NO carbs and fat in a diet.

GlamourVintage
GlamourVintage Posts: 60 Member
edited November 28 in Health and Weight Loss
Okay guys, so a woman on Youtube said she lose 40 pounds in 2 months..by barely eating carbs (20 or lower) and no fat..and kept it off for the last month. She said carbs and fat is the enemy. And a person can't lose weight if they eat 20g or more of carbs and fat. My question is can you live off of 20g or lower in carbs and fat? I'm just curious. Opinions, please?
«134

Replies

  • usmcmp
    usmcmp Posts: 21,219 Member
    Dietary fat is important for fat loss and hormones. Carbs and fat are not the enemy. You can live on low carb, low fat can have serious health consequences if you do it long term.
  • queenliz99
    queenliz99 Posts: 15,317 Member
    Hi and welcome!!

    http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10257474/starting-out-restarting-basics-inside/p1

    Best wishes!!
  • vespiquenn
    vespiquenn Posts: 1,455 Member
    usmcmp wrote: »
    Dietary fat is important for fat loss and hormones. Carbs and fat are not the enemy. You can live on low carb, low fat can have serious health consequences if you do it long term.

    This. The fact that she's only kept it off a month means nothing. A month is nothing in the grand scheme of things. Over-restrictive habits is one of the main reasons people fall back into old habits. They never learn moderation.

  • MommyL2015
    MommyL2015 Posts: 1,411 Member
    You can lose weight eating anything, as long as you remain at a caloric deficit. Fat is good for you. Carbs are not evil. I have lost all of my weight so far eating plenty of carbs and fat. Other than paying attention to calories and making sure I get adequate protein, I rarely pay attention to anything else.

    That's my $.02
  • saralthrash
    saralthrash Posts: 105 Member
    My opinion only! Some carbs are good for you and are an excellent source of energy. Complex carbs are amazing! They are in whole grains, beans and veggies. They are filling too. Anytime I tried to do a low carb diet I was exhausted and cranky. Then when I introduced carbs back in my diet I gained it all back twice as fast as I lost it. But everyone is different. This could be the thing that works for you! Good luck!
  • lorrpb
    lorrpb Posts: 11,463 Member
    There are very few proteins that have no associated carbs or fat, so basically it would be impossible.
  • LuanneScott1971
    LuanneScott1971 Posts: 14 Member
    Who would WANT to live that way!?
  • strong_curves
    strong_curves Posts: 2,229 Member
    No offense, but she sounds a little cray. I'm wondering what did she eat.
  • tara_means_star
    tara_means_star Posts: 957 Member
    LuanneScott1971 wrote: »
    Who would WANT to live that way!?

    Exactly! Especially when it's soooooo unnecessary. I'm over on my fat goal every. single. day. And carbs? I'm a vegetarian, most of what I eat (including protein sources) are carbs! Hasn't stopped me from losing weight and I totally enjoy my food. Fat and carbs make the best kind of food.
  • queenliz99
    queenliz99 Posts: 15,317 Member
    edited January 2016
    Who would WANT to live that way!?


    For the hits, that's who :)
  • Carlos_421
    Carlos_421 Posts: 5,132 Member
    edited January 2016
    What channel? I'd like to see if she's as loony tunes as she sounds.

    If you can't have any carbs or fat...what are you supposed to eat? About all your protein sources have fat, carbs or both.

    ETA: this actually sounds dangerous to me, what she's promoting.
  • zoeysasha37
    zoeysasha37 Posts: 7,088 Member
    Well I lost all my weight while eating 190g of carbs and have kept it off for 2+ yrs so far while still eating all those evil scary carbs! And fat !
    Carbs and fat are macros and nothing to be afraid of.
    Don't believe the hype. People like to look for magic weight loss wand and its just not necessary . to lose weight, all you need is a calorie deficit. Eat less then you burn. Cico. No need to give up important macros , no need for extreme diets , fads and gimmicks..

    Remember - cico.
  • Shawnrivas
    Shawnrivas Posts: 7 Member
    I guess limiting carbs to 0 is great but extreme for most folks. I say keep it simple and burn more than you consume. Keep a 1,000 difference between what you've eaten and what you burn for weight loss and than start messing around with the numbers of carbs, fats, and sodium later.
  • jaga13
    jaga13 Posts: 1,149 Member
    GlamourVintage wrote: »
    Okay guys, so a woman on Youtube said she lose 40 pounds in 2 months..by barely eating carbs (20 or lower) and no fat..and kept it off for the last month. She said carbs and fat is the enemy. And a person can't lose weight if they eat 20g or more of carbs and fat. My question is can you live off of 20g or lower in carbs and fat? I'm just curious. Opinions, please?

    So she basically ate only protein? That sounds a bit unhealthy.
  • GlamourVintage
    GlamourVintage Posts: 60 Member
    edited January 2016
    I edit my original poster because I made a mistake with "my" instead of "a" in the subject line. I would post the video but I don't want to do her like that. But yeah..thanks for the feedback. :smile:
  • provitasemper
    provitasemper Posts: 12 Member
    A totally zero-fat diet is DISASTROUS for one's memory, and brain function, many times permanently if on the diet for a long time. I've witnessed it first-hand in a friend and also in my aunt.

    Also, really bad for one's hair/skin/nails. Not to mention, fat is not bad for a person--it is essential for proper absorption of many different fat-soluble vitamins.

    What works for me is HFLC (High-fat, Low-carb). My cravings are completely non-existent between meals if I eat healthy fats along with low carb foods (grass-fed meats, cheeses, eggs, fish) and lots of leafy greens and low-carb veggies. If you go to DietDoctor.com, it explains it really well. I am NOT endorsing this site (tho I really trust them) but they explain it in a really sensible way that explains the science of why the "Low-Fat" diet of the last 30+ years in America made so many of us fat and sick, and now sick and tired of being fat.

    When I eat low-fat, I am CONSTANTLY hungry. HFLC is amazing, even for kids. My autistic son does much better when he gets a high-fat, organic, whole food diet.
  • williams969
    williams969 Posts: 2,528 Member
    Whoa, I agree that such macro restrictions are completely unnecessary. My personal "low carb" diet is stay around 200g/day. For reference, my maintenance level carb intake is close to 300. 20g??? How? Zero plant based foods? And pretty much only fat free meat and dairy (I'm guessing...this is so far away from my balanced intake). Sounds dreadful.
  • RodaRose
    RodaRose Posts: 9,562 Member
    edited January 2016
    Fat is necessary.
    Carbs -- eat them or do not eat them because they do not matter one way or another.
  • diannethegeek
    diannethegeek Posts: 14,776 Member
    GlamourVintage wrote: »
    Okay guys, so a woman on Youtube said she lose 40 pounds in 2 months..by barely eating carbs (20 or lower) and no fat..and kept it off for the last month. She said carbs and fat is the enemy. And a person can't lose weight if they eat 20g or more of carbs and fat. My question is can you live off of 20g or lower in carbs and fat? I'm just curious. Opinions, please?

    My opinion is that my serotonin levels would take a nosedive on a diet like this and it would be disastrous for my depression. I have no problems with low carb, but no healthy fats? No thanks.
  • FunkyTobias
    FunkyTobias Posts: 1,776 Member
    Two words :

    Rabbit starvation
  • Shawnrivas
    Shawnrivas Posts: 7 Member
    My problem is I'm a binge eater and nothing seems to work.
  • soulofgrace
    soulofgrace Posts: 175 Member
    40 lbs in 2 months!? She didn't eat any food at all.
  • middlehaitch
    middlehaitch Posts: 8,486 Member
    Shawnrivas wrote: »
    I guess limiting carbs to 0 is great but extreme for most folks. I say keep it simple and burn more than you consume. Keep a 1,000 difference between what you've eaten and what you burn for weight loss and than start messing around with the numbers of carbs, fats, and sodium later.

    This is an aggressive calorie cut and not needed for most people. 2lb a week is advised for those with 100~ to lose.

    If you are binging raise your calories 500. You will still lose a pound a week, but it may forestall binges as you will be more satisfied.

    Cheers, h.
  • Lounmoun
    Lounmoun Posts: 8,423 Member
    GlamourVintage wrote: »
    Okay guys, so a woman on Youtube said she lose 40 pounds in 2 months..by barely eating carbs (20 or lower) and no fat..and kept it off for the last month. She said carbs and fat is the enemy. And a person can't lose weight if they eat 20g or more of carbs and fat. My question is can you live off of 20g or lower in carbs and fat? I'm just curious. Opinions, please?

    Opinions-
    Losing 40 lbs in 2 months is not particularly healthy weight loss for most people. That screams very low calorie diet.
    Vegetables and fruits have carbs. Extremely low carb probably means missing a lot of nutrients as well as fiber.
    No fat is not a good idea. Your body needs some fat to function properly.
    None of this sounds healthy.
    You lose weight by eating less calories than you burn. That is all. You don't have to do weird extreme things to lose weight.
  • theskinnyonme
    theskinnyonme Posts: 443 Member
    But But I like the carbs and fat. Seriously I m losing plenty of weight and I eat both of them. Food is good.
  • HelenRobertsNZ
    HelenRobertsNZ Posts: 16 Member
    LuanneScott1971 wrote: »
    Who would WANT to live that way!?

    It would be miserable! I'd devour the contents of the fridge after one day of deprivation and my family would flee in the face of my crankiness. I'll think of her tonight as we tuck into our 500 cal spaghetti and meatballs.
  • pollypocket1021
    pollypocket1021 Posts: 533 Member
    lorrpb wrote: »
    There are very few proteins that have no associated carbs or fat, so basically it would be impossible.

    I'm thinking that anyone advocating this diet is terribly ignorant about health, diet, and nutrition in general and probably ate far more fat and carbs than she realized.
  • AmyRhubarb
    AmyRhubarb Posts: 6,890 Member
    Sounds horrible - I've lost about 25 lbs and many many inches while eating fat and carbs, and I've kept it off 9and continued to improve strength, endurance, flexibility, and over fitness) for over 3 years. I enjoy pasta, BUTTER, full fat dairy, pizza, burgers & fries, alcohol...

    Do it for life, not for some quick fix with unsustainable eating habits and depriving your body if things it needs (yes, our bodies NEED fat and carbs!). Temporary changes get you temporary results.

  • Christine_72
    Christine_72 Posts: 16,049 Member
    Low carb I can live with, but low carb AND fat, no way!!
    you'll be hungry and fatigued the whole time :tired_face:
  • ninerbuff
    ninerbuff Posts: 49,029 Member
    Fat is ESSENTIAL for health. Don't believe people on youtube who do stuff like this and use their anecdotes to support CORRECT way to lose weight. Did she bother saying her hair fell out?

    A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
    IDEA Fitness member
    Kickboxing Certified Instructor
    Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
    9285851.png
This discussion has been closed.

Categories