Silliest weight loss/fitness myth you've ever heard?
Replies
-
That fruit is bad for you.0
-
amusedmonkey wrote: »Running will make your uterus fall out.
My mom tells me that lifting heavy will make my uterus drop and make me infertile.0 -
Pocket__Cthulhu wrote: »I had a friend once tell me that "If you eat carbs when they're cold your body won't digest them." Once. She was eating a plate of cold fries.
Probably because they read articles like this: http://www.bbc.com/news/health-32019176.
The article talks about how cooling down rice after cooking ups resistant starches which are apparently harder for your body to digest (but not impossible). So, cooling down your rice before consuming might reduce the calories your body is able to get from it, hence the idea that eating carbs cold might reduce the calories as opposed to if they were served fresh and hot.
Not that I'm logging the rice I prep at the beginning of week any differently even though it's been sitting in my fridge for a few days...0 -
A couple months ago I got sick back to back like four times in one month (had a cold, food poisoning, another cold, pink eye) and my mom and grandma thought it was because I "worked out too much".0
-
Don't eat after seven.
Eat something every two hours.
Don't eat anything white.
---all by Bob Green, the man who gave Oprah her weight problem.0 -
This thread has been highly entertaining but unfortunately I am over 50 and therefore doomedmiztessbert wrote: »You can't lose weight after 50
0 -
Oatmeal burns fat.0
-
The silliest thing I heard was from a coworker. We were at a Mexican restaurant and I was commenting on how huge their burrito was and how they could get about 3 meals out of it, and they were trying to reason out why they could eat the entire thing. They said that the body can only absorb a certain amount of calories at once, and anything over that doesn't matter, so you might as well just eat the whole thing. They said their doctor told them that they can only absorb about 500 calories per meal or something like that. And, I really wanted to say they need to find a new doctor, but I didn't say anything because I didn't want to argue with a coworker.0
-
That muscle weighs more than fat.....0
-
Pocket__Cthulhu wrote: »I had a friend once tell me that "If you eat carbs when they're cold your body won't digest them." Once. She was eating a plate of cold fries.
My guess with this one it had more to do with cold junk food isn't as good, so if your willing to eat them cold you must really have wanted them.
Honestly? I have no idea what the logic was or where she got the idea. After staring blankly at her and asking if bread didn't count either, she abandoned the idea. I didn't bring it up again, because I think she realized how silly it sounded and was embarrassed. She is one of those ladies who falls victim to "quick fixes" often.0 -
augustremulous wrote: »I've gotta say, this thread has a whole lot of judgment in it.
I think as long as someone isn't doing something that's actually harmful, we should be supportive of the efforts they're making. They'll tinker around and figure it out eventually. Maybe it's useful in these situations not to tell someone else how to lose weight, but instead relate your own experiences of how you lost weight and what worked best for you.
Also, it's pretty normal for people to conflate weight loss with fitness and health, or group it all in together. I know the board mantra is that a calorie is a calorie, but I think in the big scheme of things, thinking about fitness and longevity and wellness will make it easier to reach your goals.
A lot of these so called myths are myths, but they might work if they're targeted to someone's individual weaknesses.
For example, I know objectively that white rice isn't a killer to weight loss. But why do I avoid white rice? - because when it comes to white rice I'm a bottomless insatiable pit. Maybe there is something psychological about it, maybe it's a callback to my childhood. I mean I literally have a physical, biological reaction when I smell white rice that can only be compared to some sort of food boner. For that reason, I avoid it. I don't think it's inherently bad, but avoiding it is personally beneficial to me.
A lot of people have the same experience with carbs in general (so many of the people I know who are doing "low carb" are actually doing regular carb.) Or gluten in general. Or meat. Or processed foods. Or whatever.
And by the way, it's true that gluten isn't evil. But it isn't a necessary nutrient, either. People aren't doing any harm to themselves by replacing gluten with oats or almond flour or quinoa or whatever. I for one have never had something gluten free that wasn't also delicious and equally or more healthy than the gluten version. A good friend of mine cut out gluten and lost a ton of weight - probably because gluten rich products were a source of calories for her.
AMEN! I think that this started as a fun thread... broken cookies and rowing to good boobs fun... but if given a forum... the judgers will judge!0 -
augustremulous wrote: »I've gotta say, this thread has a whole lot of judgment in it.
I think as long as someone isn't doing something that's actually harmful, we should be supportive of the efforts they're making. They'll tinker around and figure it out eventually. Maybe it's useful in these situations not to tell someone else how to lose weight, but instead relate your own experiences of how you lost weight and what worked best for you.
Also, it's pretty normal for people to conflate weight loss with fitness and health, or group it all in together. I know the board mantra is that a calorie is a calorie, but I think in the big scheme of things, thinking about fitness and longevity and wellness will make it easier to reach your goals.
A lot of these so called myths are myths, but they might work if they're targeted to someone's individual weaknesses.
For example, I know objectively that white rice isn't a killer to weight loss. But why do I avoid white rice? - because when it comes to white rice I'm a bottomless insatiable pit. Maybe there is something psychological about it, maybe it's a callback to my childhood. I mean I literally have a physical, biological reaction when I smell white rice that can only be compared to some sort of food boner. For that reason, I avoid it. I don't think it's inherently bad, but avoiding it is personally beneficial to me.
A lot of people have the same experience with carbs in general (so many of the people I know who are doing "low carb" are actually doing regular carb.) Or gluten in general. Or meat. Or processed foods. Or whatever.
And by the way, it's true that gluten isn't evil. But it isn't a necessary nutrient, either. People aren't doing any harm to themselves by replacing gluten with oats or almond flour or quinoa or whatever. I for one have never had something gluten free that wasn't also delicious and equally or more healthy than the gluten version. A good friend of mine cut out gluten and lost a ton of weight - probably because gluten rich products were a source of calories for her.
AMEN! I think that this started as a fun thread... broken cookies and rowing to good boobs fun... but if given a forum... the judgers will judge!
She said, judgingly.0 -
RaeBeeBaby wrote: »That muscle weighs more than fat. Grrrrrrr! Can't count the number of times I've read that on MFP threads.
^ this
I can't tell you how many times I've argued with my boys on this. A pound is a pound is a pound, it's all the same unless we're talking British currency.
Muscle is denser than fat, obviously, and that is why your clothes fit better and you look leaner.0 -
my favorite lie I tell myself when I truly want to indulge, even though I know its not true is, if you break a cookie in half before eating it, all the calories fall out the crack.0
-
any crap that Freelee the banana girl spits out...0
-
5stringjeff wrote: »ClosetBayesian wrote: »Food Babe.
Dr. Oz.
Hate to say I was a Food Babe believer for a long time.
What is a FOOD BABE?
0 -
tincanonastring wrote: »augustremulous wrote: »I've gotta say, this thread has a whole lot of judgment in it.
I think as long as someone isn't doing something that's actually harmful, we should be supportive of the efforts they're making. They'll tinker around and figure it out eventually. Maybe it's useful in these situations not to tell someone else how to lose weight, but instead relate your own experiences of how you lost weight and what worked best for you.
Also, it's pretty normal for people to conflate weight loss with fitness and health, or group it all in together. I know the board mantra is that a calorie is a calorie, but I think in the big scheme of things, thinking about fitness and longevity and wellness will make it easier to reach your goals.
A lot of these so called myths are myths, but they might work if they're targeted to someone's individual weaknesses.
For example, I know objectively that white rice isn't a killer to weight loss. But why do I avoid white rice? - because when it comes to white rice I'm a bottomless insatiable pit. Maybe there is something psychological about it, maybe it's a callback to my childhood. I mean I literally have a physical, biological reaction when I smell white rice that can only be compared to some sort of food boner. For that reason, I avoid it. I don't think it's inherently bad, but avoiding it is personally beneficial to me.
A lot of people have the same experience with carbs in general (so many of the people I know who are doing "low carb" are actually doing regular carb.) Or gluten in general. Or meat. Or processed foods. Or whatever.
And by the way, it's true that gluten isn't evil. But it isn't a necessary nutrient, either. People aren't doing any harm to themselves by replacing gluten with oats or almond flour or quinoa or whatever. I for one have never had something gluten free that wasn't also delicious and equally or more healthy than the gluten version. A good friend of mine cut out gluten and lost a ton of weight - probably because gluten rich products were a source of calories for her.
AMEN! I think that this started as a fun thread... broken cookies and rowing to good boobs fun... but if given a forum... the judgers will judge!
She said, judgingly.
hee hee hee0 -
Starvation mode0
-
My sisters attended WW at the beginning, and though I was only 10, I about died laughing at the "No cheese after 5:00 p.m." rule.0
-
Drinking ACV right after every meal which will help burn the calories from the meal. Sadly I actually believed and tried this. Also I just read a post about oatmeal burning fat...smdh There are a lot of overweight ppl that eat oatmeal...0
-
5stringjeff wrote: »ClosetBayesian wrote: »Food Babe.
Dr. Oz.
Hate to say I was a Food Babe believer for a long time.
What is a FOOD BABE?
Save your sanity and don't find out.0 -
Calories don't count as long you eat raw vegan. You can drink 10 banana smoothie as a snack and you won't gain weight, as long there is no animal products in there. So basically *kitten* Freele banana girl is spreading on YouTube.0
-
~Don't eat things with ingredients you can't pronounce~
I have a PhD in a chemistry related field. I can pronounce pretty much any chemical. Must be why I'm fat.
If you did a complete chemical breakdown of most things, there's going to be some technical name for an otherwise benign substance that the average person can't pronounce.
One example I can think of might be pyridoxine, it kind of has a scary name, reminds you of 'fire', but in reality is just vitamin B6.
This kind of goes along with the ~don't eat it if it has more than five ingredients~ bit.
A lot of things are in reality made out of more than five things. Sure milk is milk, but it consists of water, lactose, fats, proteins (whey and casein), and a myriad of vitamins and minerals, and enzymes.
Also a lot of natural foods contain cyanide in non-lethal doses.
0 -
~Don't eat things with ingredients you can't pronounce~
I have a PhD in a chemistry related field. I can pronounce pretty much any chemical. Must be why I'm fat.
If you did a complete chemical breakdown of most things, there's going to be some technical name for an otherwise benign substance that the average person can't pronounce.
One example I can think of might be pyridoxine, it kind of has a scary name, reminds you of 'fire', but in reality is just vitamin B6.
This kind of goes along with the ~don't eat it if it has more than five ingredients~ bit.
A lot of things are in reality made out of more than five things. Sure milk is milk, but it consists of water, lactose, fats, proteins (whey and casein), and a myriad of vitamins and minerals, and enzymes.
Also a lot of natural foods contain cyanide in non-lethal doses.
^^^ This.... everything is a chemical people, get over it...
Also.... Thisgebeziseva wrote: »MommyL2015 wrote: »but it just sounds really, really stupid to hear someone say muscle weighs more than fat.
It doesn't because 'for a given volume' is always assumed. It is just common sense.
Well at least in science it is assumed. I'm a scientist and never heard anyone comparing the weight of things of different volumes as it would be pointless.
It's like comparing the weight of 5 apples to 1 banana. Or 1 bottle of water to 3 bottles of milk. Who cares which is heavier if the volumes are not the same. Lol.
I'm an engineer, and I too roll my eyes every time someone goes off on a rant about how 'a pound is a pound'.
Duh, that's never the point.
Yes, you can lift for a year, GAIN weight and fit in clothes 5 times smaller. Just because the person may mistakenly think this is happening to them in 1 week, doesn't make this untrue...0 -
LOL!! Yes, and the "nuts are bad" rule.bhunter428 wrote: »My sisters attended WW at the beginning, and though I was only 10, I about died laughing at the "No cheese after 5:00 p.m." rule.
I did WW several years ago. Before every weigh in, the ladies would show up earlier and drink a lot of coffee to shed water weight.
0 -
Atkins0
-
What about the whole gluten-free hype that has been all the rage? I am waiting for this none to go awaaaaay.What about the whole gluten-free hype that has been all the rage? I am waiting for this one to go awaaaaay.
As someone who buys GF products (for a family member with celiacs), I love this 'fad'! The availability of GF products as well as the quality and taste has gone up exponentially. Plus the prices have dropped significantly.
I hope it continues, lol. The GF substitues available a decade ago were atrocious...now they arent bad!0 -
whatshequilts wrote: »My neice gave me a list of 15 acidic foods and told me to eat just those and only grapefruit juice. To only eat and drink that for 2 weeks. On the third week I could eat anything I wanted, then back to the acid foods for to more weeks. So on and so on...
Apparently according to her expertise the high acid level will "eat away your fat"
...and eat away the lining of your stomach resulting in ulcers, lol.0 -
tincanonastring wrote: »augustremulous wrote: »I've gotta say, this thread has a whole lot of judgment in it.
I think as long as someone isn't doing something that's actually harmful, we should be supportive of the efforts they're making. They'll tinker around and figure it out eventually. Maybe it's useful in these situations not to tell someone else how to lose weight, but instead relate your own experiences of how you lost weight and what worked best for you.
Also, it's pretty normal for people to conflate weight loss with fitness and health, or group it all in together. I know the board mantra is that a calorie is a calorie, but I think in the big scheme of things, thinking about fitness and longevity and wellness will make it easier to reach your goals.
A lot of these so called myths are myths, but they might work if they're targeted to someone's individual weaknesses.
For example, I know objectively that white rice isn't a killer to weight loss. But why do I avoid white rice? - because when it comes to white rice I'm a bottomless insatiable pit. Maybe there is something psychological about it, maybe it's a callback to my childhood. I mean I literally have a physical, biological reaction when I smell white rice that can only be compared to some sort of food boner. For that reason, I avoid it. I don't think it's inherently bad, but avoiding it is personally beneficial to me.
A lot of people have the same experience with carbs in general (so many of the people I know who are doing "low carb" are actually doing regular carb.) Or gluten in general. Or meat. Or processed foods. Or whatever.
And by the way, it's true that gluten isn't evil. But it isn't a necessary nutrient, either. People aren't doing any harm to themselves by replacing gluten with oats or almond flour or quinoa or whatever. I for one have never had something gluten free that wasn't also delicious and equally or more healthy than the gluten version. A good friend of mine cut out gluten and lost a ton of weight - probably because gluten rich products were a source of calories for her.
AMEN! I think that this started as a fun thread... broken cookies and rowing to good boobs fun... but if given a forum... the judgers will judge!
She said, judgingly.
LOL!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions