claims on the website and what we currently know about weight loss, I think we can answer her question with a fair degree of confidence.0 -
Woo. Just like Beachbody/Snakeoilogy, Advocare, ItWorks and all the other MLM scams. The only person getting any benefit from it is the person who sells it to you.0
-
_dracarys_ wrote: »I have yet to see a thread in the Success Stories titled "ISAGENIX IS HOW I LOST ALL MY WEIGHT AND KEPT IT OFF!"
That made me laugh.0 -
It probably works. Anything that helps you cut your calories will work! You needn't pay for some specific product in order to cut your calories, though.
Personally, I prefer healthy food and watching my calories. There is no way I'd pay for powders or shakes...but I know people who drink the shakes and like to do things that way.
It's just a personal preference - how do you want to lose your weight?
If the company says that the product is eliminating toxins, they're just flat-out lying. I wouldn't trust anything they said after that.
I am being quite successful on MRP's for two meals a day and then eating the majority of my calories for dinner. Right now I'm at about 1.5 pounds a week when I'm being good and when I'm bad then I stall. I've just added in the last 2 weeks regular exercise (aerobic and light weights). I'm using MFP to track exercise and calories. I just started to weigh my food yesterday so that I can get a more accurate calorie count but I'm losing slow and steady by watching CICO. I just happen to do it through MRP's because I can get high amounts of protein and fiber which keep me full and not needing to snack for 4 hours. Plus I like the fact that I get to have sweet stuff and not feel deprived (chocolate shakes).0 -
chillaxin69 wrote: »I would ask how it is different from soylent, and why it costs more.
Well Soylent uses rice protein and contains soy, Isagenix uses whey and doesn't contain soy so those are some differences. Have no idea on the cost question.0 -
Its a mlm scam. I call woo on isagenix0
-
If it works for you, that's great. I'm not a fan of the shakes, like I said, but I have a friend who drinks them when she's dieting. I've known others who drink the shakes, too. I get that people like them.It probably works. Anything that helps you cut your calories will work! You needn't pay for some specific product in order to cut your calories, though.
Personally, I prefer healthy food and watching my calories. There is no way I'd pay for powders or shakes...but I know people who drink the shakes and like to do things that way.
It's just a personal preference - how do you want to lose your weight?
If the company says that the product is eliminating toxins, they're just flat-out lying. I wouldn't trust anything they said after that.
I am being quite successful on MRP's for two meals a day and then eating the majority of my calories for dinner. Right now I'm at about 1.5 pounds a week when I'm being good and when I'm bad then I stall. I've just added in the last 2 weeks regular exercise (aerobic and light weights). I'm using MFP to track exercise and calories. I just started to weigh my food yesterday so that I can get a more accurate calorie count but I'm losing slow and steady by watching CICO. I just happen to do it through MRP's because I can get high amounts of protein and fiber which keep me full and not needing to snack for 4 hours. Plus I like the fact that I get to have sweet stuff and not feel deprived (chocolate shakes).
Just keep in mind that if you're not planning to drink them for life you'll need some plan for when you stop drinking them. Maybe transition into food and count your calories when you're ready to quit the shakes - something like that. Just keep it in mind, you know? You don't want to start gaining when you stop drinking the shakes.
Best of luck with your weight loss!
0 -
SCAMWOO0
-
This content has been removed.
-
It's all about cleansing and ridding your body of toxins.
Major WOO.0 -
I think it's woo personally. Of course if you cut your calories enough, you will lose weight. But that's not due to any special "properties" of their products. You could get the same results with less hunger and less expense on your own.0
-
I have two soon to be sister in laws who SWEAR by (and one of them sells in the pyramid scheme) Isagenix and the whole platform. Once has claimed MIRACLES in her life and they really want me to 'get on board' and "believe in the miracles".
I've done SOME research but it's hard to find anything real since it's so heavily marketed by the pyramid scheme people...
So, what's the consensus Woo or Science?
Woo.
The reason any person loses weight on any diet aid, including Isagenix, is because they are eating at a calorie deficit.
If they are not eating at a calorie deficit and taking Isagenix, then they would not lose weight.
Therefore, it's best to tell your sister in laws to stop bugging you.
Eat at a calorie deficit and you will lose weight. 0 -
I say woo, sorry.0
-
Woo0
-
Multi-level marketing. In other words, a scam. With woo on top of it.0
-
Anytime you restrict your calories, you're going to lose weight. That's just basic science. You don't need a magic drink for that. Just eat lean proteins, lots of vegetables, and exercise. I just checked their prices, though. Ten oatmeal raisin bars for $14? Fourteen vanilla shakes for $66? I sense a scam to separate desperate, overweight people who don't want to diet from their money, Calling it 'woo' is being kind.0
-
Lol, Isagenix is not a pyramid scheme. It's called network marketing. When I lived in Thailand I met a few guys in their thirties who made their fortune from network marketing.
Now, does it work? IMO, a diet rich in vegetables, fruits and lean meats is a better choice. Want to get rid of toxins? Go on a juice cleanse instead. Most of this stuff hasn't even been tested yet. We don't know the long-term effects yet, or if it even works or not.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions